Can we talk about this movie please? I don't think an ending has left me feeling so angry before.
This was basically "Listen & Believe: The Movie". She slit a guy's throat, blood everywhere, but she said she was being raped at the time, so I guess no further investigation is necessary. Case closed.
The guy owned a nice car and a mansion. Obviously he was a working man which means he had an alibi for that morning. Easy as shit to solve.
>>64149096
Did she delete all the footage of her willingly entering his house since she told everyone she was kidnapped?
And shouldn't there be a massive wound on her body somewhere from where all that blood on the kitchen floor came from?
The cops were completely incompetent.
>>64149096
That was all her Amazing Amy money. He didn't have a job.
Watch "Return to Sender" instead. Superior movie.
>>64149137
I'm talking about Neil Patrick Harris. She had no fucking clue what he was doing when she "disappeared." It was morning so I'm assuming he was at work paying for his expensive shit. All the police have to do is call his place of work to figure out he was behind a desk instead of at the scene of the crime. But I guess the police in this movie are completely fucking worthless and can't do anything right.
>>64149132
That was the point of the movie.
It's criticizing many things, and it's supposed to make you feel upset and unsatisfied at the end to get the message across.
>>64149491
I watched this for the first time yesterday completely clueless I'm so mad reading what you have just said.
>>64149491
she faked the rape then killed him
The book is better.
The first third of the book where you're reading her fake account of their relationship is insanely accurate of your typical real life relationship.
>>64149872
Her defense at the end of the film was that he kidnapped her that morning from her home. Obvioulsy not the case because she left the house alone and faked her death. At this exact moment Neil was probably at work. Understand? She had no fucking clue where he was. He wasn't part of her plan at that moment.
>>64149491
The book explained this to make sense, I forgot what it was though.
>>64150048
Neil did not work, not saying he didn't have another alibi, but he was old money and did not work.
>>64148915
I almost walked out of the theater when you found out she's alive, I was so hyped for a who dun it. I bled it out and it fucking sucked.
>>64148915
What do you expect from Ben Al-Afflecki the Male Feminist Muslimo?
webm dump
The ending is just so fucking retarded
>I'm going to leave you
>I'm pregnant
>Oh ok, I'm staying
Is this some kind of christian propaganda? Just punch her in the stomach until she bleeds you fucking pussy
>>64151316
Hours and hours of footage of her walking the house unharmed and consenting sex, but hey! let's tell the police to look the tapes...
JUST
The more bad stuff she did, the more attractive she got to me.
That being said, I do believe all the stuff she did was completely justified giving the situation she was in. She didn't do any wrong and I'm happy she got away with it
Why would someone as methodical and cunning as Amy bring her entire purse of cash with her to play mini-golf?
>>64151488
the point was that somehow the police loved her and believed everything she said except for that one detective. the ending scene even has the detective calling out the gone girl, but then she makes some shit up and the cops are like "oh you poor thing"
One year ago, /tv/ recognized this as one of the very best of the year. Now, /starwars/ can only deal in >muh plotholes XD
>>64151615
I know, I'm just saying that mentioning the tapes is an incoherent move for Amy, she took an exceptional risk there...
>>64150310
Independently of the plotholes, the point was that the world loved Amy, and that's why she was able to get away with it. This and Birdman were the best of 2014 imo.
If you seriously didn't enjoy a movie and were 'about to walk out of the theater' because of something you think is a plothole or incoherence in the story, or even just something that is part of the story that you don't think should be there, you're going into it with the wrong mindset.
>>64151178
Why is from behind standing up with clothes on sex so hot?
>>64151849
it was a total change of pace in the movie from that point onward
it took a turn for the surreal, since she basically became this super autistic criminal mastermind who planned every minutiae
![rosamund-pike-gone-girl-weinstein[1].jpg](https://i.imgur.com/ZcBuAuq.jpg "rosamund-pike-gone-girl-weinstein[1].jpg")
>tfw no perfect wife
Life is unfair
R I O T
I
O
T
So there's a sequel in the works right?
>>64152396
And there was none
>/tv/ entitled of defending its granny waifu's honour
>>64151615
>the point was that somehow the police loved her and believed everything she said
Yeah. No. That's not how shit works in real life.
>>64152452
>granny
Post her forearm hair or fuzzy sideburns.
>>64152561
>the whole second half of the movie
did you watch it? is your gripe with the movie that its not realistic enough? because it wasnt realistic
>>64148915
>upset feminists because it had a woman as the bad guy and had her using a made up rape as an alibi
kek, it's a great film for the butthurt alone
>buy a car
>go to Big Lots
>go to gas stations and a land drive around in broad daylight around places all on the day of her disappearance
>walks around for days afterwards in the log cabin rental area and befriends the neighbor when the case goes national and her face is plastered fucking EVERYWHERE
>still isn't recognized or spotted
>>64152788
She had died her hair all shitty and wore huge glasses
>>64152864
>cutting her hair and hinting her cheek with a hammer is a good disguise
>>64152928
you forgot about the eyebrows bruh. you know, the most important trait of someone's face
>>64152928
well it turns out it wasnt a good disguise
>>64148915
The film is all about women manipulating their position in society to get what they want, you aren't supposed to be satisfied with the conclusion of her case.
>>64152957
>>64152959
For all her planning it was a demonstrably shitty inconsistency in planning and plot armor, akin to having someone like Osama bin Laden living undercover somewhere in Texas post-9/11 only having shaved his beard as a disguise. People get recognized from flyer ads with surprising results all the time, am I to believe someone with as much exposure as her can be so public and not get spotted?
>>64152993
The fact that this movie didn't get more shit from women surprised me tremendously.
>>64153370
they didnt see it
>come join me bed anon
>>64153370
>woman gets painted as an evil manipulative bitch but gets away with it
why would they complain? she won the movie
>>64153460
"Ew, you're so old!"
>>64153460
i'd cum in her without a condom on
>>64149491
Wasn't it implied that the rape took place the night before and she escaped after he left for work? You may be overthinking this part anon.
The only good thing about that film was soundtrack. The film is mediocre at best.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vdzhJk24KNk
>>64153897
she's too old to get pregnant, so a safe bet.
>>64154116
Bad taste. Gone Girl is a solid 8.5/10.
>>64154222
>there are people who struggle this hard with suspension of disbelief
>so much so that it makes it impossible for them to analyze a film as a whole instead of searching desperately for plot holes that the movie doesn't need to explain away in the first place
Plebian /tv/
>>64154339
>suspension of disbelief
they attempted and failed
>>64154339
No, you don't get to have a shitty ending where everyone in the movie becomes retarded and ignores the obvious fact that Amy is a murderer and say "It's supposed to be like this. You just don't get it".
If it were any other movie by any other director, you'd also be baying for blood at how shit an ending it was.
>>64154303
Alternatively, >>>tumblr
>>64155097
I don't give a shit about Fincher either way - if he makes a good movie, he makes a good movie. If it's shit, it's shit.
The movie is not supposed to be an exact replica of real life. Obviously, there's the potential for deep police investigations into all of the events of the movie. However, that wasn't the point, and it wouldn't make a very good story if all that happened and the police came in at the end and said "Wait a sec, you are arrest!".
It's making a point/statement, and it knows what that point is. It's criticizing the media, police, and human nature in general. It goes to the extremes in each of those aspects in order to convey the statement it's trying to convey.
Even then, it's not like shit like this HASNT happened in real life. The wife was idolized by the media, and it only intensifies throughout the film, which is why she gets a "slide". See OJ Simpson and various other "victims"/celebrities.
None of the cameras looked inside the house.
She was driven right into to garage.
>>64153370
It was written by a woman.
If Gillian Flynn were a man this movie would never have been made and the book would be denounced as MRA propaganda.It would have been a better story if Affleck was guilty.
>>64155602
If you need to create a completely unrealistic scenario in order to make a point about real things, you're defeating your own arguments.
Which is something female authors don't seem to get, even after hundreds of years.
>>64155713
>>64155805
If NPH was keeping her captive and raping her daily, the camera system would have him coming and going, daily. If he deleted those logs, there would be holes in the logs where he was arriving and departing. He had cleaning staff there maintaining the lake house semi-regularly during the interval where amy was supposed to be captive and being raped to sleep every night.
Which isn't even the biggest hole in her story.
>>64157245
>completely unrealistic
That's a bit of a stretch, friendo. Also sounds like you might just be criticizing her more harshly because she's a woman, which - again - has no reflection on the story itself.
Also, what the fuck are parables, fairy tales, literally anything that isn't a documentary?
>>64158173
That was a comparison to ayn rand.
>>64152113
It's more civilised.
>>64152113
The added texture + warmth, probably.
>>64148915
I do not like this movie very much but ever since I saw it
and each time I've updated any of my TVs or monitors
I've always watched Gone Girl to gauge the monitors
That movie just looks so fucking hnnnggg
>>64149096
It is specifically explained why Nick didn't have a good alibi you idiot
>>64149137
>He didn't have a job.
He got laid off in NY but later found a professor job in missouri. He also owned a bar with his sister. He had money.
>>64155097
It wasn't Fincher's script so I don't know why you're blaming him
The author was in control of how the plot was adapted
>>64150019
>fake account of their relationship is insanely accurate of your typical real life relationship.
I always had the impression their meeting at the party was fake because of how cheesy it was and Nick was pretty charming, a complete difference from how he is like in real time.
>>64150310
You really thought she was dead? Was this your first Fincher movie?
>>64151520
How do you know that? We only hear about the past from her POV which she admits to bending in order to gain sympathy from the reader
>>64148915
You do realize that that is a major point though. It's calling out the media and law enforcement on its BS.
>>64158693
Amy mixed truth with lies. It wasn't unfathomable that their relationship started off that way.
>>64159133
Nick came across as a chad so I doubt he was as smart as he seemed in their encounter. Amy says the beginning of the story was key so I pretty certain she added fantasies to that meeting.
>>64159220
I don't think he came off particularly intellectual, he was just charming and funny. Maybe that whole meeting was concocted but to snag a girl like Amy you would pretty much have to be a charming alpha Chad.
>>64151423
The book spends a lot of time on his dad issues and how he wanted to be a dad to prove he could do a better job.
>>64159428
NPH was just rich and sophisticated, but I can't remember anything special about the guy she lied about raping her or whatever that case was.
>>64158854
Well he dragged her to that lame ass town (Which she accepted just because of him) and then he has the guts to cheat on her.
He deserved what he got for being a shit person.
>>64159761
Yeah he's shit, but I bet Amy is shit, too.
>>64148915
sexist virgin detected. why don't you grow some balls and be a real man instead of forcing gender expectations
>>64159761
>>64159833
She proves she really loves the guy, enough to not letting his ass burn in jail.
Even if she was shit too she would had likely change for him but the guy was an asshole so she had to resort to what she did.
I dont believe he beat her but i do believe his inferiority complex ruined the relationship.
Did he fuck his sister?Would you?
>>64160011
Both characters had inferiority complexs. Amy and her whole "cool girl" attitude
>>64160252
Her inferiority complex actually motivated her to work towards the relationship while the guy´s one had the opposite effect.
>>64160376
No, she wanted to be the one controlling the relationship and if she couldn't she screws the guy over for life
>>64160441
>she wanted to be the one controlling the relationship
>Willingly goes to live to the guy´s hometown.
Something doesnt adds up.
>>64160482
They went there because the guys mom was dying. She clearly had no intention of living there forever
>>64160539
Again if she really wanted to be the one controlling the relatioship she would had taken more steps towards it which was never shown in the movie.
I excepted something more thriller-ish and criminal like Spoorloos and got a boring melodrama
>>64160625
It's pretty much implied
>>64160656
It's actually better than Spoorloos, but I guess you couldn't realize that.
>>64160684
Not enough to believe she was the main reason why the relationship went to waste.
Its almost all on the guy given its never shown how he works towards fixing it, even more when he still bangs that girl while his wife is missing.
>>64160836
Their relationship took a nose dive when the economy crashed and Nick lost his job. It's obvious that it wasn't very solid if they couldn't get past that down turn
>>64161208
That was in part from Nick though, you cant fix a relationship if one of the parts its not willing to do so.
It's been quite a while since I watched this film and I've forgotten most of it but I remember thinking it was a crafty manipulative work of wonder and enjoyed every not knowing what the hell moment.
>>64161208
And who can? When you get to 'poverty', I think few relationships can be sustained.
>>64161300
they weren't poor, far from it. They were turning into "those miserable married couple" they didn't want to become
>>64161300
Retard detected.
>>64161856
That's rude. No need to call your colleague bad names.
>>64161252
It's not Nicks fault the economy crashed. He obviously needed her support and what's the problem with wanting to spend time with your dying mom?
>>64162115
One of the problems was Nick not being able to deal with his mom´s death and then losing his job which caused a toll on the relationship.
>>64151423
The point is she and the media will ruin him if he bails. They are forced topretendto be a couple and make each other miserable
>>64162561
and boning miss massive titties
desu though dem titties are hard to resist
>>64152561
>the point was that somehow the police loved her and believed everything she said
>Yeah. No. That's not how shit works in real life.
When was the last time you left your basement
>>64163487
I always like to think these are satire. Makes life happier.
>>64153370
It was written by a woman
She/the book was still criticized as misogynist
>>64158621
>but later found a professor job in missouri
I guess I forgot this one
>He also owned a bar with his sister. He had money.
Bought with his wife's money. This is specifically brought up in the movie
>>64163636
I thought he went in half, but the bar wasn't making profit
>>64151423
Besides what others have said, the hubby knew that if he left or continued to try and prove his wife was a monster, she'd do pretty much ANYTHING to deny him access to his kid (up to and including falsely accusing him of physical and sexual abuse towards the kid) and also brainwash the kid into hating his father's guts.
The only chance he had to make sure his kid was not another victim of Amy, was to eat shit and basically stay married to her and promote her lies.
>>64153370
It got a TON of criticism when it came out.
Granted the book, was largely championed by feminazis when it came out (to the point that the feminist crowd were shitting bricks that Hollywood would force a change in the ending so Amy gets caught and goes to jail for her crimes). But the movie was widely divided because among other things, it doubled down on Amy being evil.
The movie itself fell into two camps reaction-wise:
1. Those who felt Amy did nothing wrong and was fully justified
2. The ones who HATED HATED HATED the film and were flat out accusing Flynn and Fincher of making the movie be a blatant Pro MRA film.
The fact that there was a huge fear of it being seen as pro-MRA led to a lot of websites largely downplaying coverage of the film. It got reviewed, but for all of the hype SJW controlled pop culture websites were basically wanting the film to leave theaters as quickly as possible so they could pretend it never existed.
>>64164139
I can understand this but... if he was so sure he was gonna leave her (assuming the consequences), why a kid should change his mind? Just fuck the child (still unborn btw), raising him along his psychomother is a hell far worse than just abandon both...
>>64164369
>did nothing wrong
She didn't murder anyone in the book?
>>64148915
It's basically a lifetime movie for MRAs
>>64163439
If he had showed at least the slightest of interest in fixing the relationship maybe she wouldnt had wanted to fuck his shit up
Was it incest?
>>64164411
Again, this was omitted in the movie but in the book, Nick has HUGE daddy issues due to the abuse he suffered at the hands of his father, which is why he is going to endure Amy's torments and force a few torments of his own (like banning Amy from banishing his twin sister from Nick and the kid's life), to make sure the kid doesn't have to endure what he endured at his dad's hands from Amy.
>>64164369
Luckily it was a box-office hit though. SJW propaganda can fail aswell.
>>64158677
>I don't know why you're blaming him
Because at the end of the day. the director is responsible for how the film comes out.
>>64160656
on that note, is Spoorloos as good as it is praised, because i kinda felt like that guy >>64150310 and i'd really like to watch a good mistery film
>>64164488
You realize nothing the movie showed (read: she said) about the relationship is accurate, right? Because it was all fabricated to give credence to the lie that he was a murderer?
>>64164680
>You realize nothing the movie showed (read: she said) about the relationship is accurate, right
Part of it is true while the other is exagerated. You can see how little of a fuck he gave about Amy during the whole missing chapter while in the end of the movie shows she cares wnough about him to give the relationship another chance but now Nick has to try to make it work.
>>64164603
Fincher consistently makes the best possible movie from a script.
This was a case where the script was garbage, so the movie was little more than passable.
>>64164433
Feminazis truly believe that Amy was fully justified in that she was "avenging herself against the patriarchy" and that Nick's cheating made him fair game for torment.
Similarly, in the book, Desi is a LOT more skeevy and manipulative towards Amy once she went running to him for safety after getting robbed. So feminists again, thought he had it coming. It also "helped" that in the book, Flynn never shows/describes Amy murdering Desi. The chapter ends just as she gets him drunk and he passes out and in the following Amy chapter, she is in police custody having already killed Desi and alerted the police that she had been "kidnapped" all this time.
Also, the movie changed the entire plotline with the ex she claimed raped her (in the book, she changed her mind and recanted her claim of being raped so the charges got dropped, but in the film she showed ZERO regret and went full steam ahead towards falsely accusing Scooty McNairy of rape in order to ruin his life, ultimately forcing him to take a plea bargain and spend a couple of years in prison (and be permanently registered as a sex offender) rather than go to trial, where Amy was all ready to lie on the stand and face decades in prison for rape/assault with the intent to kill.)
The later was one of the things that the feminazis HATED HATED HATED about the film and what they pointed to with regards to the film being "Pro-MRA".
>>64164911
For fucks sake. It's time these feminazis are banned from the Internet.
>>64164911
Yeah.
The feminist crowd fell in love with the book and the whole "Cool Girl" speech, which they obsessed over as being a "crowning moment of modern literature" in terms of justifying any and all evils inflicted upon men by women.
When the movie was being made, they were obsessed with Fincher possibly "ruining" this "important literature monologue in the history of modern literature" and even when Fincher gave lip service, they still bitched and moaned about how he "messed it up" by treating it not as a seminal "to be or not to be" scene but as a generic villain speech.
>>64165056
I'd say the Cool Girl speech was the weakest moment in the film. Felt quite out of sync.
>>64165116
>Wax my pussy raw
It had some doozies
>>64164760
>she cares
Shes a psychopath. Her obsession is to have a "perfect" family. Shes wants a grounded, dedicated father and to be the strong/perfect mother. There's also the bit about how NPH came as he died, and she made sure to ride him every second he was bleeding out. Not in the book, of course, but in the movie, nick's clearly going to be raising another man's child.
Which just goes to another gigantic hole in her story. As, after she escapes, shes supposed to be 2-3 months pregnant.
>>64158414
virgins
>>64158495
virgins everywhere.
you're kidding right? it's uncivilized to fuck clothed, that's why it's fun.
it implies spontaneity and, for the man, control (can do whatever whenever whereever)
note that nobody ever fucks with clothes on in a bedroom, unless they're really lazy or really busy.
>>64165566
You dirty pig, having sex without clothes omg dude you rancid swine.
> I don't think an ending has left me feeling so angry before.
You're supposed to laugh at how unbeliavably everything turned out. I know I did
>>64165323
>Shes wants a grounded, dedicated father and to be the strong/perfect mother
That´s what every family aspires. You make it sound like she wasnt willing to concede things to make it work, she accepted Nick desition to live in the town because that would make him happy.
The psycho bitch persona was triggered entirely by Nick cheating.
>>64151423
>>64165840
>>Shes wants a grounded, dedicated father and to be the strong/perfect mother
>That´s what every family aspires
not the House of Cards family of UNderwoods..
>>64165840
The literal psychopath perfectionist was who she was her entire life.
The bits about her parents idealizing her childhood were lies. Her parents wrote her literal childhood.
>>64148915
>Please don't leave my side
>I'm always with you. I've been with you before we were even born.
Dawwwww that was adorable
>>64165912
How can she be a perfectionist and like someone as imperfect as Nick?
>>64151117
>You will never find a waifu that's a sociopath.
My life is empty.
>>64151491
>people actually gasped at that scene
Oh no the psycho murderer who almost had her husband executed was shoved by him into the wall, what an evil wife beater he must be leave her alone.
>>64170320
Violence doesn't justify violence how can you fail this hard in basic philosophy
