Joel or Mike, /tv/?
>>63013205
Mike. Joel is a massive faggot.
I respect Joel as the original driving force behind the show, but I found Mike to be more watchable. He had better timing and delivery.
>>63013277
ditto
Joel was okay, but Mike had the best comedy.
Also, it's sad to see both sides of MST3K hate eachother now even know they all were on the show since day 1.
Mike, but I'm biased as that's the era I started watching.
Clearly none of them were as good as Felicia Day is going to be, so why even have the discussion?
Mike.
>>63013382
Kill yo self
I used to be a Mike fan but then Joel brought us this
Mike.
Joel's quite likeable, but Mike was just more funny.
>>63013437
god that woman is aging badly
the host/MAD chemistry is gonna be fucking horrible
>>63013408
#quirky!
>>63013467
>>63013437
What? She looks pretty on fleek to me senpai
>io9 (Gawker site)
>In the Greatest Casting of All Time, Felicia Day May Be MST3K's Next Mad Scientist
Joel is great, but Mike is better. I loved him in the Movie
Would Mike have written something like this?
>>63013467
The Mads were always the worst part of the show though. I laughed maybe twice ever at anything they were doing.
>>63013661
>And if your hands were metal, that would mean something
>>63013690
>adorkable
>>63013205
Mike, Joel hates Kevin Murphy so fuck him
>Felicia Day
Fuck you Joel. Mike was always better.
>>63013205
Mike was not only the better host, but he was the head writer on Joel's best seasons. Joel may have made MST3k, but Mike made MST3k great.
>>63013835
source? I'm genuinely curious about this.
>>63013991
This.
>>63014031
You know Joel seems ti hate the whole RiffTrax team. They never say why.
>>63013690
I cancelled my $10 pledge when I read that shit. Also the new Crow and Servo suck.
>>63014130
because Mike took the show to comedy central and cut him out of it
Joel's drier sense of humor appeals to me more but Mike's episodes indisputably more consistently funny.
Best Joel episode: Catalina Caper
Best Mike episode: Puma Man
Bill's Crow > Trace's Crow
>>63013690
>Nerd royalty
Also, holy moses was her delivery terrible in that video. Not looking forward to this at all.
>>63013991
According to the interviews I've seen, it was a team effort - everyone watched the movies together and threw out riffs. "Head writer" just meant Mike held the remote.
>>63014310
What? Joel hosted several seasons on Comedy Central, he left because he had a fight with Jim Mallon.
I don't think there's real hostility between Joel and Mike, the problem is both of them are the leads and neither would go back to a smaller role.
>>63013690
Probably not, Mike is married.
>>63014369
>Puma Man
Pyooma Man
>>63014525
With the power to rear-project major cities!
>>63013690
Nerd Royalty does seem like a perfect term for her. You have to suck up to her like this to get her to do anything off of youtube, and people think her presence gives whatever their working on instant legitimacy. Princess Look-At-Me's involvement has made me lose any interest I had in this revival. I'll just stick to pirating rifftrax.
>>63014197
>Crow and Servo suck
>new
Wait, what? Why the fuck couldn't they get any of the other 4 people to do them?
Neither. MST3K was kind of a lousy show.
>>63014872
People keep saying its because Joel hates everyone else involved in MST3k. It seems likely, since none of the other actors really have anything else going on to the point they couldn't come film for a week or two, and they aren't going to be demanding big paychecks.
>>63014872
Joel didn't tell anyone about it, he was just short on cash so he started a kickstarter to make some easy money
>>63014919
Wait, so Joel didn't even want Trace, Frank or Elvis to be a part? Jesus Christ. I assumed that this new season would bring as least Trace and Elvis voice for the voices.
The more I read the more it seems like Joel just wants all the attention back on him again.
I liked mike, I think joel is ruining everything by pandering to pop-culture nerds and reviving a classic for the sake of income.
>>63015004
He wants a new cast every few years, like Doctor Who.
And did you expect Sylvester McCoy and Sophie Aldred when Doctor Who came back?
>>63015086
Why the fuck would you recast the voices though?
>>63015086
no because he regenerated into paul mcgann
>>63015086
I would like the new cast more if the show had stayed on the air and were gradually brought on.
I just have some misgivings with doing all new people (especially when all i wanted was the old team back)
That other guy with two robot friends supports new MST3K.
>>63014505
Mike's wife is a cutie too, she showed up in a few skits
>>63013690
being redpilled I agree Sweden should be seen as evil. I get it now
>Tom Servo is a black man
Rumor-mill says that Patton Oswalt is the yet-to-be-revealed evil henchman.
Mike had better timing, better delivery, an was all-around a more likeable host.
>>63013690
>nerd royalty
>adorkable
I'm willing to accept a new cast, but something will be lost if they don't have anyone from Wiscaaansin.
>>63013437
No.
NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
THIS WAS LITERALLY MY NIGHTMARE SCENARIO, FUCK THIS
Started watching with Joel, and he will always be my sleepy voiced narrator, but I like Mike just as much.
>>63013730
>TV's Frank
>Not based as fuck
He's /tv/'s frank desu.
>>63015086
>And did you expect Sylvester McCoy and Sophie Aldred when Doctor Who came back?
That Stupid movie should have been retconned and SylDoc should have been given a proper regeneration.
>>63015004
>taking this long to realize this is simply a Joel vanity project poaching the show name to get a quick buck because when he's forced to stand on his writing ability alone (Cinematic Titanic) it's a trainwreck.
The obscenely over-inflated budget makes a hell of a lot more sense now that Felicia Day is officially involved, though. Why spend a fraction of that money on a small dedicated group of underground comedy writers (you know, like the original show) when you can rake in millions to put in a name that meme-spouting millenials somehow look up to for 3-5 minutes an episode?
>mike and jay are the new crow and tom servo
>>63013205
writing - absolutely Mike
hosting - tie. Mike did a lot of fun stuff but I liked Joel's muted approach more than a lot of people seemed to. With Joel there was also more of a father-sons relationship between him and the bots which I found really charming as well.
>>63018299
>with Rich Evans as host, Jack and Colin as the mads, and Wizard dead
literally perfect
>>63018401
Go to bed Jack.
>people donating to this to get riffs
>joel isnt riffing, original robots arent either
just get some rifftrax since they got mike and the original robots
>>63013690
>yes pleassssssssss@ssse
How did that @ get in there if she was just holding down the S key?
>>63013205
Joel is flight, Mike is fight.
Joel is the quintessential quitter.
Joel was ok, its more consistent I guess
When Mike had a good episode, it was way funnier than anything Joel did
>>63018375
>implying https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8xvhn122ygc doesnt confirm mike as best forever
I've seen every episode, lots many times
I always hated 99% of the skits with that dumb fat bitch or the pale guys, those parts sucked so bad
>>63014369
agree
The original crow was kind of a fag.
>>63013437
Mike. Of course.
>>63013375
W-what? :'(
>not choosing Felicia
Why so sexist?
>>63018802
DUDE IM A GEEK LMAO
>>63013437
>>63013690
I used to be a Joel fan all the way.
Used to be.
>>63013205
Joel, duh. I can't believe you twats.
>>63013991
And no, no. Citation needed. Writing the show was always a communal affair.
![CT99qiNUkAAmGcw[1].png](https://i.imgur.com/qSKUB3p.png "CT99qiNUkAAmGcw[1].png")
>>63018802
Because she's not the host. This guy is.
>>63018802
Anybody that disagrees is a misogynist and is a gamergater.
![2610916-8134799398-fef54e[1].jpg](https://i.imgur.com/ZCvn3dd.jpg "2610916-8134799398-fef54e[1].jpg")
>>63018993
She's playing the Forrester, and there's already been a woman in that role.
If we like Pearl better than her, WHO'S SEXIST NOW?!
Is it true that Rebecca Sugar drew rule 34 of Joel & the bots?
>>63019310
she certainly drew a lot of scaly shota
Why not both?
>>63019310
Probably.
>>63013690
Based Mike would never ever do this. Joel is such a sellout.
>>63015086
But WHY should it be brought back in the first place? MST3K ran for many years and ended on a high note. Joel bringing it back without any of the old writers screams cash grab.
Always been for Mike. His humor has always been a bit meaner, and it makes for a funnier show. Last 3 seasons are GOAT tier. Joel always seemed pretty bland to me. Plus this Felicia Day shit is just embarrassing.
![Bots[1].jpg](https://i.imgur.com/DLG2BbC.jpg "Bots[1].jpg")
>>63020218
no, Jim Mallon bringing it back as a poorly drawn flash cartoon with no movie riffing was a cash grab.
compared to that, this is freakin' Star Trek TNG (which everyone thought they were gonna hate going into too)
Mike.
Bill.
Kevin.
GOAT lineup. This is objectively correct.
>>63020313
TNG had the Star Trek brand but it was its own show. If it had been shit people could've easily ignored it because it didn't affect the ending of the original series. Joel should call his revival "MST3K: The Next Generation" or something. Instead he's going to shit all over the legacy of the show for a quick buck.
What about this guy? I can see him making a few guest appearances :^)
>>63017160
ugggggghhhhhh
>>63017160
>>63022138
I wouldn't mind Patton. He's definitely a better casting choice than Jonah Ray and Felicia Day.
>>63022387
>>63022138
I'm gonna be completely honest, Patton has some pretty good stand up and is a pretty good actor. There's just something about him I don't like that I can't put my finger on, so I'll chalk it up to autism.
>>63017160
Patton was the star of a Pixar movie and does the narration for The Goldbergs, I think it'd be way underneath him to be a henchman in MST3K.
>>63022784
He's in RLM's latest movie. Anything's possible. Patton is a "nerd" so I could see him having a cameo.
JOEL
JOEL JOEL
JOEL
J O E L
O
E
L
And the worst part is, he didn't even finish his last season...
>>63013661
Normal view! Normal view! Normal view! Normal view!
>>63020313
>>63020606
>being old enough to remember the lead up to TNG
Go to bed grandpas.
>>63013991
Well put. And Joel's voice sucks. Still, Santa Claus Conquers The Martians is a favorite episode of mine.
>>63014310
They moved it to The Sci-Fi Channel at the end.
>>63018802
She hasn't fucking started yet!
>>63021945
He has helped out on Rifftrax.
>>63013730
>not relating to forrester and his desire to inflict horrible cinema on people.
Joel and Mike are great, but this is the first time MST3K will have nerd royalty in the cast.
