[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Home]
4chanarchives logo
Is it even possible to make drow interesting?
Images are sometimes not shown due to bandwidth/network limitations. Refreshing the page usually helps.

You are currently reading a thread in /tg/ - Traditional Games

Thread replies: 110
Thread images: 22
File: 1452725700690.jpg (94 KB, 751x1063) Image search: [Google]
1452725700690.jpg
94 KB, 751x1063
Is it even possible to make drow interesting?
>>
>>44890371
Yes.
>>
Yes, with minimal effort.
>>
>>44890371
Dunmer.
>>
File: 1451799198560.png (509 KB, 1332x3858) Image search: [Google]
1451799198560.png
509 KB, 1332x3858
>>44890371
>>
>>44890437
>Elder scrolls having anything good

Laughable.

If you want interesting drow, just model them as closely to the Melniboneans as possible.
>>
File: ALTlsG3.jpg (209 KB, 600x450) Image search: [Google]
ALTlsG3.jpg
209 KB, 600x450
>>44890371
Impossible
>>
>>44890371
Yes. Steal inspiration from this:
http://wiki.alternatehistory.com/doku.php/timelines/green_antarctica
>>
Make them Russian
>>
Shadow Elves.
>>
>>44890371
Yes, you S'Wit
>>
>>44890467
>this anon was smothered by moths in his sleep
Good night Skyrim Baby.
>>
>>44890371
My overall beef with Drow is that while the Underdark is a cruel and borderline inhospitable place, the Drow themselves don't seem to put much of a premium on the lives of their own race. I get that they're evil but honestly that 'evil' should be far more focused on other races than on trying to murderise each other.
>>
Melniboneans and/or Dunmer. Next.
>>
>>44890371
If you have to ask, then no. You obviously have no interest in them to start with, so nothing we could say will change that.
>>
>>44890442
/thread
>>
File: 1453011682822.png (814 KB, 600x849) Image search: [Google]
1453011682822.png
814 KB, 600x849
>>44890371
Make them brown instead of black.
>>
>>44890371
>Implying black femdom spider elves aren't interesting
>>
>>44893657
Oh god, what's wrong with your legs???
>>
>>44895140
E L V E N F L E X I B I L I T Y
>>
File: is this bait.png (27 KB, 527x409) Image search: [Google]
is this bait.png
27 KB, 527x409
>>44890467
>>
>>44892401
We mostly see the nobles and the priesthood, two classes closest to Lol and two classes traditionally completely removed from the lives of their subjects. Drow peasants or footsoldiers probably can't afford to be retarded chucklefucks. They have to take care of each other and their kids instead of just stabbing every back they see for short-term benefit or divine favor of a crazy evil demon bitch who gets off on treason.
>>
>>44890371
Yes.

>>44890442
This, however, is starting to get old.
>>
>>44893657
Oda non needs to draw more.
>>
File: lloth_throne.jpg (37 KB, 341x479) Image search: [Google]
lloth_throne.jpg
37 KB, 341x479
Drow need to graduate from the edgy the edgehog persona into a new perspective. Yao and her clan in GATE is an example of this.

but not go full retard like the main character in Drowtales
>>
>>44890371
No.
>>
>>44896381
>Oda Non needs to draw more than one girl and scenario
Ftfy.
>>
>>44896482
>GATE
>drowtales
Or how about not?
How about merchant drow? They can't create societies above ground, but they can build buildings which the sun doesn't shine into. The huge differences in climate and ecosystem would make for some awesomely profitable spice trade, I imagine.
>>
>>44896753
How do they restock their wares? I imagine surface races wouldn't frequent the shops if they were too close to Underdark entrances.
>>
>>44890371
>is it even possible to make drows interesting?

yes, if you know how to fucking right a campaign you faggot.
>>
>>44890371
Drows could only be interesting if the players were all really into femdom.
>>
>>44896875
Caravans, exchange around the entrance/exit, abovegrounders caravan it to nearest port. A dangerous business, for sure, because anyone in the Underdark or aboveground would love to lay their hands on those caravans.
>>
File: FrpzE4f.jpg (22 KB, 480x600) Image search: [Google]
FrpzE4f.jpg
22 KB, 480x600
>>44890467
>>
>>44890437
But Dunmer is so completely different from Drow it's basically like saying, that Drows can be neat as long as you play them like a gnome. Kinda pointles.
>>
>>44897066
Adventure hook:
Party stumbled upon a group of Drow haggling over trade goods at a previously unknown Underdark entrance on the night of a new moon.
>>
>>44897400
And perhaps these Drow are members of a certain house or faction which is looking to move away from the tenets of Lolth and gain further power through less regulated trade (as Lolth only permits a certain level of trade due to the whole "drow stronk womyn who needs nobody else")?
>>
>>44896943
So about 60% of /tg/?
>>
>>44897264
>worship a spider god
>ashen skin
>sanctioned, holy murder
>women are promiscuous and evil
>cloak and dagger house politics
>racist
>hate and enslave foreigners

Seem about right to me desu senpai
>>
File: Drow Autism.png (70 KB, 946x343) Image search: [Google]
Drow Autism.png
70 KB, 946x343
>>44890371
Stop trying to legitimize them.
>>
Make them Dark Elves, not Drow. Dark Elves are the "dark" reflection of other elves like the High Elves but not evil. More really fashionable Addams Family than BDSM club demon worshippers.
>>
>>44900723
That's one way to make them not villains.
>>
>>44900586
This is my favorite version of the drow. Their goddess is insane. Their society exists only because Lolth makes it exists. She is overwhelmingly the most active of all the deities in the pantheon, but all that effort is expended into making drow dance and suffer and die solely for her amusement.

The Underdark isn't some Soviet Slavic nation. It's North Korea.
>>
>>44890371
They're not-very-nice Elves that have their own sophisticated and advanced, but not-very-nice society. Not only is it possible to make them interesting, it shouldn't even be hard.
>>
>>44890371
>is it even possible to make shitposting interesting?
>>
>>44901104
Take this for instance, Drow society is basically a slightly muted Commoragh. It's so nasty that it should be actively hostile to its inhabitants, Drow society should have collapsed, but it hasn't because there is one incredibly powerful fucker in charge who keeps the whole sorry mess limping along because they find it amusing to do so.

My current Drow has an Eastern European accent because I like the idea of them having a weird accent and I found the concept funny, but they're more like people escaping from North Korea or a Moonie style cult; they should be fucked up beyond belief and shocked to the core when they finally realise how insane their idea of normal really is.
>>
>>44897976
More like 85%
>>
>>44901617
Was actually thinking more like 90% but didn't want to overshoot it and wasn't sure if it was a case of people who dislike femdom being very loud or not
>>
>>44902040
Feels good to be the 10%.
>>
>>44890371
Easy as shit. Just ditch the Underdark and Lloth or Lolth or whatever the fuck the spider goddess is called. None of that shit is drow, that shit is Forgotten Realms.

The core of drow is 'dark or black skinned elves' That's it.

Eberron drow - jungle fighters par excellence with a thing for scorpions and jungle poisons.

Eastern European drow - as per >>44890442 work as a comedic twist on FR drow.

You can do drow as simply nocturnal elves. They live in the same communities, doing the same things, but they have diametrically opposed sleep schedules.

Drow as traders, using underdark tunnels or shadow planar portals for trade that can't be interrupted by simple bandits.

Basically, once you uncouple 'dark elves' from all the other horseshit that people associate with drow because of Forgotten Realms, you can do plenty with the concept. But if you're locked into drow that worship a spider-butt goddess, backstab each other all the time, and live underground, then your ability to make them interesting is limited because we already know all about those drow.
>>
>>44901104
>The Underdark isn't some Soviet Slavic nation. It's North Korea.
It's not even North Korea. North Korea is a shittily run country, but even their leaders don't actively dick around with their people on the same level. The relationship with Lolth and the Drow is more like you playing Sims to dick around with virtual people by deleting their bathrooms or making them drown in the swimming pool.
>>
>>44903995
Drow kind of are a FR thing. Sure, Eberron has very different Drow, but Eberron goes out of its way to make all races different from the norm (Halflings are dinosaur-riding barbarians, Elves are not-Mongols, Orcs are what Elves are in most settings; against that backdrop Drow being jungle-dwelling scorpion-worshippers instead of underground-dwelling spider-worshippers is pretty normal). I don't think other DnD settings even have Drow (except 4th edition's "points of light" setting, where they were practically same as FR Drow).

In my homebrew setting I did actually completely redo the Drow because I don't like the way they're done in FR, but eventually noticed they had nothing in common with what people associate with Drow other than being evil Elves and having a society centered around worship of gods that other races would consider evil. So I decided there's no real point to keep calling the Drow, and decided to drop all connection with the Drow (including making them look more like Dunmer, with grayish skin instead of the black skin and white hair look). They still get called "Dark Elves" in-setting due to being the evil counterpart of Elves, though.
>>
I like to have Drow Elf Society backwards, rather than evil.
Drow Elf Society is a strange mix between Magic being a High Priority and a side Project. Most Drow practice some kind of Magic alongside a their Profession, whether or not it would be helpful to their career, just whats interesting to them. Fungoll? That Fisherman you buy your Bloatfin from? Master Cryomancer. Gwerten Mill? The lowly Servant in Castle Dread? He teaches Pocket Dimension Making on Thursdays. They Honor Pure Warriors, feeling the're superior for resisting the temptation of Magic. Hell, Most Guards in Drow Societies are Spellswords or Mages in Shoulder plates.
>>
>>44890371
Is it ever possible for OP to not be a faggot?

Some things are meant to stay mysterious.
>>
File: stop your fetish.png (38 KB, 351x242) Image search: [Google]
stop your fetish.png
38 KB, 351x242
>>44893657
>>
>>44890371
I played drow in a civ game, I think they were pretty interesting.

Here's some of the things I did that were unusual:

Drow don't so much worship a spider goddess as that spiders are really important in their religion. Giant domesticated spiders were to Drow what cows are to Hindus - the primary source of wealth and valued above their caretakers in a lot of respects.

They were hardline libertarian capitalists, every adult member of the society had the powers of a central bank and could print as much drow currency as they wanted. The drow currency was called the slave hour, and was backed by, as you might guess, one hour of slave labour. It could be redeemed at any time.

They lived in a coastal area, were really into night surfing and fishing, and were kind of annoying but endearing traders that always threw the best orgies.
>>
>>44906344
Nothing fetishy about brown girls anon
>>
Do Drow like they're Deldar, brah. The Drow are evil because it's fun and they're all fucked in the head. The Spider bitch doesn't really exist, and neither does the matriarchy, it's just a popular fetish in their society.
>>
>>44906268
This made me laugh out loud at work
>>
>>44890371
I once played a lowborn Drow male in a game. He was a common soldier who cut and ran when had the chance. He was just happy to be away from the backstabby bitches of the Underdark, even if the sun was too bright and the food was weird. No angst or speshul snowflake about him. Fun times were had.
>>
File: right.jpg (4 KB, 318x159) Image search: [Google]
right.jpg
4 KB, 318x159
>>44896918
>yes, if you know how to fucking right a campaign you faggot.
>>
File: virgin dark elves.jpg (128 KB, 885x641) Image search: [Google]
virgin dark elves.jpg
128 KB, 885x641
>>44890371
>>
File: yes.gif (2 MB, 235x240) Image search: [Google]
yes.gif
2 MB, 235x240
>>44907978
>and were kind of annoying but endearing traders that always threw the best orgies.
>>
>>44899891
>and others
>dunmer are grey instead of black, have red eyes and don't have white hair
>murder for the greater good instead of the lols
>non-matriachal, no bdsm in sight
>true
>everyone in the setting is
>setting is full of that
on top of all that their history, homeland, fashion, style, religion, names, and just about everything else is different.
>>
>>44903995
>None of that shit is drow, that shit is Forgotten Realms.

Uh, point of order, Lolth predates the Realms. She was created by Gary Gygax for Greyhawk (and is a part of Greyhawk) and first premiered in 1978; the Realms wasn't published until 1987.

Everything about the drow in the Realms is just based off of their appearance in Greyhawk. It's just that the Realms are overwhelmingly more popular than Greyhawk.
>>
>>44904577
Again, drow as we know them originate in Greyhawk and premiered more than ten years before the Realms were published. The Realms just made them vastly more popular, because the Realms themselves are vastly more popular than Greyhawk.
>>
File: 1418584401526.jpg (411 KB, 849x1200) Image search: [Google]
1418584401526.jpg
411 KB, 849x1200
>>44890371
yes and/or duh
>>
>>44914004
she's not a drow though
>>
>>44914004
Post more "interesting" drow
>>
File: 1415928473761.jpg (109 KB, 675x900) Image search: [Google]
1415928473761.jpg
109 KB, 675x900
>>44914043
That is how you make them interseting: NPC only race of right proper elves

Maybe have them train humans to do their dirty work (and sometimes have them purposefully orphan human children)
>>
>>44914097
>NPC only

Ugh.
>>
File: you.jpg (10 KB, 300x168) Image search: [Google]
you.jpg
10 KB, 300x168
>>44890467
>>
File: 1435045825231.jpg (417 KB, 600x3254) Image search: [Google]
1435045825231.jpg
417 KB, 600x3254
>>44890371
Okay so here's what you do. First, remove male dark elves, their society is all female. Male slaves of other races are acceptable, but kept on close watch for reasons below.

Second, introduce Love. Dark elves bond in pairs that are utterly and completely devoted to each other, body and soul. Such pairs will shamelessly display their status in public by holding hands wherever they go and any challenger will find that they fight as if they were two bodies of a single mind. Even more, the individuals themselves appear to be strengthened dependent on the strength of the bond, encouraging dark elves both to seek Love but also to be very picky.

Third, reproduction. Dark elf pairs replenish their numbers by kidnapping virgin surface elves and adopting them as their daughters. Only paired elves are capable of amassing the amount of Love needed to fully convert their surface kin, but once the process is complete the bond between daughter and mothers will be almost as strong as the pairing.

Fourth, vulnerability. Dark elves must remain completely pure. Direct contact with any male poses the risk of "whitening", the process in which a dark elf is converted into a surface elf, forever, losing her strength and Love. This is also why only virgin surface elves can be converted to dark elves.

The most hated enemy of the dark elves is of course the winged, all-male sky elves, but due to the natures of both races, they're restricted to a cold war fought through proxies, for fear of mutually assured destruction.
>>
>>44890442
This is amazing.
>>44890371
Tasty chocolate Elves.
>>
>>44890442
Borat Drow is best Drow.
Also best Borat.
>>
>>44890371
They're already interesting, faggot.
>but I want to be different from DnD cause reasons
Fuck off.
>>
How about a campaign where a bunch of evil drow sets out to murderfuck all the mary sues like drizzt?
>>
>>44911909
Looking for that promotion, anon?
>>
>>44890371
Yes, what the Elder Scrolls did to them.
>>
>>44897264
Not really, the setting from ES was originally a D&D setting. The Dunmer being a way to play Drow without being terrible. So they're no different then how the other races vary from setting to setting (see everything Dark Sun, Dragon Lance, Forgotten Realms etc.)
>>
>>44912682
No different then how Drow vary across D&D settings (well, Elves in general) also slight nit picking but they don't necessarily murder for a greater good. Trust me there's a game where you can end up doing the opposite (with houses Telvani or Hlaalu).
>>
>>44902074
This. Femdom is worst fetish.
>>
>>44917076
>they don't necessarily murder for a greater good
The ones who do the sanctioned, holy murders do. Shady cloak and dagger political intrigue =/= sanctioned, holy murder.
>>
File: 1374504932890.jpg (262 KB, 528x528) Image search: [Google]
1374504932890.jpg
262 KB, 528x528
>>44890467
>>
>>44911591
I feel like brown would just make them elves from warm climates or something.

Gotta be pitch black or some degree of blue or purple with white hair to sell it to me.
>>
>>44912682
>non-matriachal, no bdsm in sight

Actually, the biggest leader of their country and the most loved of the Tribunal was Almalexia.
And before that, their biggest gods, the 3 Daedra, were all represented as females.
The Drow have gods beyond Lolth too, they just are of lessar importance. The most important one for the Dunmer is the god of backstabbing treason, but closely followed is the sex-murder-spider god
>>
>>44915008
Damn, that shit is just asking for a player party to go to war and wipe their dumb race out.
>>
>>44915008

...what.
>>
>>44917194

Um. Were we doing different quests for the Morag Tong? They were political assassinations, through and through. There was nothing 'holy' or 'good' about it. They're more well organized, more methodical, more efficient and frankly just better in every way than that frothing-at-the-mouth, edgelord, deviantart-tier Dark Brotherhood, but they're still a bunch of assassins.
>>
>>44917205
>A human who doesn't know a thing about CHIM

I thought only Vivec knew anything about Chim.
>>
>>44917273

I'm pretty sure Azura was/is their most important Daedric Prince; Boethiah is great, but I'd hardly call her 'most important'.
>>
>>44892379
>>44895200
>>44897212
>>44914564
>>44917205

>Scrollfags confirmed for butthurt memesters

Why don't you go get yourselves kicked out of /vg/ again?
>>
>>44917647

Sotha Sil and Almalexia both had a solid grasp on it (as solid as any mental grasp the Tribunal had, really), but Vivec was the one who contemplated it the most and who understood it best. It's pretty easily arguable that Sotha understood and just didn't care because he was a freaky robosexual and that Almalexia just loved being venerated too much, but who knows! They're all 'dead' now anyways, right?

I wonder what Vivec got up to, honestly. Those seem like they'd be great stories.
>>
File: old_boethiah.jpg (23 KB, 320x200) Image search: [Google]
old_boethiah.jpg
23 KB, 320x200
>>44917653
No. Azura was the most important in the game Morrowind, and the favoured Daedra of Nerevar. But don't let that fool you, Boethiah was by far their main deity. It was Boethiah that inspired Veloth to gather the Chimer on their pilgrimage, it was Boethiah that fought Trinimac so that they might go, it is Boethiah that they give credit for all their development according to the books in the game.
An excerpt from Varieties of Faith:
>Heralded by the Prophet Veloth, Boethiah is the original god-ancestor of the Dark Elves. Through his illuminations, the eventual 'Chimer', or Changed Folk, renounced all ties to the Aldmer and founded a new nation based on Daedric principles. All manner of Dark Elven cultural 'advances' are attributed to Boethiah, from philosophy to magic to 'responsible' architecture. Ancient Velothi allegories are uniformly heroic successes of Boethiah over enemies of every type, foundation stories of Chimeri struggle.
The order of importance for the Dunmer people was Boethiah, Mephala and finally Azura. Azura is important in the Morrowind game story, but as far as their myths go she isn't so great. Some of her stuff even gets credit given to Boethiah:
>Azura was the god-ancestor that taught the Chimer the mysteries needed to be different than the Altmer. Some of her more conventional teachings are sometimes attributed to Boethiah. In the stories, Azura is often more a communal cosmic force for the race as a whole than an ancestor or a god.
>>
>>44917702
Freaky sex stuff mostly, I imagine.
>>
>>44890371
They are already intersting enough for me.
Learned about them in 2001 and liked them since that time.
>>
>>44917273
Almalexia being the most popular of the Tribunal doesn't really make the Dunmer matriarchal, or have anything to do with Femdom.
And of the three Anticipations/Good Daedra, only Azura is portrayed consistently as female. Boethiah is actually more commonly portrayed as male (although is occasionally portrayed as female as well) and Mephala is more commonly portrayed as hermaphroditic or unknown gender (Mephala keeps their sphere hidden from mortals and rarely manifsts to anybody directly). The genders of the Tribunal mirror their Anticipations: Almalexia's Anticipation is Boethiah and she's female to his male, Sotha Sils's Anticipation is Azura and he's male to her female, and Vivec's Anticipation is Mephala and he's also a hermaphrodite (sometimes; he changed his gender on a whim, appearring as a man, a woman or something in between).
>>
File: 1439842573803.jpg (2 MB, 938x1250) Image search: [Google]
1439842573803.jpg
2 MB, 938x1250
>>44917702
Vivec is the only one of the three who had the correct mindset to truly achieve CHIM, though the others were probably aware of it on some level due to their divin powers.
The key to achieving CHIM according to Vivec is love. More specifically, you must love yourself and love the world as you love yourself. This is because to achieve CHIM you must be aware that everything that exists is part of a single vast pattern that is the Godhead's dream, while at the same time not loosing your sense of self and zero-summing yourself out of existence.
Almalexia loved herself but had little love for the world, and thus would not have been able to achieve CHIM, and probably was only dimly aware of the nature of the Dream.
Sother Sil loved the world (in the way of a scientist: he loved experimenting, studying and exploring how it works). He probably was aware of CHIM on an academic level, but had no interest in achieving it, as escaping from the Dream was never his goal, and likely would not have been able to achieve it anyway as he largely neglected himself in favour of his studies. I do believe he likely achieved immortality of a different kind, though, and still lives on in his creations.

Meanwhile, Dagoth Ur achieved some form of bizarred reverse-CHIM where he became convinced that everything in existence is part of his dream, and attempted to take over the world with the power of agressive solipsism.
>>
In my campaign i just made them underground elves who come from not-Persia/India. They are more chaotic than evil, but dabble too much with infernalism.
>>
File: Q9IvG.jpg (71 KB, 500x594) Image search: [Google]
Q9IvG.jpg
71 KB, 500x594
>>44890437
>Dun and Dunmer
>>
Currently playing a half-drow archer scout in a setting with olympian gods, playing her like an over zealous follower or Artemis bordering the fanatical feminism, so far my group likes it.
>>
>>44916375
Lolth would fully encourage them doing so, whip them into a murder frenzy, send them out in the world, and then at the least convenient time suddenly switch off all their magic for 5 seconds.

Then when this causes failure she'd blame the drow matriarchs and punish them except for one, who didn't do much other than happen to be slightly further away when the power was switched off and so had a chance to hide rather than get killed and then make her getaway. That one would become her new high priestess.

DROW ARE INSANE. LOLTH IS INSANE.
>>
No one plays an Honest To God drow anymore. Everyone is trying to make them unique or special in some way.

So just play a real drow. Try to make their actions seem like a real drow's. Don't try to make him/her a special snowflake of a drow, just play it as it should be.
>>
>>44890371
My current DM has them as moon worshipping, mask wearing true Koreans.
>>
>>44890371
You can make anything interesting.
Though threads on drow are always fun due to their ability to expose the fact that most people who post about them also only know the memes instead of any actual lore.
>>
File: requiem_2.jpg (433 KB, 1280x956) Image search: [Google]
requiem_2.jpg
433 KB, 1280x956
>>44915008
I would want my paladin to fall and become a blackguard so I could kill this entire fucking race now, thanks anon.
>>
>>44915008
That's stupid, and I'm normally okay with blatant fetish bait
>>
>>44890371
Yes, make them murderous fapbait
>>
>>44924078
but that's what they are already
>>
>>44890371

just make them like dark elfs where used to be.

dorfs.
>>
>>44926014
Yes and?
Thread replies: 110
Thread images: 22

banner
banner
[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Home]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
If a post contains personal/copyrighted/illegal content you can contact me at [email protected] with that post and thread number and it will be removed as soon as possible.
DMCA Content Takedown via dmca.com
All images are hosted on imgur.com, send takedown notices to them.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from them. If you need IP information for a Poster - you need to contact them. This website shows only archived content.