[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Home]
4chanarchives logo
>yeah. A big part of the play is depicting Romeo as an outsider,
Images are sometimes not shown due to bandwidth/network limitations. Refreshing the page usually helps.

You are currently reading a thread in /pol/ - Politically Incorrect

Thread replies: 82
Thread images: 14
File: 1464840119283.jpg (217 KB, 1140x641) Image search: [Google]
1464840119283.jpg
217 KB, 1140x641
>yeah. A big part of the play is depicting Romeo as an outsider, making him an outsider ethnicity really helps depict that.

>Shakespeare would have loved it

>>>/lit/8114783

/lit/, everyone
>>
>>75898576

Well at least they kill themselves and don't spread half-dindus around.
>>
>>75898576
Coal burner pays the toll. Good.
>>
>>75898576
Is that the cutie from game of thrones ?
>>
File: Cucked.jpg (50 KB, 540x627) Image search: [Google]
Cucked.jpg
50 KB, 540x627
>>75898576
Tbqh, Romeo and Juliet makes a lot more sense when depicted within the context of an interracial relationship.
>>
>>75898945
Yeah
>>
>having a nigger play nobility in italy from a few hundred years ago when they had no niggers besides slaves in the colonies
TOP FUCKING KEK
WE WUZ SHAKESPEAR AND SHITZ
>>
>>75899090
Yes, in the modern world. But I don't think it's set in the modern world
>>
File: 1464376677800.png (170 KB, 521x495) Image search: [Google]
1464376677800.png
170 KB, 521x495
>>75898576
WE
>>
>>75900775
This. For almost all of post-Roman Empire Italian history, a black Romeo wpuld be assumed to be an invading North African Muslim and would be killed on sight by both families united. The reason for this is constant raiding by Muslim pirates.
>>
>>75900960
Where are the African intelectuals?
>>
File: 1463526710503.gif (4 MB, 158x223) Image search: [Google]
1463526710503.gif
4 MB, 158x223
>O Romeo, Romeo, wherefore art thou Romeo?
>ooga booga bix nood modafucka
>>
File: 1464797161762.png (97 KB, 265x258) Image search: [Google]
1464797161762.png
97 KB, 265x258
>>75901337
we were monarchs and stuff
>>
Romeo, a symbol of a promising younge man with everything going his way more than a character; is absolutely not an outsider. The whole star crossed lovers being out of their minds in love and trading the world for a chance at a lower class life in hiding doesn't have any dramatic weight if Romeo is some wall flower paste licker that gave up a job at dad's company being an embarrassment. The kids fall hard for each other and it changes everything while changing nothing; it's a cautionary tale, a romantic dream, a social commentary, and a timeless work of art because Romeo isn't some weirdo, outsider that nobody relates to. He's every young man in the audience and he's every father's son. A black actor playing romeo means less than nothing to the play and it's only damaging the performance to cast anyone but the best actor you can find. The crowd of progressives that shoe horn minorities undermine them and promote the stereotypes that already exist. A quota of black actors with a tranny director and a gender queer juliet (s/Julio mind the pro noun of the day shit lords) will not put on a good play; so you shame the audience and brand them racist. This is communist Russia level logic, it's fucking Animal Farm and the majority of the good people are working harder and harder to support everyone else never suspecting the trip to the glue factory waiting for them.
>>
/lit/, /mu/, and /co/ are nothing but Marxist-Leninist hives.
>>
>>75902540
Reminder that it was literally a Romantic-Comedy of it's day.
>>
>>75902679
No, that would be something like As You Like It. Romeo and Juliet ends with both lovers killing themselves.
>>
>>75902903
And you obviously haven't seen enough rom-coms
>>
>>75902975
Saying Romeo and Juliet is a rom-com is like calling Titanic a rom-com
>>
File: 1460416931838.jpg (76 KB, 733x672) Image search: [Google]
1460416931838.jpg
76 KB, 733x672
RRRRRRRRRREEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE
>>
>>75902679
>literally a Romantic-Comedy of it's day.
false. Shakespear had 2 different kinds if plays he wrote about and he detailed this quite thoroughly. He wrote about comedy, aka a midsummer nights dream, and he wrote about tragedy, aka Macbeth and Romeo and Juliet. The play is a tragedy as stated by Shakespear himself
>>
>>75903136
He also had history, like Henry V
>>
>>75898576
>A big part of the play is depicting Romeo as an outsider

>entire thing is about two feuding families who know all about one another
>>
>>75903136
>>75903279
And plays like The Tempest that are sometimes called romances and don't really fit the other categories.
>>
>>75900654
You do know that's not the case, right? That, during the sixteenth century, there were black people both in England and Italy?

Not from Italian nobility, sure. But we have primary sources in England discussing "blackamores" "black neigros" and "black moores."

And no--they weren't slaves. There were no slaves in England. Oh and the primary sources? Marriage records from the white people they married.
>>
>>75898576
>AYO BITCH, WHAT DAT LIGHT BE ON YA ROOF?
>I BEEN THINKING IT DA SUN, BUT IT IS YOU CUS YOU IS A FINE ASS BITCH!

Literally poetry.
>>
Don't worry guys, for you idiots that don't know the story they both kill themselves at the end.
>>
File: Ota_Benga_at_Bronx_Zoo.jpg (63 KB, 500x375) Image search: [Google]
Ota_Benga_at_Bronx_Zoo.jpg
63 KB, 500x375
>>75904661
Didn't know they had zoos in the 16th century, but it is an easy mistake to make.
>>
>>75904661
citation required
>>
>>75899090
>Interracial
Homosexual relationship makes just as much sense,maybe even more.I'd watch a Romeo and Julius desu senpai.
>>
>>75905526
Really? Are you just illiterate and don't know that one of Shakespeare's most famous plays is about.... guess what? Interracial marriage?
>>
>>75905637
citation required
>>
>>75905635
>Julius drinks some AIDS blood
>>
>>75905767
No. It really, really isn't. You've never heard of Othello? I didn't know Canadian education was this bad.
>>
>>75905635
a lesbian one would be better if the couple looked like this
>>
>>75898576
The entire play is about satirizing teenage love and making fun of what morons teenagers are. And the terrible decisions they make.

How is it about "depicting Romeo as an outsider".

Not to mention of course that, according to leftist logic, calling a nigger an outsider just for being a nigger is extremely racist, as it implies niggers are outsiders to our (multicultural) society
>>
>>75905842
>Othello
you know that its never actually stated what his race is in the play and people just think hes black because of a slang term used right? holy shit you are dumb
>>
>>75906158
You...

You don't actually believe that, right?

You're just shitposting?
>>
>>75906276
>ARE YOU KIDDING ME????
If his arguments are so full retard then why don't you counter them faggot
>>
>>75906276
>There is no consensus over Othello's ethnic origin. E. A. J. Honigmann, the editor of the Arden Shakespeare edition, concluded that Othello's race is ambiguous

https://www.jstor.org/stable/2866304?seq=1#page_scan_tab_contents
>>
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Merchant_of_Venice

Shakespeare was a pretty /pol/ guy.
>>
I think its fine. Shakespeares plays are meant to be portrayed by tons of actors everywhere.

I see no problems with this unless it was done for SJW means which we don't really have any proof.
>>
>>75904661
>That, during the sixteenth century, there were black people both in England and Italy?

Yeah, all five of them.
>>
>>75906276
Othello has been more frequently played as an Arab, i.e. a Moor, than a nigger.

Do you even read Shakespeare, Nigger?
>>
>>75898576
>po/lit/buro
yeah no
>>
>>75906557
except for the fact the same people that think romeo should be played by a nigger are the same people who have problems with white actors playing non white roles. They cant have it both ways.

Either white people can play any race and niggers can play any race, or people should play roles of their own race.
>>
>>75898576
He wasn't an outsider though, both families belonged to that town
>>
>>75905842
>No. It really, really isn't. You've never heard of Othello?

Moors weren't black.
>>
>>75906812
>He wasn't an outsider though, both families belonged to that town

He was not only an insider, he was from a privileged, wealthy background.
>>
>>75898576

How the fuck was Romeo an outsider? He was a Montague through and through, that was the whole fucking point.
>>
>>75905821
>Romeo drinks the AIDS blood
>Julius stabs himself with a pink dragon dildo
>>
>>75906674
If people say romeo should be played by black people is one thing, people who say romeo should be played by anyone is another.

Unless you bring me proof that the man got his role specifically cause hes black then I'm on board on the lynch train.
>>
>>75907074
>Unless you bring me proof that the man got his role specifically cause hes black
its literally in the OP that they want to make it an interracial thing and have romeo be an outsider. This would not be the case if he was white.
>>
>>75904661
You're bluffing. Marriage certificates in England and Italy would not have shown race. You got that from your lit class and not your renassaince history class. If not, lets see these primary sources since they will be easily available online. That being said, in the play Othello, whether Othelo was black or an Arab, he certainly is quite the scene in Venice, suggesting that the local Venetians aren't used to people of his race.
>>
Romeo wasn't an outsider.

Romeo and Juliet is about a family feud between two powerful families that lived right next to each other, saw each other everyday.
>>
The whole point of the story was the both families were extremely alike, the same, and were fighting over bullshit.

Two white families, who have similar genetics, background, social level fight over bullshit.

It's about white on white violence.
>>
File: 1447556404448.jpg (552 KB, 1625x1117) Image search: [Google]
1447556404448.jpg
552 KB, 1625x1117
>>75898576
>>yeah. A big part of the play is depicting Romeo as an outsider, making him an outsider ethnicity really helps depict that.
>>Shakespeare would have loved it

Shakespeare wrote his works with blacks (moors) in them. He chose NOT to make Romeo black. What the fuck is the logic of "would have loved it"?

Might as well say Romeo should be portrayed as a green martian with three legs going ACK ACK ACK because it emphasizes how he's "an outsider".

Fucking pseudointellectual cucks.
>>
>>75907578
>Shakespeare wrote his works with blacks (moors)

Moors weren't black.
>>
>>75898576
Shakespeare would have loved it, considering he has a different play that involves a outsider black man as the hero. He has a white wife and everything. White people are mad jelly bigots and ruin everything.

Uncultured faggot.
>>
>>75907578
>blacks (moors)
t.
>>
>>75907668
>>75907959

Aren't they part black?
>>
File: y5Rh_22T[1].jpg (55 KB, 512x512) Image search: [Google]
y5Rh_22T[1].jpg
55 KB, 512x512
>>75898576
http://www.nationalreview.com/article/shakespeare-white-stop-teaching

yo furrill who even give a shit bout what some dead crackkka wrote 200 hunnit yiez ago
>>
>>75907668
>Moors weren't black.
>>75907959

Othello the moor literally says:
>"black as mine own face"

You people are as bad as the /lit/ cucks.
>>
>>75908183
"Black" could just mean dark or swarthy. Kind of like how the Greeks may have described someone as having fair skin when it was just a lighter shade of brown. His race is was not definite, and back then Moorish was very fucking broad.
>>
>>75907668
You should read Titus Andronicus, Act IV, Scene ii.
>>
>>75907668
>Canadian
>Commenting on whiteness
>>
>>75898576
Act VII : Juliet is working for tips to raise Tyrone, Deshawn and Jamal all by herself.

Neggromeo went to find another Juliet in the lands of pussified white boys.
>>
>>75904661
The only blacks there would be traveling Muslim merchants
>>
File: 1464793554325.jpg (394 KB, 1319x1174) Image search: [Google]
1464793554325.jpg
394 KB, 1319x1174
>>75907578
>blacks (moors)
Just so you know, that's what moors think of blacks.
>>
>>75908619
>"Black" could just mean dark or swarthy.

Is this some kind of reverse WE WUZ by a buttmad dego?

The character has been portrayed as a black man since fucking medieval times.

And either way it doesn't change the fact that Shakespeare was aware black people existed and still chose to not make Romeo black, my point about a martian heritage swap stands and you can fuck off.
>>
>>75900775
>>75901321

Shakespearean plays are timeless and can done in many different ways. There was once a production of Othello where patrick stewart played Othello and the entire cast was black. In theater you can definitely do racial casting like this. As long as it is not a historical film I am not usually upset by black, white, yellow or whatever washing.

I agree with the other anons about Yuri Rome and Juliet tho, or maybe instead of the obvious black guy white chick, how about black chick white guy?
>>
>>75909122
And my point is, Moors weren't exclusively black, you faggot. What are we even arguing about anymore?
>>
>>75908109

lol! some historian even debate the identity of shakespeare. Fucking english teachers shouldn't be talking about plays ffs
>>
File: Shakespeare and Outsiders.jpg (115 KB, 980x699) Image search: [Google]
Shakespeare and Outsiders.jpg
115 KB, 980x699
>>75898576
Shakespeare was obsessed with outsiders. Most of his plays feature at least one: Caliban, Cleopatra, Malvolio, Antonio, Shylock, Jaques, witches, fairies, and more.
It's not a bad suggestion to think of Romeo as an outsider. He goes into exile, after all, and Baz Luhrman picks up on the marginality of this quite nicely.

>>75906401
Othello is a Moor. This is a term that doesn't have a modern translation, since it's an intersection of ethnicity, religion, and geography.

Shakespeare scholar here killing time. AMA. Most posts in this thread are retarded and terribly ill informed.
>>
File: romeo.jpg (26 KB, 220x355) Image search: [Google]
romeo.jpg
26 KB, 220x355
>>75898576
>yeah a big part of the play is depicting Romeo as an outside, making him an outsider species really helps that

>shakespeare would have loved it
>>
>>75910052

okay. Is it true that shakespeare was many people, or is that just a myth?
>>
>>75910342
Just one person. The evidence is quite solid, mostly in legal documents about the Globe, his residences, his property ownership in Stratford, and also in regional allusions and vocabulary in his plays.

However, he definitely did collaborate, like with Fletcher on The Two Noble Kinsmen and Henry VIII, with Middleton on Macbeth, and with many on Sir Thomas More.

The conspiracy stuff about authorship is /pol/ tier shit that belongs with area 52, Elvis lives, and the Loch Ness monster.
>>
>>75909122
Shakespeare wrote the play in the Elizabethan period.... Long after the Middle Ages.... And you don't know how he was portrayed then, but there is no evidence the actor wore blackface
>>
File: 11 Peacham sketch - 1595.jpg (793 KB, 1057x1363) Image search: [Google]
11 Peacham sketch - 1595.jpg
793 KB, 1057x1363
>>75911682
There is evidence of blackface being employed. The only picture we have of a Shakespeare play being performed in Shakespeare's time is of a scene in Titus Andronicus where Aaron the Moor is pleasing with the Goth Queen Tamora. The actor is clearly very dark in skin tone and there were no black actors in Shakespeare's company.
>>
>>75899090
>projecting modern """"values"""" onto an age old play

Kill yourself.
>>
>>75899090
OTHELLO IS ACTUALLY ABOUT AN INTERRACIAL RELATIONSHIP AND THE TENSIONS INVOLVED

YOU DON'T NEED TO CHANGE ROMEO AND JULIET WHEN THERE'S A FUCKING PLAY THAT HAS WHAT YOU WANT RIGHT FUCKING THERE
>>
>>75909476
there are a lot of things you "can" do, but first you should ask yourself if you "should"
Thread replies: 82
Thread images: 14

banner
banner
[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Home]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
If a post contains personal/copyrighted/illegal content you can contact me at [email protected] with that post and thread number and it will be removed as soon as possible.
DMCA Content Takedown via dmca.com
All images are hosted on imgur.com, send takedown notices to them.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from them. If you need IP information for a Poster - you need to contact them. This website shows only archived content.