[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Home]
4chanarchives logo
Why do all planets in Star Wars only have one type of terrain?
Images are sometimes not shown due to bandwidth/network limitations. Refreshing the page usually helps.

You are currently reading a thread in /tv/ - Television & Film

Thread replies: 117
Thread images: 12
File: hoth1.jpg (61 KB, 800x497) Image search: [Google]
hoth1.jpg
61 KB, 800x497
Why do all planets in Star Wars only have one type of terrain?

Snow Planet
Sand Planet
Forest Planet
City Planet
That's No Moon
>>
>>63050739

I forgot Water Planet and Red Sand Mars Ripoff Planet from the prequels.
>>
>>63050739
because it's all made up, anon
>>
>>63050739
darth icky decreed it so
>>
>>63050739
>only see one part of planet
>all planet must be like that
retard
>>
>>63050798
Poorly made up
>>
Earth-like planets are probably pretty rare. The habitable zone near a star is quite large and "very cold" or "very hot" take up a much larger portion of it than "just right for a variety of climates."
>>
>>63050856
Like your facial features.
>>
Each planet rhymes with the last
>>
>>63050850

No... they show shots from space of the planets you dumb shit

the same damn terrain covers each planet
>>
>>63050739
They only went to one place on the planet. There could be a jungle area somewhere else on the planet, or maybe the poles are uninhabitable cold.

I like how Inception turned this concept on its head, every planet they went to was awful uninhabitable shit.
>>
>>63050739
Because it was never advertised as having huge perfectly detailed worlds. It's a fucking 80s space fantasy movie, lighten up.
>>
>>63050850
>>63050939
>Coruscant
>planet entirely covered by one large city
This is probably the first thing that made me hate Lucas.
>>
File: fatty cheesemo.jpg (34 KB, 620x413) Image search: [Google]
fatty cheesemo.jpg
34 KB, 620x413
>>63050959
>80s
>>
>>63050943
>Inception

what
>>
>>63050998
Oops the other Nolan movie that begins with an I
>>
>>63050739
copied flash gordon senpai. kek wars aint original and star wars fags are the cancer of pop culture.
>>
its medieval fantasy in space

>ships = horses
>destinations are just planets instead of some far off location
>white knights, dark knights
>big wars all the time
>fucking magic
>god damn princess
>>
>>63051037
>kek wars
You aren't even trying.
>>
>>63050998
He means Interstellar

That being said, it's actually pretty realistic when you look at our solar system.
>>
Because Lucas ripped off trantor from Asimovs foundation and Arrakis from Herbert's Dune.
>>
File: image.jpg (34 KB, 400x363) Image search: [Google]
image.jpg
34 KB, 400x363
>>63050988
>IV: 1977
>V: 1980
>VI: 1983
>>
Because Lucas is a hack and you can't do better
>>
>>63050850
>Forest moon of endor
>Ice planet hoth

These are verbatim lines
>>
>>63050739
What is Naboo?
>>
>>63051070
>kek
>>
>>63051036
Interstellar, you dingus
>>
>>63051080
Yeah Mercury, Venus, Mars are all just one type of terrain. That's what makes earth so unique.

Does anyone remember if naboo had deserts or snow?
>>
>>63051088
>2/7 released in 80's
Go back to school, reading is easy.
>>
Well in all fairness our solar system pretty much has ice planets and desert planets too. Of course you can't breathe on them but still.
>>
>>63050739
who fucking cares you dumb redditor
>>
>>63051132
>core of the planet is water and goes straight from one side to the other
>>
>>63051037
I fucking hate how big star wars has become. Flash Gordon was the original, and I loved that movie, there's way more fantasy but as a movie it's shitty. The comics were fun though.
>people LOOOOVE star wars
>Most people haven't seen star wars in years or ever at all
Everything star wars is now is merchandise. It's the worst thing ever aside from whovians.
>>
>>63050988
dumb nigger go back to watching kekleodeon.... gotta be born in 1998 or some shit not to know this common knowledge
>>
>>63051132
French Rivera planet
>>
>>63051179
It only took like 20 minutes to drive through it too.
>>
>>63051191
We already covered this, kid, and the conversation is over. Welcome to the thread.
>>
>>63051179
The planet core isn't water, there are just flooded lava tubes.

The planet has forests, plains, swamps, seas, and polar regions.
>>
>>63051200
they had a bomb bad bongo
>>
>>63051059
>medieval

It's jap shit mixed with WW2 you pleb.
>>
>>63051231
>Yousa be takin....DE PLANET COOOOOORE
>>
File: image.jpg (8 KB, 250x250) Image search: [Google]
image.jpg
8 KB, 250x250
>>63051167
IV only had 2 planets(yavin didn't even have a distinct landscape). V and VI, which had the most planets, started this trend.

There's no need to be such a dick about it, dude.
>>
>>63051188
At least SW had 3 good films.

Nice dubs btw.
>>
>>63051296
>There's no need to be such a dick about it, dude.
There's no need to cry, either, but here you are. Two out of the seven movies were made in the 80's, in case you didn't know what that fraction meant(numbers are hard sometimes, much like reading).
>>
This is about Jew Jay copying everything from the original trilogy and making it more action-y and lens flare-y isn't it anon?

It's okay, you don't have to lie to us.
>>
>>63050739
I know, right?
I mean just look at that giant desert on Pluto.
>>
>>63050896
elaborate
>>
>>63051346
What I meant was that IV-VI should be excused from this criticism while I-III were just lazy.
>>
>>63051346
Prequels don't count and 7 isn't out yet. 2/3 it is.
>>
Because Lucas is a fucking hack.
Everyone who's ever worked on these garbage movies are hacks.
And every single fucking fan is a certified diaper-wearing retard.
I hope every theater showing this piece of shit gets shot to shit.
Fuck ALL of you!
>>
>>63051449
>Prequels don't count because I said so
Take your fangirl tears elsewhere.

>>63051445
>What I meant
I know what you meant, due to my literacy. Nobody was talking about criticism except you. Feel free to check that out, the posts are still there.
>>
>>63051489
aww babbies first post
>>
>>63051489
Pretentious Tarkovsky fan detected
>>
>>63051539
daww, babbies first butthurt

hang yourself pedophile
>>
>>63050739
What planets are there.
Tatooine - desert
Yavin 4 - forest
Yavin - gas
Alderaan - earthlike
Coruscant - city
Utapau - earthlike with big ass holes
Dagobah - swamp
Bespin - gas
Moon of Endor - forest
Kashyyyk - forest/earthlike
Geonosis - desert
Hoth - snow
Kamino - water
Naboo - earthlike
Mustafar - lava
Jakku - desert
>>
>>63051548
so your only talent is getting mad? neat trick you useless piece of shit
>>
>>63051497
Nobody sane counts the prequels. Only edgelords, autists and kids whose first movie was TPM.

Furthermore, prequels are only an extension of the original movies because Lucas is a talentless hack. So 80s it is.
>>
File: image.jpg (70 KB, 555x526) Image search: [Google]
image.jpg
70 KB, 555x526
>>63051497
Well I guessed that OP was just being passive aggressive and calling SW lazy but whatever, I guess not.
>>
>>63051598
Better than your only talent, growing mold and filling diapers with shit.
Come back when you're not a worthless cum stain see: never.
>>
>>63051602
>Prequels don't count because I said so
The fact is that they are Star Wars movies. Don't like facts? Too bad.

>>63051631
Clicked the wrong post?
>>
>>63051598
At least he has talent unlike you disney kike.
Keep rehashing others' intellectual property oven bait.
>>
>>63051637
even your insults suck but i can see that you're a kek.
that's probably why you're angry with the world, any in high school you couldn't pick up any girls.
>>
>>63051700
>kek
What a fucking loser, can't even bypass the word filter.
Fuck off back to reddit cumlord, your tired, rehashed insults are boring, just like your movies.
Fucking queer.
>>
>>63051637
>>63051679
same faggot
>>
>>63051724
>>63051700

butthurt obvious small-dicked samefaggot
>>
>>63050739
Really, when was the last time you saw science-fiction avoid this? The only fictional planet I can think of that isn't an Earth knockoff or one biome is the one from VOTOMS.
>>
>>63051646
>facts

Mere opinions of yours. Anybody with a iota of movie knowledge knows better.

>but muh titles

Shit isn't roses just because you write roses on it.
>>
LOL fucking loser
>>
>>63051772
I wish you were half as good at trolling as you want to be. Maybe you should practice on Reddit for a few years?
>>
>>63050739
Naboo is shown to be very earth like, most other planets we don't get to see much of like Felucia.
>>
File: 1307922622001.jpg (14 KB, 262x337) Image search: [Google]
1307922622001.jpg
14 KB, 262x337
>>63050739

any snow planet and desert planed actually make perfect sense. They're just planets too close or too far from their host star
>>
>>63051721
hey bro how mad are you right now?
>>
>>63051832
enjoy the no oxygen
>>
>>63050739
you mean biome
>>
>>63051826
>all defense fails
>I know I'll just give him the old Reddit meem
>>
>>63051976
Apparently I'm trolling you now, is that how bad you are at this? Just because you're sad about the prequels being part of the Star Wars franchise?
>>
>>63052005
>I'm trolling
>You are trolling

Are you 15?
>>
>>63052064
That doesn't even make sense, anyone using outdated terms would be much less likely to be underage. Anyone old enough to post here would know that.
>>
>>63052104
It's not the terms, it's that you care and mention it at all
>>
>>63051218
oh damn you sure did put me in my place calling me kid, thanks for the welcome by the way.... faggot
>>
>>63052151
And now you're backpedaling, I'm getting embarrassed for you.

>>63052160
Did it take you that long to think of that?
>>
>>63050986
Ayy lmaos are great with infrastructure.
>>
>>63050896
kek'd
>>
>>63051602
How ass-ravaged do you have to be if you can't get over a 15 year old movie being disappointing?
>>
>>63050986
City-planets goes farther back than asmiov, son.
>>
>>63050739

>Forest Planet

TRIGGERED
>>
>>63050739
Single biome planets aren't the issue, the issue is breathable air on said planets.
>>
Naboo = Average Earth-like planet.
>>
>>63051579
Dantoiine - Earthlike
Sullust - Lava
Ilum - snow
Mandalore - earthlike

ayylmao
>>
>>63051923
Thats what midichlorians were for.
>>
>>63052759
>Mandalore - earthlike
not really
>>
I love the idea of a forest moon, imagine our moon was all forest, that would be so cool man
>>
>>63051167

You think Starwars happened in the 80s, eh?

Here, let me prove you wrong in the worst way possible.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z4CtXcjib4o
>>
>>63050739
because it's fiction senpai
>>
>>63050856
You can't imagine how much /tv/ would bitch if they went from sandplanet to sandplanet.
>>
>>63050887
like his DNA
>>
>>63050986
City-Planets are cool though.
>>
>>63051059
>fucking magic
They're midichlorians, you pleb.
>>
>>63050739
>forest planet

That was a moon orbiting a gas giant you fucking nigger.
>>
Better question is how does an ice or desert planet have oxygen?
GEORGE LUCAS YOU FUCKING HACK!!!!!!!
>>
>>63051188

>why doesn't anyone like what I like!!!
>>
File: Cloud_City.jpg (47 KB, 640x480) Image search: [Google]
Cloud_City.jpg
47 KB, 640x480
this is cloud city from star wars...
>>
>>63050871
What's even rarer is a planet in the habitable zone that doesn't have any variance in climate as you vary your latitude
>>
File: originalcloudcity.jpg (20 KB, 400x400) Image search: [Google]
originalcloudcity.jpg
20 KB, 400x400
>>63055597
...this is cloud city from star trek.

>>63050739
star wars just copies shit and everyone reveres it for being so original. truly a plague.
>>
>>63055597
>>63055620
How are they similar except both being airborne cities surrounded by clouds?
>>
>>63050739
And Alderaan was the rebel planet.
So there weren't any collateral loses when it blew up, only rebel scum died.
Sheev literally did nothing wrong.
>>
>>63055642
>how are the similar except for the fact that they're similar

HURRURRRRR
>>
File: TheLookout.png (208 KB, 608x456) Image search: [Google]
TheLookout.png
208 KB, 608x456
>>63055597
>>63055620
woah...
>>
>>63051296
Planets from the Original Trilogy:
Tatooine - Desert Planet
Aalderaan - Dunno, planet is blue and white, and gets blown up.
Yaavin - A Gas Giant
Yaavin 4 - A Forest Moon
Hoth - Ice Planet
Bespin - Another Gas Giant
Dagobah - Green and white planet, Luke lands in a swamp.
Endor - Another Forest Moon.
>>
File: bkFH9IP.jpg (19 KB, 579x329) Image search: [Google]
bkFH9IP.jpg
19 KB, 579x329
>>63055642
>two giant cities floating in the clouds
>"how are they similar"?!
>>
File: laputa_pic.png (207 KB, 324x568) Image search: [Google]
laputa_pic.png
207 KB, 324x568
>>63055664
>Star Wars cloud city
>saucer shaped and alien looking

>Star Trek cloud city
>average metropolitan skyline slapped on top of a cloud
>>63055690
But they are completely different design wise, and it's not like Star Trek invented flying cities to begin with
>>
>>63055685
Why do they call it 'Hoth'?

They should call it "Coldth"
>>
>>63055729
It's advanced pottery
>>
>>63050739
> city planet
that's literally earth 2.0
>>
File: dersu_uzala.png (225 KB, 640x480) Image search: [Google]
dersu_uzala.png
225 KB, 640x480
>>63055717
great read, and never said it invented flying cities ya dingus, however trek and wars were the first ones to do it onscreen.
they are both called the same thing, not to mention he took a bunch of shit from trek, so i wouldn't doubt he took this from trek

pic also related.
>>
>>63055835
I'd say that SW looks more like the original Laputa (disc shaped), so I wouldn't say that Lucas took that from Star Trek
>>
>>63055868
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rmU9HLGA5fQ
disney, pls go. blacked.com is the other way.
Thread replies: 117
Thread images: 12

banner
banner
[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Home]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
If a post contains personal/copyrighted/illegal content you can contact me at [email protected] with that post and thread number and it will be removed as soon as possible.
DMCA Content Takedown via dmca.com
All images are hosted on imgur.com, send takedown notices to them.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from them. If you need IP information for a Poster - you need to contact them. This website shows only archived content.