Is this the best scene in Star Wars?
No, although it's potentially the worst
>>64346934
>muh prequel suck shilling
>>64346955
Do you even know what shilling means?
>>64347037
Shilling means "liking/not liking something I don't like/like."
Just like cuck means "sex with black people or something, I don't even care."
>>64347157
Did the animators deserve an Oscar for the prequels?
>>64347082
Never fucking reply to me unless you're contributing to the thread.
>>64347037
You're promoting Disney's anti-prequel agenda
>>64347183
>JEDIS DYING IN DROVES
LOL
What a shitty bunch of fighters they are.
Fremen would rape their worlds.
>>64346923
without a doubbt
>>64347157
Looks so fucking dumb
>>64347260
>>64346923
No
>>64347254
Never fucking reply to me again unless you're contributing to the thread.
>>64347302
that angle on those guys in the bottom
>>64347421
thought it was fake
That's not the pod racing scene
>>64347371
Why are the droids charging them if they have ranged weapons and jedi only have melee weapons?
>>64347568
They have to move forward to make way for the next wave of droids
>>64347587
Windu looks pretty uncomfortable on that thing.
>>64347587
>jedi use window shades popular in the 60s
>>64347644
checked
>>64347236
Quit same fagging with this reply you autist
>>64347371
Why did those two jedis have spare lightsabers?
>>64347325
yea, they should have used practical laser swords and blaster robots for this
>>64347780
Why wouldn't they have spare lightsabers? Would you carry only one gun?
How did all the Jedi enter the arena virtually unnoticed?
Did they show up at different times and pay for their tickets?
Why did nobody ask questions to the only non-bug-aliens in the crowd?
>>64347797
Because that's the only other possible option, right?
>>64346923
What's wrong with Anakin's saber?
>>64347843
Because in every movie when some jedi loses his weapon he tries to get it back instead of getting out his number 2 lightsaber and now suddently those two faggots have spares?
>>64347916
Why lose your main weapon just because you have a spare? Then if you lose your spare you're left with nothing but force lightning.
>>64347945
I mean they lose it in the middle of the battle. The logical thing to do is to get your spare and continue the fight, not risk your life to get the first one with no lightsaber.
>>64347183
why didn't they all just fire at the same time?
why take it in turns and let the jedi deflect everything?
>>64346923
no, it symbolized everything that is wrong with the prequels
>lets shove as much shit as we can into the frame guise!!!
honestly it was a huge clusterfuck and i couldn't care less about anything that was happening
FUCK ME this movie sucked, it's the worst SW movie
>>64347302
>>64347568
Because they are fodder. Bigger droids coming in the back. Who says their weapons are ranged?
>>64347644
These are just generally high performing blinds you fucknut. They are efficient. Next you'll be
>hurr durr jedi use footpaths popular in the dark ages
>>64347644
>jedi use diners popular in the 60s
LUCASSSSS
>>64347872
jedi mind tricks
>>64347780
I imagine when they set out to save some jedi they realized that those jedi may need some lightsabers
>>64348383
>Jedi use pillars and arches popular in roman times
Natalie portman was hot in that scene
How did we get from this
to this >>64346923
>>64347236
every time
>>64348945
Costumes and weapons that were essentially WWII gear with futuristic elemetns were replaced with Star-Trek space Utopia crap. The prequels would have been better if they dropped the utopian look for the slightly grittier one from the original trilogy.
The originals just used normal sets, they didn't build worlds, they didn't convince me the film was occurring in a galaxy far away. Same with TFA
The prequels however showed mindblowing architecture, creatures, and transportational scnes
>>64346923
Mary Sue Rey is already more powerful than half of those scrub "jedis" out there.
>>64348945
>>64349028
No they wouldn't, fuck off. If plebs like you were in charge, nothing would ever change.
the utopian look was great because it was weathered just slightly enough to seem natural. It was also inspirational and spawned dozens of shitty clones
>>64347236
a site where you could earn a reputation for saying the same thing repeatedly and be rewarded for it might be more suitable for you. reddit would be a good place to start.
>>64349091
totally dated, looks like a robot chicken episode
>>64349076
I agree, although the OT was still convincing for me because I saw it when I was 4-5
>>64347371
>that jedi at the beginning just battling air
>>64347644
The whole movie has a 50s aesthetic, anon. Check the old Amazing Stories covers.
>>64347990
Also, why no droids up in the seats firing down on them as well? Also why no explosives?
padme is cute
cute!
>>64348754
>jedi have taste
Why not?
best on paper
terrible in practice
it's like something a kid would imagine happening when he's bored in his room on a rainy sunday afternoon.
>>64347878
what is the alternative nigger?
>>64347219
More like a Congressional Medal of Honor. Their sacrifices in trying to make that nonsense look coherent shall not be forgotten.
>>64347254
>>64346955
Disney gets money every time someone buys or rents one of the PT so if any one is shilling here it's you.
>>64347399
dis
>>64349129
I agree somewhat with you. I actually liked the Pre-empire look of the universe in the prequels. It was different, but almost too different, to the point where they feel like entirely different universes. Some similarities would have been nice
>>64349091
Trenches and laying prone. Holding your gun against a ledge for support. Deadly explosions. Sense of desperation. Actual RL military tactics.
>>64346923
People standing around upright in a random ball formation in the middle of a field of open terrain. Shooting at each other from 10-15 metres and somehow missing. This is a G.I.Joe cartoon.
>>64346923
Attack of the Clones is by far the worst Star Wars movie ever made.
>>64348382
This so much. Every battle scene in II-III gives me a headache.
>>64349424
2>7
>>64347371
Why the fuck does this remind me of TDKR
>>64347157
question: did they have stage directions on how and when to swing or did they fit the cgi monsters based on the actors' actions?
>>64349446
:^)
>>64349457
They were fitted in, hence:
>>64347219
Yes
>>64347183
THIS is true star wars, not that force awakens crap
>>64349457
Looks like they're just flailing randomly. Probably the latter.
>>64349451
Because both sides employ the same tactics.
>police have no guns, charge the enemy
>Jedi have no guns, charge the enemy
>Bane's mercenaries have guns, charge the enemy
>Dooku's droids have guns, charge the enemy
>>64346923
Man, I still haven't actually seen this scene. Went to see the film when it came out, fell asleep at some point during the endless Anakin-Padme bits, and woke up again towards the end.
>>64346923
It sure is the most dense.
Lucas jumped on the CGI bangwagon like right when a lot of this software was still just starting to be developed, right? it was still shitty as fuck, looks outdated now, if he had done this in 2016 it would be a different story, instead you have one retarded looking thing after another
I loved this shot
>>64349642
M A N L E T
A
N
L
E
T
>>64349424
ever made so far*
>>64349680
Fuck, I just noticed the tiny trooper.
>>64347082
holy shit is cuck unblocked
cuck
>>64349743
Yeah, fair enough. I'm not too worried about 8, I think Rian is going to make something spectacular. I'm worried about 9 though. Jurassic World was okay, but nothing to write home about. The only reason Colin got the job was because that movie made a fuck ton of money.
Also Rogue One looks promising, but the screenwriters scare the shit out of me.
>>64348754
Is this a joke? It's a stylistic choice, you imbecile.
>>64349865
HAPPY NEW YEARS EVERYONE
KEK DESU BAKA SENPAI IMO
>>64347157
>like some fucking jeditards at a con
;__;
>>64349954
cuck is but KEK isn't
>padme escapes to top of pillar
>anakin:"what about padme?
>obi wan:"She seems to be on top of things
>>64346923
>jedis run out into the field swinging laser swords
>half of them get gunned down
>nobody using the force
>>64349954
so wait only the undercase isnt blocked?
cuck desu senpai baka
>>64347183
Jesus that look so shitty
>>64347481
Is that real? If it is, that's fantastic.
>>64347219
>>64348715
One spare makes sense, but not two. They were only there for Obi-Wan. Anakin was instructed to stay where he was, which was tatooine at the time, and not get involved.
Just want to point out Mace and Yoda decided to risk the lives of countless Jedi and make an official declaration of war just to save Obi-Wan.
>>64349420
>giant stupid robots that make no sense
>explode when they fall over
>can be taken out with a bit of rope
>sense of desperation
dudududududududududu
>>64347157
It's like poverty.
It sucks.
>>64347481
>beat it white slavers
>>64350267
WW1 and WW2 tanks could be rendered immobile with a blanket.
>>64350270
>>64350159
Ewan deserved an oscar, his acting is stellar considering what he had to work with
Diarmid's is as well but he didn't have the same kind of scenes as poor Ewan
Seeing Kit Fisto 'go to town' was definitely a highlight of the saga (including the OT).
>>64350400
I keep seeing this claim, but from what I remember he was as wooden as everybody else in the first two at least, maybe slightly better in the third. Imo McDiarmid was the only actor who came out from those films looking good.
>>64346923
My wife's son and I loved that scene.
>>64350539
>Kit Fisto
>Kid Fister
is George secretly a pedo?
>>64350539
He was cool as fuck in the Clone Wars cartoon.
>>64346923
>HEY, EVERYONE LOVES LIGHTSABERS RIGHT? LET'S JUST HAVE THEM ALL THE FUCKING TIME
ugh 2tbh
>>64346923
>Is this the best scene in Star Wars?
From a certain point of view
>>64351131
From my point of view, the prequels are good!
>>64347157
LARPing.webm
>>64351237
Then you are lost.
>>64350723
My boyfriend's wife up-voted it
>>64347183
It's so dense, every single frame has so much going on.
>>64351770
Redditlettermedia detected
p.s, i did like their vader suit video
>>64349133
>a-am i doing it r-right guys?
>>64347410
This is why Anakin keeps losing his limbs.
He needs to stop twirling and needs to start spinning because it's a good trick plus he keeps giving up the high ground.
>>64347481
>outta my way Disney fucking shits>>64346923
>>64347986
>>64347916
DRAMATIC EFFECT
Ain't no fun if they could all just pull a ton of sabers from their pockets.
It's common sense but Lucas writes the stories so it's best not to analyze it.
>>64347371
Literall\y something Nolan could have made.
Bravo.
>>64351490
kek
I think pic related is the worst part of any of these flicks
>>64352498She actually has a good arc with a nice twist in TCW
>>64349420
>Trenches and laying prone. Holding your gun against a ledge for support. Deadly explosions. Sense of desperation. Actual RL military tactics.
trench warfare hasn't been viable for a hundred years I really hope you're never my general
>>64349424
maybe the worst movie but VII is the worst star wars movie by a parsec
>>64352560
Is this some metajoke about prequel defenders making excuses by saying the band aid that was TCW cartoon actually had good writers and made a certain character better or does this character actually show up in TCW?
>>64349457
basic directions and animators fitted it in. In the Last Samurai they hand ed out death cards to the extras so they know to die but the manor of their death was determined by the animators
>>64350015
the tentacle head that sheev kills uses the force to knock over droid-PO
>>64352904
IT'S KIT FISTO YOU CUNT
>>64352629
Yeah trench warfare is not a thing anymore, but trenches are still quite handy when you're defending some area.
>>64347780
>tfw in the canon sheev actually has a spare
not shitting you look it up
>>64347236
This was funny one time yesterday. You can stop now
>>64353280
he's supposed to have loads hidden around the senate. Pretty silly in my opinion but then I hate that he has one at all.
desu episode IV isn't even that good. Rethink the movie. Forget the nostalgia and make an opinion on episode IV regardless of "huuurrr it's old so it's good". Of course it's a good movie, especially for its time. But compared to Episode 1-6 this movie may be the second or third worst.
prove me wrong
pic related, it's the most unnecessary scene in the saga
