Why is Elementary so much better than Sherlock? Is it because Brits cant make interesting TV shows?
>>69144451
>Elementary
>good
I'm not fan of neither of those shows, Sherlock was pretty meh, but last seson was bad, but Elementary was simply terrible from the beginning.
Elementary=Detective show about a detective
Sherlock=Idiots writing about someone smart who happens to be a detective
because in elementary Sherlock is actually a fucking human being and Watson isn't a useless pile of shit
plus better Moriarty
>>69144628
i hate how they turned Moriarty into a jaredletojoker in Sherlock
>>69144597
>I'm not fan of neither of those shows
So you like them both?
>>69144699
I was embarrassed for that actor. He wasn't bad, he just was given a shitty direction. I felt sorry for him, his family probably watched his performance.
He was far more enjoyable in Locke.
>>69144628
>better Moriarty
NO!
Moriarty is also Irene
A lot of Elementary is a cluster fuck but it does find itself.
Elementary
>actual detective show
>proper cast with human drama, well orchestrated logical detective cases and constant plot development
Sherlock
>glamour MTV tier show with fabulous gay drug addict
>>69144794
>Moriarty is also Irene
Didn't have a problem with that, considering Irene is just a character appearing in only one of the Sherlock Holmes stories.
Better than the spy shite they pulled in Sherlock in my opinion to be honest famalam
>>69144451
Better actors and less memey.
>muh mind palace.
>>69144451
>american Sherlock
Elementary is House MD rip-off stealing Conan Doyle names.
Sherlock is Monk rip-off stealing Conan Doyle names.
Better rip-off wins.
>>69144872
But he's English.
![img10[1].jpg](https://i.imgur.com/itlC1dv.jpg "img10[1].jpg")
>>69144872
Its not like British is worthy of looking down on it. They still didnt manage to make anything even near the level of Soviet adaptation.
At least the British Poirot shows are ok.
>>69144451
Sherlock is so insensitive.
At least we now have a proud muslim mayor in London.
>>69144834
Well yes but being better than Sherlock isn't really difficult, It's like being called the gentlest rapist.
>>69144451
Lucy Liu looks more as drug addict than MC does. Asians dont age well.
>>69145102
>implying if she was lying in your bed naked, you'd go sleep in the bathtub
Anon, please.
>>69144451
I hate this show, the science and writing in it is just fucking terrible.
Guy gets crushed by something thrown outta a window on top of him.
Character:
>Their knowledge of physics to do something like that would have to be considerable!
Bullshit. Do you think niggas study physics when dropping a ball through a hoop?
The writing in Sherlock at least made me think the writers were smarter than me.
With elementary I think of some fat neckbear who didn't even finish high school writing this.
>>69145134
Elementary writing
>proper detective stories, with motives, clues, deduction and outcomes
Sherlock
>deus ex machina ima genius it just has to be cool not gonna explain shit
>>69144628
>Sherlock is actually a fucking human being
The whole point of Sherlock Holmes is being above human beings, being superior, Sherlock is basically the proto-capeshit
>>69145134
I think you're just too stupid to understand Elementary and easily impressionable to fall for the stupid shit they pull in Sherlock.
>>69144722
I don't like them, I tolerate Sherlock a bit more.
>>69145202
Sherlock became shit when Moffat became full on delusional.
But Elementary have inconsistent stories, the deductions don't make any sense and half the time you can guess the ending of the show. Seriously Sherlock doesn't seem that smart in this show.
>>69144821
>fabulous gay drug addict
>Implying that's not what Sherlock Holmes is
>>69145302
I'm stupid because I recognize it when Sherlock says stupid shit to sound smart?
No.. my feeling...
>>69145295
Umh, no? He was a drug addict, possibly abutist, basically living in his mother basement (not litterally) and being a disgrace for his family and ACTUAL genius brother.
And both TV series in question did a point to highlight exactly this broken part of him, rather than just showing him merely an excentric.
>>69144451
Both are bad
>>69145473
Bad is better than nothing.
>>69145022
This. The Soviet series got everything right, the atmosphere is perfect.
>>69145298
fucking this
especially after the shit they pulled with "lol we won't tell you how Sherlock faked his death :)" because they wrote them self into a corner and had no fucking idea how to explain it
>>69145405
>Resolving magically every case with magic science
>Knowledge of many martial arts
>Knowledge of almost everything (Biology, chemistry, physics, etc...)
>Above normal human senses (olfactory and gustatory)
>Can achieve athletic feat easily, above average strength, above average speed
>Expert in make up and disguise
Come on dude, he was like Batman v0.10
>>69144628
/thread
>>69144628
>plus better Moriarty
//DOUBLEthread
>>69145102
>Asians dont age well.
>>69145765
![image[1].jpg](https://i.imgur.com/ZP3rhKR.jpg "image[1].jpg")
Both inferior to Caslte
>>69145953
how is she so cute?
>>69146350
Lots of plastic surgeries.
>>69145953
All of them born the same year, Ironically Julia Roberts who is not the most attractive, looks the youngest, the rest looks attractive, but aged.
I feel really bad for Pamela, she is a mess.
IMO Lucy look pretty good for a 48yo
>>69146260
Castle is the worst because the only draw of the series was whether Beckett and Castle fuck and when they did, there was no tension anymore. Moreover Castle's presence in the police is unrealistic and the character himself is annoying.
>>69147444
Castle is best since it doesnt try to be "realistic". Its exactly as the book "Castle" writes - fantastic paperback fiction for quick read.
What other show does have detective solve Star Treck murders, actual "invisible suits", non-retconed supernatural artifacts and other silly staff thats completely canon.
