[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Home]
4chanarchives logo
Why do people keep calling Rey a mary sue?
Images are sometimes not shown due to bandwidth/network limitations. Refreshing the page usually helps.

You are currently reading a thread in /tv/ - Television & Film

Thread replies: 201
Thread images: 34
File: Rey-750x375.png (273 KB, 750x375) Image search: [Google]
Rey-750x375.png
273 KB, 750x375
Why do people keep calling Rey a mary sue?
>>
>>67627871
cuz she is
>>
>>67627871
That's her Sith name.
>>
>>67627878
/thread
>>
Because 67% of the posts here are Max Landis samefagging.
>>
>>67627878

Lol proof? Im so tired of the sexism in this argument.
>>
>>67627921

Nothing sexist about point a character out for having OP plot armor and expert skills in every field possible
>>
Just read the previous threads on 4plebs. It's always the same shit anyway.
>>
>>67627871
Because she is. She is also below-average and bland look-wise I dont understand how did she get into such a blockbuster.
>>
Because they don't know the difference between a poorly written character and a Mary Sue. That's such terribly misused word on here.
>>
>>67627921
Holy shit fuck off wasn't getting shat on in the JJ thread enough?

She's a badly formed character through and through, mainly cos she's a woman :)
>>
>knows how to fly the Falcon and knows how to take care of Falcon better than Han on first try
>instantly knows how to use Force mind tricks when it took Luke 3 movies to do, and outskills her
>outduels Kylo (albeit weaken still impressive) on her first try using one handed style light sabre fighting
>knows several languages, meets BB for first time and already knows his language (unlike Luke who needed a translator)

and so on and so on

proof doesn't matter, baiters gonna bait
>>
File: 1415406020054.jpg (6 KB, 200x200) Image search: [Google]
1415406020054.jpg
6 KB, 200x200
>>
New starwars is shit, deal with it.

Everybody loves her + CAN DO EVERYTHING= MARY SUE!
>>
>>67628257

She was a pilot, as well as force attuned without even knowing it. Also it was modified thats why she was better than han

She got enough of a dose when kylo tried to know how to at least attempt it so thats okay because she didn't do it on the first try and had to really get good at ti

Kylo just killed his father for fucks sake as well as got hit directly by a blaster that sends people flying with a single shot

She has had to live in a seedy terrible place where all sorts of species and droids come through it isn't surprising that she knows so many languages, luke didn't need 3po he knew how to speak with r2

You need better arguments without getting pissed she is a girl kicking ass
>>
She's automatically awesome at everything she tries. Never been in the Falcon but is such a badass mechanic that she figures it all out in a few minutes. Never had a hint of Force training and all of a sudden she can block Ren from her mind and use the mind trick on a Stormtrooper etc.

Don't forget Luke got zapped a few times by a training ball and struggled and failed to raise the X-Wing before he got competent enough to barely hold his own against Vader, let alone do the Force tricks she does. He had a lucky moment when he blew up the Death Star but most other times it clearly wasn't easy for him and he improved slowly. That's what makes him interesting.
>>
>>67628387
Luke doesn't understand R2 until episode 6. He uses translators.
>>
>>67628421

She knew it hadn't been flown in years she probably was the one who flew it and knew there was extra stuff installed so yeah, also ren used brutal type mind tricks not the sophisticated ones so her blocking him out with pure effort makes sense.
>>
Rey is so cool everybody likes her instantly
>bb8 follows her
>black guy falls on love with her instantly
>han offers her a job 30 minutes after meet her
>kylo ren wants to train her

She's worse than kid anakin, and he was the "chosen one"
>>
>>67628387
How did she know that she could use force pull to get the light sabre?
How is her untrained force pull stronger than Kylo's?
Maybe Kylo was severely hurt sure but I think guy with nickname "Jedi killer" and fighting style that drains power from pain should have been able to handle someone who never held a light sabre before
>>
I Rays defence. Luke fought Sith Lord who was almost Jedi Master before.
Kylo is like an apprentice to the sith.
>>
>>67628387
You do know that just because there might be an explanation doesn't not make her a Mary Sue
>>
File: 14458765000.webm (3 MB, 1218x520) Image search: [Google]
14458765000.webm
3 MB, 1218x520
>>67628421
Also that Luke was basically useless for the first two movies beyond blowing up the Death Star.

It's not that Rey is a Mary Sue, it's just hard to think of where she can go from here considering how skilled she already is.
>>
File: 1347548840242.jpg (16 KB, 397x461) Image search: [Google]
1347548840242.jpg
16 KB, 397x461
>>67628586
Luke had TRAINING from both obiwan and yoda who was an actual jedi master.
Ray Ramano had zero training.
>>
It's almost as if the writers want us to question how she is so powerful.
>>
>>67628626
The best part is they are just fucking implications(if at all) and assumptions, nothing we actually got in the film. Just off the film she exceeds at everything and outclasses everyone for zero reason
>>
>>67628626

Just makes your argument a strawman argument people just hate her for being powerful because she is a woman instead of a badass guy
>>
>>67628718
Guy's can be Mary Sue's too faggot
>>
>>67628679
Luke had barely any training at the end of star wars. Dude closed his eyes and missiles did a 90 degree angle
>>
>>67628718
All fucking day with this sexism shit no matter how wrong you are proven, you are the exact reason a cause like feminism is getting the opposite reaction it wants, you're just shitting on people who disagree with you with a buzzword
>>
Howcome vader/anakins space ghost never gets in touch with kylo to tell him that he is fucking up and that he doesn't want jedis dead and evil to come back
>>
>>67628754
rewatch the triology retard
>>
>>67627871
Name one flaw she has.

Protip: you can't.
>>
>>67628768
I don't know. Why did Obi-Wan talk to Rey during the force vision she had?
>>
File: 1453730927643.png (211 KB, 386x480) Image search: [Google]
1453730927643.png
211 KB, 386x480
This movie is not so clever as you thought. It's just pandering.
>>
>>67628785
O SHIT WAIFU FAGS GET THE TABLES TURNED
>>
>>67628785

She went black and will never go back
>>
>>67628768
Maybe Kylo isn't fucking up.
>>
>>67627871
I wouldn't call her a mary sue if she didn't have the acting skills and charisma of a retarded baby
>>
>>67628826

Are you implying he is going through all of this so he can gain the power to destroy the dark side for good, from the inside?
>>
>>67628768
Too busy fucking ghost Obi.

Besides it's confirmed Kylo doesn't give a shit about reformed Anakin, it's only Vader he likes.
>>
>>67627871
People are dumb desu. It's a fairy tale, she's fine.
>>
>>67628874

Where was that confirmed. I doubt he would shun vaders fucking ghost
>>
File: a7dN6iJ.gif (2 MB, 281x281) Image search: [Google]
a7dN6iJ.gif
2 MB, 281x281
>>67628791
She is related to him that's why, there is a reason why ewan mcgregor did the voice. its for the obiwan prequel movie to tie in with the current universe.
Also all why do you think she has an English accent and Luke doesn't? She is a Kenobi
>>
>>67628889
She is shit, but who we are to tell normies about that.
>>
>>67628918
He considers Anakin weak or misguided for turning good and doesn't have respect for him like he does Vader. He'd tell Anakin to take a hike.
>>
>>67628944

Anything backing that claim up?
>>
I think the whole movie was too quick to get to things. The new characters aren't interesting at all.
>>
>>67627921
>>67628387
>>67628718
oh fuck off back to rεddit or /b/ or wherever you underage faggot rusers come from
>>
>>67628930
>rey is a kenobi
DO WANT
>>
>>67627871
Shes awesome!
>>
>>67629108
you want to trigger someone, boy, aren't you?
>>
>>67629138
yeah, the manchildren
>>
>>67629195
Why are you trying to trigger yourself tho?
>>
>>67629036
It feels like JJ was worried about getting hired for the sequels, so he just condensed 3 movies into one.
>>
If Rey was in episode 4 instead of Luke, she would have picked up Obi-Wan's lightsaber and slapped Darth Vader's shit right then and there.
>>
File: image.jpg (30 KB, 543x271) Image search: [Google]
image.jpg
30 KB, 543x271
>Rey and Finn are removed as characters
>Poe is now the lead
How much better does TFA get?
>>
>>67629138
did you see her reading for the part? Shes a great actor!
>>
>>67629284
It seems more like a 3 hour movie crammed into a little over two hours.
>>
>good at everything
>no flaws
Yep
>>
>Ok guys we just bought Star Wars for $4 billion
>We're making a move but need to avoid making the same mistakes as the prequels, what have you got?
>Well... ah.. you remember that annoying kid that's good at everything and saves the day?
>Let's make him a girl.
>Brilliant.
>>
File: 1458742892205.jpg (291 KB, 1920x802) Image search: [Google]
1458742892205.jpg
291 KB, 1920x802
marey sue
>>
>>67627871
Because it's only okay when the males from their childish video gayms and movies are overpowered for some bullshit reason or none at all. Not even a libfag either.
>>
File: image.jpg (113 KB, 960x640) Image search: [Google]
image.jpg
113 KB, 960x640
>This is now the Star Wars market
>>
>>67629540
Except for the fact he doesn't always save the day, remember ESB?
>>
>>67629371
>no flaws

She couldn't save Han Solo
>>
>>67629574
>Because it's only okay when the males
It's never ok, it's why no one like superman
>>
>>67629592
pretty sure he meant kid Anakin
>>
>>67627871
What if they made Rey a bad guy in episode 7 or 8?

Having a Mary Sue as a villain is interesting
>>
>>67629540
>that annoying kid that's good at everything and saves the day?
That's surely not Anakin, motherfucker was a liability more than anything

And let's not even talk about Luke "I swear I'm ready to beat Vader now" Skywalker
>>
>>67629574
First of all, self awareness.

Second, Rey is not a Mary Sue by the classical definition of the word - that is, a female character created by a fan, introduced in fanfiction and who not only has every trait of everything awesome ever, she carries love interests left right and center while causing OOC moments.

That said, she does posses traits that are not terribly endearing, such as suspisciouly high mastery of skills she should not posses from what is seen of the character, established characters taking a liking to her on first meeting, and victories over superior foes with little effort considering the disparity.

Time will tell however how deep does the rabbit hole go.
>>
File: lil Annie fit.png (460 KB, 1545x871) Image search: [Google]
lil Annie fit.png
460 KB, 1545x871
>>67627871
She's very strong, but the movie doesn't tell us why she is so strong.

The reason as to why will probably be answered in episode 8.
>>
>>67629574
fuck off back to /v/, bitch
>>
>>67629651
only if Kylo fucks her brains out again
>>
I haven't been keeping up on my shitposting but it seems like there's one faggot the last couple of days that brings "your argument is sexist so I win" into every thread and every argument no matter how retarded or unconnected that is. Anyone else seeing this
>>
>>67629686
>classical definition of the word
The word now goes beyond fanfiction, fuck off.

She is the perfect Mary Sue stereotype.
>>
>>67629690
Could it ever be an actual good reason tho ?
Let's marvel at the possibilites :
She was trained, then got amnesia
She's "the one, for real this time"
She's sucked off a force elemental

At the end of the day it's gonna be another powerlevel-tier writing
>>
>>67629686
The word has been accepted for use beyond your autism of the early 1990s for almost 15 years now. Move on.
>>
>>67629724
They just baiting you, sad little cuck.

And you always respond.
>>
File: hansolo.0.png (967 KB, 1280x854) Image search: [Google]
hansolo.0.png
967 KB, 1280x854
>He was a bad parent
>Billions died

Why did TFA make such shits out of the original heroes? It should have been set way in the future where ROTJ characters would have been mythical heroes. Not some alcoholic has beens.
>>
>>67629740
>powerlevel-tier writing

I think they're moving away from that. JewJew hated the idea that one force user was inherently stronger than another. The idea is that hard work is how you become powerful. It's really fucking odd he stated this though considering how Rey turned out. There's something about Rey we don't know yet. It won't fix how she was characterized in TFA but it will explain a lot.
>>
>>67629792
Han was never a good person.
>>
>>67629740
>Could it ever be an actual good reason tho ?

Not without making her even more of a Mary Sue. Even if she was trained by Luke, the only way that she would still be so powerful after such a long hiatus, after at most a few years of training, is if she was some prodigy child. That's probably why she was saved, because she was top of her class or some shit.

Being the one is even worse, because it gives the writers even more free reign to do whatever they want.
>>
>>67629691
I followed you there :^)
>>
>>67629792
There is nothing indicating he was a bad parent.

Kylo was likely getting mind molested and even outside of that, some kids just turn out bad.
>>
File: 1459116903100.jpg (71 KB, 1280x720) Image search: [Google]
1459116903100.jpg
71 KB, 1280x720
>>67629740
>She's "the one, for real this time"
yep, the Force did it. I can accept that. But they're going to make her a Skywalker to appease the autists, aren't they?
>>
>>67629808
She's Jaina Solo, Jacen Solo's sister. When Jacen gets more powerful, so does she because muh "bring balance to the Force poetry"
>>
Rey is one of Luke's students with amnesia / force mind wipe / whatever... stop pretending like this isn't a thing
>>
>>67627871
I won't regurgitate the multitude of reasons mentioned in this thread but they could at least partially remove her Sue status if it turns out that she was Lukes top student but he mind wiped her after the student he failed - Kylo went dark and killed all the others, and he wiped her mind and hid her to protect her identity.

Otherwise it's just too far fetched that she knows the exact mind control procedure and how to verbalise it and hpw she's far more attuned than anyone else we've seen,
>>
>>67629958
She was abandoned at what, the age of 10?

How much training could she have possibly had that after all this time, she still manages to defeat the arch villain?
>>
>>67629299

Roughly a thousand times better, dashing rogue fighter pilot? Indiana Jones in Space?

Yes. Please.

but instead we got Princess Rey Jedi Master and HOL UP
>>
>>67629991
>defeat the arch villain
he was injured and wanted to take her alive
>>
>>67629991
>arch villain?

She didn't defeat spooky giant hologram man though

All she did was wound Darth Angst, before their fight was interrupted due to planet cracking
>>
>>67629991

One of two things, she was an adult and only got deposited on Jakku a year or so ago (she was force tricked into thinking she's been there a life time) This explains the fact that she instantly knows the ways of the Force

Two, she was a kid and left there, and has no business instantly knowing Force Pull, Jedi Mind Probe, Jedi Mind Trick, advanced Saber techniques.
>>
So now there's a planet sized Sun in that system? Surely it should have collapsed in on itself and super nova'd / formed a black hole?

Oh wait.. JJ Abrams

>A Star will explode and threaten to destroy the galaxy

lol riiight
>>
File: 1453175767219.jpg (63 KB, 315x332) Image search: [Google]
1453175767219.jpg
63 KB, 315x332
>>67630024
those are terrible arguments
>>
>>67629686
What the fuck are you talking about.

Mary Sue was a Star Trek character that was better than everyone else.

Get your facts straight.
>>
>>67629740
Really can't believe nobody thinks of this. They talk about how Luke used to have a camp of Trainee Jedi and he was trying to revive the force. Well, Kylo Ren was one of the trainees and got seduced by the dark side and went all Allah Ackbar.

The trick of it is that I think she was trained AFTER she was delivered to that planet. That will be the twist. So its not that she is a baby and fends for herself, she was given all these trainings and hung out with Han Solo and Chewie.

My theory is REY is The Force Awakened because she "awoke" out of her memory wipe. Luke force blocked her memory so she wouldn't be sensed by Sith. The Jedi mind trick has only ever been used by Obi Wan and Luke in the movies. Huge clue.

She is still too good to be a apprentice but at least it explains it. Plus feminism.
>>
>>67630113
How about you do
>>67629730
>>67629763
I don't care, and more importantly, the euphemism has been so badly mishandled it barely has meaning anymore.

The simpler definition is bad writing.
>>
>>67630154
>Really can't believe nobody thinks of this.

We've all thought of it. We just don't like it, and even with a later explanation, it won't change that her character was poorly executed for this film.
>>
File: 134567899870-.webm (3 MB, 640x480) Image search: [Google]
134567899870-.webm
3 MB, 640x480
>>67629540
>Well... ah.. you remember that annoying kid that's good at everything and saves the day?
>imfuckingplying
>>
File: 1456789876000.webm (3 MB, 1216x520) Image search: [Google]
1456789876000.webm
3 MB, 1216x520
>>67630399
>>
File: Marey Sue.webm (3 MB, 1000x416) Image search: [Google]
Marey Sue.webm
3 MB, 1000x416
>>
>>67629808
>The idea is that hard work is how you become powerful.
Well he surely fucked up that part because Kylo Ren was trained by a master, experienced and shown at the start that he have strong mastery of the force and he still get out-forced in atleast two occasions

It bother me because you have 6 episodes of grumpy old men who look like hobos but are actual final bosses with traits defined by their masters and deep knowledge of the force

And then Rey show up and say "I bypassed the source material"
>>
>>67627878
/thread
>>
>>67630484
>I'M ACTING
>>
>she was just force tricked into forgetting she is a yoda tier jedi master, a commando, a droid language translator, a mechanical wizard, and an extremely skilled expert pilot!

Remember, kids. If you ever encounter unbelievably shitty writing, just say it's because of super-convenient unprecedented force hax. It will make it all feel better.
>>
>>67630503
>he still get out-forced in atleast two occasions
Rey is strong in the Force, Kylo even says that.
>>
File: 1451014487346.jpg (215 KB, 1000x980) Image search: [Google]
1451014487346.jpg
215 KB, 1000x980
This combined with the fact her name is Race Mixer
>>
File: ScaredRey.png (407 KB, 699x377) Image search: [Google]
ScaredRey.png
407 KB, 699x377
>>67630543
>>
>>67630484
>>67630543
>>67630642
ACTING
>>
File: angrr.jpg (34 KB, 368x355) Image search: [Google]
angrr.jpg
34 KB, 368x355
>>67630642
CUTE
>>
File: 6954.jpg (31 KB, 366x266) Image search: [Google]
6954.jpg
31 KB, 366x266
I've no problem with someone as frail as Rey being a powerful Jedi because the force can do that. The problem is that in this movie she's fighting on mostly physical strength and willpower, yet she's a very small and young girl. Supposedly her training in hand to hand is one of the reasons she should have been able to defeat Kylo yet when it came down to it all she did was push him back with pure force. On one hand she's supposedly very smart but on the other hand she's infatuated with a nigger despite the fact that no highly intelligent women has ever willingly copulated with one here in the real world.
>>
File: bll-cosby-confused.png (226 KB, 500x385) Image search: [Google]
bll-cosby-confused.png
226 KB, 500x385
I have never watched a movie before do such a terrible job at trying to explain who a certain character is, what their goal is, what is their motivation and what is their back story - Rey has NOTHING of that throughout FTA!!!

It's as if they hired a nobody as director/writer for this film off the street, who has 0% knowledge of script or story writing and has only watched Michael Bay films.

This is exactly how this movie feels to me!
>>
>>67630029

Wound? She fucking destroyed him.
>>
>>67630659
she looks like a pug
>>
>>67627871
I feel Rey is more of a Tom Selleck type character.
>>
File: kylo gets rekt.webm (3 MB, 1000x416) Image search: [Google]
kylo gets rekt.webm
3 MB, 1000x416
>>67630735
It's Star Wars. If someone has an angryface it means dark side. That's why she "destroyed " him.
>>
File: AAAAAAAHHHHHHHHHHHH BEN HELP.webm (3 MB, 1216x520) Image search: [Google]
AAAAAAAHHHHHHHHHHHH BEN HELP.webm
3 MB, 1216x520
>>67630484
>>67630543
>>67630642
>>67630655
>>67630659
No different from her dad desu
>>
>>67630611
So yeah, hard-work doesnt matter anymore, it come down to powerlevel
>>
>>67627871
Ow ma gawsh this site is full of fuckin nerds !!! Go get laid u losers haha Sheldon cooper wannabes haha
>>
>>67627871

She's not cool enough to be flawless
>>
DESU I didn't have an issue of her beating Kylo. Dude was emotionally distressed after killing his father and just got done tanking a bowcaster shot.
>>
File: 1458398866835.jpg (35 KB, 736x552) Image search: [Google]
1458398866835.jpg
35 KB, 736x552
>>67630799
just like my prequel kinos
>>
>>67630880
Not even close

Anakin is the one and still get shat on by Dooku and Obiwan
>>
>>67630780
at least he is enjoyable to look at
>>
>>67630867
That would be possible if that was all that there was to it.

It's a combination over everything about her that make her a Mary sue
>>
>>67630867
he didn't look like he was really nursing that wound at all though, that was the problem
>>
she is the best waifu in all seven films
>>
the only positive is that it wasn't a complete trainwreck character-wise and the sequel could retroactively fix basically all the problems
>>
>>67631004
>implying the best waifu in SW isn't _Luke
>>
File: mlZfX1.jpg (196 KB, 680x352) Image search: [Google]
mlZfX1.jpg
196 KB, 680x352
>>67631004
That's just wrong
>>
I'm kind of conflicted about kylo ren
at first I hated him because I thought he was an incompetent, immature faggot that had temper tantrums and just was a shit character, but now I'm thinking about and it's like if they wanted me to think he was a weak ass bitch then they definitely succeeded

just saw the movie today for the first time btw
>>
>>67630880
The entirity of TFA feels exactly like that relatively short sequence in Episode I where Anakin flew that space fighter and by simply pressing random buttons and doing good tricks like spinning, he defeated a motherfucking army.
>>
>>67631252
jesus it wasn't THAT bad
>>
>>67631213
I like that his lightsaber is poorly constructed and crackles as a reflection of his character
And his helmet seems to weigh a tone every time he sets it down
>>
>>67630965
>>67630988
Wasn't he dripping blood from the wound the whole fight? Maybe it was poor directing but I will give them a pass for now. By the way I am not saying she isn't a Mary Sue cause there is a strong case that she is I was just saying her beating Kylo didn't bother me.
>>
>>67631343
yeah I think you're right, it shows it once for like half a second before they start fighting and he keeps pounding it with his fist for some reason idk what that was about
>>
>>67631326
honestly that scene where he killed han solo was really fucking good, and yeah when he drops his helmet on the bridge it makes a huge THUNK like he's dropping a huge burden
>>
>>67631286
I bypassed the auto-pilot !
>>
>>67631395
He takes it off to interrogate Rei too. He slams it with a thud onto what looked like a pedestal of steaming charcoals.
>>
>>67631395
I wish he hadn't taken of his helmet for Rey. Otherwise the Han scene would've been 10x better. His burden should be for Han to see only.
>>
>>67630867
That would be an okay argument if they had even hinted that Kylo was having difficulty fighting at any point before Rey remembers to use the force and then beats the shit out of him.
>>
>>67631506
true
>>
File: maRey_sue.png (110 KB, 1521x680) Image search: [Google]
maRey_sue.png
110 KB, 1521x680
>>67627871
>>
File: heh.jpg (49 KB, 1024x1024) Image search: [Google]
heh.jpg
49 KB, 1024x1024
Are y'all ready for the "Rey will turn dark side" in episode 9?
>>
>>67630867
The only problem is that Kylo Ren wont be very threatening. If she can activate the force to be extremely fast and powerful, then the significance of Kylo Ren's skills go away.

Now, since Rey is being trained by Luke, she'll be as trained as Kylo and have the "force" mode to call upon.

They wrote her character into a hole desu.
>>
>>67630880
First, it's established that Anakin was born of midichlorian and that he was supposed to be the chosen one, so his powerlevel is at least explained. Secondly, he still gets stomped by more experienced force users, and is constantly getting put in check by wiser jedi, because he's still young and immature, regardless of his natural talent.

His dialog was shit and I hated his acting, but he was a better developed character than Rey hands down.
>>
>>67631561
>has the tendency of walking into new plots all the time, and is able to solve them alone or with very little help from others

This basically sums up Rey. Somehow, during the movie, they focused on Rey without developing her, and basically threw away any gradual development of character interactions/relationships all in favor on focusing on her skills as a pilot/engineer/force user.
>>
>>67631613
I'm waiting for "Rey was Luke's secret apprentice who had her memory erased as a test of character and related to Obi wan and the real chosen one who will unite both light and dark side and who is more powerful than Luke, who will sacrifice himself for her, but for the wrong reason"
>>
>>67631686
Famalam I got dizzy reading that in my head without breathing
>>
>>67631746
That was the point.

Rey's radiance in the Force is dizzying.

That's what you call quality fanfiction writing
>>
>>67631613
Please, it's the only thing that will save the new trilogy.

Then the Resistance can realise the only way to end all this strife is to wipe out force users for good. A final solution.
>>
Rey needs to get thick a bit, too skinny for me
>>
>>67627871
Because he is.
Thi is not mistype he not she.
>>
File: nimetön.jpg (70 KB, 749x408) Image search: [Google]
nimetön.jpg
70 KB, 749x408
i dont find her attractive plus she has no flaws.
>>
>>67628842
Yes
>>
File: eating.webm (2 MB, 1280x536) Image search: [Google]
eating.webm
2 MB, 1280x536
>>
Am I the only one to wonder they chose such a shitty name ?
Rey...
Seriously JJ?
>>
>>67631613
my fingers are crossed for "Rey is the clone made from Luke Skywalker's hand" story arc. They pretty much said that the asian orange lady gave her the lightsaber that was attached to Luke's hand.
>>
>>67632687
she said she stole it from kylo
>>
>>67632591
Her name is Rey Smixer. I don't see what's weird about it, very Star Wars-y.
>>
>>67632792
i didn't catched that. i thought she found it, and how she found it was a story for another time.
>>
>>67632799
>Rey Smixer
KEK, I just spat out my tea, cheers anon
>>
>>67632873
she says it in the scene shortly after Rey touching the lightsaber
>>
She doesn't have any flaws, character-wise. There were no stakes, there was never even a slight bit of worry that she wouldn't be able to accomplish anything she tried.
>>
>>67632906
i'll have to rewatch it. thanks.

still holding onto the Rey is a clone theory.
>>
You know, it wouldnt have been so bad if Han and gang had rescued her as they intended

But instead she singlehandely resist Kylo Rens mind tricks, and then mind trick a storm trooper to release her, going full Solid Snake on a enemy base loaded with troops and whatnot.
Im actually surprised she didnt lower the shields herself and escaped with her awesome pilot skills
>>
>>67632906
no, she doesn't.
>>
>>67632963
yes she does
>>
>>67628506

>How did she know that she could use force pull to get the light sabre?

How did LUKE know that he could use force pull to get the light sabre back in ESB?
>>
>>67632974
watch the scene again, retard
she says nothing about Kylo
>>
>>67633012
maybe you should rewatch it grandpa
>>
File: 1456365646154.webm (782 KB, 1920x820) Image search: [Google]
1456365646154.webm
782 KB, 1920x820
>>67633006
From two movies worth of figuring shit out.
>>
>>67633006
they said that the lightsaber literally called to her
>>
>>67633163
Plus Obi One had been guiding him, in human and Ghost form, I'm sure he'd have mentioned at least once about being able to move shit with your fucking mind

>Luke, did I ever tell you about the time I blew up a group of battle droids with telekenisis? Shit was so cash"

>Luke did I ever tell you about the time I was hanging over the 1000ft drop into the Naboo palace's reactor core, vaulted myself up, grabbed my lightsaber from across the room with my mind and then sliced a sith apprentice in two?
>>
>>67633199
Whereas acting talent had the wrong number
>>
>>67633199
Clearly it just desired more youngling blood
>>
>>67632974

No, she doesn't. ''Is a story for another time'', that's all.
>>
>>67633238
They honestly didn't spend that much time together before OBW died tbqh sempai.
>>
>>67633306
he was talking to his ghost a whole bunch though, and hadn't a year or so passed between the first and second film? That's a long time
>>
>>67633006
It's very reasonable to believe Luke tried experimenting with the force between blowing up the Death Star and moving to Hoth. And he still struggled to do it.
>>
>>67633238

So we can use our imagination to fill the gaps for Luke being able to perform the fucking trick, which he didn't know about; but we can't use our imagination to make sense out of the skills of Rey.

Got'cha.
>>
>>67633369
For all we know he spoke to Ghostbenster the first time after he escaped the Wampa cave.
>>
>>67633395
>So we can use our imagination to fill the gaps for Luke being able to perform the fucking trick, which he didn't know about

When that gap is about a year long, yeah.
>>
>>67633395
>So we can use our imagination to fill the gaps for Luke being able to perform the fucking trick, which he didn't know about
Are yo dense? There's a fuck load more context to the Luke scenario, he'd been a friend of one of the greatest Jedi Masters of all time, be it for not that long, and it's highly implied that he's been training to be a jedi prior to IV's ending and at V's start

Whereas as lived-all-her-fucking-life-in-afghanistan-yet somehow-jewel-of-the-commonwealth-Rey teaches herself to be a master of the force in less than a week
>>
>>67633436

>When that gap is about a year long, yeah.

Well isn't that convenient.
>>
>>67633493
>and it's highly implied that he's been training to be a jedi prior to IV's ending and at V's start

By fucking who? Again, you can use your imagination all you want, but that only makes you a hypocrite.
>>
>current year
>not calling them laser swords

Plebs
>>
>>67633579
OBW trained him, a bit on camera, a bit off camera. And he had the time to feel the explore and develop its powers naturally between episode 4 and 5, that should give him an idea of what he can and can't do with the force (can - move a lightsaber, can't - move a fighter, that's impossible). With Rei, she needs a force power so she learns it on the spot.
>>
>>67633635
>not calling them Jedi weapons
>>
>>67627871
Why did she hug Leia after they got back from destroying the not-Death Star?

Had they met before? Why didn't Leia look/ask Chewbacca what happened to Han instead?
>>
>>67628754
>Luke had barely any training at the end of star wars
He had training from both Obi Wan and Yoda. He spent most of ESB training with Yoda, and still gets his ass handed to him by Vader.
>>
>>67633643

Pretty sure Luke could have used a force power or two throughout the entire first film.

But it's ok, you can keep using the mental gymnastics you learnt on tumblr to defend your average film
>>
>>67633692
He meant A New Hope, originally called Star Wars.
>>
File: gipadgayhy.gif (3 MB, 340x339) Image search: [Google]
gipadgayhy.gif
3 MB, 340x339
>>67627880
underrated post
>>
>>67631561
according to this every main character is a mary sue.

great job
>>
>>67633699
Honestly, just what OBW taught him.
>Don't trust your eyes, let the force pass through you and you will be able to detect and strike a target.
>>
>>67633508
There is nothing wrong with Luke barely being able to manage a simple feat with the force, after clearly being shown he's force sensitive and leaving some time for him to experiment on his own. This chick either became a jedi master on her own over the course of a few days, or she used to be a jedi master and through some contrived never before seen plot device she loses all her extraordinary abilities and very conveniently regains them at the exact time she needs them. Both scenarios are utterly terrible writing. On the other hand, what happens with Luke is just basic common sense. Something you lack.
>>
File: 26562.jpg (66 KB, 704x476) Image search: [Google]
26562.jpg
66 KB, 704x476
>>67627871
The First Order is Abrams' and Kasdan's vision of what white people are like when they aren't under the watchful eye of international Jewry.

And I'm not even meme-ing or bullshitting. Kasdan said in an interview that he and JJ asked themselves what it would be like if the Nazis had gone to Argentina and regrouped after WWII.

From birth, Jews are raised with this idea that homogeneous white societies will inevitably result in goose-stepping, ethnic cleansing, and warmongering. And I could understand that outlook if history had begun in 1930. But the truth is, whites are the most egalitarian and least barbaric group in human history.

That's what frustrates many of us when Jewish Hollywood sensibilities become accepted norms. They're slanted (indeed, prejudiced), and their bias goes unchallenged by everyone.

The First Order is a Jewish take on ultimate evil. And because modern Jews are obsessed with The Shoah and WWII, everything somehow magically relates to MUH SIX MILLION.

It has gotten boring. It's stale. I wish we could get a more nuanced view of evil, but that won't happen because show-biz Jews always find a way of politicizing everything.
>>
>>67633841
>Kasdan said in an interview that he and JJ asked themselves what it would be like if the Nazis had gone to Argentina and regrouped after WWII.
... because the Empire were already Nazis.
Thread replies: 201
Thread images: 34

banner
banner
[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Home]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
If a post contains personal/copyrighted/illegal content you can contact me at [email protected] with that post and thread number and it will be removed as soon as possible.
DMCA Content Takedown via dmca.com
All images are hosted on imgur.com, send takedown notices to them.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from them. If you need IP information for a Poster - you need to contact them. This website shows only archived content.