If Luke fought Anakin in his his prime(before suit), would Luke still win?
Yes, Anakin is an even ground babby
Who has the high ground?
Would really depend on who had the higher ground, ceteris paribus on an even surface luke would win.
>>63805299
Luke is a master of the high ground technique.
yes anakin was even weaker before he had his suit.
So Obi Wan was the best combat Jedi of all time right?
>>63805450
From a certain point of view
>>63805299
depends on Anakin's mental state.
focused, not angry Anakin is the only one who has a chance at winning, because he wouldn't fall for the high ground.
>>63805450
That's Windu
>>63805450
Revan
>>63805299
ani would mop the floor with luke tbqhwymf
>>63805563
wasn't he 0-1 tho? who did he ever beat?
>>63805600
What? Who is that?
can you use the force to jack off?
>>63805923
Well if it wasn't form anakin he would have killed sheev
>>63806025
>he thinks sheev didn't planned his loss
>>63805923
Revan is from Knight of the Old Republic which takes place some 3,000 years before the movies I believe. He was an exceptionally gifted Jedi and strong with the force or something stupid like that
It depends on who has the high ground
>>63805299
Ep 3 Anakin would beat Ep 6 Luke.
>>63806089
Well it looks it it actually was a good trick then
>>63806017
yes thats how you spray midichlorians on things and they are bent to your will
>>63805299
Luke at the end of ROTJ became the most powerful Jedi ever
>>63805299
FROM MY POINT OF VIEW YOU HAVE THE LAVA GROUND!!
>>63806235
Doesn't make sense desu
He beat old, half mechanical Darth Vader
Obi Wan beat young Vader in his prime.
I think Obi Wan epi. 3 could run train on epi. 6 luke
>>63805299
Obi would have lost in a straight up fight, hell most Jedi would have died falling down the damn lava waterfall. His master was well trained and knew he was prone to arrogant decisions and used it against him which is why he didn't engage him in any place for too long and kept moving.
Only Jedi that would have truly bitch slapped Anakin around at that stage is yoda.
Palpatine and Yoda = different level of mastery
>>63806327
Windu easily won vs Palpatine
>>63806235
Luke at the end of ROTJ couldn't even stand up to an unarmed old fossil.
>>63806289
Luke is basically god
windu = yoda > obi wan > ep 3 anakin > luke
>>63806403
Faked it
>>63806403
Not according to the novelization.
>>63806419
He could have, but he didn't want to, that is the point
>>63806513
>not according to the noncanon fanfic
>>63806552
Novelizations of movies were endorsed as written version of said movie, even if you want to split hairs, nobody is on your side on that.
>yoda and windu both shown being able to deal with force lightning
>luke gets fucked up by force lightning in ep 6
>Vader never even learned how to use force lightning but Dooku did
lmao luke and anakin a shit
Both Luke and Anakin take the lowest possible ground. Depends who has the least low ground.
>>63805563
You'd think, he should've just thrust the lightsaber forward and stabbed Sheev in the face before Anakin could have time to react and cut his hands off. His arm isn't fully extended and he almost gets killed by the force lightning the first time because he doesn't just kill Sheev instantly. instead talks about how he's going to kill Sheev for like a minute only letting Sheev sway Anakin further to siding with him.
Windu was a fucking idiot
>>63806432
EU Luke = God
NuLuke is a failure and it is fantastic how they took the guy that could do everything and save the day and turned him into an abortive fraud that kept the Jedi in a current morass of apolitical weakness and senseless monasticism.
>>63806813
Obi Wan defeated Darth Maul, Darth Vader, and Darth Krayt. That's three Sith Lords down. He also defeated General Greivous, not to mention surviving run-ins with Asajj Ventress, Savage Oppress, Darth Tyrannus, and Darth Sidious himself. He mastered the defesive style and we all know defense is better than offense. Obi Wan is the strongest Jedi, hands down.
>>63806932
Krayt was defeated by Cade Skywalker so you're full of shit.
Obi Wan defeated Maul, I'll give you that and Grievous and I would argue Anakin defeated himself, because every time Obi stood and fought he got pushed back.
Dooku beat the shit out of him so I'm not even going to go there, and Labyrinth made it pretty clear he had been holding himself back when he bested Obi the first time.
He lost again in his = prime
Anakin literally carried his ass to safety.
I don't put much stock in cartoons so I won't go into those.
I agree Soresu/Sokan
Sokan
High Ground Defense: Usually involves environment, combatants made use of large amounts of terrain, trying to maneuver their opponents into vulnerable areas during the course of battles that involved Sokan techniques.[36]
ironically the meme is real.
http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Lightsaber_combat/Legends
Obi-Wan was the best student hands down but he wasn't the strongest Jedi.
>>63805923
Windu beat Boba's dad which even Obi-Wan had a hard time capturing
>>63807293
He defeated Krayt waaaaayyyy back on Tatooine
>>63805299
Nah. Anakin in his prime rekt Count Dooku, former Master Jedi and Sith Lord.
Was there ever a good lightsaber combat vidya? I think the ROS one on PS2 had a good setup IIRC.
>>63808026
i remember playing one with my friend a lot. it was co-op and you could be jedis and shit and had to fight through a lot of droids mostly. forget the name.
>>63807664
That's because he lost his jetpack, and no longer had the advantage of the high ground
>>63808196
Jedi Power Battles
Anakin is the strongest Jedi ever prior to becoming Vader.
Blue Saber Luke would have been interesting.
Green Saber Luke is a pastor-samurai and would probably just calm-talk Anakin into stabbing himself.
Green Saber Luke is boring and sucks, is the point.
>>63805299
>high ground memes
PT Anakin would ass rape OT Luke. Every time.
One aspect of the PT that I liked was how well they showed the vast difference between trained Jedi of the Old Republic and Luke struggling to find his way. Obi Wan as a padawan in the beginning of Episode I would beat Luke at the end of ROTJ and just destroy Ren in TFA.
Obi Wan or Anakin at their peaks in III? Shit...not even a contest.
It's the difference between learning basketball from Jordan when he's 90 and learning it from him at his peak where you actually play against him on a daily basis.
>>63806706
That's Windu alright.
>>63809346
How can he Blue Saber Luke if it was Anakin's saber to begin with?
>>63809947
They'll each hold on to the saber with their good hands and thumb wrestle with their mech hands.
Are any games canon? If so, the guy from TFU could pull Star Destroyers from orbit, and even he jobbed to Vader. I think that indicates a pretty large power differential between Luke and Anakin.
anakin is the strongest jedi autist ever
> all these nostalgic manchildren screaming yes
anakin killed sheev
anakin killed dooku
anakin killed dindu
anakin killed obi
if that little green piece of shit yoda wasn't hiding like a BITCH, he would've killed him too.
>>63810246
Obi-wan died on purpose with that shit-eating grin.
Also Obi-wan defeated Anakin before anyway.
>>63805299
We've never seen Luke in his prime, so who knows. I would say the answer is maybe.
RotJ Luke would definitely lose, shoddily trained jedi vs years of actual training and real life war probably made Anakin a beast.
>>63805299
Wow, you know what, he does look like a better villain than Kylo.
Maybe Lucas wasn't a total fuck up.
>>63805299
anakin was trained his whole life and fought in the clone wars
that should tell you enough
>>63806932
>Savage Oppress
every fucking time
has there ever been a worse name for anything?
>>63805299
Anakin would just force choke him and call it a day.
>>63810246
>anakin killed sheev
disctracted sheev
>anakin killed dooku
acting as a bait for sheev plans
>anakin killed dindu
sheev did it
>anakin killed obi
obi grew stronger
>>63807293
Obi cut off Krayts arm
>>63806706
yes but he was the best fighter, goddamn i'm mad he didn't have more fights.
>>63805450
he had the best defense.
