Is Rivers a HoF quarterback? What about Rapistburger? Or Eli?
Eli yeah
Rivers no
Burger yeah
Unless the chargers win an owl in the next few years Rivers isn't gonna get in, and the chargers are cursed so Rivers isn't getting in. The other two might not be first ballot but they'lll get in
>>64113590
Eli absolutely is not a HoF QB, rings or not.
>>64113730
I don't necessarily disagree with you but the media will vote him in regardless
>>64113730
Surpassing HOF Dan Fouts on the passing yards list and getting closer to 300 TD passes? Yeah he's gonna be HOF and you'll just have to like it.
>>64113730
Why? He has the stats and the rings.
>>64113575
>Rivers
Should he: borderline
Will he: without a ring, I doubt it
>Roethlisberger
Should he: Yes
Will he: Yes
>Eli
Should he: No
Will he: Probably
>>64113730
he shouldn't be, but playing in NY (NJ really) will put him in the HOF
>>64113844
>Eli
>no
give me some legitimate reasons why outside of hurr durr autism maymay.
What makes Roethlisberger better than Eli? They were both carried to owls by good defenses and just above average throwers. Is it just Ben's >muh durability
>>64113876
Super bowls do not equal hall of fame. That's the only thing Manning had. Rivers will get in without winning one.
>>64113876
he's never been a top 5 QB in the league in any year during his career
>>64113916
Ben is better, but I'm pretty sure Eli has gone the longest without missing a start in the history of the position.
>>64113974
I thought that was Favre, by a wide margin too
>>64113974
in that regard it's 1) Farve, 2) Peyton, 3) Eli
>>64113940
yeah he's on pace to throw more than 50,000 passing yards and 300+ TD passes. Add 2 SB rings on top of that you have a HOF get fucked.
>>64113575
Ben is a lock for the Hall of Fame. Maybe not first ballot, but he will get it.
Eli has a strong argument to get it. Hasn't missed a game in +10 years with slightly above average stats, but the two rings vs. Belichick cannot be ignored.
Rivers won't make it, even if he might deserve it.
>>64113844
Fouts never got a ring and rivers wont either. Rivers gets in on the technicality he has stats
>>64114036
that would be impressive if guys like Matt Stafford weren't on the same pace with the new passing rules
>tfw if Eli wasn't such a little bitch about getting drafted by the chargers RIvers could've gotten to go somewhere else that wasn't a shithole of a franchise
the hall has a boner for qbs, they'll probably all get in eventually
>>64114223
>mfw Stafford gets in
>>64114138
If Fouts is in, Rivers def gets in with or w/o muh ring
>>64114213
>>64114241
cutler too probly, even though he ain't won shit
Rivers no
Eli yes, made not first ballot
Now Rapelisburger is a trick one, if he wins another ring yes. If he stays with 2 rings I'm not sure if he will because of all those sex scandals, maybe it'll took a couple of tries
>>64114381
I don't see how Burgers a question considering he's a legit contender for the best quarterback in Steelers history
>>64113575
Yes rivers and Berger should be, they both have top ten career passer ratings, so far... Eli is only 37th... Nuff said
If rivers get 1 ring he is in
>>64114548
well we know that's not going to happen, so what then
>>64113575
Only Roethlisberger
>Rivers will never get a fucking ring
please please please for the love of god trade him before it's too late
>>64114846
It's literally one of the worst tragedies of professional sports
>>64113575
Maybe rapist and Eli but rivers might get in 40 years down the road
>>64114251
Letting Foust in was a fucking mistake
>>64113954
This is the end of every pro-Eli argument.
Eli and Ben are no brainers at this point and Ben has honestly gotten better as a passer these past 2 years and has a stacked offense. Ben may move up an echelon on the QB totem pole before his career is over.
>>64114381
You're dead wrong. Ben has the strongest case out of all. He would get in if he retired today
>>64113730
Asspained Patriots fan detected. How many QBs have two super bowl rings? (Winning both from Tom Brady no less...)
>>64114874
He is a serial choker and very mediocre player overall. He had tons of shots. At one point, he had a good defense and LT and Antonio Gates.
