How would you create a monster girl setting which is not magical realm but serious?
>>45989015
Introduce monster boys.
>>45989015
By...not making it magical realm? Monstergirls have proper sexual dimorphism and are treated like monsters and not cum hungry sluts.
>>45989015
>monster girls
>not magical realm
Pick one.
>How would you create a monster girl setting which is not magical realm but serious?
>By...not making it magical realm
HOW IS THIS SO HARD TO UNDERSTAND?!
The drider wants to rip your fucking head off for daring to enter her lair to try and steal her shit, not make you her husbando.
>>45989229
Addendum: Avoid slice of life as well.
>>45989015
> what are huldra
> what are sirens
> what are amazons
> what are succubi
The fact is, history is full of smut from all cultures and walks of life. We just don't really think of them as such in the modern day. Mythology is basically the old world fapfic OP; quit worrying about how realmy your setting is and instead worry about making it interesting enough independent of the monstergirls to be enjoyable.
>>45989229
Make them horrifying, not hot.
They're monsters, things that are killed because they are monstrous and a threat to civilization. They cannot be reasoned with, they do not understand relationships, they despise order and reason,which is why most 4channers are infatuated with themthey hate humans, civilized races, and civilization. They're cannibals, literally depraved.
Though given that you're using the term 'monster girl', you're already too far gone.
>>45989015
>>45989062
Monstergirls who have have sex and reproduce with human are not the problem anon. People are the problem. They think to much about sex to not make it a magical realm. It's all in their head.
>>45989053
Take your rape fetish somewhere else.
>>45989327
This should have been addressed to OP, because I agree with the post it's pointed to.
Just go Kamen Rider.
The hero keeps killing evil monsters, and the dads get a semi for monsterchicks.This picture isn't really related, I just like it.
>>45989229
>The drider wants to rip your fucking head off
You say it like that's not already deep into my magical realm.
>>45989408
>because I agree with the post it's pointed to.
Thanks, anon. My first friend on 4chan.
Pokegirls and cut out the sex and the threshold entirely.
/thread
>>45989479
I'm afraid your too far gone. Consider aiding the human race by ending yourself.
Take away the sexual dimorphism.
By making them primarily a physical threat.
>>45989572
So the monster boys also look like girls?
>>45989015
You can't. This monster girl shit is already inherently fetishy. I would be surprised if I ever read a monster girl setting that didn't have obvious skeev.
>>45989515
what now?
>>45989539
>aiding the human race
>implying I'm not the future
Just wait and you'll see as medical breakthroughs make vore seem vanilla to most people in a few decades.
>>45989625
Why wouldn't they, anon?
>>45989648
Maybe a few centuries.
>>45989515
>you're*
>>45989015
If it isn't sexual, the term monster girl would probably no longer apply. At least not around here.
You'd just have beast folk or intelligent monstrous races.
"Monster Girl" would only apply if you have female-only races that look explicitly femine to humans, and then you're already doing it wrong. Sucks for stuff like bee people, but as a creator you need to consider your audience.
>>45989015
Wouldn't, famalam.
>>45989015
Humans use a poison to exterminate the monsters. For unknown reasons, it only kills the male monsters. In revenge they attack en masse the humans.
>>45989699
We're trying to make it less magical realm.
>>45989361
>tfw no shitposting waifu who mocks you for only knowing about pop science
>>45990068
>tons of females
>no males except human males
They would just attack us and go into heat during the attack and then a massive orgy would happen like my magical realm desires.
>>45990208
>>45989015
Holy shit I like those redesigns.
>>45989015
make them creepy science abominations of spliced DNA. I can think of three main scenarios already-- created to survive in a hostile environment, to pave the way for future human settlement or as shock troops against a tricky opponent.
>>45991023
seriously. I wanna know who the artist is.
Pssshhsaw
>Disgaea setting
>worlds collide Mortal Kombat style
>generic fantasy except monsters are actual races, sexual dimorphism is a thing because because that's how ye oldie stories actually went. Males are straightforward and don't need no beauty, females are fucking harpies and succubis in nature
Fuck, I did every one of those and more and no one gave a fuck, just don't put a blatant fanservice and waifuism into your game like It's a fucking quest thread, shit.
My games had all sorts of shit that would be considered "magical realm as fuck", and through all the people I used to play with, ultimetally no one really cared. Just don't be obnoxious with your shit. This applies to fucking anything. In the end, everyone just want to play a game about adventure people doing adventure shit
>>45989015
Not!Greek mythos meets grimdark fantasy
Basically make them ugly as hell, perhaps make them coming out of hell
>>45989015
You can't monstergirls are inherently fetish. If they aren't fetishistic, then they aren't monstergirls.
>>45989015
No polygamy allowed.
>>45989015
You don't, because the whole concept of monster girls is fetish wank in the first place.
Rather, introduce monstrous RACES. You know, like the normal races in D&D? If you're going with a female-only race that can only live on male semen, you're doing it wrong.
There's something inherently pathetic about the concept, that you're so thirsty you NEED a race that's all about fucking men to get laid. Seriously, it's a bad idea. (The alternative is that they're so afraid of competition that male monsters scare them...Because MALE MONSTERS MIGHT FUCK OUR WAIFUS!)
I had a race of Arachne in one of my dungeons. There were male and female ones and the royal family had a mix of male and female rulers. Give them some character besides just fucking every male that nears them.
>>45994678
While I think that's mostly the case now it came about as a justification for monsters attacking adventurers in the form of female on male rape but that was straight up porn not stuff for a setting. Also bear in mind many monstergirl stuff has male monsters. They just sexualize and give the females a lot of dimorphism.
>>45989015
Not call it a monster girl setting.
>>45994678
>Because MALE MONSTERS MIGHT FUCK OUR WAIFUS!
To be fair, male monsters are even more hideously pornified than female ones.
Footlong Minotaur dick porn is generally way more graphic and fucked up than say, Snakepussy.
That's one sexy Elise
>>45989229
>The drider wants to rip your fucking head off for daring to enter her lair to try and steal her shit,
But the only thing I wanted to steal is her heart
>>45996537
she shat her heart out long ago...
>>45989361
>Monstergirls who have have sex and reproduce with human are not the problem anon.
Yes they are. They're dumb and make no goddamn sense
>why are monstergirls in my setting?
If the honest answer is because they're your fetish, there's no stopping it from being magical realm.
>>45995632
That is about as magical realm as you can get.I like the cut of your jib, kid. Have a good evening.
>>45989015
Just use science to explain what would otherwise be considered magic.
Monstergirls are an inherently fetishistic concept, you just have to come to terms with that. Otherwise you end up with your head up your own ass like all the people in this thread thinking they're clever with "add monsterboys" and "make them ACTUALLY monstrous", without even realizing that's just normal fantasy and they didn't invent anything new at all.
>>45995632
How lewd!
>>45996622
>they are a problem because I thought too much about the sex and don't think it makes sense
you're sort of proving him right
>>45989318
This.
Anyone complaining about fapbait while being anywhere NEAR fantasy is just a massive hypocrite, since they are playing with yesterday's fapbait regardless of what they choose.
>>45996910
normal fantasy is inherently fetishistic, anon.
>>45989015
Girls are demonic succubi out for each other's blood and to prove themselves worthy after the Queen of the Succubi mysteriously disappeared. The other levels of Hell and even Heaven are jostling to help put their favored candidate on the Throne.
>>45989015
They are A: An alien race who can breed with anything and just chose you. B: Genetically engineered by humans for humans
>>45996814
>Dare you enter my Scientific Laboratory?
>>45989015
A species looses its male members to plague, magic, whatever. The remaining females craft a spell to make sure that -
1 - They can breed with other races
2 - The offspring favor the mother's species, and only inherits a few minor, mostly cosmetic traits from the father's species.
They hope this means that their race will eventually recover, but a flaw in the spell means that only female children ever result from these magically-permitted unions. Over time, everyone comes to think of them as an all-female species with lots of little variations.
>>45997383
That's my magical realm.Especially, if you replaced succubi with monstergirl
>>45989015
I would make a monster race that is primarily or only female, and simply refrain from introducing sexuality to it.
>>45989015
1. THE MONSTER GIRLS ARE ACTUALLY MONSTERS, IE HORRIFIC AND DISGUSTING
2. THEY 'BREED' BY EATING HUMANS AND BREAKING DOWN THEIR GENETIC MATERIAL IN THEIR STOMACHS TO PRODUCE THE NECESSARY SLURRY TO IMPREGNATE THEIR EGGS, WHICH THEY LAY IN THE CORPSE OF THEIR HALF EATEN 'HUSBAND'
3. YOU LET ANY VORE FAGS WHO GET OFF ON THIS GET EATEN IN SESSION 1, MAKING THEM HAPPY AND GETTING THEIR SHIT OUT OF THE GAME
>>45998174
>monstergirls are only okay when they are my fetish
I see
>>45996599
Then we shall find it together!
>>45997212
Mote of from a biological point of view, which I guess includes sex since we're referring to reproduction, so you're -technically- correct I guess.
>>45997567
YES
Subject: how to make monstergirl reproduce with human
Solution-1
>monster phenotype does are transmitted in the cytoplasm, but are suppressed in presence of Y chromosome.
>MG give birth to MG and human boys.
It's a simple system that works, but it does not allows monstergirls to give birth to human daughters.
Solution-2
>Monster phenotype is determined by the condition in the ovary.
>MG's two ovaries has different "environment".
>Ovary-1 egg has no monster traits
>Ovary-2 egg carry (or activate) monster traits in cytoplasm.
>Fertilized eggs from Ovary-1 results in human girl/boys
>Fertillized eggs from Ovary-2 results in monsters girl/boys. But monster traits+ Y-chromosome results in dead embryo there are only monstergirls.
>25% boy, 25% girl, 25% monstergirl, 25% monsterboy(always dead)
>>45998468
I strive to be technically correct, the best kind of correct.
>>45991668
Filename you retard
>>45989015
Depends... is it still Magical Realm if it's only fear boners?
>>45997567
I demand an edit now.
>>45989015
Make them behave like monsters instead of whores.
Done.
As an aside, monster girls don't really fit for me, because even if they behave like monsters they can never be as intimidating as a fully inhuman monster.
They have semi-familiar body shapes, most of them have expressive human or humanlike faces. These traits do not lend themselves to an effective and intimidating monster.
>>45989327
[Spoiler]horrifying monster girls are hot though[/spoiler]
>>45989015
This has been discussed a lot and every thread produces the same answers.
1. Only use 'monstergirls' taken from actual mythology. People are less likely to make the fetish connection if it has it's roots in well established cultural patterns.
2. Make them properly monstrous so that most people would no longer find them sexually attractive (arguably this just makes it a much more niche magical realm while getting rid of a lot of their appeal).
3. Introduce monsterbois, and generally flesh them out like you would any other race in a fantasy setting.
4. Some combination of the above.
5. Don't care what people think and use your natural charisma to convince them to take your fetish fuel seriously.
>>45999197
This image makes me realize there is an appalling small quantity of best girl smut on the web.
>>45994678
Yes, because mile-long monstercocks that are as thick as a tree are much better.
>>45989015
Make then sexually incompatible. Even if the spider lady wouldn't tear your dick off, what's the point of there's no orifice it can safely go in?
Though I guess then you wouldn't can them monster girls now would you?
>>45989361
>tfw you'll never rape a big orc
>you'll never slide your human meat between his taut orc buttocks
>>46005326
What do you mean? Miia has tonnes of smut online.
>>46006083
>wanting to rape a big orc
You disgusting filth.Go consensual or go home.
>>46006129
What if it's consensual play-rape?
And then you cuddle afterwards to calm down?
>>45989015
> How would you create a monster girl setting which is not magical realm but serious?
Make monstergirls actually monstrous and lacking core humanoid features, such as face, primary and secondary sexual organs, replacing them with monstrous analogues.
>>45991023
Agreed, I remeber Zyra and Elise both being hyped up as monster champions, something that league has had a severe lack of compared to DotA. Imagine my suprise when they where just sexy looking humans with mindset bits tacked on. to be fair they where both designed by the same guy so he's more at fault then the game itself, but honestly how hard would have been for something like OPs image
>>46005626
Sounds like a case of sexual jealousy to me.
But really, if guys can get slutty monstergirl waifus, there should be horrible woman-raping monsters too. You'll be amazed by how much women love that.
>>46007192
There already are, by the truckload.
>>45989015
>>45989062
You can keep the sexual demorphism if you recognize the sexuality of the monsters as a perversion of beauty, a haunting bridge between beautiful familiarity and the terrible.
I mean, if you are into that sort of thing, there's nothing I can do for you, but it's the right way to do it.
I would also refrain from using the term monster girls.
>>46007192
Why not make them one and the same?
>>45989229
>The drider wants to rip your fucking head off for daring to enter her lair to try and steal her shit, not make you her husbando.
Sounds like a really shitty setting.
>>45989179
Pretty much this. They aren't monster people, they are monster girls, the whole point is giving attractive females interesting traits from monsters for individual kinks or fetishes. Now a setting that is full of sentient beasts could certainly be interesting but they should be monsters first. A female minotaur should look monstrous, not a big titted woman with cow hooves instead of feet and a human head. Likewise males should exist for the species unless the monsters were monogendered in the actual mythology in which case it could go either way.
Regardless the question itself is wrong you shouldn't look at something that sexually arouses you and ask how you can make it a serious and non-magical realm setting. If you want to run an ERPG go ahead and do it, but don't try to sneak magical realm into your game under the guise of seriousness.
>>45989015
Unrelated, but that Elise actually looks pretty badass.
Sort of loses the idea where she lures people into joining Vilemaw's cult, but eh.
>>46007192
>there should be horrible woman-raping monsters too. You'll be amazed by how much women love that.
No I wouldn't.
>>45989015
>which is not magical realm
>but serious?
Can't it be magical realm AND serious?
Monstergirl society is full of legends of human men who seduced monstergirls, only to enslave them.
All these stories about selkies being mutilated with fire and lamias having their tails nailed to the floor and harpies ending up in golden cages makes any kind of relationship with humans, let alone romantic ones, tense.