This was funny.
Nah he didn't deserve it.
>>69275377
He did.
>I love you snow
>Snow you can't do this, muh family!
>Die Snow
>omg ur alive >:(
rippy-roo
>>69275197
fuck Olly. god what a little bitch
>>69275197
Jon never explained to him that it was his waifu he shot through the heart, did he?
>>69275377
Committing mutiny against your Lord Commander because you're too much of a fuccboi to get over your feelings and do the necessary thing is most definitely grounds for hanging.
>killing a kid you saved just because he shared a stab
proof that jon is a shit leader, this show is a meme and i dont even need to download the new ep cuz you spoiled it already. and not really spoiled so much as save me 50 mins of filler to get to the "point"
>>69275642
>you saved
He showed up one day with a sob story and they started feeding him.
>>69275197
>Be Olly
>Live a simple life farming with your Mom and Dad
>Wildings come and kill and eat them.
>You go to Castle Black
>They take you in and they too hate the Wildings.
>The Lord Commander lets the Wildings get away with murder
>You kill the Lord Commander.
>Lord Commander comes back
>You're hanged
>The whole time you're just a kid and your life was taken away from you and you don't fully comprehend it
>we should be happy
>>69275197
Even better because Jon using the short-drop hanging method means that Olly, Alliser and the two dipshits on the left got strangled and tortured to death for like five minutes. The show cut all that out, but it had to happen.
>>69275642
>shared a stab
he was an accomplice. He conspired against hm. He stuck a piece of sharp metal into his body.
There's little no way to sugar coat it or diminish it. That's straight up murder
>>69275562
SHOT THROUGH THE HEART
AND YOU'RE TOO LATE
>>69275197
GET REKT
>>69275642
>you saved
Nigga what?
>>69275878
Fuck you. Olly got dealt a shit hand in life, and you know it.
None of them deserved it. Jon Snow is alive now. It's a life for a life. Jon Snow only has one life. He got his life back.
>>69275197
>tfw Olly dies while Tormund gets to live
>>69275819
>a hard life justifies murder
>>69275825
Apparently it takes like 20 minutes, pretty miserable way to get executed
I would say that the guys the Mountain was straight up murdering for practice were probably more tragic than this little shit.
How did Howland Fucking Reed get stabbed through the heart with a sword, get up a few minutes later and kill a guy, only to then walk around and begin examining bodies?
Why is nobody on the internet talking about this? Was the fart a distraction for this?
>>69275955
This.
But Tormund is le funny big man!
Olly got a shit end in life. We all know it. Little fucker was just a kid who's family was slaughtered and eaten.
>>69275377
Jon did what needed to be done. Fuck off, cuck.
>>69275955
Fuck off back to /r9k/ and drink that cup of bleach I just poured for you.
Olly was a rotten little shit and a traitor to the Night's Watch and the Realm. He deserved every inch of that rope and every horrible second of agony Jon gave him.
This whole "Olly was okay!" meme needs to die. The "this show is a meme" meme needs to die. Really, you just need to die too.
>>69275940
GET
REKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKT (pronounce all the k's n ur hed uf aggo)t
>>69276069
Crannogmen are half lizard, they've probably got like three hearts or something.
>>69275946
sure bud. Except Thorne admitted he'd do it all again
<----/got/ thread
>>69275998
Man. They should have really extended the episode 20 minutes then.
>>69276069
The whole Tower of Joy fight was pretty dumb, but not as dumb as that fucking fart. Thanks D&D!
>>69276193
There's a dozen. Deal with it, normie.
>>69276198
>Man. They should have really extended the episode 20 minutes then
I dunno if your being sarcastic or not, obviously no one wants to sit and watch that, just saying that's how long it takes
>>69275197
ayy
you fucking ruined it for me. i saw the screenshots before i watched it
>>69276294
>normie
>>>/r9k/
>>69276328
Well, it would have been more interesting than all the Dany "i'm the mother of dragons!!!" nutsack drama for the 20th time.
>>69275955
Only Norwegian on the show. He has to live.
>>69275991
So you admit that Jon's hard life doesn"t justify him killing Olly?
>>69276349
>going on /tv/
>not wanting to get spoiled
Hello, faggot!
>>69276482
I never claimed it did. His murder justified the executions, not "I never knew my real mommy."
>>69276618
No. You actually did. You said:
>a hard life justifies murder
>>69276816
Well played, with a 5% chance you're actually this new.
>>69275850
Fuckin kek
>>69275819
Olly is just a representation of how terrorism has dehumanized an innocent child into a back stabbing cunt and finally gets killed by his own beliefs and thirst for vengence just because of the amount of hatred that could never be controlled.
>>69275642
Did you not see the first epsiode of the show, it literally opened with a lesson about justice and execution.
If Ned taught him anything it would have been that.
>>69276897
>I have no answer
>>69275197
it actually was kind of funny how they showed multiple closeups of the faces
>>69276897
Just don't reply. Why pretend to be retarded?
>>69277162
She tempted me again but I'm done playing with her.
>>69276989
Yeah they've been getting pretty overt with the parallels between him and Ned. In last week's episode when flashback Ned was training the one dude he said the exact same thing Jon said when he was training Olly.
>>69275197
Aliser Thorne looked like fucking Bubbles from TPB at the end there lmao
wait a minute was Ned using ice in that flashback? he didnt have the sword yet? coz that thing he was using looked like a normal sword.
>>69276112
>accepting rapist refugees into your lands
you're the cuckboi here, nigger
>>69277335
He wasn't using Ice. Ice is probably pretty fucking useless in the field, its huge and likely won't have an advantage vs. the sword in the morning.
>>69277342
It's fine, they're white.
>>69275642
>>69276329
someone shop the painted stone eyes over Olly's
>>69277390
>greatswords have no advantage in the field
nigger
You may have a point about vs dawn though, I know it cuts through regular steel, but I don't remember if it cut through Valyrian steel.
>>69275850
You cant even get the fucking lyrics right, wow.
>>69277464
Is that RL Stien?
>>69277342
Literally described the whole of the nights watch
>>69277876
No, it's RL Stine.
>>69276150
The lack of replies against this post proves how just it really is
>>69277948
Give that meme a rest already.
>>69277948
I agree
> bad men eat my parents so I need to kill my only friend
If you play stupid games
>>69277471
>I"ll post this to Reddit!
>>69277342
They're all northmen though
It's basically as retarded as the Britons fighting the Irish, when really, everyone is white and should unify against the fucking shitskin hordes
>>69277948
Nice reverse meme, ignorant faggot.
>Le kid who's family was just slaughtered deserves!
>>69276198
Someone please make a webm that just has an extended scene of olly hanging from the rope and flailing, with the occasional (farts) subtitle. At the end it can say FUCK YOU OLLIE in big letters
>>69278432
Le upboat! Leddit silver!
>>69275377
>He didnt deserve it
He attempted to kill possibly the only person able to fight the undead
>>69275197
Jesus Christ. D&D have no fucking class!
Why the fuck can't I find a decent torrent?
>literally nobody character they tried to make self important for a grand total of 5 minutes of screentime
>Dead within 5 episodes
>>69275819
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mmp3esRz4Wk
>No one boils a potaytoe better than yer mum!
I think the fart was funnier tho
>>69278709
cause you're a retard...
>>69278709
it doesn't exist
>>69278801
All the ones are tpb are fake, torrentz is basically worthless now
I almost feel bad for the little shit.
The wildlings WERE fucking shitheads who terrorized, flayed, mutilated, killed innocent people, and they killed his parents right in front of him. The wild shits, including Jon's waifu, did attack the wall, and get a bunch of night's watchmen killed over nothing.
Even if they're honorary white men, they still were fucking shit heads, and I can see from the kid's view that Jon was a traitor and weak for allowing their enemies to just walk through the fucking gates.
Him killing Jon avenging his parents was probably the "right" thing to do, and now look at him, he's dead for nothing, merely for having just and noble intentions of revenge and honor.
Like I said, feel bad for the kid. Even though his death was necessary to send a message and stop divisiveness I still feel bad for him.
>>69275642
>>69275642
>>69275642
>>69275642
>>69278827
thepiratebay . se/torrent/14567544/Game.of.Thrones.S06E03.HDTV.x264-KILLERS[ettv]
>>69278827
kat.cr scrub, it dethroned tpb forever ago.
>>69275940
Nothing worse than disloyalty. The Goddamn wall was built to protect men from the Others. And that is what Jon's actions did.
>>69278885
this
>>69278827
literally search "game of thrones s06e03" you fucking moron
>>69278004
>>69278397
Notice lack of actual argument against my statement.
>>69278875
you realize every other comment on r/gameofthrones is "fuck olly". Olly haters are literally REDD-IT.
>>69277342
This so much. Olly was a savior of Westeros fighting against the foreign rapefugee hordes of wildniggers.
>>69279040
>you realize every other comment on r/gameofthrones
Of course not, I don't visit that website.
>>69278827
http://www.projectwatchfree.tv/serie/game-of-thrones/season-6/game-of-thrones-6x03-s06e03-online-free-stream/
Go here for every show the night it comes on
>>69275197
rip potato lad
>>69276816
>a hard life justifies murder
Thats fucking retarded and doesnt apply to Snow at all.
He got fucking murdered and he is the lord commander. I am very confident that mutiny is grounds for execution.
>>69278004
Not an argument
>>69279121
so you know nothing of them then
>>69279040
Well look at the pot calling the kettle nigger
>>69275819
fuck olly mang
>>69279040
thanks for confirming my post
>>69279474
>pretending to be the person I replied to when you're obviously not
>>69275819
hey olly. do more song covers maybe you'll hit 1k subs
Arthur Dayne definitely beat Dark Souls on NG+++
>>69275377
You have no honor, cunt
>>69277166
gotta love how so many people around the world have that disgusting hair .png on a 4chan meymeys folder ready to paste it on whatever they can
Soon he'll be a baked potato lad.
>Being executed for murdering a man who's still alive
wew
>>69279834
>that disgusting hair
That's the joke, gaiafag.
Glad he's dead, not because I think he deserved it or whatever the fuck. Just an annoying character, glad he won't take up screentime in the future.
>>69280180
He deserved it, but I see your point. I didn't really give two shits about him and got annoyed every time the show tried to force his story down your throat.
>>69280064
>letting 4 conspirators who are more than willing to execute your leader roam around the walls like nothing happened
This would be like Abraham Lincoln surviving his assassination and inviting John Wilkes Booth over to dinner the very next day.
>>69276618
Technically attempted murder, as he isn't dead.
>>69280392
Keep your friends close and your enemies closer!
>>69280404
I thought something like this. Interesting question whether it counts as murder. Usually if someone's alive now, that means they weren't dead in the past. But if someone can really die and then come back to life, then they might really have been murdered even if they're no longer dead. (Sort of like something really could have been robbery, rather than just attempted robbery, even if the victim has the stolen goods in their possession again). Any lawyers here that could clear this up?
>>69280064
Attempted murder is still a crime. You think someone shooting the president, who then walked it off wouldn't face charges?
>>69280560
>Any lawyers here that could clear this up?
It was murder.
>>69280628
yes, of course it's a crime no matter what, but was it murder or attempted murder? these might have different sentences, e.g.
>>69280628
It wasn't attempted murder. It was murder, they killed him.
Then he came back to life, thus voiding the murder. Really the only thing they should be punished for is slander for calling him a traitor and making that little wooden sign.
>>69280560
That's an entirely philosophical question, I'm not sure how a lawyer would help you here.
At bare minimum that would be considered attempted murder, and I've never heard of a legal system that knowingly gives you a second chance for that kind of shit if you didn't succeed on your first try.
>>69275197
I wanted to see is head smashed in like in Irreversible.
>Olly got killed
Thank you. That's all I wanted to see. I don't even feel like watching the rest of the episode.
>>69280684
>murder or attempted murder might have different sentences
Completely. But in this context it's mutiny, which is invariably going to be a death sentence. I only see this distinction mattering if it were civilians involved, and even then I'm pretty sure that the penal codes in Westeros are going to call for execution.
>>69276426
>tfw he wasn't played by Svend Karlsen
>>69280560
Yeah, we learned about this in Resurrection Law class. For it to be murder, the defendant must have (1) the requisite mens rea (in this case, there was obviously purpose, so it's irrelevant) AND (2) must have actually killed someone per Model Penal Code 210.2. Given that the resurrection removes the second element, they could not be convicted of murder. The best they could do is attempted murder. It'd be like if you tried to kill someone, but instead fucked up, and your victim ended up on a ventilator for the rest of their lives after being technically "dead" for a few minutes.
t. law student
>>69280699
>Then he came back to life, thus voiding the murder.
They didn't "void" anything. They killed him successfully. It was a murder. His condition changed, but that didn't go back in time and erase their act.
> Really the only thing they should be punished for is slander
Even if you were right about the murder, which you aren't, they'd have committed assault, attempted murder, conspiracy, treason.
>>69280699
>>69280722
Suppose they intended for things to go exactly as they did: stab him a bunch of times, let him be dead for a few days, then have him raised from the dead. Would that even be attempted murder? Maybe just assault?
I think if there were real cases where people come back to life, we'd want to distinguish between murder and, say, perma-murder, where the victim dies and stays dead permanently. But then I wonder if our current laws and moral evaluations of murder are really about perma-murder.
>>69280699
Incorrect.
Definition of murder:
the unlawful premeditated killing of one human being by another.
Definition of Kill:
cause the death of (a person, animal, or other living thing).
Definition of Death: Irreversible cessation of circulatory and respiratory functions and of all functions of the entire brain, including the brain stem.
Irreversible being the key point here.
>>69280699
>thus voiding the murder
No, the death was voided. They still committed the ACT of murder. The act was not voided. They are still guilty.
>>69278358
The White Walkers are whiter, fag.
>>69275197
Vikings is way better than this retarded show t B honest.
First season only good season.
>>69280699
>then he came back to life, thus voiding the murder
>and then Tyrone bought a Schwinn, thus voiding the robbery
>>69280684
>>69280699
attempted murder is the same as murder sentencing wise today. even in ancient civilizations consequentialism is pretty rare.
also, arguing that him getting better voids the crime is like arguing that you're not guilty of assault because they didn't catch you until he recovered.
I still don't get what the point is of Jon being able to warg.
It's like that particular trait is completely dropped and ignored.
I used to think it will become relevant when the dragons get delivered to the wall at the very end and Jon gets to be one of the rare people who can warg into one but the show is nearing the end and he has no practice with warging and it doesn't seem like he will at all.
>>69280960
How are you this retarded? Attempted murder is nowhere near murder in sentencing.
>>69277390
>>69277794
Ice was a ceremonial sword. It wasn't intended to be used for battle. GRRM said Ned didn't use it during the rebellion.
>>69280871
>>69280889
Oh cool, thanks. So death is, at least according to the law, not something that someone could come back from, even in principle.
>>69280889
>Irreversible being the key point here.
this is just playing semantics. it's obviously not a concrete definition. people can be medically dead and be revived.
>mfw seeing the life drain from his eyes after he stood there putting on a sourpuss face
Fucking best episode right here cause of that shit. God what a little shit he was, so satisfying to see him die like a bitch.
>>69278885
>>69278916
>using reborn-botnet kat
You're barely above the tpb-fags.
>>69281048
No, they could. If I shot you in the head, and you were clinically dead for a few minutes until some paramedics revived you or something, I could not be found guilty of murder. You must die and stay dead for it to be murder.
>>69280960
Even in the clusterfuck of a draconian law system that we have in the US, attempted murder is nowhere fucking close to actual murder. Attempted murder doesn't carry the death penalty.
>>69280949
You think that's a Schwinn!
>>69280871
>>69280889
>>69281048
Haha, another thought: has anyone ever tried to argue down a murder charge to attempted murder because for all we know, there might be a miracle and the victim might still come back to life, and then it won't have been irreversible?
>>69281063
The most tension I've felt all season was when I thought Jon was going to bitch out after seeing that bitchy angst face. I've been itching to see that little fuck executed ever since he robbed us of pale redhead tits.
>>69281057
>this is just playing semantics
Welcome to Law.
>people can be medically dead and be revived.
People can be declared dead. That declaration is voided if they are somehow revived, however.
>>69281177
I'm sure at some point in the hundreds of years of common law jurisprudence, someone has argued something like this. The most common analogy today would be a case where there is strong evidence that the defendant killed the victim, but no body can be found. In that case, the prosecutor would have to prove that the person is actually dead somehow.
>>69281177
As someone pointed out earlier, Murder and attempted murder carry a similar sentence. If you are trying to defend a murder charge, you are much better off proving that there was no intent to kill and getting it knocked down to manslaughter.
>>69281022
attempted murder only has lesser possible sentences because it is a broader definition i.e. getting caught after the planning stages but not far enough into execution where the victim was in immediate danger would be considered attempted murder. When it goes far enough though, like being stabbed 10 times, it would be charged at the highest degree which will carry the same sentence as actual murder, with only a few exceptions. i.e. some states will not allow the death penalty for attempted murder, while others will.
>>69281387
And is there some 'attempted' correlate of manslaughter? Like causing someone some harm and almost killing them but not quite? Because then you could combine these strategies: show that there was no intent and maybe not even death either.
Just to be clear, I'm not trying to come up with real legal arguments.
>>69281473
It's unconstitutional to have the death penalty for anything other than murder (Kennedy v. Louisiana, 554 U.S. 407 (2008)). I personally think that's a dramatic difference in sentencing. And while it's true that some states have a similar sentencing structure for attempted murder, in practice, I doubt that California (to use an example) imposes a life sentence for attempted murder very often compared to actual murder.
>>69281241
it's not voided, they just didn't stay dead. they'll still tell you that you were dead for x minutes
have to hand it to the old knight cunt
he stuck to his convictions throughout the story
lead like a man, fought like a man, and in the end died like a man
>>69281497
You could not attempt manslaughter, because manslaughter by definition doesn't allow for an intentional killing. You must have intent to kill to attempt to do it, of course. Manslaughter will, at most, be a reckless state of mind. You could not attempt to "recklessly" (the most common mental standard) kill anyone. Thus, you could never attempt manslaughter.
>>69281703
Right, but is there some related crime of unintentionally causing serious harm but not quite death?
>>69281497
Not really, for something to be attempted, there needs to be intent.
I get what you are saying though, the charge for something like that would be Negligence causing grievous bodily harm.
>>69281749
Just injuring someone would be battery, in varying degrees.
>>69281630
>It's unconstitutional to have the death penalty for anything other than murder
the specific case law established there was that states cannot impose a death penalty for the rape of children. it doesn't mean that it's unconstitutional to do it for other crimes (even though it makes it likely that the supreme court would rule against any other crime as well) and in fact is still allowed for treason. also, it federal law still permits it for attempted murder of certain victims as well as large drug traffickers.
https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/18/3591
as for california, that place is fucked. i personally know a case where a 25 year sentence was given for threatening with a firearm (although they were held up in their home) and ended peacefully. i don't doubt they'd give life for a severe enough case of attempted murder.
Westeros: Europe
Castle Black: Germany
Wildings: Muslim refugees
Jon Snow: Merkel
Olly: /pol/
>>69281666
It is from a legal standpoint.
Legally, Death is permanent.
>>69282318
that's stupid. /pol/ would never hesitate to kill merkel. and the wildlings are more like an enemy in war than a bunch of sandniggers who take over another country with that country's consent.
>>69282318
White walkers are Muslim refugees.
Wildlings are Christian Syrian refugees; they're Savages but they're running away from even worse Savage's.
>>69275819
When you put it like that.
>>69275197
Wow, they showed a reaction shot of a child character getting hanged.
This show is so edgy and mature.
>>69275377
He deserved it, but his desire for vengeance to kill Snow and the people that killed his parents and ate them was justified.
The other hanged fuckbois were not.
>>69280392
This. Even if what happened didn't happen the way they just kind of Jon chalantly let these people who quite literally murdered in cold blood their commanding officer just take over is horse shit. No one argued, no one fought, no one even objected.
These people were perfectly content to let a guy who decided "I don't like my commander and his choices I'll murder him." Run the show.
Like what the fuck at least give command to someone who isn't a cowardly back stabbing murderous whoreson
>>69283354
> complete destruction looms
> don't have nearly enough numbers to fight what's coming
> only chance to survive is to team up with your former enemies
But muh personal grudges sempai!
>>69275642
>shared a stab
jon just thanked him by sharing a noose
