>implying this scene isn't perfect
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q_cwRqXBR4Q
>>62917405
HOLY SHIT THAT SCARED THE SHIT OUT OF ME!
They really shit the bed on the "Gandalf means me" speech. Whoever was giving direction McKellen there had no grasp on the intended tone of that scene.
Gandalf is mysterious and quick to anger and bursting with power, he's not a beat to shit tired old grandpa.
>>62917405
I prefer the original.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Sl7w2Z0vGpA
>>62917517
>lecturing an Oscar winning director and one of the most celebrated actors of our age how to do a scene
>>62917544
AMERICA BTFO
RUS RUS RUS RUS
>>62917612
So The Hobbit films are immune to criticism then?
The Bilbo/Thorin acorn scene was also perfect
>>62917544
>those subtitles
>>62917544
This is better than Jackson's in every way
>>62917612
>>62917517
They knew how it was supposed to be, but they thought it would be funny to take the opposite approach
Favorite scene from "The Hobbit?"
Mine's https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6VAF1YThcbc
