[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Home]
4chanarchives logo
What is your most hated Lucas edit that had been made along the years.
Images are sometimes not shown due to bandwidth/network limitations. Refreshing the page usually helps.

You are currently reading a thread in /tv/ - Television & Film

Thread replies: 255
Thread images: 89
File: Fuck this force.png (254 KB, 612x290) Image search: [Google]
Fuck this force.png
254 KB, 612x290
What is your most hated Lucas edit that had been made along the years.
>>
>>64273742
That sand nigglet falling off the dinosaur. Fucking stupid
>>
>>64273742
Definitely this:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PiDRgDmXGi4
>>
>>64273742
That one by a mile. Everything else is bearable.
>>
>>64273742
The rocks in front of R2, it's just so fucking uunnessesary that it makes absolutely no sense why it was added
>>
everytime vader says "no"
>>
That one and the NOOOOO added into ROTJ. That one was just a pure FUCK YOU from Lucas. The only edit he did that was actually a good idea was changing the emperor in ESB, but he even fucked that up by putting Sheev in his retarded looking ROTS makeup instead of using his ROTJ makeup.
>>
>>64273742
I don't really mind OP. It's egregious and stupid, but it's supposed to demonstrate that the 'original' anakin became a force ghost, not that cyborg cripple.

The worst thing is the wall of CGI flesh that passes in front of the camera in the special edition of a new hope, when Luke and Obi Wan enter Mos Eisley. That scene is already extended with needless CGI bullshit but the fucking Dinosaur OBSTRUCTING THE SHOT is just goddamn terrible.

>>64273798
this is just bewildering
>>
>>64273798
Objectively the correct answer, just fuck my narrative pacing up
>>
>>64273742
call me pleb, but I like that one. better to have anakin (as he was when young jedi) than old vader guy for the new generations to watch
>>
>>64273798
As a kid, I think this was probably one of my first memories of cringing at how painfully awkward someone was.
>>
>>64273742
EVERY SINGLE ONE OF YOU ARE WRONG

Its adding all the jarjars to the celebration scenes at the end of ep6
>>
Seeing as I'm not autistic, I enjoy all of Lucas's edits, even the "Nooooo". It acts as a nice callback to epsode 3, and it shows the deep emotions of Vader. Him beign silent made it seem like he was a machine when in reality he's a tragic hero,as shown by Hayden's edgy and dangerus acting, which was great of course.
>>
let me jog some of your memories

>han talking to ugly dirty CGI Jabba the hut

>mos eisley intro extended with unnecessary establishing shots and CGI monsters

>Han chasing Storm Troopers into a docking bay full of like a trillion Troopers all standing around

>Han 'dodging' Greedo's bullet so he doesn't have to shoot first

>Jizz

>JIZZ
>>
>>64273905
I'm going to throw up.
>>
>>64273742
Wow, not a single "han shot first" thus far.
>>
That

Or the blu ray change to Obi Wans kraut dragon scream, it makes no fucking sense and makes some sound like a drunken Ric Flair. Lucas didnt even make him sound like a fucking Tusken Raider

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-yxuDU8gims
>>
The one that has stuck out for me over the years is a scene from the original don't remember which one(I think it's the bar scene) and there's this alien cabaret singer that's jumping from one place to another and we get a really close shot of her face.
>>
File: SW-R2-D2.jpg (78 KB, 600x318) Image search: [Google]
SW-R2-D2.jpg
78 KB, 600x318
>>64273742
This shit right here.
When I was about to start watching Star Wars on Netflix, this was the first thing I looked for.

This was the reason I downloaded the Despecialized edition in the first place in one night.
>>
>>64273880
Pretty much this. He was just mad at fans for mocking Vaderr in Episode 3 so he shat all over the OT some more.
>>
>>64273905
Fuck you rick berman
>>
>>64273944
Not gonna fall for it.
>>
>>64273798
Granted, the rendition of Lapti Nek in the 1983 version was ear grating, but why the fuck would he

1. Write an entirely new song
2. add retarded CGI characters THAT ALREADY LOOK DATED to a scene full of costumed actors
3. ADD NEW FUCKING COSTUMED ACTORS ALONGSIDE THE FUCKING CGI CHARACTERS, WHY DIDN'T YOU JUST HAVE A COSTUMED ACTOR SING THE SONG INSTEAD OF A FUCKING CARTOON FROG AND ALF???
4. Make a scene that was already a little jarring and out of place (but it kinda worked, I mean if you're a crime lord you're gonna have entertainment at your hideout and it's kind of nice to see little details) and make it more jarring and out of place

Like none of this shit makes sense, you might think that Lucas just had ILM interns come up with a bunch of ideas, taped them to the wall and started throwing darts at them while blindfolded. But I really doubt a completely random process could make a scene this uniquely bad.
>>
>>64274000
Star wars...netflix....w-what?

Ive also downloaded the despecialized editions bit havent watched them yet. Wating for ROTJ 2.0 to be released so i can watch them all together.
>>
>>64274000

What the fuck was he thinking?

Also checked.
>>
'noo' in ROTJ is the worst thing
>>
>>64273951
The docking bay one is one of the few edits I'd keep. That and 'close the blast doors - open the blast doors, open the blast doors!'
>>
>>64273798
It's legitimately hard to watch
>>
>>64273965
Man, I never watched the blu-rays so I only heard about these edits from the internet, this one passed me by.

I still don't think it surpasses the ROTJ NOOOO, but this is pretty awful too. His ideas for edits just got progressively worse as time went on.

If Disney didn't take the rights away I'm sure he'd be making the XTRA SPECIAL EDITION where Obi-Wan projected a CGI illusion of a Krayt Dragon using the force.
>>
File: lemmystarwars.jpg (22 KB, 599x307) Image search: [Google]
lemmystarwars.jpg
22 KB, 599x307
i hear lucas is a huge fan of motorhead and is considering this addition to the OT.
>>
>>64273965
I can't even get angry about this, it's too funny and inoffensive compared to Jorge's other choices, such as http://youtu.be/O3tuBH3R7xk , which literally ruins the pivotal moment of the movie.
>>
>>64273798

i think most of these revisions were so he could improve his IP rights.

it had to come down to copyright splits or something
>>
>>64273742

Changing the Emperor & Vader's conversation in ESB. Updating the visual was fine, but the altered dialogue wrecks the scene. You can tell George was just like "I can write this better than Kasdan." No, George, no you can't.
>>
>implying Han shot first
>>
File: Finn and Rey.jpg (82 KB, 580x333) Image search: [Google]
Finn and Rey.jpg
82 KB, 580x333
>>64273742
1 > Rotj alien singing/shouting into camera
2 > Vader saying no when he throws Palpi into the abyss
3 > Just clutter my screen up with CGI senpai
4 > Han glitching the matrix because an agent tries to mold into Greedo appearantly
5 > More random alien clutter on screen, espacially in Hope is this so out of place and looks plain dumb
6 > Fucking dumb rocks R2D2 couldn't even hide behind
7 > That stupid fucking neo Anakin grinning at the end of Rotj (OP pic)
8 > Poor Sheev, Empire make-up which made him sort of mysterius is now gone as he just looks like Prequal monster mash Sheevster
9 > CGI Jabba, simply cringy as fuck
10 > those extended celebration scenes at the end of Rotj where you see Peruskin and Naboo free'd. Actually they just look the same as as before but hey, what do we know or have seen about Naboo? It's a planet of 20 pilots a queen and a few bureaucrats.
>>
>>64273798
I remember that scene. Oh boy, do i remember it. Its been so many years but it still hurts.
>>
>>64273798
http://vocaroo.com/i/s1RhKfFhpIjo
>>
>>64274202
>CGI jabba
Hoy shit this, they spent so much time on the practical puppet and then lucas just shits on it and introduces a shitty looking cgi jabba that looks fucking out of place and ruins the surprise of jabba
>>
>>64274128
>The docking bay one is one of the few edits I'd keep

Fucking why
>>
File: alderaanshotfirst.gif (2 MB, 320x240) Image search: [Google]
alderaanshotfirst.gif
2 MB, 320x240
Definitely this, what was he thinking?
>>
>>64273942
One of the few edits that really didn't matter. Who gives a fuck about that, it's a celebration scene, the tension is gone and we can have a good laugh with the gunga after our tense teddy bear adventure.
>>
File: c3.jpg (144 KB, 535x355) Image search: [Google]
c3.jpg
144 KB, 535x355
>>64274317
Delete this
>>
I don't really remember where but i saw a documentary before the release of the first edits made to the original trilogy and the people involved in special effects and puppets for the original trilogy said that they tried to make the alien singer scene with a puppet but it looked fucking retarded and decided against it, they even showed the puppet.

Apparently Lucas was a fucking stubborn merchant and wanted this made just because he couldn't at the time.
>>
>>64274128
The troopers aren't really that bad, no. Also, they added in a sound effect for when the trooper conks his head on a blast door, I'd keep that.
>>
>>64274404
kek
>>
Stuff wot I liked

>Boba Fett's new voice
>updated visuals for Bespin
>various vfx fixes
>>
>>64274478
i can see someone saying "oh its a great idea george but we just cant do it... whew close one"
>>
>>64274522
>Boba Fett's new voice
Fuck off fag
>>
>>64274522
>Boba Fetts new voice

I fucking hate you.
>>
>>64274202
>That stupid fucking neo Anakin grinning at the end of Rotj
it's a lot better than fucking Uncle Owen being a force ghost imho
>>
File: image.jpg (34 KB, 585x251) Image search: [Google]
image.jpg
34 KB, 585x251
The worst edit was when Lucas had a 6 month /tv/ shitposting binge.
>>
File: 1425139507134.png (154 KB, 309x302) Image search: [Google]
1425139507134.png
154 KB, 309x302
>>64273798
You see this is almost definitive proof Lucas was basically fucking with us with the remastered editions.
He knew he was selling Star Wars so he wanted to get back at us for not liking the Prequels.
>>
>>64274662
GET OUT
>>
>>64274694
Why should he? It's a funny image.
>>
>>64274202
eh the original mask for Sheev was kind of creepy but really inconsistent with RotJ. There was another edit being considered which used Sheev from RotJ but Lucas made it monster mash later on
>>
>>64274317
Is that you George?
>>
Not the most offensive but probably the most baffling for me, was in empire. When R2 gets thrown up by the swamp monster, they changed Luke's line from
>You're lucky you don't taste so good
to
>You're lucky you didn't get eaten

I literally can't believe George felt this needed to be changed. I just have no words.
>>
>>64273944
Shit this is some next level bait right here
>>
>>64274878
at some point he tasted r2 and changed his mind.
>>
The Jabba scene in A New Hope was unecessary as fuck because Han has the exact same conversation that he had with Greedo all over again, except he lets him live.
The CGI looks god awful too.

Ontop of all that they put Boba Fett in there and he literally stares into the camera, it's really panderous.
>>
>>64273880
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EyxwJ_cqNZ4
>>
File: 1449575626110.png (1 MB, 471x1207) Image search: [Google]
1449575626110.png
1 MB, 471x1207
>>64274878

He changed "IMPERIAL FORCES HAVE ENTERED THE BASE" from a man's voice to a woman's voice saying the exact same fucking line.

It makes zero fucking sense.
>>
>>64274878

Yeah that was beyond retard, would love to hear George explanation on this
>>
File: 1423510694492.gif (990 KB, 209x200) Image search: [Google]
1423510694492.gif
990 KB, 209x200
ROTJ
CHEWBACCA
TARZAN YELL


FUCKING WHY
>>
>>64274753
dumbass
>>
File: 1449264231015.jpg (24 KB, 392x411) Image search: [Google]
1449264231015.jpg
24 KB, 392x411
>>64274317
please stop
>>
>>64274878
Autism
>>
>>64275006
Which movie was this? Never noticed it.
>>
>>64275034
You can do better than that. You didn't even capitalize or use a period, you silly goose!
>>
File: sww-r2d2-kidsmeals.jpg (77 KB, 539x344) Image search: [Google]
sww-r2d2-kidsmeals.jpg
77 KB, 539x344
>>64275010
im sure its got nothing to do with selling stuff like this.
>>
>>64275059
Van Helsing I think
>>
File: 1442150557624.jpg (48 KB, 499x499) Image search: [Google]
1442150557624.jpg
48 KB, 499x499
>>64274317
>>
>>64273742
Next to the Christensen edit, probably that giant CGI dinosaur ass over the classic Mos Eisley scenery.
>>
>>64273798
So this wasn't in the original version?
I loved this scene
>>
>>64275109
is that a corndog
>>
>>64275244
what
you dont store corndogs and milk in your r2d2 cookie jar?
>>
File: han-fucking-shot-first.gif (933 KB, 450x190) Image search: [Google]
han-fucking-shot-first.gif
933 KB, 450x190
>>64273742

H . A . N . . S . H . O . T . . F . I . R . S . T
.
A
.
N
.
.
S
.
H
.
O
.
T
.
.
F
.
I
.
R
.
S
.
T
>>
File: bioware plot twist.jpg (449 KB, 1547x1048) Image search: [Google]
bioware plot twist.jpg
449 KB, 1547x1048
>>64274522
>Boba Fett's new voice
>>
>>64275264
no but i always make sure to have a case of ranch in it
>>
>>64273742
I don't mind that one. The original had some random old guy as pretty much as a placeholder anyway.
>>
>>64275480
k i l l y o u r s e l f
>>
>>64273798
I like this song better, sorry.
>>
Without a doubt, this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PaXgK5HRBjk
>>
>>64275480
Why would Darth Vaders force ghost be while he was in his mid twenties and yoda/obi wan are both at there age of death?
>>
>>64273742
Easily Vader screaming no when he saves Luke, it completely ruins the silent conflict and conclusion Vader goes through with some cheesy yell.
>>
>>64273742
OP's pic was one I kind of liked desu.
>>
>>64275402
You mean Han shot, only er solo. Greedo never fired.
>>
>>64273742
Why people get mad with this edit? This makes sense.
>>
>>64274671
That was released before the prequels though.
>>
>>64275567
>Why would Darth Vaders force ghost be while he was in his mid twenties and yoda/obi wan are both at there age of death?

That's how he appears to Luke. Luke never accepted Darth Vader as being his father. He never accepted Darth Vader

>I have accepted the truth that you were once Anakin Skywalker, my father.

The aged version is not what Anakin looked like at death either. The kindly old man never existed.
>>
>>64275747
>>64275659
>>64275588
>>64275480
George, why are you spending your retirement on 4chan?
>>
File: Darth-Cupcake.jpg (57 KB, 550x367) Image search: [Google]
Darth-Cupcake.jpg
57 KB, 550x367
>>
>>64274128
That "close the blast doors, open the blast doors" line has been around since 1977. That was part of the mono mix they sent to some theaters. The 5.1 and stereo mixes didn't have it though
>>
File: haydenvader.jpg (30 KB, 1280x720) Image search: [Google]
haydenvader.jpg
30 KB, 1280x720
>>
>>64274048
>3. ADD NEW FUCKING COSTUMED ACTORS ALONGSIDE THE FUCKING CGI CHARACTERS, WHY DIDN'T YOU JUST HAVE A COSTUMED ACTOR SING THE SONG INSTEAD OF A FUCKING CARTOON FROG AND ALF???

Because it was the 90's when CGI was brand new and George thought it was amazing, so he wanted to show it off everywhere.
>>
>>64274991

Damn that revisited one looks much much better. Sheev's face is way too clear in the 2004 version
>>
>>64273886
>not that cyborg cripple
but in the original unfucked version anakin wasnt a cyborg crip, he was just an old man who was free of that mechanical bondage pottery.

did u even watch the original version?
>>
I actually liked Vader screaming "NOOO!!!!" when Luke was getting wrecked by Sheev
>>
>>64276362
Well Lucasfilm did pioneer 3DCG
>>
>>64275567
Because Anakin Skywalker died long ago, killed by Vader.
Like i said in many, many "im hate le prequels, me so hip guise XDDD lol" - you manchildren cannot understand even a basic imagery and symbolism if it is not narrated by old wise jedi.
Every single other edit was shit, the singer in Jabba palace being the shittiest along with bantha ass at Mos Eisley.
>>
>>64276761
>anakins ghost replaced by a machine edit insert
>why are people so mad dude symbolism lel
>>
>>64273905
So basically the fact that Anakin's redemption occurred decades after he turned to the Dark Side (and that he wrestled with his demons for as long) means nothing to you. Old Ghost Anakin is the only justice his character deserves.
>>
>>64273944
You almost had it until you complemented Hayden
>>
Despite the horrible Anakin insert, the fucking abysmal new Jaba's palace music scene, and the poor dubbing of all of Boba's lines with the Jango actor, I still prefer the special edition of Return of the Jedi because I like the song that replaces Yub-Nub much better than Yub-Nub.
>>
>>64273742
>TFA starts getting analyzed and people dont like it
>threads pop up "r-remember george and the p-plinkett reviews, its not as b-bad"
>>
HARD MODE

What is the BEST change Lucas made to the OT?
>>
>>64277397
>HARD MODE
Ian McDiarmid's Sheev in ESB

Not hard at all.
>>
>>64277397
See>>64277265
>>
>>64277436
>sheev
Nice meme
>>
>>64273742
some of the edits are great

a lot of the spacecraft scenes were improved and adding the audible noise to the stromtrooper bumping his head was really fucking funny
>>
>>64277509
>>sheev
>Nice meme

?

It's literally his canon name.
>>
File: 1375314509741.jpg (34 KB, 350x401) Image search: [Google]
1375314509741.jpg
34 KB, 350x401
>>64274317
>>
File: paply.png (80 KB, 276x255) Image search: [Google]
paply.png
80 KB, 276x255
>>64277509
>meme
>>
>>64277436
I don't know why people like this, Sheev in Episode 3 looks like a corpse's ballsack
>>
>sheevs name is so terrible everyone adopted it immediately as a joke confusing marketers thinking theyve done a good job.
>>
>>64276997
>b-but cgi is baaaaaaaaaad because Plinkett said so!
You are literally a luddite. Literally. Not even memeing with "literally" here.
>>
File: FuneralPyre.png (1 MB, 1280x800) Image search: [Google]
FuneralPyre.png
1 MB, 1280x800
>>64277397
>What is the best change George has made to the OT?

The new theme used for the Ewok celebration at the end of Return of the Jedi.

Here is the original
https://youtu.be/np6vAuS0KNs

Here is the new theme
https://youtu.be/AiM5zEEI_Jo
(Skip to 1:30 if you want to avoid the added in scenes of Prequel cities)

I just find the theme much more emotionally powerful and far more suiting as the conclusion song of the saga.
>>
>>64277739
implying ive even seen that.
implying i think cg is bad
implying i wouldnt replace anakin with darth vader.
>>
>>64277781
>implying ive even seen that
You did.
>implying i think cg is bad
Shit about "machine edit" is your words.
>>
>>64277397
>>64277756

The song at the end is a good improvement. Just the song, the added footage wasn't necessary. Sheev being in ESB was a good idea for continuity's sake.
>>
>>64275016
Pretty sure that was in the original, dude.
>>
>"MEESA FREEEEEEEEEEEEE"
Really George?
>>
>>64277870

YOU HAD ONE JOB EMPIRE

ONE JOB
>>
>>64276595
>>64277153
These
>>
>>64277870
>>"MEESA FREEEEEEEEEEEEE"
>Really George?

He said WEESA FREEEEEEEEEEEEE you luddite
>>
>>64273965
I dunno. Its a creepier noise that would be unfamiliar to the Tusken Raiders.
If someone walked up to you and two friends and screamed "fuck off" (or something similar) from over fifteen metres away you wouldnt run away.
>>
File: UuYuGwP.jpg (172 KB, 692x960) Image search: [Google]
UuYuGwP.jpg
172 KB, 692x960
>>64274317
>>
File: get.jpg (58 KB, 640x450) Image search: [Google]
get.jpg
58 KB, 640x450
>>64277756
Huh, I literally don't remember the original Ewok song... has it really been that long?
I could have sworn the new song was in the original.
Either that or the new one is just that much more memerable.

It's funny because I grew up watching the OT via pic related. Maybe I need to break them out of the attic and give them another go.
>>
>>64277996
>If someone walked up to you and two friends and screamed "fuck off" (or something similar) from over fifteen metres away you wouldnt run away.

y-yeah I wouldn't anon
>>
>>64277756

Come to think of it did Yoda even get a funeral or did Luke just leave his body to rot in the swamp?
>>
>>64277870
>MEESA FREEEEEEEEEEEEE
>mise ry
>misery
Oh shi~
>>
>>64273965
did they get jontron to a scream for them?
>>
File: explosion2004.jpg (55 KB, 700x301) Image search: [Google]
explosion2004.jpg
55 KB, 700x301
It's unfortunate that there is no ultimate edition blu Ray for each film that lets us optimize certain features from each version of each film for viewing.

There's certain things I like from various release of each film in the OT.

For example in a new hope, I like Han Shot First and there being no Jabba scene, but I enjoy the improved opening score and CGI edits to the Death Star battle.
>>
>>64278139

He faded out of existence, didn't he?
>>
the one where he is in a massice yacht in St. Barts right now having an awesome day while you make this thread. I never got that edit.

http://www.tmz.com/2015/12/30/george-lucas-st-barts/
>>
>>64278186

That is one of those ideas that is too good for anybody to ever implement.
>>
File: Why.jpg (38 KB, 288x499) Image search: [Google]
Why.jpg
38 KB, 288x499
>>64274317
>>
>>64278208

So does the body have to be destroyed for one to be a force ghost?
>>
>>64278139
Yoda's body was literally absorbed into the Force, anon
>>
File: hqdefault.jpg (31 KB, 480x360) Image search: [Google]
hqdefault.jpg
31 KB, 480x360
>Your thoughts betray you, Father. I can feel the good in you
>The conflict

What did he mean by this?
>>
>>64278229
another daily bait star wars story
when will they run out
>>
File: 1432418388270.png (248 KB, 600x335) Image search: [Google]
1432418388270.png
248 KB, 600x335
>>64278229

>mfw Lucas spends his days Sheev-posting on /tv/
>>
>>64278186
Fuck... That's a damn good idea.

>tfw watching HD empire strikes back with all original diologue and no Lucas edits with the exception of sheev
>>
>>64276211

>Let me look upon you with my own eyes, clean and sandless

What did he mean by this?
>>
File: authentic-darth-vader-costume.jpg (323 KB, 1750x2500) Image search: [Google]
authentic-darth-vader-costume.jpg
323 KB, 1750x2500
>>64278296
THERE IS NO CONFLICT
>>
>>64278052
Oh, you!
>>
File: darthvader.jpg (406 KB, 2560x1600) Image search: [Google]
darthvader.jpg
406 KB, 2560x1600
So... what actually killed him?
>>
>>64275567
Maybe the ghosts fluctuate, I don't know. Ewan McGregor AND Alec Guiness were in TFA as Obi-Wan.

>Alec Guiness's actual ghost when he is put in a new Star Wars movie
>>
Who played it better?
>>
File: ben2.jpg (63 KB, 500x300) Image search: [Google]
ben2.jpg
63 KB, 500x300
>>64278581
Forgot pic
>>
>>64278524

Sheev's lightning
>>
>>64278524
indifference to RotJ's potential for sequels.
>>
>>64278524
Luke beat him but refused to kill him so he went crawling to the Emperor's side. Sheev's electricity is what actually killed him when he was redeemed.
>>
File: PHzSmAJcTC9cDA_1_l.jpg (37 KB, 600x338) Image search: [Google]
PHzSmAJcTC9cDA_1_l.jpg
37 KB, 600x338
>>64273742
The Lego game actually had some good fun with OP's pic
>>
>>64275535
Lucas had the sense to remove that, though.

I don't mind him bastardizing the entire trilogy, I just wish he would release originals. The only originals we got are the shit quality dvds that came out like 10 years. An enhanced original that doesn't play like garbage would be nice.

Then he could take a giant shit on the rest of the movies and no one would care.
>>
>>64278524
When Luke took off his mask.

There's no way getting his robot arm cut off is fatal. He wanted to die and become a force ghost.
>>
>>64278618
theyre both great but Ewan is trying to mimic Guiness especially in III, so I guess Guiness
>>
File: 1451233185894.jpg (11 KB, 234x231) Image search: [Google]
1451233185894.jpg
11 KB, 234x231
>>64274317
>>
>>64273798
>trying to turn a scene where a gang boss has an unwilling whore murdered into a fun cg singalong for kids

This is pure autism
>>
>>64278719
I want to see more of this conversation.
>>
>>64278618
Old Ben is kind of flat, Obi-Wan has an ok progression from Qui's pupil to whatever he is in 3.
>>
>>64278139
>Now I am Yoda
>>
>>64274317
For what purpose
>>
those weird cgi creatures that appear at jabba's place out of nowhere and have a sing and dance show
>>
>>64274317
I fucking lost my shit. My fucking sides, died at chimichangas
>>
File: Jedi_Council_RotS.png (2 MB, 1919x816) Image search: [Google]
Jedi_Council_RotS.png
2 MB, 1919x816
>>64278788
He's a Jedi master in ROTS which is actually a retcon by Lucas himself, as in the old canon Kenobi never progressed past Jedi Knight rank.
>>
>>64278524
he died... of a broken heart ;_;
>>
>>64278838

Fucking this forever

I can't believe people actually let Lucas get away with this
>>
File: Councilrots.jpg (165 KB, 1600x678) Image search: [Google]
Councilrots.jpg
165 KB, 1600x678
So I'm confused.

Sheev just appoints Anakin straight to the tank of Jedi master?

He has that power?
He can go right over the Jedi council's heads?
>>
>>64274404
Hue
>>
>>64278525
It was just their voices. And the only clip from Guinness was him saying "afraid" which they edited down to just "Rey"
>>
>>64273742
>hating any of the Special Edition edits
HELLO REDDIT!
>>
>>64274048
>ear grating
but it fit the palace so well
>>
>>64274404
Kek
>>
>>64279066
You didn't watch the movie. Ani got mad the Council kept him a simple knight and not a master when he was put on the council by sheev
>>
>>64279066
sheev made a request that anakin be made a master

sheev is the supreme chancellor of the republic which the jedi ostensibly serve (by their own will, not officially or legally). refusing would make him a political enemy. they don't completely trust sheev but at the time it seemed that sheev trusted anakin (though we, the audience, all knew this was a ruse). the jedi council decided to grant his request in order to use anakin to spy on him.

this is all explained in the movie
>>
>>64279066

You can literally youtube the scene where they explain it in plain words.
>>
File: starwarsl.png (519 KB, 1054x900) Image search: [Google]
starwarsl.png
519 KB, 1054x900
>>64278996
every time
>>
>>64273742
Yuh nub
>>
File: GeorgeLucas.JPG.jpg (59 KB, 709x913) Image search: [Google]
GeorgeLucas.JPG.jpg
59 KB, 709x913
>Yoda is more powerful than Windu
>Sheev loses to Windu
>Sheev beats Yoda

BRAVO GEORGE
>>
>>64279066
They appointed him to the council as Sheev wanted but did not grant him the rank of master. There's a scene right after where Anakin is fuming about it with Obi-Wan, saying it has never happened before and it's insulting.
>>
>>64278011
These are the best versions. THX remastered, picture cleaned up, no actual changes other than making them look better. Came out right before the special edition did, still have my copy. Even converted them to digital versions just to hang onto them forever.
>>
File: tmp_10419-large1428581661.gif (2 MB, 500x280) Image search: [Google]
tmp_10419-large1428581661.gif
2 MB, 500x280
>>64278011
>mfw my vcr ate my copy of ANH from this set
>>
>>64279288
Windu had type advantage
Purple->Red->Green->Blue->Yellow/Orange->Purple
>>
>>64279288
sheev lost the lightsaber battle with windu and windu is super strong in the force as well

windu is pretty much the perfect person to fight any type of sith
>>
How does apprentenceship work in the Jedi order?

So once Anakin moves up from Padawan to Knight, he's still Obi's apprentice?
And once Obi becomes a master, he still keeps an apprentice?

I thought there was an "apprentice" rank between Padawan and Knight and that Masters didn't have an apprentice.
>>
>>64279288
>i am literally autismpaedia neckbeard who actually thinks that his capeshit power level fantasies mean shit to one of a greatest visionaries of our time
>i even dare to think that he read any of this bullshit consisting of "uwhwhwum achshwchchoooollee" only
Whew lad, you are retarded.
>>
>>64279421
mido clorians
>>
>>64279380

>>64279421 goes well for you too, fren'. You two are retarded pieces of horse shit.
>b-but my POWAH LEWUL
Go play streetfighter and stay away from the mediums that require compassion and imagination, assclown.
>>
>>64277397
Adding in the scene with Biggs and Luke before the Battle of Yavin
>>
>>64279518
Side effect, not the cause. Just bacteria that feed on the Force.
>>
>>64274522
Bobas new voice is FUCKING TRASH
>>
>>64279540
when they why do jedi autistically measure it hrmmm
>>
>>64279420
It's an apprentice till they finish there training
I wonder what happened to a skins orange butt cheeks aprentice
>>
File: 1409262526523s.jpg (15 KB, 250x250) Image search: [Google]
1409262526523s.jpg
15 KB, 250x250
>>64274317
>CHIMICHANGA
>>
File: thx_box2.png (240 KB, 600x400) Image search: [Google]
thx_box2.png
240 KB, 600x400
>>64279353
What about the widescreen variants of those versions?
Better or worse?

I'm thinking of picking them up on ebay.
>>
>>64279583
It's like smells no for rotten eggs during a gas leak
It's not actually rotten eggs originally
>>
>>64279656
I only have the regular ones. Good luck, hope they're in good shape. I suggest you get them turned into digital formats asap. VHS wears out
>>
>>64279420
I don't think Anakin was really his apprentice after he became a Knight, they would just be together on missions. Anakin was given his own padawan when he was a Knight. I could be forgetting a line that implied they were still student/teacher.
>>
>>64279583
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FoVpSPXGCvc

Because it can help ROUGHLY estimate the POTENTIAL of somebody FEELING THE FORCE.
>>
>>64273798

It is the most blatant example of the prequels taking a huge steaming shit on the originals.

Will we honestly ever tire of hating on everything Lucas did to the series after RoTJ?
It's just so perfectly awful I don't think we will.
>>
>>64273798

hey guys

this will blow your mind

are you ready?

star wars is LITERALLY for children
>>
>>64273742
>when they go to mos eisly and you cant even see them since so much stuff is shoved into the screen
>Vader screaming No in ep 6 when saving luke
>>
File: 1446194441059.jpg (143 KB, 400x400) Image search: [Google]
1446194441059.jpg
143 KB, 400x400
>>64274317
>>
>>64279697
>I only have the regular ones. Good luck, hope they're in good shape. I suggest you get them turned into digital formats asap
Que?
>>
>>64274317

I don't believe for a second that you haven't rehearsed this for hours.
>>
>>64273742
>ROTJ CGI dance number
>Luke's scream in ESB even though he's supposed to be commiting honorable suicide
>Vader's NOOOOOOO because Lucas was pissed at fans for mocking Episode 3
>>
>>64279760

But George you made that film where literal child murder happens!

That doesn't happen in kid's films.
>>
>>64279823
Disney now owns the franchise. Can they go back and re-edit the movies?
>>
>>64273742
The movies got worse by every edition, I'm 100% certain that George Lucas is a complete autist.
>>
>>64277870
Crazy how George is so fucking bitter over fans shitting on Jar Jar he decided to shove him into the OT.
>>
>>64279866
Star Wars is one of the few children's franchises in America that doesn't shy away from death and some disturbing things.
>>
>>64279896
Nope. THe publishing rights for those movies belong to Fox for 9 more years. It's the same with the PT.

George put that in the selling deal as a way to make sure that Disney wouldn't bend over backwards to the fanbase and undo his changes to OT, or re-do the prequels with a new script.
>>
An edit so terrible it was changed back again.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PaXgK5HRBjk
>>
>>64280041
>THe publishing rights for those movies belong to Fox for 9 more years.

But after that? Is there hope then?
>>
>>64280104
after that it will be so old literally kill yourself for caring.
>>
>>64280104
Fox also has the distribution rights for A New Hope until literally the end of time.
>>
>>64274202

The Sheev edit was the one of the few good edits.

The mask made him more mysterious which was good but it didn't match up with Jedi at all.
>>
>>64280041
Would Disney even redo the prequels? They stated that the prequels were an important pillar in Star Wars history, and Clone Wars as well. Since TCW is so heavily connected to the prequels, and then their own Rebels so heavily connected to TCW, wouldn't it just be a domino effect that's not worth their time?
>>
>>64274317
I knew I got out of bed for something good today.
>>
>>64279760
I don't think there's a kid alive that enjoys that
>>
>>64280104
ESB and ROTJ go to Disney, but ANH is Fox property forever.
>>
File: 1328042681145.jpg (68 KB, 577x599) Image search: [Google]
1328042681145.jpg
68 KB, 577x599
>>64274317
HOLY FUCK
>>
>>64274878
This will be changed back to "You're lucky you didn't fly so good" in the upcoming theatrical re-release
>>
>>64279960
i think that was added when the special editions came out - before episode 1 came out
>>
File: 1422581829050.jpg (73 KB, 495x636) Image search: [Google]
1422581829050.jpg
73 KB, 495x636
>>64280277
>but ANH is Fox property forever.
>>
>>64273798
Couldn't even fucking finish it.
>>
>>64279760
>hey guys
Fuck off back to reddit.
>>
File: star-wars-327.png (198 KB, 590x369) Image search: [Google]
star-wars-327.png
198 KB, 590x369
>You fought in the clone wars?
Really lucas?
>>
>>64273798
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NkLMSpDJH1A
>>
File: ABUNAI.gif (492 KB, 455x393) Image search: [Google]
ABUNAI.gif
492 KB, 455x393
>>64274317
why
>>
>>64280673

>Making your actors reference every autistic idea you come up with just so you can edit it in later should you ever decide to use it.

wow
>>
File: twdson.jpg (30 KB, 292x342) Image search: [Google]
twdson.jpg
30 KB, 292x342
>>64280700
>>
>>64280104
Fox owns the theatrical, non-theatrical, and home video rights through 2020, and outright owns A New Hope until the end of time
>>
>>64273798
George Lucas is literally autistic
>>
>>64273798
goo, ni, tey
nonono ah louwa
GOO NI TEY
>>
>>64279988

Harry Potter had a bunch of deaths and didn't have anyone steppin in da poopy as far as I recall.
>>
>>64279866
George was molested and raped as a child this how he visions kid movies
>>
File: finn-and-rey.jpg (56 KB, 1000x432) Image search: [Google]
finn-and-rey.jpg
56 KB, 1000x432
>>64280673
>You fought during the return of the jedi?
fucking really, JJ?
>>
>>64280741
New game: find random OT lines and decide what idea george didnt get to put in that he wanted to based off that line
>>
File: image.jpg (31 KB, 299x340) Image search: [Google]
image.jpg
31 KB, 299x340
>>64274317
>>
>>64273798
literally looks like roger rabbit when the sasquatch manlet close up happens
>>
File: 1451290038771.gif (954 KB, 400x300) Image search: [Google]
1451290038771.gif
954 KB, 400x300
>>64274317
>>
File: 1443143454520.gif (2 MB, 320x320) Image search: [Google]
1443143454520.gif
2 MB, 320x320
>>64278954

>mfw even the chairs are CGI
>>
>>64274522
The Bespin fixes and the updated explosions are the only good edits i can think of
>>
>>64273942
we-sa free!
>>
>>64273742
I just finished going thru all six episodes chronologically, and this really triggered me.
>>
File: 1451263948645.webm (772 KB, 1280x720) Image search: [Google]
1451263948645.webm
772 KB, 1280x720
>>64273886

but Old Vader redeemed himself at the end so why wouldn't it be Old Anakin ghost?
>>
>>64273742
This is just a big fuck you from Lucas
>Oh so you didn't like my prequel trilogy
>Here have this
>>
File: OsGXboK.gif (473 KB, 117x95) Image search: [Google]
OsGXboK.gif
473 KB, 117x95
>>64274317
>http://vocaroo.com/i/s1RhKfFhpIjo
>>
File: bravoilm.png (2 MB, 1164x819) Image search: [Google]
bravoilm.png
2 MB, 1164x819
>>64273742
Lucas can take a lot of the blame for the dumb overall decisions on changes, but don't leave the actual simply bad quality of the work out too.
>>
>>64279529
Literally anyone can win in Street Fighter. It all depends on the skill of the players.
>>
>>64279760
Don't tell the Americans
>>
I really only love duel of the fates in ep1. But it was great and is my favourite moment in prequels.
>>
>>64280104
>>64280277
>>64280779
So will Disney be unable to release a home video of the original trilogy at all?
>>
File: different versions.jpg (328 KB, 1000x1350) Image search: [Google]
different versions.jpg
328 KB, 1000x1350
>>64273886
Hayden's Anakin was only a jedi for a short amount of time before he started murdering innocents and wouldn't have known how to become a force ghost.

Also, Luke wouldn't have recognized him.
Thread replies: 255
Thread images: 89

banner
banner
[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Home]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
If a post contains personal/copyrighted/illegal content you can contact me at [email protected] with that post and thread number and it will be removed as soon as possible.
DMCA Content Takedown via dmca.com
All images are hosted on imgur.com, send takedown notices to them.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from them. If you need IP information for a Poster - you need to contact them. This website shows only archived content.