Why didn't Elrond just push Isildur off the edge?
Because Elves are little moralfags
Why did Sauron put the ring on his finger instead of his... more private... finger?
>>69751498
Elrond was literally a beta manlet cuck. Isildur would have #rekt him
>>69751657
because then someone would have cut that off of him instead
>>69751498
It would have started a war between the elves and men.
It's actually implied that Elrond is in love with Isildur.
>>69751801
When was this explained in the movies.
>>69751769
fair point
>>69751801
But wouldn't it be worth it since the Ring was destroyed? Ending all evil.
>>69751801
lol nobody was there and there would be no evidence
>>69751905
They both go up and only Elrond comes back, wouldn't that be suspicious? What's the point of winning if you incite a war between elves and men?
Plus this shit didn't happen in the books.
>>69751905
Destroying the Ring doesn't end all evil, it just sends Sauron.
>>69751911
In the books this confrontation never happens, Isildur just keeps it and that's that, they don't saunter on over to the volcano for a dramatic scene. In fact the issue of what to do with the One was probably going to be an open one until Isildur went and got himself killed and the Ring lost.
>>69751498
Isildur was the king of Gondor and killing him, even if it was to get rid of the ring would have started a war.
>>69751498
>>69751498
Isn't Isildur like his great-great-great-great-great-grandnephew?
>>69751498
Because LoTR is garbage written for children. Watch some adult fantasy like GoT, my man.
>>69751498
>blames the weakness of men for not destroying the ring
>too fucking weak to kill the weak man and destroy the ring himself
i fucking hate those self-righteous elves cunts
>>69754093
you tried
>>69751498
Númenóreans like Isildur were 7 foot tall killing machines. Wimpy ass little elf bitch couldn't have even knocked him off balance.
Because they were lovers
Its not even subtext, its painfully obvious
>>69754475
>tv and film board
>talks about books
fuck off, nerd with your numenoshit
>>69754577
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=R9j7LFHmkO0
>>69751564
edgelord nigger spotted.
>>69754475
elrond was even taller you cuck
Short answer is that Isildur would have put him on his ass and he knew it, OP. Isildur would have kicked his ass without the ring, Elrond had no idea what he was capable of with it and didn't wanna find out.
>>69755091
>the extended editions count
cut for a reason you faggot
>>69753858
Yes; a descendant of Elrond's brother Elros.
Arwen and Aragorn were 1st cousins, many generations removed.
>>69752579
kek
>>69755616
lanklet please go
>>69751498
Nobody can resist the ring. He would have tried to take it for himself if it got that far
>>69754477
in the books? because there's nothing in the movies
