Trying to find out which Star Wars movie people like better: III or VII. Just three questions. I will share final results.
https://docs.google.com/forms/d/1TL6VelhbWUCZAnF3lWUhZzlASIeEnUfQ-bEBzB_rfCg/viewform
>>68162895
neat
>>68162895
A little more info, and bumping materials:
I'd like to gain some insight as to which of these two movies the /tv/ likes better and what ages/movie preferences said choice might be associated with.
Hopefully we can see if childhood nostalgia plays a role in our decision, if liking one movie is associated with a different type of favorite movie, etc.
OP here.
Would appreciate if you could bump the thread after replying. I'll try to stay with it, though.
bump again i guess
Asking for a favorite movie is retarded, it should only be one question.
>>68163573
what do you mean?
>>68163613
I mean there is three questions and it should only be about the movie.
>>68163628
yeah what the fuck was that about, it sounds like some quackery
>>68163628
Well I want to see if there are any interesting correlations between III/VII preference and overall movie preference and age.
>>68163945
>correlations between III/VII preference and overall movie preference and age
How? Looking at the responses those selections aren't linked in any way.
What do I select for age if I am either 20, 25, 30, 35, or 40?
>>68164055
You wait a year before sitting the exam.or round up/down depending on how many days past your birthday
>>68164055
lol im a fuckin idiot. pick either group you fall in, i guess.
"Your opinion is shit."
Thanks for the cheap kek OP.
>>68164052
Seems your correct, and, what's more, some people may have thought I meant what is your favorite star wars movie.
Oh well, no harm in a little extra info. It's just one more question.
Will you shitpost once you gathered enough informations?
>>68164388
Of course
There was a thread about this earlier, the best I could explain it is:
I'm not a prequelfag. I and II are abysmal and III is very inconsistent with moments of awkward dialogue and out of place tone. But, not only do I still prefer III to VII, I like III in general. It boils down to preference. Do you prefer the technically sound but bland, or the hard to watch but with high points? The payoff of III for me makes sitting through the rest worth it, while I do not feel this way at all about TFA. I didn't hate it, but I got nothing out of it, and I always prefer imperfect but moving in some way
>>68165120
And I'm sure that some of my like for RotS is nostalgia-spurred. But the more movies I watch, the more I find myself preferring those that hit those high points, those climaxes, even if the road there is a little rocky. And ep III is no doubt more than a little rocky, but it is still something I would take over TFA
>>68165205
TFA is my least favorite of them all. I just find it useless.
>>68165429
Even if it's useless it's still a better made film than anything Lucas did with the prequels.
People only hate it on because it's a New Hope resequel.
>>68165505
That's true, and my point is that there is validity to preferring either one, and that I prefer III. I do place TFA above the rest of the prequels though
>>68165120
>>68165205
I feel the same way except I actually do hate VII, for the reasons you listed and more. I think the people who hated it have given up talking about it so you're left with the /tv/ star wars threads filled with people who really liked it or just felt it mediocre. Oh and waifufags.
>>68162895
The only real correlation is between Reddit scum and liking VII. If you chose VII kill yourself immediately or leave the board, whichever comes first.
>>68165971
I don't blame you, I just try to be more moderate and reasonable because people like this >>68166059 make it seem like only memers prefer III
>>68166059
>Liking that half hour cgi mess of a dance on mustafar.
Die in a grease fire, you slime.
>>68165120
>https://docs.google.com/forms/d/1TL6VelhbWUCZAnF3lWUhZzlASIeEnUfQ-bEBzB_rfCg/viewform
I agree with this all. VII just left me feeling numb.
>>68162895
wheres my fellow taxi driver bro at?
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=LY9vk3GqZrI
>This acting
>I can't even
I saw RotS twice I liked it so much
TFA I saw once and I lost all interest in the franchise
>>68166462
This. VII ruined the franchise irrevocably.
>>68166414
I actually liked Hayden in RotS. No doubt the lines were bad, but even in the video you posted, I'm fine with most of the lines. They fit my picture of the Anakin character, especially "what have I done?"
>>68166059
>If you chose VII kill yourself immediately
ok bye ;_;
>>68166488
The audacity of that absurd statement can not be understated.
>>68166596
>audacity
>absurd
>statement
>understatement
The Reddit levels of this absurd statement cannot be understated.
III made me chuckle at the stupidity and VII made me roll my eyes.
>>68166640
English is not first language, Sorry.
>>68166640
LOL BEST MEME EVAR
>>68166710
Your grammar was fine, he's memeing ya
Both of them were a dark mark on the great original trilogy, but VII interfered more with the original characters as well as the end result of the trilogy so it's worse in my mind
I read VII as IV and wondered how the hell you could ever choose Revenge of the Sith over A New Hope.
That being said, while The Force Awakens is garbage, it's not prequels-tier garbage. So it wins by sheer virtue of being marginally less shit.
How is this even a question?
>>68162895
My prediction is that older/more seasoned fans will prefer III to VII. VII disrespects and shits on the OT while III adds to it and completes it.
>>68166640
>>68166710
>>68166735
I'm not any of you three, but he's not meme'ing you, and foreigners should fuck off.
>>68165505
>>68162895
That's the thing that always gets me, it's always comparable to how bad the prequels were but never anything else. VII just felt like mediocre attempt at everything. Bland and to the bare minimum when it came to everything else.
The only thing it inspires to do is be a nostalgia trip for fans who want to keep star wars in a little box. Despite being that it still manages to be boring and phone it in. There were plenty of ships to choose from in the OT but now all we get are a star destroyer, xwings, and tie fighters. There are plenty of iconic aliens that have roots in the OT but now all we get is the most easily recognizable ones, who are practically memes now. Not even twileks who are usually fan favorites.
Almost every scene in it feels like I can see a group of marketers sitting at a table picking ANH apart to take out small chunks, just enough to have audiences go "oh I remember that!" and be nothing more. It's like VII is corporate marketing given form.
>>68166893
III adds to the OT a complete pile of shit.
>>68167026
Lucas understood his mythos better than JJ ever could/will.
>>68166999
Well put. Exactly how I felt.
They could've even had a lot of the fucking nostalgia wank IF they'd also genuinely added some new shit.
The X-Wings and TIEs only was just a forced joke. Why not have the old workhorse X-Wings along with something new given to the 'Resistance' like a C-Wing or something?
They even had a lot of nice practical effects and some fairly creative aliens and locations going for them, but it was buried underneath the fucking OT pandering. A shame, really.
Safe as fuck, and a missed opportunity.
>>68167054
Ahhhh, the Fransh! We need moah:
>'50s diners
>nigger frog characters
>one-off villains
>head-high sets
memes, anon xD
>>68167182
It's ok, you can just say it: you don't like Star Wars. Leave Star Wars to Star Wars fans and go watch capeshit. I'm not judging you, just leave MY franchise alone.
>>68162895
III has the better memes.
>>68166999
>>68167160
Shows that VII haters are really just manchildren upset about the lack of cool new toys.
>>68166893
III was at least so bad it's funny. VII was just boring and long
>>68167215
>I'm losing the argument, better ad hom!
I do like Star Wars, friendo.
You like the worst films though, made twenty years after the fact by a filmmaker who ran away with the IP from the people who kept him from ruining it in 1977. ;)
>>68167279
Is that all you have to say? These seem like valid concerns to me. TFA did so little that I have to wonder if JJ Abrams can really consider himself an artist. The cantina scene was just despicable. No skilled filmmaker steals to that extent, especially when it's a scene that's so iconic. It was exactly Mos Eisley, just lacking all the character and the scary dudes.
>>68167054
>Lucas understood his mythos
>>68167227
This. Any of you cocksuckers remember "Do not want"? That was fucking classic.
>>68162895
Episode 3 by far
III is obviously better but I'm not using that thing and giving you all my personal information
>>68167279
You just don't get it, part of it is novelty and part of it is that the movie is just flat out bland. It doesn't push the setting in a new direction and every choice put upon it's visual direction is only to appease one audience. The most common denominator who wants just a quick laugh and a bit of tugs to make them relive their childhood.
VII feels like a bad tabletop campaign where everyone's trying so hard to shove "iconic" star wars pieces in the game but not understanding what made them iconic or what made them work emotionally. By the time Han Solo died I didn't care because the movie was already so boring and it was obvious from the get go. When xwings fought tie fighters it was actually well shot with some great effects but I didn't care about what was going on. Because the pacing was too speedy and didn't have any emotional build up, it was just going through the motions.
It's bad fanfiction, it doesn't even try to be a fleshed out picture of the era of star wars its trying to represent, and lastly it doesn't have cool toys. No interesting tidbits to bite into or read about save kylo ren and his knights really.
>>68167401
>merchandising being relevant at all to the quality of film
>I want muh toys!
Yeah, you're cancer.
>>68167279
I don't give a fuck about toys, I just like neat spaceships. Cool ships are a big part of what makes Star Wars fun, and the variety of new ones were the only thing worthwhile to come out of the prequels. JJ hardly included anything new at all.
>>68167471
>talks about reusing scenes and lacking the visual emotion behind them
>m-must be muh toys
I hope you're bait and not just retarded.
>>68167611
so you're autistic
>>68167618
Sick burn, bruh. Go play with your legos, adults are talking.
>>68167632
If expecting new things in a new movie by a new director is autistic, then yes
>>68167471
Are you projecting a person who spends $1000's on action figure collectibles every year? I don't give a shit about toys. I would hope a new installment in a franchise can balance tradition and originality...
>>68167618
>visual emotion
man you're gay lmao
do you visually emote whilst demarcus is stuffing your wife?
>>68167706
you seem pretty defensive about your collection, manchild
no need to out yourself as some convention slug so plainly. we get it, you fucking love merchandise and are upset you don't have neat new spaceships for your finn dolls
>>68167758
I can't tell what you're doing, honestly. I'm literally telling you as plainly as possible that I own no Star Wars merchandise.
>>68163751
OP is obviously going to group favourite films onto groups like 90s, 2000s, action, etc... And see if there's a difference in star wars preference between the groups
>>68162895
"Your opinion is shit"
HAHAHAHAHAHA pleb doc faggot
>>68167758
Jews made movies that made beta males like you seem capable of getting girls, yet you are against them, goy.
>>68167806
everyone could tell what you were doing three posts ago, manchild. go play in your room
VII was way too fucking clean. At least Lucas knew his settings, as silly and immature as they may be.
>>68166414
That acting is great you pleb
>>68162895
NO WAY I'M CLICKING THAT
THE LINK IS PROBABLY A PHISHING ATTEMPT TO STEAL MY 4CHAN USERNAME AND PASSWORD
Try harder anon
>>68166699
>66699
WOAHH THOSE NUMBERS
HEIL DARK KNIGHT
>>68166414
>yelling a single word, "liar"
>somehow this constitutes bad acting
>Revenge of the Sith
>60 votes
>The Force Awakens
>63 votes
>There are people who actually voted for RoS
Literally kill yourselves, contrarians.
>>68168309
You're the contrarian mate, /tv/'s favorite is III
>>68168309
>almost evenly divided
>the side that doesn't agree with me is contrarian
I thought the favorite movie meant favorite Star Wars movie.
>>68168332
No, it's not, you fucking mong. A bunch of shitposters started ironically praising the prequels and morons like you fell for the meme.
>>68168404
Relax, they are pretending to like 3 more to be contrarian, its just a joke to rile you up
>>68168404
III has always been my favorite. Fuck of
>>68167959
>VII was way too fucking clean
What does that even mean?
>>68168498
It means he liked it and he needs to justify his decision to say it's bad, so he made up a completely arbitrary measurement that can't be objectively proven and claims it fails in that regard
>>68166414
There is literally no better way to deliver these lines in the context of the movie and its conditions.
>all those pleb responses for favorite movie
>>68166462
Same here except I saw ROTS three times. I might watch TFA one more time at some point, but I'm not really interested in it or in the sequels and spinoffs. TFA pretty much confirmed all my worries about the direction Disney was taking.
I've come to terms with my demotion from devoted fan to casual fan.
>>68168840
>not liking Jurassic Park
>>68168980
Jurassic Park is acceptable but still pleb, not even one of the best Spielberg movies.
>>68168404
My praise for episode III is not ironic. It is genuinely better than the force awakens.
>>68162895
>favorite movie
>godzilla 1984 (1985)
i keked
>>68168840
Pleb movies are the best movies.
>>68169426
>majority of posters between 20-25
What the fuck? If I'm still here when I'm over 21 I'm gonna an hero
>>68165505
It's better made, but not a better film precisely because it's just a second rate clone.
>>68172237
That's what I said too, but here I am 11 years later still browsing this shit.
>>68172385
The most depressing thing is a lot of them are the people who argue "'movies are supposed to be fun!!! Why do you hate fun?!" When some wants the slightest bit of drama or conflict in a film.
>>68168404
III is Spacekino while VII is Starshit this is pretty much agreed upon by everyone outside of reddit.
