What's the worst edit in the Star Wars Original Trilogy?
Darth Vader saying "No" as he throws the emperor. That was a deliberate fuck you to all of the fans.
the CGI band in Jabbas palace in Return of the Jedi.
>>63715210
Was Anakin edited into that?
>>63715340
It's better if you don't know
>>63715323
It was pretty fucking bad in 1983 too tough
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k1sF9veTzuU
>>63715323
This
>>63715421
Stiff puppets are nowhere near as bad as the now-dated CGI abomination singer that was edited into the scene
>>63715279
Whats the problem with that?
I don't get the rage about this edit. It makes absolute sense and had little to no plot influence.
If they didn't edit it you'd be like "HURR DURR HOW DID HIS FORCE SPIRIT AGE".
>>63715421
but all the other creatures were puppets and actors in prosthetic masks. then the band appear and it would cut to shiny new CGI characters, then back to puppets, then back to CGI characters. the whole cut was jarring and so out of place it looked far more retarded than the original.
>>63715421
It's not nearly as long though
>>63715531
You're missing the point
Darth Vader redeemed himself and turned back to the light when killing the emperor. So it makes no sense that his force ghost is young Anakin. Not to mention how Luke has never seen this fucking guy
Also it' really halfassed since it's just Anakins head copy-pasted on the old guys body
Klutzy stormtrooper.
You remember him, right?
Little stormtrooper in back who banged his head on the blast door.
Or so he used it.
Kids who knew about this laughed.
It's only natural since it was a small gaffe.
Like, very hard to notice.
Least it was until the special edition.
Somehow, lucas decided to enhance it.
He added some new sound effects and I think a new sound to make the "mistake" more visible.
And now the stormtrooper falls over and makes this loud crash when he bumps his had.
Now it is no longer funny.
Does anybody have an image of the original?
I really don't understand the thought process behind this..
>>63715323
this one
>>63715210
All scenes that involve erasing the original actor from the movie like this. Fucking disgusting.
Luke screaming as he falls in ESB just because it completely annihilates the point of the scene
The Gungan screaming "WEESA FREEE" in RotJ because it's the last line of the film and it's the most clear fuck you from creator the viewer I've ever seen
>>63715725
Here it is.
>>63715654
What? All he did was add a sound to the Stormtrooper bonking his head on the door. He doesn't fall over and there's no loud crash..
>>63715798
He was supposed to be mace windu
>>63715795
>The Gungan
It has been specifically stated that it's JarJar
>>63715421
Then why did they make it worse?
>>63715421
It's far less worse then the special edition https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PiDRgDmXGi4
>>63715421
why did jabba pull her chain?
when i was young i thought jabba wanted to eat her
or is it some type of sexual thing that i missed?
I hated that new effect they put on the falcon zooming through light speed
How about we ask something more difficult to answer, what is the best edit?
Frankly the only one that isn't awful that I can come up with is that they changed the Emperors face for continuity reasons in Episode IV
>>63715932
It's the exact same one he used in Star Trek and yes that does piss me of the fuck off
>>63715531
Luke never saw him young
>>63715920
He fed her to his rancor
Don't think there was a reason for it, he's just a dick.
>>63715210
>always hated the E3 Anakin ghost
>just realized he's not even wearing the Jedi uniform he usually wore
>oh my god they just replaced the face
i fucking mad
>>63715210
>>63715790
What bothers me even more is how he now still has this menacing look in his face, like he's saying "Guess which force ghost is gonna haunt your dreams tonight, asshole"
>>63715421
this was just a bad scene full stop
>>63716008
I always thought the after shock looked cool https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=exZEGox-omA
>>63715279
This.
Disgusting.
How can one see the old versions instead of the remade one ?
>>63715421
Is this the famed Jizz music I've heard so much about?
>>63716117
I would have no problem with this scene if jabba didn't look so terrible.
any one else love this documentary?
>>63716169
the unofficial despecialized editions
the last release of the unedited versions was fucking laserdisc I believe
>>63715421
Thats literally /r9k/ the scene
>fat ass eating shit
>qt dropped into a pit
>Jizz music
>>63716117
Not only does it look fucking terrible
but it ruins all the mystery of "who's this badass space mob boss that wants Han Solo"
>>63716117
that's not even the final version
>>63716175
>Jizz music
>>63716117
>>63716310
Both look shit. It's kind of amazing that they managed to get Jabba right in TPM but failed both attempts in the special edition.
>>63716326
that's actually what it's called http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Jizz
>>63716343
at least in TPM it was an even blend of CG and real sets/actors this shit stands out like a sore thumb
>>63716326
>he doesn't clak beepbox
>>63716310
>stepping on your vindictive crime boss' tail
>not getting thrown into the saarlac right then and there
"Jabba, you're a wonderful human being" was a great line tho
>>63716357
I guess the word didn't exist in '83?
>>63715421
better song than this >>63715876
>>63715210
The fucking singing bullshit in jabbas palace.
>>63716013
Are you trolling? Or just a bit thick?
Sheev's death scream when Luke falls in ESB.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PaXgK5HRBjk
>>63716491
the old song fits because its bad in a way you can imagine weirdo sex pervert aliens liking. the new song sounds like a parody of a showtune or something
>>63716030
I mean I think he'd get the point
Not trying to defend it tho
>>63716712
why is anakin young and obi-won still old?
>>63715210
This is JUST the type of rehash I was expecting, it's nothing but a glib facsimile.
If Star Wars was all I had access to as a child in terms of sci-fi I probably would become one of those crazy fanboys, but thankfully I had access to anime from very early on in my youth years that my mental balance is very stable.
Seriously, if you have watched Akira, you'd realize just how sophisticated anime is and it blows away anything Star Wars would have to offer.
A lot of people mention Ghost In The Shell, which has just enough of sexuality in the mix to draw in the western audience I suppose but I must say that Ghost In The Shell is not even in my top 10 anime, not even close, that's just how deep the world of anime is.
Some anime is so disturbingly mature like Fractale that I wish it would challenge the system and submit it as a Drama category in the Oscars just to bitchslap the snotty Academy.
It's not just the level of maturity and sophistication anime has, it's also quite original, entertaining, and visually fantastic. I would regard anime as the highest form of cinema art-form.
But hey, me preaching about anime won't do you any good, you gotta go out and see it for yourself just how much you are missing.
The recent one I would recommend to check out is Sword Art Online which is light and easy to get into anime for the first time yet appreciate it as much, but if you want the heavy stuff right off the line check out Guilty Crown in which the plot is so complex and twisted that you'll need extra oxygen pumped into your brain in order to comprehend everything, and if you want amazing visuals and a gripping drama that also has awesome mecha battles Aldnoah.Zero is the shit.
Seriously, if you know anime like I do, Star Wars looks like it's something for little kids.
>>63716666
is lucas actually autistic?
>>63717100
/a/ pls check these dubs.
>>63717043
it's supposed to symbolize him returning to when he was good but he was good before he died so it's fucking stupid
>>63717100
this can't be a serious post. lol
>>63717100
Akira is fucking awful movie in just about every aspect the only good thing about it is it's animation
>>63717100
>>63717138
Yes?
>>63715421
>disco music exists in the future
>>63715340
The original had Anakain as he would have appeared if he had lived as long as he did without turning into Darth Vader. It made perfect sense.
Then George decided it wasn't enough, he never to actually insert Akain as he was BEFORE he turned in Darth Vader. Which was retarded, because then it means he died when he turned into Darth Vader, which means his redemption means nothing. It's all convoluted as fuck.
>>63717100
this pasta
this
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-yxuDU8gims
>>63716117
>Steps on his tail
>That fucking babbys-first-Final-Cut-Pro of Han going up then down
What were they thinking
>>63715852
Jesus christ, George Lucas just seems like petty fuck. Just changing shit out of spite to the viewer.
this
When they turned Jabba's palace into the Star Wars equivalent of a Chuck E Cheese restaurant
>>63717416
>the future
>>63716117
my god those eyes look fucking terrifying
>>63717953
>1970s music exists in a galaxy thousands of years ago
>>63717435
>he died when he turned into Darth Vader
Which is what Obi-Wan and Yoda were saying all along.
Forever will it dominate your destiny yadda yadda
>>63717435
It was always intended for Anakin to appear as he was when he was Jedi, young. They just couldn't do it at the time because they didn't know what it would look like. In the novelization released at the same time as the movie it even states that anakin's ghost appeared young.
>>63717986
>humans and english exists in a galaxy thousands of years ago
>>63715210
Just when you thought Vader's NOOOOOOOO in Revenge of the Sith wasn't bad enough...
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O3u70WELSEg
>>63716169
>>63716256
Harmy's despecialized versions are pretty fucking great, go get them, right now
>>63718207
>english didn't even exist in our galaxy one thousand years ago
>somehow exists in their galaxy
>>63719151
Yeah they should have invented a new language just for the film, what is this stupid unrealistic shit where everyone talks english?
Fucking dropped.
>>63715421
>recently wanted to rewatch Jedi
>went to some crappy pirate streaming portal and started first version I could find
>prepare myself for all kinds of ridiculous CG shenanigans and possible NOOO
>it was actually the completely unaltered original version
>mfw it dawned on me
>>63720530
>went to some crappy pirate streaming portal and started
The fuck are you doing that for?
Just pirate it, dummy.
Disney removing slave costume is worst edit
>>63715210
Hes not even looking at anyone and looks like he's sperging
>>63720037
>mfw when younglins for breakfast
>>63717834
>Han Solo force ghost appears in Episode IX
>it's played by Chris Pratt
>>63721203
>special editions are made and he's replaced with young solo
>>63715210
The giant animals CGId in in front of outdoor scenes, usually blocking the entire frame
>>63715421
Why i can't find on YouTube shots of the original monkey face Sheev ? Even in the compilation of 1983 SW he is not here.
What's the conspiracy ?
>>63718008
>luke dies in ep8
>force ghost appears in ep9
>it's a cgi 20s mark hamil because luke died when he made that rage-fuelled assault on vader in rotj after vader taunted him with leia
>>63721252
>all those bullshit unnecessary movies
>they've already thoroughly planned out the milking of the series
>they're not gonna stop after those ones come out
i know it was gonna happen, but still
>>63715421
is she died?
>>63717100
This is the exact same post you did for Dark Souls.
>>63716120
What the fuck is that revisited edition? Looks like shit
>>63717100
>if you have watched Akira, you'd realize just how sophisticated anime is
>disturbingly mature like Fractale
>Guilty Crown
>Sword Art Online
>gripping drama that also has awesome mecha battles Aldnoah.Zero is the shit
2/10, made me reply.
>>63715421
the old song was better though
>>63715421
Eh, it fits into the scene better. You get a cool shot of frozen Han in the background while the song's playing.
The new one takes all focus off the actual scene and is a bizarre deviation with bad CGI
>>63721438
You got me, I actually laughed hard at this
>>63715421
That song was pretty groovy
>>63722332
It was a pretty great scene actualy :
https://youtu.be/rKtciRCVpFE
Luke, did I ever tell you about younglings? Youngling was a term that existed in Basic to refer to a child in a species-neutral way. Thus, the term "youngling" could apply to all forms of offspring, from humanoid children to insectoid grubs, just like the term "children". The term "youngling" is also used to refer to a child undergoing Jedi training. I don't like younglings.
Anyone tried the despecialized edition? What's the risk I get slapped with an angry notice from Disney's legal team if I download it?
>>63716613
He must've thought you were talking about TFA, for whatever reason.
>>63721438
>>63722332
>>63722512
Don't see what the big deal is with this scene. It's probably the few that actually made sense.
>>63715421
can we all just finally agree that Star Wars sucked, it continues to suck, and will continue to suck for a great long while??
seriously, I've been wondering since I was a little kid why everyone thought SW was great, and then the prequels shit all over that, and now George is back to play with his space cowboys in the sand box for yet another shit movie
move
the fuck
on
>>63715798
The music in the final celebration in return of the jedi improved tho. That ewok yub nub song was shit, the new one fits so much better.
>>63715529
Because we saw "emotions" on Vader's mask, internal emotional conflict, that was epic
>>63722512
>The Emperor was originally voiced by Clive Revill for that scene, and visually portrayed by Elaine Baker, the wife of make-up designer Rick Baker
That's quite a manish woman.
>>63715279
I have to agree here. All the other edits were hurtful to someone (Actors) in some way, but that one was cringe as hell and hurt the quality of that scene. Seriously what the fuck.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bWtuhZ6A1Ds
>>63717100
>>63723190
What do you think it tastes like?
>>63723190
and that's supposed to make us what?
that shit looked amazing and i'm already on my second playthrough.
must've been so relieving.
>>63720826
Then why they still keep this?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KmAi_3byBFo
>>63716232
Yeah, its pretty good.
>>63723190
>related videos
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kFV5tjo80QQ
>>63723190
Shameful boner t b h
>>63721203
>crisp rat
fucking lel
>>63715725
>>63716232
I liked it a lot. A good discussion.
>>63723098
>this new shiny polished turd is soooo much better than my old turd
>>63722512
god this is creepy as fuck
i love it
>>63717100
Carbonara/10
>>63721203
If this happens I'll blame you anon.
>>63718405
>that fucking audio popping
THANX YIFI 10/10
>>63718018
Why didn't they put cgi Obi Wan in then?
How about the BEST EDIT IN STAR WARS HISTORY?
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=32itsA81Ouw
>>63715210
3rd place
>>63715279
2nd place
>>63715323
1st place
ROTJ was the most heavily victimized by CGI edits.
>>63723414
posting the wrong, non-cluster fuck version as lucas envisioned it.
>>63724568
I never realised Sheev's guards wore mandalorian helmets
>>63715920
He was reeling her in to fuck her, or slobber all over her with his slug mouth or something. She resists, Jabba is like, "Fuck it bitch, if you're not gonna put out then I got no use for you" and feeds her to the Rancor
>>63715876
Reminds me of this
https://youtu.be/fiBLgEx6svA?t=2m24s
>>63724674
*sun guard helmet
>>63718405
Why didn't it melt luke or dindu's face when they was electrocuted?
