Here's a stern grading of the Episodes on a Star Wars scale.
IV - 10\10
V - 10/10
VI - 9/10
VIII - 8/10
III - 7.5
II - 6.5
I - 5.5
>>64203830
>VIII
>>64203830
Correct order is
3>6>5>1>4>2>Ewok 1>>>>>>>>>Ewok 2>>7
VII as a standalone = 8/10
VII as a Star Wars = 3/10
>any Star Wars
>10/10
they're really not that good. Iconic, yes, but not 10/10.
>>64203910
You're really a faggot if you think 3 is better than 6 5 or 4. And you're a nigger for thinking 1 is better than Star Wars
>>64203830
>those roman numerals
>>64203996
>on a star wars scale
These scores are based on all movies of the saga
>>64203929
More like 6/10 and 2/10
>>64203830
Offical power ratings coming through
dont even bother with memeing
>>64203830
>IV - 10\10
>>64204023
ANH aged pretty badly, has god awful special effects, has a very rushed story post meeting ben, and even Vader doesn't get to be Vader thanks to Tarkin. 3 is the best though just for the ost alone, before things like the opening battle or anakin and obi wans last convo even come into play.
>>64204121
Good. Gooood
VIII
>>64204152
Get a better copy and TV ANH is still solid as puck. All the prequels ost were goat even AOTC but that's no reason to be a sperg and rate it as the best film.
>>64204152
>>64204257
ANH literally only looks good on old tube tvs. In HD the props dont hold up at all. They were never intended for that level of detail.
>>64203830
IV - hack/hack
V - hack/hack
VI - hack/hack
VIII - hack/hack
III - hack/hack
II - hack/hack
I - hack/hack
There's nothing original about Star Wars.
>>64204407
>>64204341
>ANH literally only looks good on old tube tvs
That's nonsense because I and many others enjoy watching them still on led TVs and they haven't looked better. Check out the despecialized rips that are around 20gigs. They are only 720 hd but look fantastic. 1080p will be coming in another couple years.
I - 4/10
II - 0/10
III - 0/10
IV - 10/10
V - 10/10
VI - 9/10
VII - 8/10
>>64203830
1 - 4/10
2 - 2/10
3 - 3/10
4 - 6/10
5 - 7/10
6 - 6/10
7 - 6/10
This is the truth. Stop forming rankings in comparison to the other star wars. Put these up against cinematography as a whole. Base it on all aspects of the movies.
>>64204547
mah nigga
>>64203830
IV - 9/10
V - 10/10
VI - 7.5/10
VII - 8/10
III - 6/10
II - 2/10
I - 4/10
>>64204341
>they were never intended for that level of detail
They were made to be seen at theatre. Not your shitty little TV.
>>64204547
>>64204547
>>>64204547
Nice sincerely OP
>>64204568
>talking out your ass and shit ranking
>>64204152
>>64204479
WEIRDING WAY
Controlling people with the voice is even taken from Dune.
>ITT: Redditor geeks with no taste whatsoever.
Bazinga
>>64204637
sorry fag i'm not blinded by nostalgia
how lame is every single concept in star wars?
why does your juvenile brain cling to familiarity and nostalgia?
here's something really general about star wars to think about, seriously think about it.
>it's literally called "the force" and it can force things to happen
>>64204835
all the names are fucking hilarious. here's a few
>luke is named after himself
>anakin > an a kin, kin to luke
>han solo, SOLO
>it's called the death star
>most of the darth names
How is the stupid pointless story even supposed to come to a resolve if there always needs to be "balance in the force"?
>>64203830
>stern grading
>everything is above mediocre (5/10)
>mfw
IGN pls go.
IV - 6/10
V - 7/10
VI - 4/10
I - 2/10
II - 2/10
III - 4/10
VII - 5/10
>>64205009
>"balance in the force"?
That was the whole point of Paul Atreides in Dune.
>>64205061
Nobody cares about dune. Fuck off. Even the vidya was outdone by CnC
>>64205121
You're still a fan of the hack, /tv/ proves again that it's pleb tier, as always.
>>64204835
In mechanics force is literally called force
>physics thrown out the window
Seriously faggot that's what you're going with this isn't hard scifi or even scifi its a scifi fantasy samurai western space opera
>>64203830
I - 6/10
II - 4/10
III - 7.5/10
IV - 8.5/10
V - 9/10
VI - 8/10
VIII - 7.5/10
>>64205420
go weird your way out of being a turbo nerd, faggot.
>>64205629
>its a scifi fantasy samurai western space opera
It's literally set in the desert.
TFA used Max Von Sydow for this reason alone. Von Sydow was a Fremen fighter in Dune as he was in TFA, TFA invokes Dune for the first 1/2 hour.
>>64203830
actual grading
IV - 8\10
V - 9/10
VI - 7/10
VIII - 8/10
III - 5/10
II - 4/10
I - 4/10
>all these faggots giving out 9s and 10s
Yes, you philistines, Star Wars is on the same technical level as The Human Condition or Un Chien Andalou.
The mythology and worldbuilding are 9/10 shared across the saga, but the individual installments are deeply flawed if your rating takes any sort of technical merit into account. That's also why so many "Best of the Year" lists including Fury Road signal 2015 as the year non-studio film-making died.
>>64203901
>...VIII...