[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Home]
4chanarchives logo
Alright, let's do this: V > IV > VI > III >
Images are sometimes not shown due to bandwidth/network limitations. Refreshing the page usually helps.

You are currently reading a thread in /tv/ - Television & Film

Thread replies: 213
Thread images: 31
File: ForceWars.jpg (47 KB, 700x394) Image search: [Google]
ForceWars.jpg
47 KB, 700x394
Alright, let's do this:

V > IV > VI > III > VII > II > I
>>
>>63821339
>III > VII
Nice meme
>>
File: JUST.jpg (170 KB, 853x479) Image search: [Google]
JUST.jpg
170 KB, 853x479
>>
>>63821349
>Nice meme
Nice meme
>>
>>63821349

He's not wrong though
>>
>>63821339
5 > 7 > 4 > 6 > 1 > 2 = 3
>>
5 > 4 > 7 > 6 > 3 > 1 > 2
>>
File: sabers.jpg (19 KB, 640x107) Image search: [Google]
sabers.jpg
19 KB, 640x107
>>63821365
>>
V > IV > VII = VI > III > I > II
>>
File: obama-is-confused1.jpg (10 KB, 375x282) Image search: [Google]
obama-is-confused1.jpg
10 KB, 375x282
>>63821457

7 > 4
>>
empire > star wars > jedi > force awakens = phantom menace > sith > clones
>>
>5 > 4 > 7 > 6 > 3 > 1 > 2
>>
>>63821486
>Force Awakens better than Jedi
>>63821457
>Force Awakens better than THE FUCKING ORIGINAL
>>
>>63821632
>>Force Awakens better than Jedi
But he's right
>>
These threads are about as much fun as trying to arrange a bag of oranges by their estimated weight
>>
>>63821339

IV > V = VI > VII > III > I > II

Only correct answer.
>>
>>63821339


Pretty disappointing movie.

The only interesting scenes were the ones with Kylo Ren in them.

Otherwise it was a pretty forgettable and blatant rehash
>>
>>63821529
Yeah. Saw ANH again this week and it's incredibly slow. Some people who complain that Kylo is whining too much haven't seen IV in a long time: Luke's moaning is annoying as hell.
>>
File: 1450181370498.jpg (67 KB, 532x398) Image search: [Google]
1450181370498.jpg
67 KB, 532x398
>>63821734
>A New Hope better than Empire
>Empire equal to Return

fuck off back to reddit
>>
>>63821349

That's not how memes work
>>
>>63821768

It's not Luke that has become annoying. It's your failure to separate the real world from the meme world that is annoying.

The real problem is you spend way too much time on /tv/
>>
5 > 4 > 7 > 6 > 3 > 1 > 2
>>
V>IV>VI>I>III>II
>>
Anyone who puts this rehash above any of the originals needs to be shot on sight.
>>
Anyone who doesn't place II last should kill himself or at least don't even dare opening a thread.
>>
V > IV = VI > VII > III > I > II
>>
>>63821788

>Muh Empire

Empire is literally the top pick from Redditors and IMDb fags.
>>
III > V > VII > IV > I > VI > II

Not even baiting.
>>
File: 1441968558012.jpg (205 KB, 930x794) Image search: [Google]
1441968558012.jpg
205 KB, 930x794
>>63822007
sure you're not
>>
meme > reddit > /tv/ > fedora > donald duck > autism
>>
>>63821579
This guy gets it.
>>
>>63821734
Close but only this is correct
V>IV=VI>VII>III>I>II
>>
IV>V>VII=III>VI>I>II
>>
File: doom.jpg (100 KB, 1164x621) Image search: [Google]
doom.jpg
100 KB, 1164x621
>>63822007
>>
IV>V>VI>I>VII>III>II
>>
Star Wars >>>> rehashes of this film (aka "Episodes")
>>
>>63821339
> III>VII
Stop reading the post
>>
>>63822093
>IV=VI
This makes no sense. Stop.
>>
>>63821339
>>63821457
>>63821486
>>63821507
>>63821579
Why the fuck would you watch episode V first? You need IV or a prequel episode for context. Are you just trolling? Is this a meme?

>>63821734
This view order is the only sensible one ITT.
>>
File: that's bait.webm (358 KB, 1912x792) Image search: [Google]
that's bait.webm
358 KB, 1912x792
>>63822201
>>
File: 1182.jpg (45 KB, 1000x1000) Image search: [Google]
1182.jpg
45 KB, 1000x1000
>>63822201
>>
>>63821339
1>3>7>2>4>6>5

Fight me irl
>>
>>63821339
4 > 5 > 7/6 > 3 > 1 > 2
>>
>>63821339
V>IV>VI=III>>I>II>>>VII
>>
>>63822288

Wait, are we going from right to left now?
>>
>>63821349

It's not a meme if it's true Mr. Shillberg
>>
>>63822363
Sure just follow basic inequalities convention and you can read it anyway you like.
>>
File: arino-kidding.png (509 KB, 313x415) Image search: [Google]
arino-kidding.png
509 KB, 313x415
IV > V > VI > > > VII > I = III > > > II

I can't believe JJ dropped the ball so fucking hard. All that exposition, fucking up the realization of Han being Ben's father, failure to properly implement R2D2, annoying references to the OT, cringe-worthy 'girl power' pandering to people who don't and never will like Star Wars. Andy Serkis claiming you could never have done Snoke with practical effects, turns out to be complete bullshit and he was lazily designed. All the practical puppets and costumes were so coated in CGI they might as well shot the entire thing against green and blue screen again. That fucking edit in which Kylo transports into the forest before Rey could even get out there despite them previously being so close in proximity to each other. All those blatant first and last name call-outs to make sure you know who's on screen rather than just letting characters be characters. God damn trench run and Death Star 3.0. Fuck.

At least it was more exciting than the prequels.
>>
The OT was great for its time and good for the decades after. The PT was never good. And by today Ep V is the the only original SW movie that still holds up as a film among all the other films that exist by now. Ep VII is a great movie for today, better than most films released in recent years and clearly better than all other SW movies except maybe V by todays standards of technology and story-telling.
>>
>>63822048
>flick just so we can all kill ourselves
>>
OFFICIAL MEMERANK:

Baneposting > Vinceposting > JUST > Sheev > 0 >>>> VII is not abysmal shit

Thanks for your collaboration
>>
>>63822417

>At least it was more exciting than the prequels.

At no point was Ep 7 more exciting than Ep 3.

Trust your feelings Anon You know it's true.
>>
>>63822735
>not more exciting than wooden couch and office dialogs with some cgi action scenes sprinkled in.
>>
>>63821491
Is it sad that I know what this is really from?
>>
>>63822824

Sheev, Obi-Wan and Yoda are better than anything in Force Awakens.
>>
V > IV > VI > VII > I haven't seen I and II > III
>>
V > IV > VI > VII >>>POWER GAP>>> III > II > I

Is objective.
>>
>>63822093
Only correct answer
>>
File: 1392486824313.jpg (946 KB, 2048x3072) Image search: [Google]
1392486824313.jpg
946 KB, 2048x3072
>>63821339
V>VI>IV=VII>III>I>II
>>
>>63823108
Only Sheev. and he is better than anything in the OT too
>>
You will call me names for my opinion but here I go:

1. Ep VI (My first Star Wars ever and the climax was so breat taking and the whole pacing and editing is so top notch that it's still my favorite. I just have the fondest memories with this one.)

2. Ep IV

3. Ep V

4. Ep VII

5. Ep III

6. Ep I

7. Ep II
>>
5>6>4>3>7>1>2

>>63822693
sheev deserves better
>>
5>6>4>7>3>2=1
>>
>>63823884

>he watched 6 first

Were your parents monsters?
>>
File: www.wwe.com 2014-12-14 0 16 55.png (348 KB, 638x717) Image search: [Google]
www.wwe.com 2014-12-14 0 16 55.png
348 KB, 638x717
IV > V > VII = VI > III >> II > 1
>>
File: im the real mace windu.jpg (5 KB, 150x150) Image search: [Google]
im the real mace windu.jpg
5 KB, 150x150
ESB > ANH >>> TFA > ROTJ >>>>>>>>> ROTS >>>>>TPM >>>>>>>>>>>> AOTC

Search your feelings, you know it to be true
>>
>>63823922
They didn't care about Star Wars at all. I already knew from friends in my elementary school back then what was up with Darth Vader, so I was kinda spoiled anyway.
>>
>>63823924
You and me bros, bro.
>>
>>63823957
Well okay. Other than that the list isn't too bad but you should really watch V again to appreciate just how good it is.
>>
V > IV > > VI=VII > > > > III > I > II

VI literally has one great scene, one good scene, and five bad ones. The throne sequence alone puts it equal to VII, which is otherwise a much better movie.
>>
>>63823884
Your opinions are entirely reasonable to be honest, it's weird that you have ROTJ ahead of ANH and ESB but you conceded it's entirely due to nostalgia and the weird order you watched the films in as a kid
>>
>>63823950
That's the most normie rating that anyone could possibly come up with
>>
>>63821339
5>7>4>6>3>2>1

Call it derivative all you want fa/tv/irgins, I think it was good at giving us a sense that the OT and the NT in the same universe.
>>
File: Surprised Sheev.jpg (26 KB, 658x524) Image search: [Google]
Surprised Sheev.jpg
26 KB, 658x524
>>63823998
Pretty much how I feel also, except I'd be a bit bolder and claim TFA is better than ROTJ. Both recycle plot elements previously, ROTJ is half a great movie and half prequel tier stuff. The Jabba palace scenes are good. Everything on Yavin's moon with the Ewoks is prequel tier, while the battle in space and the throne room scenes with Sheev/Vader/Luke are some of, if not the outright best scenes in the entire franchise.

Meanwhile TFA is heavily derivative but has a fantastic new villain, great new characters with similarly great on-screen chemistry that stand on their own without the original cast, and fantastic direction, visual aesthetics, cinematography, etc.

Right now I'm still on a high from seeing the film at midnight and all the hype so I think I prefer TFA, but in a year or two I might come back to preferring ROTJ.

I think I can split the Star Wars films into tiers though

GOD TIER: ANH, ESB
HIGH TIER: ROTJ, TFA
MEME TIER: ROTS
SHIT TIER: TPM, AOTC
>>
>>63824024
I am a normie
>>
>>63824179
reee
>>
File: 1444016221379.jpg (88 KB, 560x300) Image search: [Google]
1444016221379.jpg
88 KB, 560x300
>>63824259
Good, good... let the autism flow through you. Embrace it.
>>
>>63823999
>>63823991

Yeah it's highly subjective and regarding story telling, acting and character development TESB is really the best movie.
>>
>>63823950
This 100%
>>
>>63821349
>liking the nigger cuck version of star wars

GOOD GOY
>>
>>63823950
It really is. Perfect order right here.
>>
>>63824392
>/pol/ meme post
fuck off
>>
>>63824628
prove me wrong then faggot, kike boy BLACKED the star wars saga.
>>
File: maxresdefault[1].jpg (29 KB, 1280x720) Image search: [Google]
maxresdefault[1].jpg
29 KB, 1280x720
>>63822735

you're right, RoTS was exciting in it's entirety, well acted, and bullet-proof in its consistency.
>>
File: george_lucas_3163389b[1].jpg (83 KB, 620x387) Image search: [Google]
george_lucas_3163389b[1].jpg
83 KB, 620x387
IV > II > III > I > VI > V > VII
>>
The Prequels had a nice background but poor execution. TFA had a shit background and a nice execution.

I prefer the former
>>
>>63821768
4 is not incredibly slow, 7 is incredibly fast and has no character development at all
>>
File: 1388035592141.jpg (44 KB, 500x666) Image search: [Google]
1388035592141.jpg
44 KB, 500x666
IV > V > VI = VII > I > III = II
>>
>>63824658
There's been black Star Wars characters since IV.
>>
>>63821339
>III over VII

I wish sheev fag would stop posting
>>
File: 1437062754047.jpg (14 KB, 225x225) Image search: [Google]
1437062754047.jpg
14 KB, 225x225
>>63823950

My man.
>>
File: 1450420145853 (1).jpg (202 KB, 960x898) Image search: [Google]
1450420145853 (1).jpg
202 KB, 960x898
>>63821339
V
IV
VII
VI
III
I
II

this is the right answer and you know it
>>
>>63824709
JJ deliberately made finn black and phasma a woman on purpose. He's pushing his kike bullshit agenda
>>
V = IV > VI > VII > III > I > II

Only struggle is to choose wether III or VII as the best new one.
>>
>>63824706
VI = VII
GTFO
>>
>>63822937
fuck of reddit
>>
>>63821954
fuck off you disgusting pleb
>>
>>63821339
why was that shot not in the movie though?
>>
>>63824773
>JJ deliberately made finn black and phasma a woman on purpose.
Okay?
>He's pushing his kike bullshit agenda
What agenda is he pushing by having a black character and a female character that all the other Star Wars movies didn't despite also having black and female characters?
>>
III>VI>II>I>V>IV>VII

I rank them according to Sheev screentime and performance
>>
>>63821349
no, it's kinda accurate though. episode 7 was glorified shit.
>>
>>63821720
This is like argueing if a 100 ml holding cup with 50ml water is half full or half empty.
Its alway opinions.
>>
>>63824829
by making them main characters. niggers and women should stay on the sidelines.
>>
>>63824870
it wasn't all shit
the writing on the two main character was shit
everything around it was cool
>>
>>63823751
lol no, pleb
>>
V > IV > VI > VII > I > II

III is Meme: The Movie and therefore can't be ranked any more than one could rank the TDKR plane scene on an objective scale.
>>
>people genuinely rating TFA over Jedi
This is just honeymoon period delusion, right?
>>
>>63824897
Besides Rey being a bit of a Mary Sue, she did a fine job. Did you see her scrunched up cute face in the middle of the movie? Adorable, she may be my new Waifu

Finn was great too, definitely exceeded my expectations.
>>
5>4>3>6>JJ's Star Trek>7=1>2
>>
IV > V > VI > VII >>> III > I > II

It's actually pretty difficult to place TFA. It's a well-made movie, but it's also effectively just ANH for a new audience, to the point where it's annoyingly derivative. They could've done something really interesting and different with the characters, I feel that Finn and Kylo could've been expanded on in particular, but they went for the safe option, and ultimately that's disappointing and kinda boring.
>>
>>63825200
finn is a stupid nigger and rey is a woman which makes her shit by default. fuck off with your "waifu" bullshit
>>
>>63824930
II is objectively better than I

more fighting, no jar jar, no lloyd

hayden is realistic as a deranged idiot
>>
File: 1450488806611.png (3 KB, 432x141) Image search: [Google]
1450488806611.png
3 KB, 432x141
V = IV > III = VI > VII > I > II
>>
>>63824911
It just felt...fucked. Rey was too powerful for me to invest anything in and Finn was...Fucking movie man. I waited so long to see star wars done right and it's not that much better than episode 2. fuck i'm so disappointed.
>>
File: shitposting.gif (33 KB, 250x250) Image search: [Google]
shitposting.gif
33 KB, 250x250
>>63825344
>finn is a stupid nigger and rey is a woman which makes her shit by default
>>/pol/
>>
V>IV=VII>VI>III>I>II
>>
>>63824851
I can accept this. But what if Sheev is somehow Snoke?
>>
File: 1450361377084.jpg (157 KB, 600x800) Image search: [Google]
1450361377084.jpg
157 KB, 600x800
IV > Spaceballs > VI > VII > I > V > III > II


YOU KNOW ITS TURE
>>
>>63825473
the truth
>>
V > IV = VII > VI > III > I > II

t. Rewatched all movies before going to see VII
>>
>>63826362
This is the correct answer
>>
>>63823924
Hmm, never considered how close 7 was to 6. however it should be 6 then 7, not the opposite
>>
>>63826685
7 is objectively better than 6. 7 has rushed pacing and never hits the highs that 6 does, but it's consistent, and enjoyable all the way through.

6 is a frustrating rollercoaster between the worst moments in the saga (translation wars in Jabba's Palace, Ewok village sequence, etc) and the best (Luke/Vader/Sheev, Death Star space battle, etc) that leaves you annoyed. 6 is closer to the prequels than the OT. It really shows that Lucas was given increased control during its production.
>>
>>63821457
You don't even like star wars do you
>>
>>63825713
ok
>>
>>63823924
What is she? Jesus its like a Dali painting
>>
File: EmperorThroneRoom.jpg (58 KB, 852x480) Image search: [Google]
EmperorThroneRoom.jpg
58 KB, 852x480
V > IV > VII > VI

Let's be serious. Because RotJ wasn't the hottest meal. I still tear up thinking about throne room, but I couldn't watch the whole movie till the VHS broke like I did with ESB.
>>
>>63825713
>And the film was directed by a subversive anti-white jew filth manlet
>>
Female protagonists are the stupidest thing to ever happen to action movies.

Unless the movie is about someone needing to bake 40 cakes in a pinch, mop the floor to make bad guys slip, or seduce a man into bed and be a lying manipulative cunt (honeypots in james bond) women have no place in action movies.
>>
This is the only correct answer

V > VI > VII > IV = III > I > II
>>
>>63822093
i agree
>>
>>63821339
V > IV > VI > III > I > VI > II
>>
>>63828289
Fuck. The second VI is supposed to be VII.
>>
>>63821339

V > IV > VI > III > I > VII > II
>>
5>7>4>6>3>2=1

Deal with it
>>
>>63822937
guys i know old memes, am i sad or what, do i fit in or what
>>
IV > V > VI > VII > III > I > II
>>
>>63822129
I agree with this.
>>
4>5>2>6>3>1>7
>>
IV > V > VI > III > I > II > VII

At the very least the prequels offered decent memes and were very funny in how bad the dialogue and characters were.

TFA is a rehash without any of the funny parts of the prequels or the memorable parts of the the original trilogy.
>>
>>63829257
>Episode 2 that high
Holy fuck
>>
>>63828748
all correct, but 4=6
>>
>>63821339
V>VII=IV>VI>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>III>I>II
>>
>>63829275

Not like it had much competition.
>>
V > IV > VII > VI > III > I > II
>>
>>63829319

>7 that high
>M-muh prequel!!!
>>
>>63824897
Opinion discarded
>>
>>63829349
Muh meme xD tbqh fa m xD well memed lad well faggot anon
>>
>>63829349
only reason to watch star wars is to have fun
7 was fun, unlike the prequels
>>
>>63829319
V>IV=VII>VI>II>>>>>I>>>>>>>>>>>>II

VII isn't as good as you remember
>>
>>63821491
fucking lost
>>
IV>V>VI>III=VII>II>I
>>
>>63829459
do you not understand what "=" means
>>
5>3>7>6>4>1>2
>>
Anyone that puts 7 above any of the movies is a capeshit ape that grew up with the prequels
>>
>>63821339
Only problem is II > I. That movie relied way too heavily on CGI and the animation didn't age well
>>
3 > 6 > 5 > 4 > 2 > 1 > 7
sheev = memes, memes are fun
>>
>>63821457
>5>7
anon gets it. This was a better ANH. You're all confused by the fact that you watched the 4 first. If someone watches the 7 AND THEN the 4, he'd say this too
>>
>>63829507
Rewatch the OT and PT.

Nostalgia messes up your memory.
>>
VII>III>II>I>V>VI>IV
not trolling in the end you have to chose between nuking your son or boston
>>
V>III=VII>IV>>>>VI>>>>>>>>>>>I>>>>>>>>>>>II
>>
>>63829527
Rewatch 7 without the artificial social media hype clouding your mind. It's the worst star wars material right after the cartoons.
>>
Here are my real problems with this movie:
chewie's lips aren't that bright
his hair thingies look different
anakin's lightsaber either had a replaced crystal in it or for some reason has a burning effect to it
which it clearly didn't in either V or III
Lightsabers don't burn like that
in some expanded universe books and The Force Unleashed there are things as Unstable Crystals that mostly Siths use, and they have a burning effect to them
and the pitch of their sound effects is very off
the humming sound is too low in volume
why would Ray take the millenium falcon at the end if Han said it's easily picked up on radars and shit?
why did Luke take the skin off his hand?
he had skin before back in V
why didn't Kyle just use force to beat Ray up? How could Ray stand up to him with no jedi training or even military training like Finn?
Ray got thrown to a tree moments before they were clashing swords and they try to sell to me Kyle couldn't just push her with the force?
also how the fuck did he make laser freeze in the air?
laser isn't a projectile, it doesn't work that way, it's a burst of energy and he could at best deflect it with the force but hold it still is a bit nonsensical
how the fuck did the jacket that Finn picked up in that shit not burn?
it looks like it was burning
and if the ship sunk in the sands AFTER it's impact it means those were the kind of sand that suck shit in, but why did it not suck Finn too?
>>
>>63829597
no its not, ur just living the hate meme bro, no one here thinks you're cool for that, just stfu
>>
File: dubsman.png (63 KB, 150x200) Image search: [Google]
dubsman.png
63 KB, 150x200
>>63829507
Anyone who honestly considers the prequels better than 7 is a contrarian retard who will go through mental gymnastics and bend over backwards to have the most niche opinion possible so he feels special to fill the void in his soul left by whatever serious personality defects they have
>>
Cont. from >>63829638

How did that pilot dude get home?
and why did he leave his jacket?
how come Lightsabers can't cut through some metal melee weapon shit that other stormtrooper used?
how did Kaylo know Finn was a traitor?
how did Ray pull of such a complex stunt as flying through an engine of a cruiser when moments before she was struggling to take off?
how did they manage to steal the ship? did the dude just not lock it or anything and thought nobody would bother trying to steal literally a legendary ship?
how has she not believed in Jedi when she obviously heard about Han Solo and the Millenium Falcon?
why did Han say he never believed in Jedi before?
he fucking did, he just didn't think Force was that good
why did Han leave Leia anyway?
and that's aside what the fuck was Rebellion and the new republic doing for 30 years they couldn't even find nazi ISIS that was stealing kids and building an empire?
why was Luke acting so selfish?
why did Leia give Han a deathwish of trying to turn their asshole sun back into good even though she knew it was way too dangerous?
how come TIE Fighters could target Finn and Ray while they were running on the ground on Jakku? No way they could actually be this accurate at a speed they were at
and is every second person in the galaxy a whore for First Order or something? and why do everyone of them conveniently have a radio or something? and how do they know First Order is looking for something? do they have convenient connections on every single planet or what?
so how come Finn is not okay with shooting innocents but okay with killing tons of stormtroopers if he knows they are just confused kidnapped children that are also innocent in a way?
why was Ray such a Mary Sue?
>>
>>63829271
There are plenty of memorable parts, maybe you have alzheimer's? Scenes in the prequels are are memorable only for being disappointing or laughable. If you walked out of TFA feeling like it was a bad movie there's probably something wrong with you.
>>
>>63826362
Correct
>>
File: 1380681648455.jpg (16 KB, 195x200) Image search: [Google]
1380681648455.jpg
16 KB, 195x200
>>63824676
>>
File: 2.-cabbages-and-roses-1.jpg (213 KB, 960x960) Image search: [Google]
2.-cabbages-and-roses-1.jpg
213 KB, 960x960
>V > IV

The greatest mistake in this thread
>>
File: 1300720251139.jpg (17 KB, 358x423) Image search: [Google]
1300720251139.jpg
17 KB, 358x423
>>63829660

If you use the word "contrarian," you're literally an idiot. It's an invented concept by idiots with reddit sensibilities who are too fragile to deal with criticism of mediocre media that has widespread appeal.

It's a troubling manifestation of millennials' mental weakness. Seriously, the only people who would even entertain any "argument" involving the concept of being "contrarian" are weak, lazy idiots who can't deal with criticism substantively.

If it bothers you that much that people criticize mediocre mass-marketed work designed to appeal to the lowest common denominator, like Star Wars, Breaking Bad, pop music, etc., you should find a safe bubble and stay there. Or kill yourself.
>>
>>63829710
> If you walked out of TFA feeling like it was a bad movie there's probably something wrong with you.

Are you kidding me? This movie was terrible. 4/10 at most. Worse than Episode I.
>>
>>63825275
>>63829146
I agree with these two posters.
IV > V > VI > VII > III > I > II

I said as soon as I walked out of the theatre and I'll say it again - TFA is better than the prequels but not as good as the OT, and anyone who expected anything different is an idiot.
>>
File: 1408144448973.jpg (110 KB, 800x800) Image search: [Google]
1408144448973.jpg
110 KB, 800x800
V>VII>IV>V=III>I>II
>>
>>63822129
V > IV > VII > III > VI > II > I

Fuck those Ewoks.
>>
>>63829820
V>VII>IV>VI=III>I>II

I think you meant^
>>
>>63829784
I agree
>b-but IV its so slow and boring
you have OCD or something?

IV = Alien
V = Aliens
>>
>This new 7 is good meme

DANK
>>
I seriously hope you niggers putting VII above any of the original movies are trolling.
>>
V>III=VII>>IV>>>>VI>>>>>>>>>>>>>>I>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>II
V - Overall perfect. I can`t remeber a single thing wrong with this movie.
III - It`s a very solid movie. But still it has the same problems that the first two prequels have, just in smaller dosage.
VII - I ejoyed the mvoie, but recycling the plot, and especially Death Star 3 definitely spoil the experience.
IV - It is a nice fairytale, but it definetly is not perfect , especially in retrospect.
VI- yeah, after a perfect episode 5 we are back to goofy shit, ewoks, and another death star.
I - Well.... it was really bad. It has only a couple of redeeming moments.
II -. ... This movie has none.
>>
4=6 >3=5 >1=7 >>>>2

imo desu senpai
>>
>>63829888
Hopefully it'll take over the III is good meme.
>>
>>63829888
Don't worry most of these retards will change their mind when "nerd" meme culture turns on the movie by the time rogue one is out
>>
>>63829638
1) Really? Discarded.
2) Discarded
3) The lightsaber effects are the best, no it doesn't burn
4) Sounds are amazing, you're just a retard
5) Easily picked up if you're looking for it, also perhaps they modified it? Also, they just blew up the fucking planet, they don't need to worry about being followed
6) Didn't need it, couldn't get it repaired when he's in the middle of nowhere
7) She had the force too, did you not see her overpower him with the force getting Anakins lightsbaer?
8) It's star wars, there have always been lightsaber fights, not force fights, since the OT. If that bothers you, don't watch Star Wars
9) It's just energy, Vader did this to deflect bolts fired at him, Kylo did for dramatic effect too.
10) It wasn't a fucking fireball, the ship was not on fire, so the jacket didn't burn.
11) Ask the sand worm? What kind of retarded question is this? Maybe it detects heat? Fuck you and your stupid questions, you are truly a mouth breathing autistic faggot.
>>
/sp/ here let me show you how its done

1. a new hope
2. empire strikes back

gap

3. revenge of the sith
4. return of the jedi

POWER GAP

5. Phantom Menace

.
.
.
91. Attack of the clones

.
.
POWERFUL GAP
.
.
.
POWER GAP
.
.
.
.
900000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000001. The force awakens
>>
>>63823950
I agree.
>>
>>63829936
I didnt BUT lets be honest here, RotJ had big chunks that were absolute crap.
>>
>>63829597
I don't really get hyped, I go in expecting nothing. I've been playing vidya for too long to still get hyped about releases before even trying them out.

Rewatching all 6 movies before going to 7 also helped put it into perspective.

You pretend that people who thought it was alright are delusional and biased, but you're the biased one. Only you've parroted /tv/s pre-watch opinion instead of the medias pre-watch opinion.
>>
>>63830118

Good tastes.
>>
>>63830118
That is a cool story that continues.
>>
>>63829809
I actually also agree with this order.

IV/V - 8/10. Both great, especially IV in terms of world-building surrounding a nice story and then V in building upon that. Both fall short of excellence by not having any overly complex thematic elements.

VI - 7/10. Same as above, and I don't even hate the Ewoks, but the first fifteen minutes (everything up until Luke arrives at the palace) are so unbelievably boring I need to take another point.

VII - 6/10. Better than your average movie, one big homage to the original made well but lacking any sort of vision.

III - 5/10. A definitively average movie.

I - 4/10. Had some redeeming qualities but was definitely not a good film.

II - 3/10. Not abysmal, but definitely bad. Only Williams and ObiWan managed to garner some enjoyment out of me.

>TFA is better than the prequels but not as good as the OT, and anyone who expected anything different is an idiot.
Yeah, well said.
>>
The general consensus is going to be V>IV>VII>VI>III>I>II
>>
>>63821349
reddit strikes again
>>
>people unironically saying a blatant rip-off is better than the thing it ripped off

WOW
>>
>>63830118

based /sp/ looking out for authenticity 2bh

reminder that TFA is a Marvel movie
it has everything those movies do
>the mediocre script
>the made for television look
>the quips
>the humor
>the antagonist that could be great but ends up being shit
>the mary sue
>>
>>63830283
I think the standard acknowledged order will be V>IV>VI>VII>III>II>I.
In any case, it'll be

Tier 1
IV and V

Tier 2
III, VI and VII

Tier 3
I and II

with everyone having individual preferences within those three tiers.
Seriously, if I met someone who mixed and matched those tiers, I think I'd end the conversation there.
>>
>>63821507
This is LITERALLY correct.
>>
>>63829671
1) Called for a pickup, that's not important, we didn't see it so you can't complain.
2) Came off? Took it off? Why do you care?
3) It's riot gear, these troopers are a specialized division. It's got energy around the main part. They're designed not to be disabled by laser fire etc.
4) Because he stole a TIE Fighter, helped Poe escape, killed stormtroopers, helped the resistance, among many other things. Did you watch the movie? That's what you call a traitor.
5) Because she can fly already, she was getting used to the controls of the ship.
6) No one knew it was the falcon, you hear her say this herself, it's just garbage.
7) She heard about them, it's a story.
8) Because no one else did. Go watch Star Wars
9) Their son turned to the dark side, they have a conversation about this. He ran away to escape from everything.
10) They clearly knew about the First Order. That doesn't mean they can go in and kill them all with little resources. The Empire was huge, you get that?
11) Waaaaah, Luke stop being selfish. He went looking for the first Jedi Temple.
12) He was going anyway. He's their son. They wanted him back. Simple.
13) They missed, if you watched the movie. it's not that hard to hit the ground with your weapons.
14) The First Order is a huge organization, it's the remnants of the empire. Yes, everyone has communications, word spreads. It's not the middle ages. There are sympathisers on many worlds, even Finn is wary of this.
15) Because it's not senseless murder when you are fighting an enemy. The Storm Troopers were killing innocent civilians and planned on destroying all of their planets. It's not really confusing.
16) Why is every main character in 90% of movies a Mary Sue? They're not, you just use this way too freely
>>
>>63830329
Well, I agree IV is definitely better than VII, but you might want to rethink your logic - there are plenty of ripoffs better than the original.
>>
>>63823108
BAAHAHAHAHAHHAAHHAHAHAHAA

LITERALLY LOLING
>>
>>63830118
epic
>>
>>63830400
Tier 1
V

Tier 2
IV, VII

Tier 3
III, VI

Tier 4
I, II
>>
5 > 7 = 3 > 1 > 2 = 4
>>
>>63830329

IV is a rip-off itself. It rips off lots of shit especially Flash Gordon, Dambusters, Triumph of the Will.
>>
1.) Empire Strikes Back
2.) A New Hope / The Force Awakens
3.) The Force Awakens / A New Hope
4.) Return of the Jedi
5.) Revenge of the Sith
6.) Attack of the Clones
7.) The Phantom Menace
>>
File: Knights of Ren.webm (2 MB, 1280x720) Image search: [Google]
Knights of Ren.webm
2 MB, 1280x720
>>63821339
V > VII = III > IV > VI > II > I
>>
>>63830468
cba2readurshit t-b-h familia, but first order isn't remnants of the empire, or maybe a little, but not much, i bet rebellios took over their resources on Couruscant or whatever
i liked Mission Impossible 5 more than this movie, and i fucking like star wars i even played some game that just came out on my friend's xbox let me tell you that friend
>>
>>63821339
V = IV > VI > VII > III > I >>>>>>II
>>
>>63822377
How does that apply though? I mean it's not even close to true.

There's a big gap between VII and the prequels.
>>
>>63823108
Not Episode III Obi-Wan and Yoda.

They're dreadfully boring characters in III. Everything in III is boring. Episode VII has a sense of purpose and energy, something III at no point had.
>>
V > IV > VI = VII >>>>> III >> I=II
>>
>>63821339
>that pic

Wait, was Ren the Keyblade master the whole time?
>>
>>63822417
but the prequels were different. this is rehashed
Thread replies: 213
Thread images: 31

banner
banner
[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Home]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
If a post contains personal/copyrighted/illegal content you can contact me at [email protected] with that post and thread number and it will be removed as soon as possible.
DMCA Content Takedown via dmca.com
All images are hosted on imgur.com, send takedown notices to them.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from them. If you need IP information for a Poster - you need to contact them. This website shows only archived content.