ungeons & Dragons 5th edition general thread.
>Previous thread:
>>42142559
>Core rulebooks, adventure modules, Unearthed Arcana
https://mega.co.nz/#F!5JsxCBKT!f6DaTrp19uTPrWuZyabZAQ
>Pastebin with homebrew list, resources and so on:
http://pastebin.com/X1TFNxck
Bad guy appreciation thread. Who's your favorite?
>>44603797
Displacer beasts are neat
>>44603797
Non standard constructs. Threw a calzone golem at my players once.
>>44603797
Hobgoblins, easily
>>44603797
>Who's your favorite?
They're in the name, Anon.
>>44603649
The blade swung: the thrum of divine power crackling along its length was interrupted only by the splitting of bone and a horrific, hissing screech as the black dragon's head was severed.
The beast's heavy body thudded to the temple floor, caustic spume and bile spilling out to eat at the ancient stones. The head rolled a short distance across the floor, coming to rest at the paladin's feet.
As the party gathered around, and the last of the light left it's eyes, the ancient black dragon A'non breathed his final testament:
> "Whatever, fag. You're all niggers."
From last thread,
Give me eccentric shop names for my big city. Some examples of what I already have:
>When Hammers Fly Blacksmithing and Enchanting
>Manachadnezzar the Magnificent's Museum of Mechanical Marvels
>The Mind's Eye Divination Emporium
Only good one from last thread was
>Bloodbath & Beyond
>>44603921
Caustic to the end, I see
I killed my players with a manticore the other day. They're pretty neat.
>>44603797
The BBEG that my guys are fighting right now is a Gnoll shaman. They're all level 5, I made him basically a level 12 Warlock. He's not the biggest baddie in the world, but a glaive wielding, bone-shaking gnoll with a skullhat is pretty cool.
Killed a party member with that hellish rebuke. Shit's nasty.
>>44604006
I sincerely hope that you mean you killed your players' characters with a manticore the other day.
Would this work as a 5e generalist wizard?
College of Satire Bards' Tumbling Fool feature does not specify any requirement for a flat surface to tumble on. How do we fluff tumbling with your swim or fly speed?I now want to make a forever-tumbling Winged Tiefling Bard, but that'll just get me punched in the face by my DM.
>>44604142
And we thought it didn't get worse. God dammit, anon, you glorious asshole.
>>44604103
It would work, though it seems rather boring. Apart from the level 14 feature, there doesn't seem to be anything that directly benefits the wizard in combat either.
>>44604172
> prepare 2 additional spells
> learn more spells
Yeah, no combat applications there.
>>44604172
Hmm, I was thinking that increasing their versatility (spells known/spells prepared) and letting them cast lower level spells more often per day (improved arcane recovery) would help them in combat. Might make the level 6 feature something that works directly in combat though...
>>44603797
>>44603921
Anon will always be my favorite antagonist.
I love you guys.
>>44604188
No direct applications. They become more versatile, but they don't get much of anything they can directly use in combat. Even Illusionists get shit like interposing an illusion in their place to take an attack.
This archetype literally gets nothing to actively use in combat. It's like the Champion archetype, for Wizards.
>>44604103
> half a page, no formatting
> .3M
Fuck, people, learn to compress your files.
>>44604227
>nothing to actively use in combat
>It's like the Champion archetype
Anon.
So no more games for me, lfgs sucks, so I make characters now for whenever I do get a chance to play. I need something else to do, are there any good 5th ed or D&D novels?
Any ideas for "random encounters" that aren't necessarily combats?
One that I'm thinking is a man that's preparing to play the fiddle against a devil. The players then can help one of them or just watch the show.
>>44604386
A medium dragon falls out of the sky and crashes near the party, dead.
>>44604427
Is this a reference to something or is this Baneposting?
>>44604386
Tournaments of any sort are a classic, but your twists to them will usually not be interesting.
Acidents happen, specially magical ones, maybe a wizard set somewhere on fire.
Characters in the wilderness might face some challanges to survive, I think DMG has some suggestions. You could maybe have a eclipse or something and have them lost.
A travelling merchant attempts to trick the more gullible PCs into buying junk or just beat them in banters.
>>44604499
If it was baneposting the dragon would bebig.
>>44604598For youmaybe.
Maybe it was crashed by abiggerdragon.
>>44604598Fore Ewe
>>44604386
The patron of the party warlock calls in a favor in an unsubtle manner. The rest of the party may react rather strongly to this.
The party happens upon a wandering dog. there is a bit of twine around it's neck, into which a note has been tucked.
The party finds the smoldering remains of an attacked caravan.
>>44603948
So thats what homer simpson looks like without the beard!
>Playing OotA
>prisioners that escaped and that we found along the way also get xp for the combats they get involved and for milestones
>they start leveling up and becoming useful and likeble
>Feels great man!
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1-BVCXEWrpY3F_-MDyfntJwPhNe2R3mFgG7dQO-fE5Ys/edit?usp=sharing
A sci-fi expansion to D&D 5e. I didn't want to write six pages of setting lore that would never be used, so I provided some scant background so that DMs and players can at least follow the train of thought behind character classes, archetypes, and skills.
So far, I have one class without archetypes, but I just want to verify that I'm not thinking outside of the D&D box or fucking balance up from the get-go.
Anyone have the rulebook I could snag? The link in this thread isn't working for me.
>>44603797
How do you guys handle a party of loose canons?
I mean, they want to be super agressive with every npc they meet, torturing and killing prisioners, even if they are friendly.
If I threw back at them a drow archmage that was initially friendly towards the party for the rescue, then they burned one of his eyes while he was restrained by chains, before teleporting away, would they complain?
>>44605220
>rescuing a drow archmage
what? well, I guess it could happen
>he acts friendly towards the party
so he didnt have anything preventing his speach or if the party pulled it off, not only he didnt kill them straight away, he also acted friendly?
>burned one of his eyes
why the fuck did they do that for?!
I know drows are evil and shit, but goddamn!
>>44605014
> sci-fi expansion
> no background
> limited other content
The DMG provides most of the tools necessary to get started with a sci-fi game.
Fortunately for you, this means you don't have to waste time writing additional rules either. Congraturation!
>>44605220
You should do it and find out.
>>44605263
Most of them, but not all of them. Many of the classes have to be actively modified and refluffed.
Posted hambro warlock archetype feature for feedback yesterday. I've revised it to make it less potent:
> Ranged and Melee spell attacks targeting you are made at disadvantage
> On a miss, you may spend your reaction to force the attacker to make a Cha save; failure applies the Recharge quality to the opponent's spellcasting feature
> Recharge threshold is your cha mod
Spends your reaction, doesn't apply to AoE spells anymore, made Recharge variance less weird. Is this better?
>>44605254
its from the ocupation of szith morcane adventure, from the adventurers league.
They rescued the drow from a fire giant and some demons, they also needed a brooch that a mind flayier requested in exchange for a teleportation there.
>the drow tricked the illithid into thinking that the brooch was magic and was because of it that the flayer couldnt control his mind
>when players ask him about the brooch, he laughs, because the illithid bought it
>paladin punches him
>he explains why he laughted and that the brooch is not magical
>they keep mistreating him, until the halfing ranger decides to burn both the drows eyes
>drow sees that and start casting teleport
>halfling jumps and stabs his eye with burning rapier
>he teleports away
>party tries talking with the brooch anyways and detecting magic
>its a plain brooch
>they feel no remorse
>>44605366
Wow, what a bunch of dicks.
Bet they picked chaotic neutral, so they can act all edgy and "the ends justify the means"
Or maybe their ideal play is to fuck npcs with no real consequences.
>>44605220
>>44605366
Szith Morcane, huh?
The drow take it back from the giants not long after that.
Their main concern is holding the giants and demons off, so if Solom, the drow archmage, survived and managed to rescue his crew (did the party rescued the drow prisioners?) and take the fight back to them.
But fucking Solom like that was not a smart move, the guy can scry the shit out of the party on his free time and bid his time.
If they went back to szith morcane, and he sees them, they should get fucked. Solom too should change as to expect the worse from everyone and maybe become even more evil.
>>44605267
>having players face bad consequences of their actions
The players will hate it and call it bullshit, probably say that the DM had it for the party or some shit, maybe some of them will even be like "but I wasnt the one that burned his eye, so he shouldnt hate me too!".
Players who act edgy are the worst and they bitch a lot. A lot.
Can War or Tempest cleric pair well with a barbarian?
>>44605470
The ongoing issue with Barb and any caster archetype is that you end up with 2 core features in conflict.
That said, play what you want to play, but you may get more functional mileage out of a Cleric of either type with the outlander background.
>>44605441
No, they didnt rescue any prisioners, they didnt even met them. They went straight to the mansion, chaos sorcerer chaos'ed a firball centered on himself and killed 2 party members, before fighting the giant and "rescuing" the Solom. After collecting the treasure, they picked a friends body and took it back to be ressurected at his faction expense.
>>44605511
Hum... how did they leave? Didnt Solom had to open the passage, otherwise they would have to walk 21 days in underdark, which is pretty much suicide?
I'll assume that you changed the boss fight into the "very weak party" setup.
>>44605529
I made solom open the thing, without them knowing.
>>44605511
>chaos sorcerer fucked the party
classic!
>>44605541
Hum, that was nice of you. Even though they didnt deserve it. You are making things way too easy on them.
Maybe you should get the OotA adventure and make some real hardcore underdark darksouls shit happen the next time they go there.
>>44605470
No caster pairs well with barbarians rage.
I mean, you could make a "rage last resource" build, I guess, for when you run out of spells.
>>44605366
What a bunch of retards.
Did you do it right? I mean, did they know that Solom was a kind of a big deal?
>>44605366
>blinding the archmage
>not raping him
get on my magic realm level, bitches!
>>44605626
Yes, he introduced himself.
I should've said that the guys who gave the party the mission, wanted him alive. I have indeed failed and now I feel bad.
I skiped that part of the intro by accident.
>>44605580
Yeah, maybe I should.
Underdark expeditions on the adventurers league are way too easy and streamlined.
>>44605684
>forgot to mention how important the guy they would find captured later on is and that he is wanted alive
shithead, its all on you.
>>44605705
>its all on you
Did you miss the part that anon said that he introduced himself and acted friendly towards the party, even after being suckerpunched?
>>44605465
probably this.
>>44605705
> party tries to kill NPC the DM didn't specifically say was wanted alive
> what a shitty DM
No anon, you are the shitheads
>>44605705
Did you even read?
He introduced himself and acted friendly, answerd all the parties questions, even being mistreated.
>>44605705
>NPC is saved by party
>is thankful and answer all the parties questions
>paladin punches him for laughing at the stupid mind flayer for beliving his shit
>keeps it cool
>they decide its ok to blind him
Its an edgelords shitfest, there was nothing the DM could've done.
>>44605382
>chaotic neutral
pretty much sums it up.
>>44603797
Hate to say it but it looks like the Mega files got nuked again.
>>44605882
>>44605722
>>44605883
>>44605948
I guess we can all agree that that party needs some good old drow revange, right?
Do it, DM. Fuck them hard.
Specially the paladin and the halfling.
>>44604286
Champion is purely passive isn't it?
>>44603797
Must go for the classic Beholder.
>>44606015
If by passive you mean "passive features," then yes.
If by passive you mean "ineffective in combat," then no, and check your head for holes.
>>44606071
That's exactly what I thought. I'm not the same poster just curious how the other Anon could've work out his statement.
>>44606000
Trips fucking confirm it.
I need some ways the Archmage can get back on them, while distracted by the fire giant/demon attacks.
>>44606084
If anon wants more stuff to do, anon can go battlemaster. Champion is geared around taking what you can already do up to eleven.
I mean, what would you even replace, and with what? There's not a wasted feature on that archetype.
How would /tg/ build Beowulf?
>>44604052
And I, for one, really hope that he caved his players' skulls in with a Genius Manticore keyboard.
>>44606195
human, Wolf or bear barbarian?
>>44606195
On a similar note, Achilles?
>>44603948
Incorporate NPC names into the shops. It further reinforces the name for your players and it probably makes more sense for the D&D setting.
Arren's Angelic Armaments
The Zigbault Brother's Smithing Services
Gilmore's Glorious Goods (from Critical Roll)
Too often my players will say "alright, lets go back and talk to uhh.. that guy from the place." I find the more you can tie the name into the setting, the more the players will care about it and remember it.
Hey /5eg/, I'm mulling around the idea of running an 80's action movie inspired series of one shots for my group some time in the future and I'd like to use the firearms available in the DMG. I'd also like to give martial classes modern magic style archetypes, but I'd like them to be inspired by the source material. I'm just spit-balling at this point, but tell me if the thematics make sense with the classes:
Paladin - A commando type who specializes in automatic weapons with the Burst Fire property (ala "spray and pray")
Rogue - the detective who uses the innate skills potency of the rogue class and applies it to items or tools, beside the thieve's tools.
Barbarian - I'm kind of at a loss for barb. I can either base him off of the invincible russian wrestler type guy or maybe some coke snorting rager, but I'd much perfer to not even try the later.
Monk - literally already perfect, Daniel-san
>>44605984
Somehow OP copied the *old* link, of the one that got nuked ages ago, because he's a dumb fuckshit.
This one from the actual previous thread still works. https://mega.nz#F!UVkTnT5b!FJ34UZ98BMY2mEtexenS7g
Anyone have a pdf of the 5e spellcards using one of those online spell card designer things?
>>44606596
oh nvm, I found the site I was thinking of and I guess they just have them already set up for printing. DIdn't think WotC was okay with that sort of thing.
Are there any good, short adventures for a single player and GM?
I need to catch a player up to the group who all just hit level 2 without her (she was at a friends birthday).
If not prewritten adventures, what are some good ideas for one on one play?
>>44605355
What's the theme here?
Mechanically sounds on-par with the PHB Lock's 10th level features. Bit more rolling involved, but that's OK.
I feel like you'll almost never run into a situation where a level 10 warlock has less than 20 charisma, though. Either make the Recharge 5-6 or find another way to determine it (1/5 warlock level, round up, maybe: 3 at 10, 4 at 13, 5 at 17).
>>44607227
>prequel dungeon
>downtime simulator alpha
>just giving it to her
>>44606566
based
So I'm gonna make a Wizard/Rogue, with Bladesinger and Arcane Trickster respectively.
How should I proceed in leveling? Which one should I pick first etc
>>44607227
Level 2 is nothing. It's 300 XP. You can just give that to her. Level 1-3 are explicitly the Starter Zone in 5e.
>>44603948
Can you rewrite "Sears" as "Spears?"
>>44607351
You don't really need the rogue levels; you'll need to go too deep to get anything worthwhile anyway. Cut off at rogue 2 if you must have rogue bits.
>>44607261
I wrote a fun noncombat scenario that was based on my plotline but I'm sure it can be modified. The premise is that a terrorist group has planted magical bombs around a city and they need to be defused. The bomb defusal is a really fun minigame and can be easily brought into other adventures as a noncombat encounter. How long should the adventure take?
>>44607351
> Wizard
> Arcane Trickster
You should run your character sheet through a shredder and use the result to start a fire in a discarded 50-gallon drum. Add fuel wood until the fire is nice and hot. Add your PHB. Walk away.
>>44607404
Oops meant to reply to
>>44607227
>>44607416
No good?
I was thinking of going like 2 levels with Wizard just to get Bladesinger
Calm down, anon.
>>44607395
So you're saying it's just not worth it to combine the two? Better off just going full Wizard?
>>44607499
Why do you want Bladesinger?
The hyperbole is because if you're going wizard, you do yourself no service by multiclassing with any other class. Multiclassing into multiple classes with spellcasting eats your slot count.
Going into Bladesinger to improve a Rogue is a wash, at best; with arcane Trickster, it becomes a liability.
>>44607499
Yes. Rogue does not have extra toughness to offer and AT just offers what a full wizard can do anyway. The only thing you could want are skills, mobility and sneak attack. The first tow can be got with just two level (wizards have spells that grant mobility anyway) and the last requires too many levels investment to be worth it. Bladesinger is pretty much already AT 2.0. You'll lose more than is gained.
>>44607601
>>44607686
Thank guys.
I'll just go full Wizard then.
>>44607601
Not him, but why? I can see it being a wash, but assuming the rogue has good INT, he gets a pretty nice boost in AC for what, 1 die of SA? AT doesn't really get much on leveling up.
>>44607822
Hm, didn't think about it coming from the angle of AT. Mgiht be a good dip in that case
>>44607251
Thanks; will try that out.
The patron is supposed to be setting-specific: the warlock is indentured to the Wizards' Guild, which acts as a regulatory body as much as an academic one. The archetype gives mostly roleplaying and utility abilities (make 1-shot wands; has tool and skill proficiencies), so I wanted the level 10 defensive ability to be at least as powerful as the fiendlock, as they don't get as much love in the fighty department.
>>44607822
Compare the wizard-only spell slots to those of multiclassing.
If you want to cast and fight, Arcane Trickster is not your friend. Almost anything would be better.
Bladelock -- BLADELOCK -- would be better.
>>44607404
It's just going to be an hour or two tonight. I think one or two quick fights, two or three noncombat encounters, and some NPC dialogue should so it.
Hey Tg, I'm thinking about a character concept, story and all, in the vague hopes that I'll finally be able to be a player and not a foreverGm.
A variant human, with the magic initiate, class eldritch knight. Picking the Hex spell, unsure about the cantrips from warlock.
How does that sound? Fluff/backstory. His mother was a warlock and taught him those spells, and he felt it natural that he temper and improve his art by working more magic training in with his bladeworks.
Asian-inspired campaign, one of the players wanted to play a Kitsune. Is this a decent statting, or should it go back to the drawing board?
>>44608315
Arcane cunning seems really strong, way to strong.
>>44608362
This just in: Gnomes are broken.
>>44608315
> small size
> 30 foot movement rate
Pick one.
> True form
How do you assume your True Form? Does it do anything worthwhile for you? I think you can lose this feature.
> Shapeshifting
Christ, just use the version in the monster manual. Also, if this is how you're meant to assume your True Form, it should be mentioned here.
> Arcane Cunning
Oh, fuck you.
> Proficiencies, bite, senses
Fine
> 400k for one page of monotype with a shitty background
Jesus.
>>44608075
Oh yeah, Rogue sucks ass for anything but a 2 level dip, maybe 3 for assassin, but if you WANT to go AT for some reason then giving up 1-2 levels for Bladesinger looks okay.
>>44608449
>> small size
>> 30 foot movement rate
>Pick one
Mastiffs are 40 foot movement at Medium size. Generally, quadrupeds are faster than bipeds of the same size. Seems a bit odd that a human would be able to outpace a fox that easily.
>True form
You're in your true form unless you take a different shape. I needed somewhere to put the "you can talk even though you're a fox" rule, as well as the stuff about equipment.
>Shapeshifting
The one in the Monster Manual lets you impersonate individuals willy-nilly, and is basically enough to make a monster in and of itself. This version just gives you access to one appearance per species. It's a pretty significant difference. Also, it does note at least once that it's how you return to your true form.
>Arcane Cunning
As >>44608428 pointed out, it's a gnome feature. Same as Stout halflings get the same poison resistance as dwarves.
>file size issues
My work computer is kind of shit, it's true.
Hey /5eg/,
I'm trying to Homebrew some flintlock weapons for a setting I want to run, and the best solution I've come up with is basically the different crossbow types with a tacked on special rule.
I've come up with several rules to represent the fact that they're guns, but I've boiled it down to two specific rules, and I'd like your opinions on which would be better both mechanically and in terms of fluff, and perhaps some tweaks to make them better.
1. All guns have +1 to hit on all creatures size-class medium or larger, but suffer -2 to hit on all small/tiny creatures.
or
2.All guns suffer a -1 (perhaps -2?) to hit rolls, but ignore piercing resistance.
Also in order to get the guns to have a loading time reasonably close to a crossbow's, I've decided to fluff them as percussion cap weapons w/ an 1819 Hallrifle type loading design
>>44608643
Just use the DMG versions.
>>44608596
>Mastiffs are 40 foot movement at Medium size.
Mastiffs aren't player characters.
>>44608315
>>44608596
> Asks for feedback
> equivocates in response to feedback
You're the reason /tg/ thinks homebrew is shit.
>>44608791
Yeah, and the foxes only move 30 feet. Which, given the inability to use weapons, doesn't seem that out of line.
Besides, dwarves and wild elves show that you can have more than one base speed at Medium. No reason that couldn't apply to Small as well.
>>44608865
...man, I'm not a huge fan of homebrew either, but that's a retarded stance. Have you never done any collaborative work? Change is not the only possible response to feedback. Sometimes, it's important for an author to get the chance to make their intent clear, if people were responding on the basis of inaccurate assumptions. The audience can then respond to those explanations, either to insist on the changes in spite of them or to revise their arguments in light of them.
In this case, until reading >>44608596, I hadn't realized that they were actually supposed to be literal foxes unless they used the Shapeshifting ability. That means there's some failure in the writing, but it doesn't mean that the fact that they're literal foxes needs to be thrown out. And Arcane Cunning looked stupidly good to me until someone pointed out that gnomes get the exact same thing.
As shitty as any piece of homebrew might be, it's hard for me to credit the idea that blindly following advice from 4chan would necessarily be better.
>>44608865
>calling that equivocation
It's like you just use words you've heard before without any idea of what they mean. Explaining things and answering questions is literally the opposite of equivocation.
>>44603797
How does a complete beginner nerd even get into the game? Where do I even go?
So i'm converting my dwarves into crabmen. Hill Dwarf stats are fine, but the Mountain Dwarf armor proficiency is a little odd for crabmen. Maybe a kind of natural armor?
>>44609065
Read the book, get a group, play.
>>44608596
I'd say to rethink how True Form is presented, then. Hell, even a name change would probably do it. "Bestial Limitations" doesn't quite sound appropriate, but it gives a better sense of what the ability is representing.
Shapeshifting is pretty ugly, but the fact that it just grants you a few different looks, rather than being a 17th-level Druid class feature, is probably a good thing. It also means that there are less societal implications--you don't have to worry about how anyone you know could be replaced by a kitsune at any time, you just have to worry about strangers. I assume that the reason behind specifying all the things about equipment has to do with the fact that you're actually changing body plan, like wild shape, rather than just getting bigger or smaller?
I might still cut Arcane Cunning, though I'm unsure as to whether that would leave them with too few features. The fact that the shapeshifting doesn't really grant you anything might mean that it looks more powerful than it is, but it currently feels like they have a lot going for them.
Changing the speed might still be on the table, though the fact that they're actually quadrupeds does change matters. I'm not actually sure it introduces any balance issues, but it certainly looks funny.
>>44608865
No, /tg/ thinks homebrew is shit because of all the homebrew writers who have no clue what they're doing and just slap shit together and just ignore criticism. This guy answered criticism, even if only to try to justify the criticized choices.
>>44609108
Instructions not clear, have to file for bankruptcy now
>>44603921
I love how you chose that despite him being a black dragon.
>>44605220
>handle loose canons
Normally, I would retcon anything particularly problematic, or try to preferably explain it away with a future plotline.
>>44609336
See >>44606566, OP was an idiot and used an OP link that's like six months dead at this point
>>44608596
>Seems a bit odd that a human would be able to outpace a fox that easily.
Fair, I suppose; had not realized that your True Form was a default and not a choice.
That said, it seems unbecoming that you can shapeshift indefinitely without any other prerequisites. Racial abilities are usually pretty minor; I'd limit this to a number of hours equal to your int mod, or similar. You could also potentially have this scale with level, a LA tiefling.
I don't care what gnomes get; they don't get shapeshift, too. Recommend you pick one.
File optimization options for PDFs can be found when saving or printing.
This guy >>44608865 is an asshole. Thanks for the thoughtful response.
>>44609354
I think fluff-wise Anon as a collective is most like the black dragon.
Hates everybody, is ultimately kind of a coward.
>>44609251
>>44609468
Yeah, I'll cut Arcane Cunning. I just felt they should have some kind of defensive/resistant ability, since it seems like every race gets one, but I'm not terribly attached to it.
Were the UA changelings considered too powerful? Because I figured this shape changing is strictly worse than theirs, what with it not changing your statistics other than increasing your size to Medium.
How would you feel about a jack of all trades style fighting style that would give a small bonus to all weapons, like +1 to hit or damage? Or do you think it defeats the purpose of fighting styles?
>>44610084
The jack of all trades fighting style is called Defense and it gives +1 AC.
>>44610084
Eh, I can't see myself ever taking it. The other ones are better. Except maybe archery, but that one's still strong. It'd also just create problems with Champions - they could just get a bonus to their existing style this way (with their second style) rather than using it for versatility.
So to any 5th Edition RPGA player, are Lawful Evil characters allowed to be played? I want to play a Warlock who serves the Nine Hells, but that'd be hard with any other alignment.
>>44610342
I'm playing a character that is very similar to that in an AL OotA campaign. He is LE and it's perfectly fine. Generally speaking.
>>44610342
Lawful Neutral springs to mind.
>>44608449
>> small size
>> 30 foot movement rate
>Pick one.
I pick kobolds.
>>44610411
Well he could be Lawful Neutral, I guess...it just would be a bit weird, since he looks like a Devil, throws infernal hellfire at people, and has an imp servant.
I guess if it gets past the rules though, it'd be fine.
>>44609645
Changelings were considered uncommonly good fit their UA, especially given the relative meh-ness about the rest of it.
>>44610084
>do you think it defeats the purpose of fighting styles?
Yes. Also, that's what +1 weapons are for.
>>44610463
Also not a PC race. Take your meme and go.
>>44608643
Why does everyone who designs guns for D&D want them to have some weird fiddly mechanic that makes them harder to use? Just use the DMG guns.
>>44610610
>Not a PC race
>The DMG gives you rules on letting you make any fucking race you want
I played a Bullywug Wild Sorcerer, and kept all its shitty stats. You could do the same with a Kobold.
>>44610620
Because if the game is specifically geared towards a focus on gunplay, it's extremely boring to not only cut down the amount of setting-feasible weapons and still delegate everything to the basic rolls.
I see nothing wrong with a misfire mechanic or something of the sort.
>>44610670
My DM's misfire mechanic is that on a crit fail for an attack, if the weapon is poorly maintained, shit just explodes
This is also due to the PC's having no knowledge of guns and finding a cache of old blackpowder weapons, then fucking around until they figured out how they work
>>44610620
Because haven't you heard? Guns are fur special players who are special people, and need special weapons with special rules that require special classes with special features in order to use them.
In my setting: A gun is a wand that deals d8 piercing damage and does not require attunement. The type of gun determines how many charges it has.
That's it.
>>44610570
Hm. Does the "only one shape per race" restriction and the lack of changes to statistics nerf the shapeshifting enough, or should I find another way to restrict it?
>Start LGS game at 5th level
>Going to use average HP as a barb
>GM says no, I must roll
>Kay
>Roll in front of him with his dice: 11, 11, 10, 12
>Gets mad and acts all passive-aggressive towards me
Will I ever find a decent group and/or GM?
>>44610650
> I MADE IT MYSELF
> with RULES
>>44611078
...yeah?
Your DM always has the option of saying no, as well. Most DM's wouldn't restrict players from making a Kobold.
>>44611075
Yeah, not in LGS games.
You may have to DM yourself
>>44610904
> 184K
My man.
> one shape per race
Honestly, I don't really think this adds or removes anything efficacy-wise. What it does do is put a lot of pressure on the DM to keep track of what forms a character had assumed, and how they looked each time.
Not exclusive to kitsune, but a common folklore theme among shapeshifters is that the transformation is always a bit wrong: sometimes the eyes stay the same, for example. Following this theme, maybe you could make it a variation on a disguise check and give opponents disadvantage on insight checks to recognize you.
>>44603797
I'm a big fan of forces of nature gone berserk. Thinking of including a corrupted Oath of Ancients Paladin as a villain after my party finished LMoP, who corrupts druid groves and is spawning armies of blights, vine golems and other plant based monstrosities in an attempt to let The Green take over.
>>44611560
> If we were all trees, there would be no wars.
>>44611507
>pressure on the DM
I can't imagine it's any more than just assuming that they look the same each time. Since that's written in, it doesn't matter whether the DM can remember the hair color--he can just say "yeah, they recognize you."
>>44610904
Maybe it's just my animoo talking, but a part of me wants you to be able to have fox traits in other forms. If I'm feeling like enough of a weeb to play a kitsune, there's a nonzero chance that I'll want to use Horo as a character portraityes, I know she's a wolf, but she has the right look
>>44607351
Shanoa is great, your mess of character isnt.
>>44610408
Wheres your party at and what LVL?
>>44606390
Bear barbarian / fighter?
Been playing some 5ed with friends, and a thing i have noticed is that ac seems really freaking good in this edition.
Is it also like this when you get to higher lvl, or does ac become less significant?
>>44606123
Scry them and plot.
BID its time.
If they show up at his home, get them killed.
>>44608483
>mfw im playing a LVL 4 rogue and having tons of fun
=/
>>44611660
Pics?
>>44611844
Even full barbarian would be ok.
>>44608483
I'm an AT with familiar and GFB and BB and I'm dealing quite a lot of damage
>>44611660
>I can't imagine it's any more than just assuming that they look the same each time.
Well, since you mentioned being weeb enough to play o-kitsune-sama:
The kind of players I've had who'd play a kitsune are absolutely the kind of players who would argue with me for hours about appearance.
>>44605366
Geez, are you playing with a party of Virts?
>>44611897
>>44611943
Read the whole thread, latefriends.
They were talking about a wizard taking a 2-level dip in Rogue. It is a bad idea. Don't get all foamed up.
>>44609106
JUST MAKE A UNIQUE RACE
FUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU
>>44611967
...far be it from me to judge how another person chooses their friends, but why would you play with people like that?
>>44612158
I GM lots of public and convention events. These people are not my friends; my friends are a different, better story.
> inb4 why would you DM public games?
Because I'm an addict and I can't say no. Next question.
>>44611119
I probably would just because they wouldn't be able to walk around town without creating a scene. I don't like it when PCs are races that are unique enough that it always draws a bunch of attention.
>>44612209
Why would you let someone play a homebrew race at a public or convention game
>>44612062
It's ok. You get dash, which is great for getting out of trouble as a squishy wizard.
If the bard with tumble is going to be a thing it'll quite pointless tho.
>>44611943
You are dealing less than a dedicated damage dealer could, but that's basically my plan as well in the campaign I'm playing in.
>>44611897
Do you enjoy what you are doing? "disengage, move, attack" got boring for me 5 levels ago.
>>44612254
I don't. Hence the arguments.
>>44612262
I really can't imagine the kind of person to firstly bring a homebrew kitsune race to a public game and then secondly argue about it
Poor man
>>44612279
It's not a self-pity thing, and I try not to be an ass about it, but when one prick fixated on being different holds up the session for everybody else to the point that security has to get involved, you just kind of learn to roll with it.
> security? What?
It's less dramatic than it sounds. Con volunteers remove people from the event if they're disruptive. They prefer the GM not get involved for liability/safe space reasons.
I do enjoy it. I can count my bad stories on one hand, but I've lost count of the good ones.
>>44603797
My favorite would have to be the Orcs, and I think that 5th edition does them even better than before.
>>44604386
Side quests are the first things that come to mind for me.
How would you all create an incredibly strong solo fighter in 5e?
We're starting a moderately high level campaign (level 9), with 3 players total including me. The other players have decided to take up pretty heavy support and mostly non-combat focused characters, on top of being relatively new players and without any semblance of optimization. Normally I don't optimize too hard, but I want to make sure these guys don't get steamrolled in combat and I know the DM is pretty fair, but won't hold back.
I'm thinking of doing an Assassin 3 / Death Monk 6 build with Sentinel. Low HP but the Death Monk feature would let me survive decently, and I'd have solid damage output both single target and in groups. I really want to stay away from Fighter or Barbarians, since I've already played those plenty and find them pretty boring.
>>44612476
>incredibly strong solo fighter
>no fighters or barbarians, though
...o-kay...
>>44612257
You don't put levels in rogue past 7, it's largely inferior to switching to fighter at that point.
>>44612500
Yeah I know, I might end up going one just because but I'm seriously bored with playing one.
The question was for anyone though, I just specifically am looking for something not heavy into Fighter or Barb.
>>44612476
Moon druid with summons.
>ToEE game
>party already has a Monk
>another might make a Cleric
Should I play a Bard, Wizard or Sorcerer?
>>44611507
>>44611660
Added fox traits in other shapes, as well as an Intelligence (Investigation) check to notice that there's something amiss.
I figured, based on the stories of argumentative weebs, that specifying exactly what was amiss would lead to them all wearing sunglasses at all times or whatever, so I left it undefined.
Part of why I'm keeping it at one form per race is for preventing worldbuilding headaches. A race that could look like the empress's daughter one minute and the captain of the guard the next is just asking for trouble.
>>44612516I'm exactly 7. Not sure if I'll switch to fighter or something else.
>>44610904
Unrelated to your homebrew, just a general lore question:
Aren't traditional kitsune, like, man-eating sociopaths? Don't they assume human guise for the sole purpose of killing horny men? Aren't they all about perverting the natural order and generally sticking their foxy dicks in everything?
I feel like that's a poor thematic choice for a PC race. Couldn't you be a tanuki instead? Racial features include a sweet hat and giant balls?
>>44612677
Looking good.
I'd maybe allow members of a race you're actively imitating identify you passively.
>>44612476
Level 9 Paladin trumps your shit multiclass.
>>44612686
You're thinking of kumiho. They're descended from the same root myth, but Korea decided that sexy fox ladies should be sociopathic flesh-eaters instead of tricksters and guardians.
>>44612622
eldritch knight because they're cool
>>44612686
>Giant Balls.
You are proficient with your unarmed strikes, which deal 2d4 points of bludgeoning damage.
>>44612933
Nah, someone else is already making a Fighter.
>>44611582
Now you're getting it!
>>44612956
Bladesinger Wizard, then.
>>44612956
but you wont be a fighter
you'll be an eldritch knight
if you want to be difficult, fine
make a dwarf arcane trickster
>>44612257
>You are dealing less than a dedicated damage dealer could
Yes, but not less than other rogues, in fact I'm having advantage to my attacks and dealing GFB+Sneak Attack, I think that's more than other rogues. Only Assassin seems to deal more and only on the first turn/surprise.
>>44612686
Kitsune were previously benevolent. When the Jesuits arrived in Japan, they got a more malevolent bent.
Yokai are more like Fey than demons in their cultural context: not necessarily evil, but weird.
>>44613207
No shit.
GFB costs a feat. In fact, now that I think about it, one feat gets you both GFB and familiar, doesn't it?
But anyway, it doesn't really matter. Didn't say you were doing bad damage for a rogue, said you dealt less damage than damage dealers.
I'm DMing a campaign set in an archipelago.
r8 and h8 my fluff
Late one evening on a galleon named The Deceit of the Sea, an elderly sailor motioned to a few of the passengers to gather around. “Let me tell you a little about this accursed region known as The Mirage Isles. 'Tis a strange place to sail through, and few have the savvy to make it out alive. Many spin tails of how this place came to be cursed so, but I'll tell ye the one truth: Eons ago, Talos, god of storms, came to Leira, goddess of illusion, with a request. He wished to keep a great treasure of his safe, and asked that she aid him in turning an entire region of the sea into a maze. Leira, while reluctant, complied on the condition that he owed her a great debt. I know not the details, but when she came to collect, he turned her away. And so she cursed that entire region, causing the islands to move about, appearing in one place one day and appearing in a diff'rnt one the next, hiding the treasure amidst the churning waters.
“Nowadays, it's rumoured that Leira drops adventurers into the region on occasion, so they may seek Talos' treasure for themselves, as a further act of vengeance.”
The ancient mariner eyes the crowd that has assembled, then beckons to a few individuals to come closer.
“You have great potential.”
A ferocious crack of thunder echoes through the previously clear skies. He draws a pair of ten sided bone dice from a pocket in his shirt, palming them.
“I have a single question.
“High? Or low?”
[A player calls out high or low. DM rolls d100. Low results are 1-50, high are 51-100. If the player calls correctly, a water spout appears. If a player calls poorly, a kraken appears.]
“An interesting choice. Good luck with all your future rolls, adventurers.” The grizzled seaman disappears in a puff of smoke as the water spout draws the ship into its powerful grasp [as the kraken breaks the first mast].
>>44614007
It might just be the fact that I love maritime adventures, but it sounds great to me
>>44603948
Don't Thread on Me - A tailoring shop ran by a retired soldier
A Fisher's Price - Fish Market
Really pissed off my players with these. Hope they do the same for you!
>>44612153
Rather not, because dwarves as they are don't have a place in the world,
I'm reskinning a great deal of the races, but dwarves and tieflings are the ones that may need statistical changes.
My DM won't let me play a tiefling Paladin because ''Your ancestry makes you bound to fall'' Is he justified in this? He knew I wanted to play something different for a Paladin so he is letting me play an aasimar instead.
>>44614333
Retarded, especially with all the different vows around.
You sure this happened and you aren't just trolling?
>>44614007
11/10 would play the shit out of it
>>44614123
Thanks. It's my first time DMing, so I was worried about not being able to grab attention with the main plot hook.
>>44614333
Pretty dumb but he's the GM and at least he's offering a compromise.
>>44603797
What do you guys think? Variant Human or Lightfoot Halfling for rogue?
>>44614511
Do you want a feat at level 1 or to hide behind allies?
>>44614511
Go Drow. Cry to everyone whenever they force you to fight outside on a sunny day.
I made an ability that makes a creature frightened, but I'm not sure what the duration should be. It's single-target, has a Wisdom save to negate, success renders the target immune to it for 24 hours, it's at-will, and the target must be able to see and hear you. I'm thinking 1 minute or until the target damages you, the source of its frightened condition.
Is this okay, or is there a better way I can make a single-target fear ability as a class feature?
Yo niggers the rulebook link doesn't work.
Anyone have a working one?
>>44614580
But see a drow in a cave
>>44614532
Not sure which I find better desu, which is why I was soliciting opinions
>>44614792
Thanks nigger
How'd your last session go, /5eg/? Gimme somecomfystories.
>>44614998
>Didn't happen again because a player had to babysit his little brothers since his grandma felt too weak from chemotherapy to do so
>>44613961
>GFB costs a feat
Nope, Like I said, I'm AT rogue one of my cantrips can be GFB and one of my first level spells can be familiar ;^)
>>44614998
>running session for a group
>keep overestimating their intelligence
>they split the party
>half find the dungeon boss
>they almost die, only live because I know if I slaughter them they'll cry
>they still complain
>"did you even read the CR rules?" they ask
>other half of the party is doing literally nothing, running around in circles
It wasn't comfy. This is the second time too, they've decided to be epic random and have half of them run off for no good reason.
>>44615085
And what I said is that a non AT rogue could pick those up for a feat.
>>44614998
It was kindacuet.I have never played with a group of all girls, and they took a concept I would normally reject, and ran with it without me having to do much of anything to encourage the roleplay.
It wasn't the best session I've ever played, but it wasn't the worst either. Mostly me just fudging the rules since I know fuck all about 5E.
>>44614998
>party is in a desert city
>previous session, found a massive cache of iron guarded by a drake (which we slew), we wanted the reward for it
>have to wait for the prince of the region to arrive
>my character was stuck wearing a cursed item which lowered his intelligence
>roll int checks once in awhile to determine if i wander off and do something dumb out of boredom
>pick a barfight with a three-kreen, accidentally start a riot
>after this incident, party decided i need to be kept occupied
>am playing monk, so they send me to a monastery
Spent the remainder of the two week downtime training in this monastery, got a homebrewed monk action called Flaming Fist for my training, the rest of the party did similar things.
>Flaming Fist
>Ability uses 3 ki points
>On hit, you use a damage die one above your normal die (a d6 instead of a d4, etc.) and roll it twice
>first roll is punch damage, second roll is fire damage
>they make a save to avoid being lit on fire for an additional 1d4 damage
It's not a fantastic ability, but it's still cool as hell
Then the prince arrived and we set off for the iron cache
>>44614998
An OotA session after missing a month of play (Work and family vacation is why I missed so much):
>Party is 2 levels above me because I missed a month of sessions.
>It's AL so I decide to bring in a level appropriate goliath fighter so we all have lvl 4 characters
>7 man party, 4 fighters. 2 arcane casters & 1 monk. Feels god man.
>but then shit starts going down.>2 Umber Hulks burst from the walls.
>Bloody fight. My Goliath stands up to the blows fine, rest of the group not doing so well.
>Wizard casts fog cloud so everyone squishy and low on health can escape.
>Me and 2 other fighters stay in to finish the job.
>After fight a bunch of mushroom people meet us because thats where the group was heading apparently.
>They want us to kill shambling mound.
>Ok.jpeg
>Short rest and head over.
>Bunch of giant centipede like creatures with it, that have tentacle mouths and beaks and can paralyze you.
>Monk and NPC bard fall unconscious.
>I go ham on a centipede and get it to low HP.
>Casters crit the mound twice and Derindel Crits it once.
>Clean up combat after a bit.
>was a good session all and all.
Now because of our lack of clerics I am considering going for a dip into war cleric after my fighter hits 5th lvl. I'm thinking either a 2 lvl dip or a 4 lvl dip. Anyone have any advice for a optimal dip into war cleric as a primary tank fighter?
So I read in the PHB some time ago that you could make healing potions with a herbalist kit. What are the costs for the healing potion? And how long does it take? Where do I find where this is written if it is? I swore I read it in one of the books that it said it took 10 days and cost 25gp
>>44615749
Healing potions at 50gp but with an herbalist kit you can craft them for 25gp over 10 days.
>>44615821
Where does it say that though?
>>44614998
>playing oota>paladin player leaves
>playing paladin/bladelock
>I get dawnbringer
>after fleeing from neverlight grove because everyone failed their sanity saves and turned into retards we arrive in blingdenstone
>everyone gets drunk while I refit some slutty drow armor for eldeth and buy items
>getting ready to figure out the wererat issue
>we get there and it's really dark
>try to activate dawnbringer
>nothing
>rush back to the inn to figure out what the fuck happened to her
>she's just mad I talked the party into giving me some money for a suit of plate armor
>give her to the EK and work with my patron to get a better sword
wew lad
>>44615520
Derendil mops shit up, dude. ripped a drow elite's arms off in the very first session. even better because the DM voices him like Vegeta. Derendil and Stool are our favorite NPC party members.
>>44617929
I love derendil and stool too personally.I am in 2 OotA groups and in the other group I befriended derindil in the first 5 minutes of the first session completely on accident. In that group I am a warlock and when we were attacked by a kua toa monk and his band of guards I got knocked out. Derindil went apeshit and killed the last enemy before going into a full frenzy and ripping the orcs throat out. We had to put him down. Shit was really sad, but I picked up a flomph as an ally awhile later so that sorta cheered me up.
So I've never played dnd before and I don't know anyone who plays.
I have gathered 4 friends and they have all read the rulebook.
I know have the task of being DM. I think I'm going to do the Lost Mines of Phandelver to start out. It seems simple enough.
Any advice?
>>44618399
For a 5e Psychic Warrior, would it be best to make a Fighter archetype or just make a new class entirely? Are there any decent Psychic Warriors for 5e out there?
Gonna be playing D&D with some colleagues in a couple of weeks, my first time experiencing anything D&D. Any tips for beginners and/or more specifically, what's the process of making my character?
>>44618439
A fighter archetype with some specific psionic abilities would probably work best. There's going to be dedicated warrior stuff when the mystic is more fleshed out, though.
I want to play dnd but everyone I know of that plays it is a sperg virgin beta frogposting loser.
Any normies here play? Where to find?
>>44618462
Chapter 1 of the PHB is pretty clear about character creation. Follow it to a T and you should be fine.
>>44618399
Lost Mines is a pretty good fit for a group of new players, but note that some of the encounters can do a very scary amount of damage.
For general advice, just keep the game flowing, and just roll with what your characters are doing (assuming it's something they could plausibly do)
>>44618462
Remember to ask the DM about any particular character creation rules (such as what rolling method/point buy, and if anything isn't allowed). Chapter 1 of the book should answer the rest.
>>44618519
You could play the roll20 roulette to see if you can find a good group.
>>44615159
>players all playing a game and having fun
sounds good to me. I want that someday
some.. day..
>>44618519
I played in AL organized play, which has many locations across the America and probably other countries too. My location is pretty tame and has a good handful of good players.
>>44618667
I've joined 3 groups on roll20 so far and 2 out of the 3 are pretty good. I guess maybe I'm lucky?
One probably wouldn't be so bad if people didn't hear "sandbox campaign" and think "my character wanders away from the party and does dumb shit in the woods ignoring plot hooks"
>make fight with gimmick
>supposed big bad is trying to pull a powerful devil from a portal to hell
>it'll take 10 rounds (1 minute) to succeed
>there's a bunch of bearded and spined devils trying to actively kill the party while he's doing this
>but each time the big bad takes damage, he has to make a Strength save or get sucked in to the portal
>warlock hits him in the third turn of the first round with repelling blast and pushes him right into the portal, before anyone else has even thought about going after him
>mfw
>>44603797
I'm always a big fan of Hydras as a monster, but as a DM nothing makes me more giddy than throwing beholdersor anything with a ton of save or X abilities, reallyat the party and watching them panic.
>>44605366
clearly your players want to play a truly evil, fuck shit up sort of game. So go with it, run that campaign for them. If they get tired of it run something else, if they don't keep going. D&D should be fun for the whole table, if that's what your players want give it to them...
Have them hunted down by villagers, paladins, angels, etc. Have them become a reckless force of chaotic evil across the lands.
This may not be the campaign you had in mind but that doesn't mean it can't be fun.
I'm designing a drunken relay race for my PCs as part of a festival.
So far I'm thinking:
>5 (=party size) legs to the drunkathlon.
>100 yard dash, hurdles, swimming, swordfighting, and archery
>Before each leg, that team member must chug 3 pints of ale, making a DC 10 CON save for each or getting the poisoned condition (disadvantage to attacks and ability checks).
>make appropriate skill rolls / attack rolls, beating DC by 5 or finishing off the dummy quickly buy the team a few seconds off their race times relative to other teams.
This seems a little cumbersome for what's supposed to be a fun little team activity for the party. Does anyone have suggestions for this or contests of skill in general?
>>44619173
Depends on whether or not it's an organized game. If it's not then you can roll with a totally evil party, but if it's organized play then there is only so far off the rails you can go before shit hits the fan hard.
Either way the players actions should have consequence, not in a dnd Fucks up the party way but in a mage seeks revenge sort of way
>>44619264
Personally I've found the more fun mini-games to be the simpler ones.
You could watch the most recent episode of critical role where the party is at the Winter's Crest Festival. There's arm wrestling, pie eating, etc.
Mercer keeps things pretty simple, usually just contested rolls (best of 3) or skill checks with a rising DC
As long as the descriptions are fun and engaging players should care more about what they're seeing/hearing than if the rules are complex
>>44619328
Is it worth watching Critical Role? I gave it a look a while back and some of the people on it seem to be pretty insufferable.
Gonna try and run spelljammer using 5e. Any tips?
>>44619443
I started with the very first episode and I really enjoyed it.
I think the best part about it is that the entire group is really into it and having fun. That and Matt Mercer is a pretty solid DM. He makes mistakes occasionally (as we all do) but I'd said the vast majority of the time he handles things pretty well.
I'd definitely recommend it, just know that Keyleth (the druid chick) can be pretty insufferable, Tiberius (the dragonborn sorcerer) is a munchkin, and Pike (gnome cleric) is that player that's been playing for like a year but still refuses to learn the rules or how to play their character.
The good news is that the cleric constantly misses games due to work, and the sorcerer got the boot from the game due to some sort of internal issue with Geek and Sundry.
>>44618428
love this image. I always read through it every once in awhile just to remind myself of the sort of mindset I should be in when DMing
>>44619595
Guess I might give it another chance. Was the Pike guy the one who made some boner joke? I remember people getting up in arms about it.
>>44619684
nah, Pike is played by the blonde chick
The guy that made the joke about having a half-chub was Orion, who plays Tiberius. As I said, he eventually got the boot.
Its for the best that he's gone. He was a That Guy for multiple reasons. I think the dick joke was starting to push it
My Players have scoffed off and even laughed at a semi-horror encounter with a stereotypical demon child killing parentals, setting daycares on fire, etc. Because they literally just stuck a damn sword bathed in holy water down his throat 2 hours into the whole thing after they pieced it together that it was the kid not people doing bad shit.
So help me, boys.
Give me bullet points, stories, tips and tricks on how to freak them the fuck out. I need something to make them shit their pants.
What are some good uses for polymorph at 15th level? Mostly for buffing/changing into.
>>44619835
true spookiness requires immersion
I've been in groups where we'd get together, toss some dice, kill monsters and maybe solve a puzzle or two. Roleplaying? Nah.
There was no way a spooky encounter was going to have any effect on us. We'd just be making jokes out of character the whole time - and for that group that was fine.
If you're going to scare your players, they need to be invested in the safety/sanity of their characters, more from a roleplaying standpoint than a mechanical one
At least that's my 2 cents worth
>>44619868
Normal polymorph doesn't get better behind the T-Rex unless your DM homebrews some stronger beast stats.
I really hate dragons.
Why is WotC so terrified of giving interesting Tome of Battle/Path of War/4e maneuvers to non-magical characters?
Battlemaster maneuvers don't improve past level 3 except in reliability and frequency, and eagle barbarians are barred from true flight for no apparent reason.
>>44619835
If there's nothing causing them to hesitate, then they're sure as hell not going to be succumbing to any horror tropes as most "horror" comes from the victims being idiots who don't just get the fuck out of there or don't act upon the solution to the problem. Just because it's a kid isn't going to be much of a barrier to any adventurer with the slightest bit of pragmatism.
Similar to what the prior Anon said, the horror has to be directed at the players rather than being some mystery in a town they have no connection to, and the solution can't be as simple as a creature they can easily find and kill.
If it has stats, the party can (and will try to) kill it. The thing screwing with them should be more abstract in existence. Afflict a player character with something they can't identify. More so, afflict one of them with a disease/curse/parasite and have it so they don't even notice it, reducing their likelihood of pointing out where it came from.
Perhaps follow up with that demon child. The person who sworded devil kid - he's marked. Whatever evil spirit that occupied the child's body decided to attach itself to him. It's lingering in there, waiting for opportunities to twist the player's actions, suggest something not truly in their best interest, mess with his perceptions.
Alternatively, afflict an important NPC related to one of the characters with something. Did one of the players' backstories mention their character's family? Well then, it's time to give him a quest, take a take a trip on home and find that his sibling has been acting strangely. Other people in the hometown are mentioning nightmares, headaches, a few with strange marks on their bodies. As time goes on, the events going on become more serious. The PC isn't going to be so willing to take out his dear family member or the people he grew up with and won't allow his allies to do so either.
-Make it personal
-Make it not so concrete / conventional
Something like that.
>>44619922
>If you're going to scare your players, they need to be invested in the safety/sanity of their characters, more from a roleplaying standpoint than a mechanical one
>>44620425
Thank you. That makes a lot of sense.
I've been toying with an idea similar to what you said. People having nightmares and experiencing sleep paralysis, with events transpiring and symptoms getting worse and worse. Kind of like a detective game contra-time to find out who or what has caused this shit.
>>44620256
I see. What is your opinion on dungeons?
>>44619569
Why are there 8 giants in a ship which can only hold 4
where can I find some good overworld hex maps?
>>44609106
Dood, hermit-crabs need their profiency to carry their heavy shell as protection. Counts as plate armor bro!
