Debate me
>>71311982
Drop Rat to negatives and I agree.
Ratatouille is the worst.
>I'll just insert a 20 minute monologue on art criticism in my children's film
>>71311982
The Incredibles>Up=Walle>Toy Story>TS2>Ratatouille>Monster Inc>Nemo>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>TS3>>MU>>>>Brave>>>>>>>>>>shit>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Cars
Ratatouille and all the cars movies should be at 0
Up is better than Wall-E
>>71311982
cars and the last 3 need to be waaaaay lower
>>71312091
you're a fucking idiot
>>71312191
Why? Because that's
>NOT AN ARGUMENT
Up should be much lower.
The beginning carries the film and the rest is boring and forgettable.
>>71311982
>first Cars movie
>bad
When will this meme end?
>>71311982
>Debate me
No real complaints actually. Good show OP.
>>71312304
Agreed. A montage is lazy. A montage could make an SJW sympathize with Hitler.
Cars and brave should be lower.
Agree with WallE though.
Pixars greatest movie
Ratatouille is their best film by far, Incredibles is the only that comes close.
>>71311982
Toy Story 2 is the best Pixar Film
>all these people still getting triggered over Cars
>>71311982
Cars 2 should be lower
Brave should be at least higher than Cars 2
and Monsters University should be lower.
>People on /tv/ agree with me being Wall-E being a masterpiece.
I'm happy with this discovery.
>>71312975
Everyone likes it but hardcore /pol/tards.
The problem films are Incredibles and the latter day ones for /tv/. For patricians, the sticking points are Ratatouille and Toy Story 2. Not hard to see why if you consider for 5 seconds.
>>71311982
In a row:
>Ratatouille
>Wall-E
>Up
Will another studio ever reach this apex?
>>71311982
Mostly accurate
Wall-E is definitely their best.
Nemo is their second best imo
>>71312275
Why do birds fly?
Why is Cars universally considered shit?
>ratatoouie that high
>monsters university that low
shit list
Toy Story 2 was the best one and Incredibles is definitely better than Finding Nemo and Up.
>>71311982
I kind of agree. Except Incredibles should be one of the highest, if not the highest.
Cars was when it went to shit. WallE TS3 and Up are great though.
I know not many people like A Bugs Life but I really enjoyed it for what it was. There was a lot of pressure on it back then because how the fuck do you follow up Toy Story?
>>71311982
I agree with everything except for Incredibles and TS2.
>>71311982
I ordered your image properly.
>>71312113
Bugs Life?pleb
I'd rate Toy Story 3 a little bit higher. Other than that, I agree.
>The Incredibles
>not at the top of your list
>>71311982
Okay
Your opinions are shit
Debate over. I win.
>>71313086
>Incredibles
Nobody dislikes the Incredibles. Stylish and fun as fuck, even if it's not your favorite it's very obviously one of their best movies.
>>71315242
>Monsters Inc
>that low
>Ratatouille and UP
>that high
Shit bait
just my onion guys
>>71315814
Yeah, sure. It has a real good "message." that forgives all the storytelling problems and obvious style issues.
Last one is Good Dinosaur
GOD TIER
>Toy Story
>Finding Nemo
>The Incredibles
GREAT TIER
>Monsters Inc
>A Bug's Life
>Wall-E
>Toy Story 3
>Inside Out
>Up
GOOD Tier
>Ratatouille
>Cars
>Finding Dory
>Toy Story 2
Meh Tier
>Cars 2
>Monsters University
>Brave
The Good Dinosaur Tier
>The Good Dinosaur
>>71311982
I actually agree with this. Finding Dory was shit too familia. Better than Cars 2 at least.
>>71315242
Bump Monsters Inc up one (or even two) but other than that pretty accurate
-----God tier-----
1. Toy Story - the original Pixar
2. Wall-E
3. Inside Out
4. Incredibles
5. Toy Story 3.
6. Finding Nemo
7. Monsters Inc.
8. Up
--Good tier--
9. Toy Story 2
10. Ratatoulle
11. Antz
--Shit tier--
12. Monsters U
13. Antz
14. Cars
15. Brave
16. Cars 2
>>71316027
I thought Inside Out was incredible, definitely at par with some of Pixar's better works.
>>71315910
>storytelling problems and obvious style issues
Such as? It was a combination of old-fashioned superhero stuff and modern family/realistic drama. Syndrome's motives were the only problem I can think of.
>>71316118
you forgot to put Shrek 2 on there :^)
>>71311982
Would raise Toy Story and Bugs life more, and Lower Cars 2 down below the picture. Past that, spot on.
>>71316122
Man nah, I wanted to like it but it ended up just being the wacky adventures of two characters who got annoying as hell REALLY quickly. The other characters were totally unused. The BingBong thing was heavyhanded. Only real strong part of the movie was the theme of the girl developing emotionally
>>71311982
good taste. maybe i'd bump up toy story 2 a bit
>>71311982
>Saying the Incredibles is just average.
Nigga you better pump up that rating or we are going to fight.
>>71316177
>Syndrome's motives
There must have been a deleted scene or something, because once its explained, it all makes sense.
Syndrome, betrayed by his Super icons, wanted to create an enemy that could defeat his old heroes. Then, he wanted to give that power to others. Syndrome would sell super-power technology to normies. Making everyone a superhero and making him even richer.
"If everyone's super, then no one is".
The only thing that doesn't really make sense about all that is how he thought that world governments would be OK with him selling superpowers.
>>71316177
Old fashioned super hero stuff was univerally socialist. Check out World's Greatest and Superman and Batman comics before 1945. The Incredibiles tries to import Ayn Rand's philosphy into that era because the architecture makes sense, and it just makes stylistic scizophrenia.
anyone else not seen a pixar film since cars 1 cuz they kinda grew up and just dont care about talking animata anymore?
>>71316658
just you
>>71316303
I can agree that Joy got kind of annoying, but to an extent that was the point, she was supposed to be annoying and bossy and then change. I thought Sadness was an okay character. They did kind of ignore the other characters, but I liked the use of BingBong.
>>71316658
tippity tip
>>71316658
nope. kill yourself asap.
>>71316708
>BingBong
Legit closest I've ever been to crying from a movie
Yes I'm a huge faggot
>>71316698
thought so. it wasnt even bait, i honestly just see pixar movies as passable these days.
i did see toy story 3 though for nostalgia and that hit me right in the feels
>>71313086
Fun fact, women think Wall-E is dumb and boring.
And idiots think Toy Story is great.
>>71313807
Because most fa/tv/irgins don't even have a basic driver's license, so seeing cars on screen triggers them.
>>71316902
Because the one girl you ever dated didn't like it?
Protip: She didn't like you because you're a boring shitfuck. Get a better job and women willl pretend to be interested in your stupid opinions.
I never saw a Pixar movie after Toy Story 3, are any of those any good?
THREAD THEME
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=px0j1EHF8Y0
>fedoras say this movie isn't good
>>71312113
I can respect this opinion
>>71317066
Toy Story 2 was great I never heard anyone say otherwise...
GOD TIER
>Monsters Inc
>Toy Story
>The Incredibles
ALMOST GOD TIER
>Ratatouille
>Toy Story 3
GREAT TIER
>Finding Nemo
>Toy Story 2
>Up
>WALL-E (although I haven't seen it in a very long time)
GOOD TIER
>A Bug's Life
>Cars
>Monsters University
>Finding Dory
MEDIOCRE/DISAPPOINTING TIER
>Inside Out
CAN BARELY REMEMBER TIER
>Brave
Haven't seen the rest.
>>71317050
Inside Out is worth seeing.
you can pass on the others.
>>71317156
>>Toy Story 3
no. it was a bank heist movie with toy story characters. it sucked.
>>71311982
Cars 2 is worse than the first.
It doesn't matter where you rate cars, cars 2 should always have a lower rating.
>>71316802
>I'm a huge faggot
>Hasn't cried from a movie.
Wow you are a faggot. That said, I actively try to be emotionally affected to increase my enjoyment.
>Godzilla 98
>Qui Gon
>every manipulative moment in Pixar EXCEPT Toy Story 3
>>71317172
Alright I'll check it out
>>71311982
hmm...
nah. I can respect it. I like you.
>>71317016
Wow, that time of the month?
>>71316118
>Antz
I enjoyed Brave and it legit made me tear up.
How come it's so disliked here?
>>71316658
No I stopped watching them because I got into ghibli and couldn't get into 3D animation anymore. I still love a bug's life, TS2 and nemo though.
Wall E is the absolute best.
But why doesn't it get the respect it deserves?
>>71317369
It's very Dreamsworks and Merida was a really boring character.
I liked it though, I just couldn't imagine wanting to watch it again.
>>71317172
Inside Out is terrible.
>>71317201
You say that like it's a bad thing.
>>71317251
Man I wish I could feel more
Feeling nothing is a goddamn curse
>>71317334
Kekkles. You got own'd by a guy so hard you thought it must have been a chick? Are you only used to girls laughing at you? Suck 4u bra. gl
Ratatouille
Monsters University
Toy Story
A Bug's Life
Toy Story 2
The Incredibles
The rest
If you're over 21+ and still watch these flicks, you should probably consider assisted murder
>people see Dory
>ask if it's as good as WallE
>"it was even better than TS3!!!!!"
>>71317401
>main characters are like Pokemon and can only say their names
>OMG America is so FAT
>robots don't have emotion
>space is a very boring setting for a kids movie
Fun fact: people actually think this way
>>71317505
Well I feel nothing in real life, I just like getting into stories.
>somehow didn't see the final scene of 11/22/63 coming
>bawled like a baby from happiness
>>71317564
It was such a good film though. It just kind of went away and nobody talks about it anymore. All of the things you posted are opinions of toddlers basically.
>>71317678
(And girls)
I think it was that WallE is a pretty pathetic character, and that is probably the most """""thoughtful""""" Pixar movie. And not very kid friendly except dat toy design.
What should I watch tonight, Finding Nemo or Wall-E?
Also, just got back from Finding Dory and I surprisingly liked it. I originally had no interest in it at all.
>>71317527
>assisted murder
What, are you saying they're too weak to kill a hooker on their own?
>>71317826
Obviously Nemo then.
I'm not even sure if I want to download Dory, it seems like it has wayyyyyyy too many "one scene" characters.
>>71317996
Its not so bad. Its just very samey and didnt do anything Nemo didnt do, and nothing better. It plays off the whole amnesia thing the entire movie. Every new character has to go through the introduction about short term memory loss. Wasnt a grand adventure like the first, more like a teleport to a singular area and then teleport back. I'd give it a 6/10.
>>71317996
What do you mean? Most of the new characters are in it for most of the movie. In fact one of my favourite parts was the new characters.
O B J E C T I V E L I S T
>GOD TIER
The Incredibles
Ratatouille
>FANTASTIC TIER
Finding Nemo
Toy Story 2
>GREAT TIER
Monsters, Inc.
Wall -E
Toy Story
>GOOD TIER
Up
A Bug's Life
>EHH TIER
Cars
Inside Out
Toy Story 3
Monster's University
Brave
>NO
Cars 2
>>71318328
I'm not even sure I've seen the real trailer, just TV shilling of it.
A manta ray, beluga whale, dolphin?, whale shark, probably more.
But I hear she just goes to some aquarium so it makes sense that there would be all of these characters with decent screen time.
I've still never seen Monsters U because Monsters Inc is one of my favorite films ever, and I truly don't understand why they decided to make a fucking PREQUEL to it.
Prequels add nothing to a story. Their existence is always meaningless.
>>71318761
Yeah they play a pretty strong part. The octopus probably has the most screentime out of the new characters.
>>71316122
Agreed, Inside Out was astonishingly beautiful.
>>71319213
It shows you why a nerd like Mike would end up with a Chad like Sully.
And I think there is a really good scare scene in it, I just can't remember because it was a prequel and nothing mattered. And it's basically Pixar going "18 year olds ate Toy Story 3 up, let's make a college movie"
>>71313796
So they can get places.
>>71319348
I guess for some reason I thought it would be another travel movie but about the new family of Dory. I could see a "dory meets people" movie being mildly entertaining if not repetitive.
Are Marlin and Nemo featured in it or just a beginning/end scene?
I tried watching the Good Dinosaur yesterday. I could only handle a few minutes of it.
I really liked Finding Dory a lot. I finally got around to watching Inside Out and thought it was great too.
>>71319348
The new characters were excellent. They all helped about as much as the secondary and tertiary characters did in Nemo. Plus, Hank is Al Bundy.
Never seen Ratatoulle. Is it good? Patton Oswald is a giant faggot, that's why I stayed away.
Shrek > Toy Shitty
>>71311982Every time I saw Toy Story 3 I cried like a fucking baby
>>71319409
It was a visually beautiful movie but I felt like they wasted the storytelling/setting opportunity they created with the premise.
>>71319659
fag. I thought the movie would have been better had they went into the fire and it played a montage of all the good times.
>>71319763
Toy Story was the first movie I saw with my parents. It all just hit home at the right time I guess.
>>71311982
I haven't seen anything from The Incredibles and onward. Is wall-e actually good? Actually, maybe I have seen the incredibles when it came out but I hardly remember it. Pixar to me is basically toy story and bug's life. Is there anything else worth watching past the incredibles?
>>71312091
>a 20 minute monologue on people who called me out on being an objectivist in Incredibles
Toy Story 8/10
Bugs Life 7/10
Toy Story 2 9/10
Monster's Inc. 7.5/10
Finding Nemo 8/10
The Incredibles 9/10
Cars 5/10
Ratatouille 9/10
Wall-E 8/10
Up 7/10
Toy Story 3 8/10
Cars 2 1/10
Brave 6/10
Monsters University 6/10
The Good Dinosaur 6/10
>>71319561
It's very good. I've rewatched it many times and it always stays as good as the first time I watched it.
>>71319561
It's about the universality of food and how important some people can find it, both emotionally and economically.
Patton Oswald is very subdued, i found out the last time watching it that the antagonist is fucking Peter O'Toole.
I crie every time.
And it's like 80s Paris with an accordion soundtrack.
>>71319849
Would only bump Monsters Inc. to an 8. Otherwise, best list
>>71319824
WallE is legitimately fantastic if you enjoy sci-fi.
Ratatouille is fantastic if you ever cook anything.
Toy Story 3 seems to be 50/50 in effectiveness.
Watch the opening to Up on YouTube and don't bother with the rest.
Inside out has all of your favorite NBC actors in a mildly interesting setting.
>>71312794
Yeah I don't get it either.
>>71319824
>Is wall-e actually good? Actually, maybe I have seen the incredibles when it came out but I hardly remember it. Pixar to me is basically toy story and bug's life. Is there anything else worth watching past the incredibles?
Wall-E is very forgettable beyond the amerifat jokes.
Up is good, Inside Out has its points, Monsters University is surprisingly decent for a prequel, and if you ignore the rest no big deal.
This ranking is indisputable, if you dispute it then you are wrong.
1. Wall-E
2. Ratatouille
3. The Incredibles
4. Toy Story
5. Monter's Inc
6. Toy Story 2
7. Finding Nemo
8. Toy Story 3
9. Up
10. A Bug's Life
11. Cars
12. Monster's University
13. Brave
N+1: Cars 2
>>71320122
Oh and Ratatouille is visually excellent with a cast that has no missed notes. Try not to take it too seriously.
>>71311982
Raise UP way, WAY the fuck higher, and put Toy Story 3 where Up is now, and I'll agree
>>71320264
Up is super overrated. Everything interesting in it happens in the first 10 minutes, and if you subtracted those 10 minutes from the movie it'd be as trite and forgettable as a Disney Movie from the 70s.
>>71320264
t. Bad taste
>>71320365
BUT
IT'S
A
TALKING
DOG
>>71316070
fixed
>GOD TIER
>>Toy Story
>>Finding Nemo
>>The Incredibles
>GREAT TIER
>>Monsters Inc
>>Wall-E
>>Toy Story 3
>>Up
>GOOD Tier
>>A Bug's Life
>>Ratatouille
>>Toy Story 2
>Shit Tier
>>Cars
>>Cars 2
>>Monsters University
>>Brave
>>Inside Out
>>Finding Dory
>>71312592
This anon has great taste
>>71320365
I feel Up is super UNDER-rated, personally.
It's probably the closest Pixar ever comes to true Kino.
Every other movie they make, while good to great, is still influenced or initiated on some level by marketing and comercialism. Everything up to and including Wall-E is hugely influenced by how many toys they can sell, and how broad they can paint the story to make it appeal to a larger audience. They still do a great job and they're still great movies, but you can smell the McDonalds on a couple of them more than others.
In Up, there's almost nothing like that. The dogs, maybe? And they feel out of place.
Like, look at the basic premise for each movie
>Toys are alive
>The ant and the grasshopper parable retold
>Why monsters are in your closet
>A superhero family discovers itself
>Talking cars
>A talking rat
>Robots!
>An old man whose lost touch with his emotions must learn to let go of his late wife
Like, it's clear, on a base level, that the STORY and the themes of Up drove the production, as opposed to the other way around. On a conceptual level, it's super daring for Pixar to greenlight a project like it, and I feel it doesn't get enough credit for that.
>>71320701
Inside Out was Great tier. Not even memeing, also
>Wall-E not god tier
>>71320754
I can't help but notice you couldn't come up with a single reason that Up is actually good, all you did was try to discredit all the actually good movies Pixar made by saying they are commercials for toys. A very hollow form of criticism that doesn't actually require you to do any real analysis. You just make vague accusations about artistic integrity in some kind of appeal to sentimentality.
Yet it remains that Up is a dull, uninspired movie and the only compelling piece of it is the main character's backstory summed up in a 7~ minute montage. Unless you want to talk about the deep themes of a dog shouting SQUIRREL or a fat little boy being endearingly obnoxious.
>>71315242
I agree with this.
>>71319525
>Are Marlin and Nemo featured in it or just a beginning/end scene?
They're in it all the way through.
>>71319849
>Bugs Life 7/10
I agree, but I preferred it when it was called the Magnificent Seven/7 samurai, they did a pretty good job remaking it for kids though.
>>71321074
Does Nemo sound jarringly different?
>mfw I kinda liked Monsters University
Up was awful. The first 10 minutes were good but everything after that was garbage.
>>71321103
>not the 7 amigos
>>71321198
Not really, actually. Unless you obsess over minor details but I thought it sounded fairly similar.
>>71320968
I'm not saying the other movies are bad, or even that they're toy adverts really (even though three of them are literally, unabashedly throwing a lampshade on the fact that they very clearly ARE toy adverts)
I'm just saying UP was a surprisingly grown-up movie from what is ostensibly a kids movie company, and it would be nice to get more like it.
Whether or not it succeeded as a movie is largely beside the point, but for what its worth, I disagree, I thought everything about it was great, and it managed to avoid a lot of the pitfalls other Pixar movies have fallen to. It doesn't drop dead in its tracks during the second act the same way A Bugs Life or Finding Nemo do, for example.
Also there's PLENTY to talk about conceptually and thematically about the kid and the talking dog
But that's, like, my opinion, man.
>>71311982
>> wall-e best pixar
>> not ratatouille
kek
>>71320918
Inside Out is far from Great.
Wall-E is excellent but the ending was somewhat weak.
>>71321270
I just actually analysed the movie recently and he has a very distinct whiny voice.
That's interesting that Nemo and Marlin are in it though, will pirate.
>>71315242
incredibles is pure kino you pleb
>>71321234
this
not sure why its so highly rated
>>71321776
My guess? Dog lovers.
>>71321776
Why do you hate it?
>>71315909
Completely right
Good job anon
>All this love for Wall-E
I'm so glad
I remember when the movie first came out. There was SO MUCH anal ache over the idea that people could pollute the earth and abandon it
>tfw you had a friend who's dad literally worked as a Pixar animator
>tfw you got to watch the movies a couple days before they were released because they got to bring home copies as long as they signed a nondisclosure agreement
too bad the his brother was a shit
toy story 10/10
bugs life 6/10
monsters inc 8/10
monsters university 7/10
toy story 2 9/10
toy story 3 8/10
cars 1 5/10
cars 2 7/10
brave 3/10
good dinosaur 7.5/10
finding nemo 9/10
incredibles 9/10
finding dory 7/10
Wall E - 9/10
Up 9/10
Ratatouille 9/10
Inside Out 6/10
>>71315242
This is objectively true
Wall-E is one of the few movies I ever fell asleep watching in the theatres. Complete garbage.
Not Brave-tier garbage but still bad. Shit taste, OP.
>>71320169
Finding Nemo is better than toy story or monsters Inc.
>>71315909
how the fuck is cars2 better than brave, brave wasn't great but it wasn't a shitshow like cars2
why do yall fuckers love nemo and the incredibles so much, they're good but awkward at certain points
>>71317778
t. HAL
wall-e is the most human motherfucker with a heart so big that he can fuck literal robots into women
>>71317996
what do you mean by download? if you have a torrent could you pass it along
>>71322781
What I meant is that Wall E is a beta cuck (I apologize) and that makes it hard for the majority to relate to him.
"Ugh, 'EEEVA EEVA' so annoying"
>>71323054
true, but hes a disney cuck who pines after the women who initially spurns him. its heartwarming
eeva, eeva was definitely annoying but him and the cockroach was KINO
>>71323175
Jesus, how could I forget about the cockroach.
Watching WallE tomorrow now.
WALL-E is amazing but Ratatouille is still the top kino of 3d animation. Nothing has approached it since.
The perfect animated movie.
Man the animation just keeps getting better and better. Just saw Finding Dori the other day and was in awe the entire time at the animation and quality of such. I don't even think I remember the story. Are they using supercomputers or some shit?
>>71323662
>impressed by hair graphics
Kill yourself
>>71323849
are you serious?
What's with all these Ratatouillefags?
I mean I'm not contrarian enough to say that it's not good or even great but I dont consider it Wall-e or Incredibles tier. Maybe Equal with Toy Story 2/3.
>>71311982
Toss and scramble me, Seattle.
>>71317401
when I went to go see it with my parents when it came out they were shitting on it because it felt like climate change propaganda
still never felt the vibe, since it was pretty obvious it was about reckless consumption
>>71312592
>>71324060
When anything goes over 8/10 it's opinion.
My top 3 are WallE, Ratatouille, and Bug's Life just because of the subject matter.
I enjoyed Wall-E until the second half. The humans just looked out of place altogether, I'm fine with how the plot went, but something about their design pissed me off, they looked rather DreamWorks-ish and didn't click with the rest of the style.
I'd say for my top 3: Incredibles > Finding Nemo > Toy Story3
>/v/eddit is too pleb for Ratatouille
Christ, no wonder this board is in such a state.
>>71324060
>What's with all these Ratatouillefags?
I don't know what you're talking about m8, Ratatouille has always been rated highly in Pixar threads.
>>71324710
did you even browse the thread
>>71311982
Inside out ain't too bad
>>71311982
>Cars 2 on the same level as anything else
Otherwise I agree
>>71312430
Cars was easily the weakest of Pixar's early movies, eclipsed only by Cars 2 which was utterly horrible.
idk why people shit on Toy Story 3 so much, its definitely one of pixar's best desu
>>71325878
It less effectively retread the themes of 2 and didn't effectively present its new themes. It mostly banked on the collective good will toward the franchise.
>>71311982
Up is a piece of shit. I loathe that crap movie.
>>71311982
>hurrdurr brave is bad meme
all these butthuret fedoras in this thread who gets triggered when the females does any thing more than being a sidekick to the main characters
Inside Out is actually top tier, along with incredibles and ratatouille
>>71321210
I really like it desu
>>71311982
>everyone jerking off over The Incredibles
i will never understand this. imo one of their weakest efforts.
>>71327995
Why?
>>71319676
>wasted the premise and opportunity
I thought they've done a great job introducing the world inside the head and explaining how each of them play a part with it. I don't see how they wasted their opprtunity on storyline, growing up is the most important and relatable themes. Seeing the thought process behind it to me was entertaining, even though it was fictional.
>>71327995
Imo you should kys
>>71316105
wow. i actually agree with this.
thoughts on my list?
>>71312091
>Ratatouille is the worst.
I should kill you where you stand.
>>71311982
Honestly i would say bump up brave by a tier. It wasn't a great movie, certainly not what we have come to expect from pixar but it also wasn't a bad movie like cars, or monster U
I unironically think that Wall-E is the greatest animated film of all time. It's not the Pixar movie that I enjoy watching the most though.
That would be [spolier]Up.[/spoiler]
>>71311982
monsters inc, toy story, ratatouille and wall-e are some of the greatest movies ever made
>>71312113
First Cars is comfy.
Second Cars is pure shit though
>all these fucking plebs sleeping on Bug's Life
It's quite literally top 3 pixarkino.
>>71312975
How can Wall-E be a masterpiece if the second half sucked?
