These are quite possibly the most overrated films ever. On /tv/ and in general. Everyone with a brain knows only the first one is good, and its perfect. The rest is overrated for nostalgia and has aged terribly.
FOTR 10\10
TTT 6.5/10
ROTK 3.5/10
someone posted in your thread :^)
They gutted the book, making an action movie for 15-25 year olds. Tolkien became devoured by his popularity and absorbed by the absurdity of the time. The gap widened between the beauty, the seriousness of the work, and what it has become is beyond me. This level of marketing reduces to nothing the aesthetic and philosophical significance of this work.
The chasm between the beauty and seriousness of the work, and what it has become, has overwhelmed me. The commercialization has reduced the aesthetic and philosophical impact of the creation to nothing.
>no Tom Bombadill
DROPPED
>these are the most overrated films ever
>one of them is perfect though
great thread
>>71297408
FOTR > LOTR (1978) > ROTK > TTT
>>71297510
>babby cant read
the trilogy a shit
>>71297408
Kill yourself fampai
>>71297408
You're a fucking faggot OP. The true Patrician ranking is as follows.
Theatrical Cut:
>Fellowship 8.5/10
>Two Towers 9.5/10
>Return of the King 9/10
Extended Cut:
>Fellowship 9/10
>Two Towers 8.5/10
>Return of the King 10/10
>>71297679
holy shit what a terrible opinion
>KINOxD
You know nothing about film though.
>>71297408
>>71298038
>its another animeposter
Yeah pretty much but the sequels are both the same mediocre quality.
>>71297408
I agree, except for FOTR being perfect. I'd give it a 9/10
>>71298038
fuck outta here weeb
>>71297408
Here's your (you)
>>71297679
but that's the generic pleb ranking. "MUH ACTION SCENES MUH BATTLES" taking precedence over the "boring" first movie.
true patricians appreciate fellowship because of its smaller scale, use of practical effects, and cohesive storyline. also for boromir. there were saving graces in the later movies like theoden or frodo and sam since their storyline was very well done, but there was too much ridiculousness like gimili and legolas' characterization, elves at helm's deep, the ghost army, the witch king breaking gandalf's staff, the CGI in general (gollum excluded), etc.
fellowship is the only one that had the whole package.
>>71298368
>true patricians
They wouldn't be watching garbage like this.
very nice >13:33:33 though
I'm impressed
>>71298236
get some taste like these anons.
>>71298167
>>71298185
>>71298368
>>71298414
No hes right true patricians appreciate fellowship, as they should you tryhard
>>71298482
>you tryhard
You're a real pleb aren't you kiddo?
>>71298562
No one even said you have to watch lotr that anon just pointed out patricians know the first one is the only good one
