What does /pol/ think of the movie Saving Private Ryan
>German Soldiers automatically throwing their guns down and surrendering
>American Soldiers execute unarmed Germans and mocked them for surrendering expect they'd be taking back as prisoners
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ny_9fkj8_qQ
>>75242079
>>>German Soldiers automatically throwing their guns down and surrendering
>>American Soldiers execute unarmed Germans and mocked them for surrendering expect they'd be taking back as prisoners
Well that DID happen. Germans were pussies when outnumbered, if they had fought like their Jap allies they would have won easily.
>>75242079
Cuckold bullshit.
>Spielberg
>berg
Delete this thread and yourself you ignoramus
>>75242079
> murricans do a movie about a glorious tank that alone saved thousands of poor "murrian civilians" in the middle of Germany
> the truth is that is was the exact opposite and the whole "legend" is about a nazi panzer tank that bravely defended poor german citizens
classic murrica, masters of propaganda
>>75242420
Did anyone actually see that movie?
>>75242079
It's pretty damn good production wise, though I wasn't overly impressed with the rest of the film.
anyone got the translation of the surrendering germans
>>75242079
>>75242763
>>German Soldiers automatically throwing their guns down and surrendering
Those were ukranian conscripts. They spoke ukranian not german. They're literally saying "We're ukranian conscripts."
>>75242782
they were Czech weren't they?
>>75242079
That's the weirdest edit I've ever seen. Tom Hanks wasn't in Saving Private Ryan and I can't work out what point is being made by implying he was.
>>75242701
Yeah it was pretty good actually
>>75242079
>hurr americans would nevar shoot surrendering soldiers.
>Also we were justified bombing Hiroshima, fucking nip children
The guys surrendering at 3:00 are speaking czech because they were just conscripts forced to fight.
>>75242420
Just searched it up - it's an amalgamation of allied tank stories - wardaddy was a real tank commander and the tank last stand was an unconfirmed anecodate about a lone allied soldier.
So what are you talking about..
>>75242079
it's garbage. I'm all for showing American heroism, but this is just a pack of lies and propaganda. anyone who has studied the truth about WW2 will most likely agree with me.
It's a very well made even if it was a bit of a spin on WW2.
That slew of WW2 movies that came out in the late 90's/early 00's were prepping Americans for 9/11 and the Iraq/Afghanistan wars by the way.
>>75243135
>anyone who has studied the truth about WW2 will most likely agree with me
Straight out of the fucking gate with no true scotsman. 4chan never lets me down.
>>75242186
Tended to happen if they lost their SAW. They relied on them far too much.
I never watched this movie, since I don't generally watch films that celebrate me being murdered.
However if they showed that, it's pretty commendable that they did. And yes it is true. The Allied Nations were and still are really awful to the German people.
>>75242079
Very good production values and scene setting for the Normandy landings and the body count seen, but things like shooting a sniper through his own telescopic sight are ridiculous.
>>75242701
Yeah, it was pretty bad. The ending is ridiculous.
>>75243374
What a faggot, no bloody wonder you lost.
>>75243428
You lost you piece of shit Pakis Island Pajeet.
>>75242186
unlike japs germans had possitive KD on all fronts. hell, japs got even fcking rekt so hard by soviets.... they were terrible fighters
>>75243465
A better comeback would have been - "You watch tv everyday celebrating being murdered, the BBC", or literally anything. However your slav rape baby brain could barely formulate a thought after having expended itself totally reading my sentence. Just remember it's 2-0 Wilhelm.
Srsly how can anybody think Germany lost WW2?
We're the strongest nation in Europe now. A German-American is about to be elected president by a landslide. Germanophobia is dead outside of a few stupid Brits and Polacks.
Face it we won the war. The long war. Britain and France and Russia are nothing, and America basically belongs to our people.
>>75243560
That KD was worth shit when millions of them died anyway in gulags and POW camps.
>>75242186
>Germans were pussies when outnumbered
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Tannenberg
>>75243638
No it's 4-1 and we raped you pretty hard. You're still not over it, apparently.
https://www.theguardian.com/football/2010/jun/27/germany-england-world-cup-2010
I'm just glad there were no niggers in it which would be illegal in modern cinema. Vin Diesel isn't 'black'.
>>75243652
You just dropped off the boat right?
>>75242420
Fury is a fucking joke, every single German soldier is a complete autist with the intelligence level of a tree.
>>75243770
Wrong link
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Tannenberg_Line
Both are great victories for the Germans however
>>75243220
what do you mean? that isn't a 'no true scottsman' fallacy. by that statement, I meant that I would imagine most people who know the truth about the war would see this film as highly inaccurate and thus, hard to take seriously. 'most likely' is the key phrase there, yes? no true scotsman is dealing with absolute 'one or the other' issues, yes?
>>75243652
and Germany belongs to the muslims
i dont understand how any german can still have pride...your people are the worst, destroyed europe 3 times: ancient rome,ww1 and ww2
you people should keep your profile low and shut up, shit country with people who are proud of being anarchist shits
>>75243652
The germany in charge of the EU today is not the germany of the 20th century, nor is it even your germany. It's a left-wing elite doing its best to remove germanic culture and to replace it with islam.
I would call that a pyrrhic victory personally. At least we had 50 years of being genuine victors before the same happened to us.
>>75242079
>Spielberg
Another kike propaganda film, into the trash
>>75243907
No, a no true scotsman is one in which you define the categories. You decide what 'true' is and such have a failsafe in case of dissent.
In your case you can just say what you think "true" history is and if someone doesn't agree with you then they clearly haven't studied "true" history.
>>75243824
> Cares about football when he is being raped sideways to saturday.
Also that '1' was one of the best wins in history. Germans will never recover.
>>75242782
They spoke czech you fucking faggot.
>>75242420
so what is the "original" story ? source
>>75244033
hmm...well, I have to concede that you have a point. I didn't intend for my comment to make that point, but looking at it from your perspective, I do see what you mean. thank you, sir. always appreciate one who can keep my brain on track.
>>75244125
czech is just a weird bavarian dialect anyway
>>75243315
I think you mean Famas.
>>75244298
shut your blasphemous mouth
>>75244319
I think you mean Deagle.
>>75242845
Yes he was lol.
He was literally the main character
>>75242420
This movie was such shit. I fucking hate Brad Pitt.
>>75242079
>Spielberg looking for cheap, tear jerking Oscar moments
>tell me I was a good man, lel
>Germans fight like Keystone cops
What's not to dislike?
>>75242845
Dude.
You fell out of your universe and into ours. I'm sorry.
):
>>75243427
Audie Murphys last stand in Italy my friend
>>75244319
Do you actually know what SAW stands for?
>>75244510
Surface Air Wocket
>>75243916
somebody iss angryyyyyyyyyyyyyy JUDEENNNNN
>>75242079
Czech people died in the movie therefore 0/10
>>75244437
Alpha as fuck haircut though.
>>75242079
Lots of Yanks die so quite enjoyable.
>>75244298
No Czech is best :(
>>75243652
You guys are shells of your former selves. The Kaiser would be disappointing.
Left wing petulant cucks
>>75244510
Squad automatic Weapon
>>75244817
disappointed...stupid phone.
Americans and Anglos would NEVER,EVER defeat Nazi Germany if it wasn't for Russians.
People forget that 85-90% of German army was wiped out in the Eastern Front.
Yet even as it was,you fuckers had a hell of a hard time liberating France and advancing to Germany.
That was the first 'big' movie without hurr durr mentality, so it's ok
>>75243560
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Lake_Khasan
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battles_of_Khalkhin_Gol
Pay particular attention to the casualty numbers dipshit.
>but muh Manchurian offensive
Nothing but kicking in the door of an already beaten enemy.
>>75242420
The only good things about this movie is the autistic attention to detail with kit and vehicles, but the way both armies tactically is pure fantasy.
Examples include. The Tiger tank continuing to advance forward towards the shermans it could have just stood stationary.
Also the movie seems to forget the Waffen SS troops at the end of the movie are armed with Panzerfausts (despite establishing how dangerous they are at the start of the movie and then showing guys in the SS column carrying them).
The soundtrack was decent tho.
>>75244215
>/pol/ btfo
>>75242186
Another drive-by brain fart by a "Mexican Intellectual"
>>75245007
One of Dan Carlin's Hardcore History podcasts he describes Germans marching it was cool.
>tfw you will never defend the Tannenberg line with you Axis bros, slaughtering Russians by the thousands
Why even live
>>75243638
actually u lost. lost ur empire for no reason. without losing a war. and maybe now losing scotland. u maybe chose the wrong side ;)
>>75243878
kek
>>75243935
this. but just 20 years until u gave up ur empire for no reason
>>75242079
you don't like my movie?
>>75242079
Was pretty awesome. She had a dozen guys. One of them found out, beat her up so bad she ended up at a hospital of Guerrero street.
>>75242079
It's over the top Steven Spielburgerstein, all of his movies are over the top and way overrated.
The movie itself is stupid and completely unrealistic in the ways that matter most.
>>75242420
Fury was pretty good tank porn.
The plot itself was even okay aside from the ridiculous final battle.
