[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Home]
4chanarchives logo
The Man in the High Castle
Images are sometimes not shown due to bandwidth/network limitations. Refreshing the page usually helps.

You are currently reading a thread in /tv/ - Television & Film

Thread replies: 163
Thread images: 23
File: Man_High_Castle_(TV_Series)_map.png (328 KB, 2359x1372) Image search: [Google]
Man_High_Castle_(TV_Series)_map.png
328 KB, 2359x1372
Just finished this. Thought it was alright, it struck more or less the right balance of adapting the book and doing their own thing, in my opinion.

The weakest parts were around episodes 3-4 or so, the entire Marshal subplot felt like it dragged somewhat, and the lead heroine was stupendously boring.

But the strength of the show was in its atmosphere, and in its supporting cast, and the political maneuvering between the Japanese and the Nazis. The events of latter half of the final episode were particularly GOAT, and characters like Smith, Wegener, Kido, and Tagomi were great no matter what scenes they were in.

Anyone else watched this, or is everyone busy watching Jessica Jones?
>>
whats the story with canon city?
>>
>>62975989
>le Nazi's wanted to conquer the world! XD

I hate that meme
>>
>>62975989
duh ebil nazis
>>
>>62976154
>>62976119
>main Nazi character is a devoted father, loving husband and popular pillar of the community who deeply holds Nazi values in his heart as the best way to run a society
>his establishing scene is him being ambushed by four would-be assassins and killing three of them, wounding the fourth and bringing him in to be tortured
I am actually confused about what a fucking hero type character this guy is
>>
>>62976154
dey dindu nuffin
>>
>>62976119
>he's too young and stupid to realize that the book came out in 1962.
There's no meme to be found here fuccboi.
>>
>>62976265
He has personal experience, his wife mentions that he and his family lost everything in the Great Depression (which he blames on the self-serving individualism and decadence that America exemplified before the war). By comparison, the stable and prosperous society that the National Socialist States of America offers, and its attitude of placing family, community, state, and duty ahead of oneself, must seem to him like worth the price that was paid to build it.

His devotion to these ideals is also part of how he handles his past involvement in the extermination camps. He clearly struggled with it internally just like Wegner (you don't go sailing anymore?) but whereas Wegner retreated from his beliefs, John doubled down on the "the ends justified the means" and "emotion cannot stand in the way of duty" thing. To him, this was the price that had to be paid to create the techno-paradise they live in.
>>
File: vlcsnap-2015-11-23-13h07m23s744.png (400 KB, 816x452) Image search: [Google]
vlcsnap-2015-11-23-13h07m23s744.png
400 KB, 816x452
>watched the whole thing
>still don't know how there were films from other dimensions/timelines

Did the Japanese guy travel to our dimension mentally or physically by meditating?
>>
File: Hitler's high castle.jpg (323 KB, 1920x1080) Image search: [Google]
Hitler's high castle.jpg
323 KB, 1920x1080
That fucking ending though
>>
File: capture.jpg (133 KB, 1920x1080) Image search: [Google]
capture.jpg
133 KB, 1920x1080
Okay, I'm confused, does Hitler have Parkinson's or not? His closest advisers all think he's weak and decrepit and that's why they're fighting for his position, but surely anyone who sees Hitler at any time could tell he's in perfect health.
>>
>>62977267
That scene was fantastic. The last episode was actually one of the best episodes of any show I had seen.

Fucking Hitler man. How did a show get me rooting for fucking Hitler?
>>
>>62976119
>>62976154
>4chan is so instantly contrarian that 2 of 4 posts in this thread are defending a movement that exterminated hundreds of thousands and started a war that killed scores of millions
>>
File: 2000.jpg (471 KB, 2000x1200) Image search: [Google]
2000.jpg
471 KB, 2000x1200
>>62977051
I mean from a storytelling perspective it would've been so easy to make him a rapist or have him gleefully laughing as he murders children, but instead the series seems to perpetually cast him in a fairly sympathetic light.

And his internal traumas and conflicts serve to add to that sympathy, not detract from it, but even in the most general directorial tricks the show has him do the instant, cheap empathetic things like

>despair as he watches his friend die, then snap out of it and kick ass while outnumbered
>give his son very sage and sincere advice
>constantly be ominous as fuck around Joe but then keep backing away from it to be a legitimate friend and mentor to him
>>
>>62977332
Maybe it's an alternate universe Hitler.
>>
>>62977397
nazi dad best dad
>>
>>62977379
There were virtually no straight up good guys in WWII. Stalin and Mao ever being considered "good guys" makes this obvious,but frankly even Roosevelt and Churchill had more in common with Hitler politically than they do with any modern politician - i.e. the treatment of Japanese citizens or the colonization of Africa and India
>>
>>62977397
Well, they probably recognized that a caricature doesn't make for a very compelling character.

Even Inspector Kido (who in the first couple of episodes is just presented as a secret police asshole) has more depth to him than just "I like to beat people"
>>
>>62977397

a 3 dimensional character rather than a cartoon villain? WELL YOU KNOW THEY CAN'T LET THAT GO ON FOR LONG!
>>
>>62976081
>please respond
>>
File: hitler parkinsons.png (30 KB, 280x318) Image search: [Google]
hitler parkinsons.png
30 KB, 280x318
>>62977332
He did. He was using a cane towards the end of his life and there's a really characteristic change in handwriting that occurs with Parkinson's overtime. If you look at his signature between like 1920 and 1940, it changes drastically.
>>
>>62977519
The show is clearly not an exact depiction of "real life" on any level but the point is in-universe Hitler is alive in 1962 and widely rumored to be on his way due to Parkinson's, except when he finally appears he looks so spry that the Parkinson's almost seems to be something else he made up, but what the fuck propaganda advantage does appearing intentionally weak have?
>>
File: rufus.jpg (30 KB, 500x270) Image search: [Google]
rufus.jpg
30 KB, 500x270
>>62977397
i was actually just thinking of this actor this morning, for some reason Cold Comfort Farm was in my brain.
>>
>>62977519
It just looks like he got too lazy to sign his fucking name.

Also this Hitler is in good health, he would be dead by now if he suffered from any of his real world ailments.
>>
>>62977573
There was a huge study done on it. I copied that picture from a 123 page pdf on the pathophysiology of Parkinson's. It's pretty legit. Obviously not 100% sure, but highly suggestive.

http://infoscience.epfl.ch/record/154747/files/GangadharGARIPELLI_MS_THESIS_2006_April.pdf
>>
>>62977397
>constantly be ominous as fuck around Joe but then keep backing away from it to be a legitimate friend and mentor to him
Oh god that first debriefing scene where he gives Joe this cold steely gaze and says "You have failed your mission" and then smirks a little, pats him on the shoulder and tells him everybody makes mistakes

You could see Joe's asshole clench just from his facial expression
>>
File: 1446068132946.jpg (48 KB, 373x345) Image search: [Google]
1446068132946.jpg
48 KB, 373x345
>>62977190

The creator even said that the whole alternate dimension thing is just a macguffin in order to keep the story rolling. And the story is meant to be the trials and tribulations of the lead actress.
>>
>>62977841
god fucking damn it philip I hate you for this shit

like in the penultimate truth

"apropos of nothing I'm a 600 year old Apache who's travelled from the past and seems to oscillate back and forth between being young and old for whatever reason and now I'm taking over the world, let's move on and never have that be relevant"

why do I love you so much you;re such a fucking hack
>>
>>62977558
to sort out the traitors
>>
>>62977841
>the lead actress
Juliana is so fucking irritating. Her motivations do not match up with the lengths that she goes to for them.
Her life seems comfortable enough, she's not starving or suffering or being abused in some way that would make her so desperate to chase the films as some kind of ill-defined "way out".
If her life was absolute shit, and everyone she loves is dead or something, then yeah it would make kind of sense that she's willing to throw everything away to find a way out because she has nothing left to lose and death is preferable to her current circumstances. That's not the case.
Instead she's just caught up in some kind of self-important bullshit about "who would I be if my dad didn't die in the war?".
Then she doesn't learn at all from the part where three innocent people were exterminated because of her actions. This would have been the perfect time for her to take stock of how her obsession with the origin of the film has consequences beyond what she's prepared to deal with, but for circumstances to force her back into the game. But instead it seems like she just doesn't care who dies because of her, and she lies to Frank about her activities with psychopathic ease.
And then she can't even be consistent. She's desperate enough for answers that she's apparently prepared to risk torture and death to infiltrate the Nippon Building. The Resistance woman tells her that this is a job for someone with a deathwish and she assents. But then when it's implied to her that she may have to perform sexual favors to get what she needs, she turns around and runs away. This is not the action of someone who is driven to the kind of desperation that you'd expect when they're prepared to give up their life and the lives of others to get what they want.
Juliana is the worst character on this show. Worse even than Ed, whose character consists solely of telling Frank to do the opposite of whatever he wants to do at the time.
>>
>>62978209
>yfw she's better written than the book
>>
File: CUCK.png (36 KB, 650x210) Image search: [Google]
CUCK.png
36 KB, 650x210
>>62977985

Actually, Philip K. Dick may have had a plan for 'The Grasshopper Lies Heavy', however in the original novel the grasshopper is a novel within a novel.

Spotniz opted for a news reel within a tv show because a because it would be hard to place a book in the plot of the show.

However, the tv show is far longer than the book, and Spotniz needed a way of continuing the plot line. So, essentially, he's just using the grasshopper as a plot device that will likely never be explained.

source: https://archive.is/BgT6J

>>62978209

I concur, I absolutely despise her character. It's just all over the place, the way she reacts to the situations such as when her bf needs her help. Or when she's forced to blow the nip.

The plot is just a complex series of coincidence that perfectly line her up for success, despite her constant effort to fuck things up for herself and everyone else.

The resistance are just a bunch of idiots blindly following every whim for a piece of film. The only good character in the entire show is the lead SS officer. Why can't they just focus the entire thing on him, and the nazi/nip plot.
>>
>>62977985

Philip K Dick's story does not use any "alternate universe" events to "keep the story rolling", in the book there is the absolute bare minimum ghost of a hint that there's maybe another world where the germans didn't win, and that's only at the very end of the book.

And "The Grasshopper Lies Heavy", by the way, doesn't describe the events of our world's history, but that of a third alternative historical scenario.

You should all read Fatherland, by the way. It's much better than The Man in the High Castle.
>>
>>62978359
also its super easy to read a book its much harder to watch a film meaning its easier to hide stuff from characters
>>62978209
it has to be the actress she's so goddamn inconstant literally everyone else is a better actor than her and all she wants is joe's aryan cock
>>
>>62978361

The Grasshopper Lies Heavy, in the tv series, has now come to represent a multitude of alternate realities. They mention a reality in which the USSR won, the Nazi's won and the normal plotline.

Spotniz had to place more emphasis on the lore, yet in doing so he has made it obvious that there is no reasonable explanation. It's exactly what happened in LOST, except he's already losing control of what can be reasonably explained without pulling a flashforward
>>
>>62978449
Only it's still easy to explain where they all come from. They've already shown that people can move between realities, it wouldn't be much of a stretch to say the newsreels originate from people who posses that ability.
>>
I know this will be a dumb question, but can someone explain what exactly the Tagomi-Wegener plan was? Microfilms and secret travel. I think I get that Wegener had to go warn Tagomi in person about an attempt on the Japanese emperor yes? But why Tagomi, what was the microfilm for, etc. etc.
>>
>>62978449
also they don't need to explain that much of it just keep it vague we've been shown that there are people who can jump between worlds
also what happened to russia how did the Germans win
>>
>>62975989
>Having San Francisco as capital

TOP FUCKING HOMOSEXUAL KUCKS
>>
>>62978359
>blindly following every whim for a piece of film
The Man in the High Castle gives them information on the Japs after they deliver him films. Hell, maybe they even think he uses the films to get that info somehow.
>>
>>62978518
Microfilm had plans for an atom bomb I think
>>
>>62978518
drop the plans for a nucleaur bomb to the jap science minister, so there's parity between the two states and they won't go to war.

>the japs want to do a preemptive strike now
>>
>>62978518
Wegener wanted to give the japs the atomic bomb in order to avoid war.
>>
>>62978518
Wegner leaked the designs for the H-bomb to the Japanese Science Minister on the microfilm. The objective was to ensure both Japan and Germany would be nuclear powers, so that if Hitler falls the Germans may think twice about launching a nuclear attack on Japan.
>>
>>62978603
>>62978604
>>62978625

Ah ok thank you. I must have mentally dozed off during one of the earlier episodes.
>>
>>62978604
As soon as they start mining Uranium, the Germans will probably drop the bomb and flatten a few cities.
>>
>>62977051
>self-serving individualism and decadence that America exemplified before the war

America wasn't a consumer paradise prior to the great depression
>>
>>62978518

It's M.A.D. tbqh family
>>
>>62977332
It is all a power play by Hitler.
He pretended to be that weak so it would weed out the traitors.
>>
>>62978740
I'm sure those tens of thousands of households being beset by runaway credit spending were simply buying reasonable, day-to-day essentials.
>>
EDELWEISS

EDELWEISS
>>
>>62980359
That's not what the Great Depression was about you dumb fucking faggot. Is this the quality of education now? Combining the credit crisis of 2008 with the fucking Great Depression and calling it "the same thing"?
>>
>that ending

its going to be lost all over again isnt it
>>
>the man in the high castle
>hitler is a man living in a high castle

B R A V O
R
A
V
O
>>
>>62979802
>>62977558
>>62978096
Are you saying Hitler was just pretending to be retarded?
>>
File: image.jpg (196 KB, 1200x900) Image search: [Google]
image.jpg
196 KB, 1200x900
>no soviet union
What the fuck
>>
>>62981200
there is no soviet union now

why is that so hard to believe?
>>
File: image.jpg (152 KB, 1000x1000) Image search: [Google]
image.jpg
152 KB, 1000x1000
>>62981227
But you are wrong
>>
College Football?

Nope.

Notre Dame 2015 CFB Champs! Paul Hronung would have fuccked your Nazi ass's up, you fucked Nazis
>>
>>62981294
soviet russia is not the USSR
>>
File: image.jpg (249 KB, 869x1520) Image search: [Google]
image.jpg
249 KB, 869x1520
You mad nazi fags ?
Based Stalin
>>
>>62981394
>tfw communism will always be the superior totalitarian idealogy
>>
File: nobody wanted mexico.png (40 KB, 1427x628) Image search: [Google]
nobody wanted mexico.png
40 KB, 1427x628
>>62981383
>>62981227
>>62981200
>>
>>62981442
>he believe in totalitarianism
Nigger please. No such thing.
>>
>>62981450
i thought canada was still canada?
>>
>>62981450
>Greater East Asia Co-Prosperity Sphere
>1/3 of it is in South America
>>
>>62975989
I liked it.

Would have enjoyed some more exposure of the world at large but the source material was very America centric so can't really complain too much.
>>
File: Man_In_The_High_Castle_map.png (54 KB, 1428x638) Image search: [Google]
Man_In_The_High_Castle_map.png
54 KB, 1428x638
>>62981450
>>62981488
>>62981509
All of these are basically guesswork
>>
>>62981450
Wait.

So citizens of the Southern US are citizens of the Reich in the books?
>>
>>62975989
I caught the first episode. I want to see more.
>>
>>62981523
mirin dat Greater-Finland
>>
>>62981450
>>62981450
>drained mediterranean

LOL WHAT
>>
>>62978361
>You should all read Fatherland, by the way
Added it to my list. I kind of liked The Man in the High Castle, but it wasn't quite what I expected.
>>
>>62975989
being this a k dick story the point obviously wasn't living in a ww2 defeated america. Is the series faithful in that regard? Or is it just a series about living in a ww2 defeated america?
>>
>>62981744
They supposedly dammed the straights of Gibraltar and then pumped the water out.
>>
>>62981744
>>62981818
Based on an actual plan by Nazi engineers.
Although I'm not sure it was ever seriously considered, it was worked out quite detailed.
>>
>>62981744
here you go senpai

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atlantropa
>>
>>62981896
>>62981952

I wonder how fertile that land would then be? Doesn't the Mediterranean seabed consist mostly of sand or similar soils?
>>
>>62981523
>newfies under occupation
This will be your undoing, my son.
>>
>>62981952
cool thanks, that makes more sense

i mean its not completely drained
>>
>>62978518
a cold war, but with Nip vs nazi this time
>>
>>62975989

Why does Germany get most of the land?
>>
>>62982339
Because in 1945 America was white
>>
>>62977190
>reality is a lie etc.
PKD typical schizophrenia writings, don't bother looking for another explanation
>>
>>62982405
>everyone was just imagining the Nazis won
...So who the fuck was genociding Jews all over the US?
>>
File: pol is invited to dinner.png (1 MB, 960x1080) Image search: [Google]
pol is invited to dinner.png
1 MB, 960x1080
Besides the Nazis calling themselves Nazis and the bibles being banned I felt this was a pretty solid good show.
>>
>>62977397
Jesus, those caps trigger my military history autism.

>SS eagle
>Wehrmacht national cockade
>No Totenkopf
>>
>>62982448
It was just imaginary jews.
>>
>>62975989
it's interesting they not even a name drop about Italy or europe state in general

it was an ok season, but they lost their way in the middle: all the 'kill the man in the high castle'' seems kinda pointless if they drop it halfway. I hope this is just because they have at least one more season already planned.

also it's funny how Nazi have no redeeming character being almost comic villains, while japs have a lot ''muh honor'' moment a great character like Tagomi. Even ispector Kido, after killing Frank family, seems a positve character when he is about to commit seppuku
>>
>>62982476
>Nazis
>literally short version for Nationalsozialist
You know id would never be an insult in a world where they won the war.
>>
>>62982493
>uniforms can't change in 20 years
>>
>>62982493
Those are American SS officers in an alternative history 1962. They can wear whatever the hell kind of hat they like.
>>
>>62982529
I recently learned the Nazi salute is illegal in half a dozen countries and only legal in some others if you're definitely not "using it to promote an ideology"

And it got me thinking it doesn't get much more fascist than banning a fucking arm movement, does it?
>>
>>62982529
That's actually a good point, the "Nazi" thing bothered me at first too, but when people outside the GroƟdeutsches Reich know it better by another name, why not just adapt that name and make it your own?
>>
>>62982498
>Nazi have no redeeming character being almost comic villains
What about Rudolph? Or ObergruppenfĆ¼hrer Smith? Joe?
Hell, by the last episode the show is making you root for Hitler.
If anything, the Nazis and the Japs have the only relatable characters. The resistance is just a bunch of annoying bastards. Frank is cool though.
>>
>>62982476
I liked how when you can hear the Japanese say 惉悤惄(etc) they still subtitled it as "the Nazis" instead of "the Germans" for no goddamn reason.
>>
File: comfy shiba inu 2.jpg (27 KB, 500x375) Image search: [Google]
comfy shiba inu 2.jpg
27 KB, 500x375
>>62982529

It was a derogatory term from the very beginning, like calling Germans Jerrys, Americans Gringos, Mexicans Beaners, Japanese Tojos and so on. I don't feel they would have appropriated the nickname for themselves, they would either call themselves Nationalsocialists, NatSocs or simply Aryans.
>>
>>62982574
I can concede Rudolph, but Smith is almost ready to be bond villain

joe on the other hand is not really a nazi. I mean he will obiously doublecross them at some point and probably join the resistence
>>
>>62982640
Gringo is not derogatory though.
Just means foreigner.
t. actual latin american.
>>
>>62982591
I'm assuming you mean "doitsu" and yes, I agree. They're fucking Germans!
>>
File: Che_Guevara.jpg (205 KB, 1600x1200) Image search: [Google]
Che_Guevara.jpg
205 KB, 1600x1200
>>62975989
Resistance boss is actually El Che

how would you react?
>>
>>62982700
>I'm assuming you mean "doitsu"
What's there to assume? That's literally 惉悤惄
>>
>>62981744
they also genocided and turned the entire african population into chemicals
>>
>>62982709
Usa going full commie

it may be fun
>>
>>62982640
That is one comfy doge :^)
>>
>>62982738
Wow, so they were finally useful for something?

I mean, I'm getting completely immune to the "baaww muh nazis" whinging because we're going in to a century that will see a nonwhite majority in the US, and in Britain, and in France, and in Germany, and in fucking Sweden.

And we're supposed to celebrate that, that there will still be black countries and arab countries and asian countries and hispanic countries but there won't be a single fucking white country in existence.

Why the fuck is that supposed to be so desirable?
>>
>>62982738
Soylent green?
>>
>>62982709
>not some greased up Kennedy Bros.

They implied South America was more free than the North.
>>
>>62982709
>fanatical white supremacists
>murderous homophobes
>great fashion sense

>imply Che and Fidel wouldn't be Nazi Party members
>>
>>62982648
I don't know.
Smith hasn't done anything about his apparently sick son, while all the other nazis are shown to be genocidal machines, hell, even that guard on the pilot that was a former American soldier talked about the hospital burning cripples and the ill like it is fucking nothing.
He also didn't agree to help Heydrich, who is, even if you take only nazis into comparison, just the devil incarnate.
We just have a lot of morally gray characters leaning way too much to the dark side if you ask me.
ObergruppenfĆ¼hrer is still my new favorite word to say
>>
>>62982818
nah industrial chemicals to support german engineering
>>
>>62982715
>assuming I can read moonrunes

Anon, please.
>>
Heydrich gives Smith a chance to join him, but he was behind the ambush on Smith. Did he want him dead or not?
>>
spreche kein deutsch. what does obergruppenfuhrer mean and how high a rank is that? what about oberstgruppenfuhrer?
>>
>>62982882
I think he wanted him dead at first but was sufficiently impressed by Smith's tenacity that he decided to make him an offer after all.
>>
>>62982648
I think Smith has a little more depth to him than the average Bond villain. See >>62977051

And for all he talks about how emotion cannot stand in the way of duty (and hence he has Rudolf arrested) he still can't accept that he has to euthanize his son.

I'm not sure whether the writers intended Joe to be Smith's bastard son or not. The groundwork for such a plot reveal is there, but the trigger was never pulled.
>>
ONE NATION, UNDER RULE

LIBERTY AND JUSTICE... FOR NONE!
>>
>Smith uses Joe's girlfriend and her son as leverage
>Heydrich uses Wegener's family

For once I wish a character would just say fuck it, kill my family, I don't care.
>>
File: colombian nazi weed pope.jpg (203 KB, 800x800) Image search: [Google]
colombian nazi weed pope.jpg
203 KB, 800x800
>>62982943

They are SS ranks

Obergruppenfuhrer < Oberst-GruppenfĆ¼hrer < ReichsfĆ¼hrer-SS

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Obergruppenf%C3%BChrer
>>
>>62983115
That pledge was never in the actual show, in the end. Dunno why they used it in a trailer.
>>
>>62983150

Shock value mostly, if you don't show the Nazis as ultimately evil guys you can't reign in views for a show like this.
>>
>>62982819
>Billionaires defending the revolution
kek
>>
>>62983150
Turns out National Socialist America is a fucking paradise. Well played Amazon.
>>
>>62983143
All things considered, as portrayed in the show the German occupation of America seems to be a pretty hands-off affair, given that they have an American in charge of the secret police there, with a rank just under Himmler himself. I can't remember seeing a single German in the Nazi States until Wegener and Heydrich show up.
>>
>>62983150
It's exactly the kind of """clever""" subversion of a well-known phrase that Amazon's marketing team knows would attract legions of normie plebs

They don't need to advertise to the 4chan crowd because we're the type of people who hear that a show has the Nazis winning WWII and we'll at the very least give it a look
>>
>>62983143
>click on any of those guys
>dead before 1946

Wow, they didn't spare the SS.
>>
>>62983257
Though most high school history books avoid it, america had a BIG nazi following up until pearl harbor that had lindbergh walt disney and i believe ford as memebers. So it would not be unreasonable to have high ranking american nazis 20 years later
>>
>>62983245
>Turns out National Socialist America is a fucking paradise. Well played Amazon.
Assuming the writers aren't idiots, I'd like to think that this was the point - it is a paradise, but it's a paradise built on atrocities that drove Wegener to treason, and it's a paradise that only certain races are allowed to live in. So the question then becomes, is this paradise worth the cost? Smith fervently believes so, Wegener fervently believes otherwise.
>>
>>62983210
Why not, though? It wouldn't be a class revolution. George Washington and Thomas Jefferson were rich as fuck.

I'd also assume that the Nazis would confiscate a lot of wealth from the Americans theyre conquering.
>>
File: image.jpg (39 KB, 357x503) Image search: [Google]
image.jpg
39 KB, 357x503
>>62977190
Good if we didn't lose kurosawa an mifune the world would still be okay
>>
>>62982448
The Americans did it. American society and culture drifted so far to the right that they effectively became the Nazis, but the national collective conscience couldn't accept the evil that they had become, and this created a mass delusion that they were defeated and conquered by Nazis and had Nazism forced on them. "We want to be good people, but Hitler won't let us, you see! So we have to be Nazis!" This is the lie that the American people have created for themselves, because the truth is an alternative too horrendous to face.
>>
>>62983340
>So the question then becomes, is this paradise worth the cost?
Nobody really gives a shit about the Native Americans anymore - although there's a healthy subculture dedicated to pretending to give a shit about them.

Same goes for the Gauls or the Trojans or the Philistines or any of history's other famous runners-up.
>>
>>62983447
The genociding of the Native Americans is no longer within living memory. In comparison, in The Man in the High Castle, WW2 only ended 17 years prior, so there are still many people around who have fought in the war and have memories of personally participating in or experiencing the ethnic cleansing.
>>
>>62983500
You're right. But it also suggests that at some point it will no longer be within living memory, either.

Fuck, we're practically at that point IRL now, that's why the SIX GORILLION panic is getting louder and louder.
>>
>>62983356
They would have much more to lose than to win in a revolution.
Besides, remember that Joseph Kennedy had a reputation of anti-semitic, anti-comunist and political ambition that would have made a very good match with the Nazis.
>>
File: 1446522054741.png (274 KB, 498x532) Image search: [Google]
1446522054741.png
274 KB, 498x532
>>62976119
This book was written by a talented author in the sixties about an alternative history where the US lost WWII. If it's a meme, he started it.
>>
>>62975989

>Hurr durr Germans took over murica

>implying the bankers that funded Hitler didn't take it over anyway
>>
>>62983500
>>62983528

Remember that France embraced German occupation and started deporting jews to the camps in less than one year

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sHAwGQoAN3A
>>
>>62983972
That's because Petain was a guy who could remember the Dreyfus affair
>>
>>62984045
And he also remembered the Franco-Prussian war
In retrospective, maybe it was a bad idea to put a 90-year old man to organize the defense of the country
>>
>Juliana and Joe are shit
>Frank kinda sucks
>Smith, Kido, Tagomi are interesting
>confusing as shit plot
>good last few episodes
>aesthetic as hell title sequence

6.5/10 series
>>
>>62984708
The title sequence is the worst part of the show.

Also not carrying ending songs through the credits (though that may be to save money)
>>
>>62984432
He was hardly the most defiant man either, he was always saying they'd lost the war in WW1
>>
THE EMPIRE NEVER ENDED
>>
>>62977332
In the book, he def has parkinsons, as well as syphillis, which has kept him from public view for a very long time.
>>
>>62980401
Did you know "Edelweiss" isn't actually a folk song? It was made up for Sound of Music.

I have no idea why they're using it at the beginning of this show.
>>
>>62985389
Because it's about standing up to Nazis.
>>
>>62985389
I have no idea why they're pronouncing it as Edelweisch.
>>
Honestly, we need to have a conversation about whether black people can ever be a net benefit to society. And if not, what the hell are they still doing here? I would love to see that sort of question addressed in a show like this instead of pussy footing around the issue
>>
>>62985389
>Did you know "Edelweiss" isn't actually a folk song?
There is however a 3rd Reich era march that sounds nothing like it that sometimes gets called Edelweiss as well
>>
>>62985911
Yeah, that got really annoying. I wish they'd shtop.
>>
>>62975989
Lol that dot for CaƱon City is way out of place.
>>
>>62982803
B-but anon, cultural enrichment is literally swamping high European culture and civilization with backward third world ethnic groups to create some kind of diverse utopia
>>
>>62986018
The Nazis exterminated blacks

And Black Diner Owner is the only vaguely sensible "good" character on the show
>>
>that weeaboo meets westaboo episode
>>
>>62976119
Kill ya self ya fag
>>
>>62977379
Nobody is defending Judaism here.
>>
>>62986338
That was easily the best and most unbearable part of the show for me. That actor did a hell of a job making me despise him and I would be considered a weeb by my society.
>>
File: Img_5307_zpse4841f3d.jpg (76 KB, 800x600) Image search: [Google]
Img_5307_zpse4841f3d.jpg
76 KB, 800x600
>>62982548
I enjoy the Nazi Soldiers wearing East German strichtarn.
>>
>>62987904
This.
There is pretty much no way Childan could've been portrayed any better.
>>
>>62987904

I actually wondered before watching the show what actor they were going to give the role to.

In the novel, his characterization is HEAVILY based on the narration of his thoughts. I did not think that any actor could pull it off.

But the dude they gave it to did. He's a perfect depiction of the novel's character.

Great stuff, like the rest of the show.
>>
>>62982029

Salt flats


Salt Flats as far as the eye could see and a desert heat greater than what the worst the Sahara could pump out.
>>
>>62987904
anyone else laugh and cringe when he accused Frank of "gaijin stupidity"? The actor killed it as Childan
Thread replies: 163
Thread images: 23

banner
banner
[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Home]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
If a post contains personal/copyrighted/illegal content you can contact me at [email protected] with that post and thread number and it will be removed as soon as possible.
DMCA Content Takedown via dmca.com
All images are hosted on imgur.com, send takedown notices to them.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from them. If you need IP information for a Poster - you need to contact them. This website shows only archived content.