Find a flaw.
It exists.
Alan Moore thinks its shit and it missed the point of his work entirely
>>64340715
Snyder.
Now gtfo
>>64340715
Directed by Hack Snyder
>>64340814
Alan Moore's the George Lucas of the comic book world.
>>64340833
"That's right, Jay!"
The ending makes no sense
>America's superweapon blew up Russia!
>But it also blew up USA so we're all friends now!
>absence of the giant squid monster
>no smoking
>>64340715
Malin Åkerman's 'acting'.
>>64340874
Yeah the idea in the comic is that they banded together to defend themselves against an alien attack but they know full well that Manhattan is not defendable against. So wouldn't the USSR logically blame the US and it just makes things worse?
>>64341103
THIS
>>64341103
this desu
she was inconceivably bad and it's odd because usually she's just below average
her performance and the fact that the story does kinda revolve around her in a way almost singlehandedly ruined it for me
>>64340715
Hallelujah playing while Nite Owl and Silk Spectre are fucking.
>>64342050
That was hot senpai desuand not just because I have a bear fetish too
>>64340869
>>64340715
It has blood on it.
>>64340814
Alan Moore also thinks the V movie is shit because V had eggs in a basket for breakfast.
>>64340715
No Squid
Final dialog line Dr. Manhattan was supposed to deliver was given to the girl.
No Squid and using Dr. Manhattan means US will be blamed
Giving the final line to silk instead of the MAN THAT CAN SEE THE FUCKING FUTURE absolutely ruins the foreboding, "Nothing ends, Adrian. Nothing ever ends." line
>>64343056
It was better not to have the Squid.
>>64340814
He hasnt seen it. He just assumes it missed the point because his fans have told him so, and because he explicitely asked the studio not to make the movie, but they made it anyway
>>64342658
He hates V for Vendetta because he thought it was cowardly of the Watchowkis to modify his story to turn the villain from a Thatcher analogue into a George W Bush analogue, and felt they should have written their own story if what they wanted to do is launch accusations about 9-11.
>>64343302
Wut
Despite being almost a shot for shot remake, it still manages to miss the point of the comics.
Also a reminder that the only film/video adaptation of his works he's ever liked was from the cartoon Justice League Unlimited. The episode is called For the Man Who Has Everything and it is beautiful.
>>64343339
You are one le thick nigga
>>64342658
the V movie is shit because the source material and execution are both shit.
Alan Moore's work is all garbage. Watchmen itself only barely works as a deconstruction, not as a believable parallel history.
>>64341108
What are they going to do? Bomb the US? As far as they know Manhattan smacked their shit around for even thinking about it.
>>64340715
The plot has a huge hole: baddie could have killed other superhero in a non-suspicious way, or not at all, and explain some BS to him, or even pay him or give him bitches, since he's not moral to begin with.
Secondly, the movie can't decide whether they're super heroes or not. Most fanboys will tell you they're regular humans, at which point I ask how regular humans punch through walls.
>one of the best scenes was removed from the movie when it came out
It's well-made but it fails on many levels.
>>64343302
>"They don't know what British people have for breakfast, they couldn't be bothered. 'Eggy in a basket' apparently. Now the US have 'eggs in a basket,' whish is fried bread with a fried egg in a hole in the middle. I guess they thought we must eat that as well, and thought 'eggy in a basket' was a quaint and Olde Worlde version.
>>64343402
I agree
>>64340715
it's shit
>>64343402
Check out the edges on le reddit man!
>>64343440
>baddie could have killed other superhero
what are you trying to say
>>64343056
Came here to post this. Veidt's face after that line becomes a sudden "what have I done?" that proves the Comedian right all along
>>64343496
He's right, though.
Everyone likes to pretend his comics are smart and tackle real thematic problems. The thing is nothing he has ever done is even close to an original idea, and people that need to be told stories through super heroes and colorful pictures aren't smart.
>>64343584
>>>/reddit/
slow motioooooooon
>>64340715
BBC
>>64343634
And don't come back.
>>64343402
Careful dude, reasonable opinions are frowned upon here. Remember /tv/ is capeshit central.
>>64343443
I've read the screenplay, so I know exactly what they're doing with it, and I'm not going to be going to see it. When I wrote "V," politics were taking a serious turn for the worse over here. We'd had [Conservative Party Prime Minister] Margaret Thatcher in for two or three years, we'd had anti-Thatcher riots, we'd got the National Front and the right wing making serious advances. "V for Vendetta" was specifically about things like fascism and anarchy.
Those words, "fascism" and "anarchy," occur nowhere in the film. It's been turned into a Bush-era parable by people too timid to set a political satire in their own country. In my original story there had been a limited nuclear war, which had isolated Britain, caused a lot of chaos and a collapse of government, and a fascist totalitarian dictatorship had sprung up. Now, in the film, you've got a sinister group of right-wing figures — not fascists, but you know that they're bad guys — and what they have done is manufactured a bio-terror weapon in secret, so that they can fake a massive terrorist incident to get everybody on their side, so that they can pursue their right-wing agenda. It's a thwarted and frustrated and perhaps largely impotent American liberal fantasy of someone with American liberal values [standing up] against a state run by neo-conservatives — which is not what "V for Vendetta" was about. It was about fascism, it was about anarchy, it was about [England]. The intent of the film is nothing like the intent of the book as I wrote it. And if the Wachowski brothers had felt moved to protest the way things were going in America, then wouldn't it have been more direct to do what I'd done and set a risky political narrative sometime in the near future that was obviously talking about the things going on today?
>>64343711
So he sold the rights, and then got butthurt when they tweaked the story and refuses to see it.
He sounds like a bitch.
>>64343706
>shit
>shit
>garbage
Yes, this is acceptable, high-brow criticism.
>>64343584
>The thing is nothing he has ever done is even close to an original idea, and people that need to be told stories through super heroes and colorful pictures aren't smart.
Jodorowksy.
>>64343787
He doesnt own the full rights. DC does.
>>64343837
capeshit is 2deep4me then
>>64343929
Fucking MLP is 2deep4u , m8.
>>64342202
Came to post this.
>>64343954
heh, stop projecting
>>64344009
fuck off foKy
>>64343168
>and because he explicitely asked the studio not to make the movie, but they made it anyway
Thank God they didn't listen