Binary sunset
>OMG so epic, such a powerful scene, he doesnt need to talk to communicate his feelings
last scene of TFA
>Such a shitty scene, he doesnt even talk,fuck you JJ
hum
Not only was I pissed that luke didnt even speak for his big reveal, but I was pissed that him and rey just kept staring at eachother for an uncomfortable amount of time before we get a completely out of place helicopter shot into credits.
It could have been a little more bearable if they reduced the length of the staring.
Binary sunset
>no out of place helicopter shot
autism. baka
>>64577928
literally the only scene i liked in that whole movie, and they fucked up with that dumb helicopter shit
>>64577928
I could almost deal with Luke staying mute if he had just done something other than give that thousand yard stare, like force whip his light saber out of Rey's hand into his own and spark it up.
>>64577987
this. jj is obsessed with having the camera in motion
What is Luke trying to convey at the end of TFA? Constipation?
Then they finish on that abortion of a closing shot with the helicopter and you just sit there in your seat, and you know you've been fucking swindled. You're a chump. You think to yourself, why the fuck am I even here on opening day for this cookie cutter 5/10 Disney action movie. Fucking Star Wars iconography everywhere. That's the only reason you're there. You handed over your shekels and became a victim of Mickey's hype machine.
>>64577928
>>64577974
Every Star Wars film including the prequels has followed the tradition of having no dialog in the final scene of the movie. Why break that streak?
>>64577974
I agree. They should have finished with Luke's sad face reveal.
>>64579726
>like force whip his light saber out of Rey's hand into his own and spark it up.
i was really expecting that. then she just stands there with her arm out like some autist.
>>64579836
he is. the man has a.d.d. and doesnt know subtlety.
>>64580162
Nah. Should've finished with a hot cumshot onto Rey's face!
>>64582559
Probably the most realistic ending. Luke just rapes Rey and steals the falcon and just hides on another planet with his new sex slave.
it may have gone on for too long
but Mark Hamill's expression was great
yeah, reduce length and remove helicopter shot
>>64577928
My anon, the binary sunset scene appears after having met and seen this Vader's wife's son for like ten minutes.
In TFA this incest-friendly farmboy is the Macguffin of the entire movie and he only appears at the very end, without being given anything to say.
He could even be Luke's evil clone Luuke instead.
>>64580162
Alternate ending:
>Rey starts hearing Luke's voice in her head
>"The Force is strong in my family. My father had it, my sister had it. You have that power too"
>Rey isn't seen extending her arm, just her sad face because she found his father after so many years
>Luke's speechless, sad face is him being overwhelmed by finally meeting her daughter
>Movie cuts to end credis with Luke's face, no helicopter shot
>>64579726
That would have been fucking lame and retarded. It was way better the way it was. Kill yourself.
>>64582591
But Rey is his daughter...
>>64583216
Exactly. Skywalkers are all about that incest YEA BOIIIII
>>64579726
It would be better if he said something in those lines
>it belongs to you now
>I have other lightsaber with greater power of life "takes off his robe"
>his dick giving her the stare
>go to helicopter shot
>end credits
>>64577928
Context is different you monkey.
>>64577928
Besides the bad direction of the TFA ending, there was a huge difference in John Williams's work. SW was prime Williams, while TFA was I don't know what.
>>64583401
I bet you think the music in The Hateful Eight was shit too.
>>64580148
If you're know knowledgable faggot, then why are you ok with the fact that it's the worst scene by far
Fellas, fellas... what if Luke is the Real Kanjiklub?
>>64583401
What Jedi Steps is probably the best track in the score
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cUBUlKgsNK8
>>64583401
The huge difference wasn't Williams himself, it was the way the songs were incorporated into the scenes, and sound mix. tfa is the work of a true hack
>>64577928I cried two different times watching this.
This isn't even bait, the second one was really embarrassing because I was emotional still after the movie and everyone could see my crying face.
>>64583314
>cantina song
>Benny Hill chase sequence
>>64583589
How much do you love Star Wars
>>64577928
>Leia should have died
>Han leaves with Chewie and Rey to visit Luke
>Han and Rey aproach Luke
>Ends with the two BFF smiling at each other after 20 years.
>No helicopter shot
>>64577928
>Binary sunset
>"Wow that looks pretty cool, never seen anything like that before. Tatooine isn't such a shit hole after all"
>Last scene of TFA
>Luke has apparently just been sitting on the edge of the cliff doing nothing, waiting for Rey
>Awkwardly stares past the camera, then cuts to Rey showing him the saber and a retarded look on her face
>Suddenly cuts to completely out of place and obvious helicopter panning shot as LE EBIN NOSTALGIA MUSIC xDDD plays
>>64583624
I like it, but I love Luke more. If it makes sense.
Why are people comparing Binary Sunset with the last scene of TFA?
Shouldnt it be the rewards ceremony?
>>64583687
Maybe Luke was raping her with the Force
>>64579836
>moving the camera at all
Fucking plebs
>>64583690
R u a girl?
>>64579836
I thought having the camera in motion was a good thing, otherwise it's just photography not cinematography
At least that's what the cinematography thread niggers had me believe
>>64583721
It used BS's theme.
>>64583769
Every gay man on this board has suddenly fallen in love in with Mark Hamill for some reason recently
>>64583826
>gay
Nah senpai, he unJUSTed himself.
>>64583721
They're getting it confused with episode III
>>64583813
>I thought having the camera in motion was a good thing
>>64583401
This. Music can make or break a movie.
They'd to use the helicopter because the camera guys couldn't be in the island or some shit.
>>64583826
>>64583826Lukelusters aren't only gay, anon. And he is a silver fox now, so hot again.
>>64583063
>his
>her
>>64583853
>>64583401
John Williams should just retire, can he even compose an original and exciting score anymore?
Just let him go.
>>64582973
Or Luke's other evil clone, Luuuke
>>64583913
>Working with another clone, Streeen, Luuuke devised a time machine that he used to attack the galaxy during the Clone Wars.
This is the Thrawn trilogy that everyone loves?
>>64583890
C O R U S C A N T
>>64577928
Why was he looking the wrong way? Could he not feel her coming? What was he looking at instead?
>>64583980
Luuuke was an April Fool's joke.
>>64583980
Putting the clone back in clone wars, one luke at a time, yes
>>64583868
Can anyone tell me what's so bad about that last panning helicopter shot? I mean when you think of the OT's a last shot like that completely makes sense even though it can come over as a bit corny it's fitting in that Universe.
>>64583868
Are you fucking serious?
Then how did they film the close up dipshit
>>64584118
On a set, you dumb mongoloid
>>64583849
I'm sorry Ozu, I'll do better nezt time.
>>64584145
They filmed on location, cameras were allowed onto the island
>>64584169
Yeah, we even followed Rey's ass as she was climbing.
>>64583314
He shouldn't have said anything.
But I think it would've been great if she held out the lightsaber to him, he looked at her, then the lightsaber, then drew his own lightsaber to show he didn't need it or something.
>>64584202
>then drew his own lightsaber to show he didn't need it or something.
Your idea is worse than what we got
>>64579912
According to the script, Luke immediately recognizes Rey (the script does not reveal who she is, though) and knows why she has arrived.
>>64584169
>>64584197
I guess it depends on what equipment they had and number of people, then.
>>64584202
She knows he doesn't need that lightsaber, that scene was symbolic. It's a way to show trust and serves as a parallel to Ren/Han's moment.
>>64584270
The answer is a lot of both
>>64583510
I haven't watched it yet. If there are no themes, no motifs, nothing but generica and unmemorable atmospheric filler, then yes, they're comparable.
>>64583582
But listen to the ost seperately. Do you find any of it memorable? Besides the classic themes of course; and even those were used very sparsely.
>>64583565
I really don't know. Other than the first few minutes which are used in the end of every SW, the rest of it is Rey's theme (which is a joke as a theme) and just filler tripe.
>>64584309
Yeah, they can have 150 or so people, daily.
dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2709106/An-island-far-far-away-Filming-Star-Wars-Episode-7-takes-place-remote-Irish-island-veil-secrecy.html
>>64584227
Hey, fuck you. If you don't like it, you come up with something.
>>64584294
Which moment? WhenHan gets impaled on a fiery blade?
Doesn't make much sense to me.
>>64584309
Man that last shot was so fuckin weird and out of place,it didn't help that it was preceded by like 30+ seconds of silence
>>64584401
>Veil of secrecy
>Literally everyone knew it would be where Luke was
It was obvious as fuck
>>64584444
Ren"offers" his lightsaber to Han, same as Rey with Luke with the exception being their intent.
>>64577928
Oh fuck you I smiled all 3 times when I saw it you people are so autistic.
Not every needs to be communicated vocally.
>>64579912
>paying to see a Star Wars movie after 1999
What the fuck did you expect? After the disappointing Phantom Menace movie, every sane person should have realized that the franchise is dead. When Lucas sold it to Disney the final nail in the coffin was placed. I get that some people need to see it regardless, but why not pirate? Get off your high horse and pirate every shekel grabbing movie out there. They shouldn't be making profits off these crap movies or else they will keep making them.
> The end scene now takes place at night as Rey and Fin approach a black figure sitting in a meditation like position, silhouetted against a small fire. There’s a small camp site with R2-D2 off to the right. The final shot is simply Luke half looking around to see who is there, teary eyed.
A bit like pic related but not looking evil n shit,
>>64585610
pre good t b h
>>64585610
Isn't this from that autists green-text rewrite of TFA? Which is actually kinda good
What emotion is Luke trying to convey here?
He looks angry, but kind of sad. So is he pissed off that somebody found him and that it was the girl he tried to hide away? And is he sad because of Han and/or because she is his daughter?
>>64587241
He's annoyed because he's stuck on a rock with a girl who can't act for shit and is putting on a dumb smug face for some reason.
>>64585610
way better
>>64577928
Fuck off you cynical peice of shit, it was a fantastic scene that would have been absolutely ruined with the inclusion of dialogue
>>64577974
Pleb
>>64588231
It was a shit scene that should have ended 10 seconds earlier without the stupid narrow helicopter shot
final scene was too long
>>64588231
except that theres something shitty about receiving a lost lightstaber that killed a ton of people from a shitty kid you've never seen before.
>>64577928
>making fun of the only good scene in the movie
It had the balls to take its time, unlike the previous two hours of non-stop movement
>>64577928
the last scene with Luke was pretty good.
>>64588334
in a film that doesn't take its time at all, lingering on the final shot and refusing to have dialogue showed a lot of restraint
>>64588341
Prequels aren't cannon, and Luke clearly knows who she is
>>64588430
>Prequels aren't cannon
>cannon
Maybe not, they certainly are canon however.
