[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Home]
4chanarchives logo
Do you think the good guys won WWI?
Images are sometimes not shown due to bandwidth/network limitations. Refreshing the page usually helps.

You are currently reading a thread in /pol/ - Politically Incorrect

Thread replies: 101
Thread images: 14
File: 1432179546463.jpg (2 MB, 4614x2986) Image search: [Google]
1432179546463.jpg
2 MB, 4614x2986
>>
>>73053479
WWI isn't black and white
There were no good, or bad guys just a tragic mess of old treaties, and alliances mixed with the closing of the age of imperialism and the underestimation of tactics with modern warfare
>>
>>73053479
>There is no right nor wrong i can do what i want
>Stole french clay
>Kill thousands of innocent people who want their clay back
>Lose the clay you stolen
>It was a joke m8 don't hate me kay
>Your treaty IS BAD AND EVIL
>>
>Good guys won WWI
>Good goys won WWII
>>
>>73053479

The goy guys defintely won
>>
>>73053479
Yes.

Imperialism is just as gross as any other multiculti bullshit. And of course nothing could make one happier than seeing the roaches get BTFO
>>
No one won WW1.
>>
Germans had by far the most impressive military machine of the war, and absolutely rekt both the French and British while knocking Russia out of the war on the other front.

If the US had not gotten involved, Germany would have easily won the war.
>>
>>73054341
was the treaty really necessary?
>>
>>73055962
>USA! USA! USA!
>check flag
Like clockwork
>>
>>73053479
Of course. We destroyed Germany for 20 years. Good thing.
>>
File: 1460955763667.jpg (99 KB, 750x479) Image search: [Google]
1460955763667.jpg
99 KB, 750x479
>>73053479
While not a TV villain, Willy really fucked some shit up. He randomly broke the alliance with his cousin Nicholas, broke his diplomatic mission in France and started the dreadnought race with the UK. In an interview of a British newspaper, he claimed that most Germans hate the British people... He even threatened the King of Belgium with invasion if he didn't help him attack France... IN A FUCKING PARTY. He WANTED a war. In the end, he only remained friends with his cultural brethren in Austria, but only out of necessity.
>hurr durr, i am germany, i will fuck up my diplomatic relationships and open 3 potential fronts
>>
There was no good guys during WW1, just the blood of the working classes of Europe.
>>
Yeah. Dissolving Austria-Hungary was just opening that region up to a long series of utter political and economic catastrophes and descent to complete irrelevance.
>>
>>73055962

Russia was pushed back to its knees.

Then they developed a superior tank to the Panzers and steamrolled the Germans all the way back to Berlin.

It would have been interesting to see what would have happened in Russia if Germany did not have to dedicate resources to the Western front and North Africa.
>>
>>73053479
No matter who won either, everybody would've lost
>>
I am sympathetic towards WW1 Germany. It was due to the jealousy of the western powers that they lost, a war they hadnt even started. their great growth, industrial might and empire building posed a threat to old stagnant nations. In many ways they were much better, their industry was the way of the future and they had much more developed systems of workers rights, social supports, etc... The french were bitter after old losses, britain wary to germany's growing naval empire, entirely hypocritical. Oh and once again, Germany hadnt even started that fucking war. godamn Austrians
>>
>>73054341
> french clay
>>
>>73056041
do you not think the US intervention was decisive?
>>
The USA were the only "winners" of World War One. Everybody else lost badly
>>
>>73056645
>The British and the French have an army twice the size of the US army
>fucking Romania has more combat casualties than the US
No
>>
>>73056645
not really lads, cheers for the help but it wasn't as big as you guys make out.
>>
>>73055981
The Versailles treaty was fucking nothing, Krauts didn't pay shit anyway. You guys seems to forget the war happened on French territory. Cities were destroyed, the land was ruined and you couldn't grow shit after the war. Hell, they still find WW1 bombshell where I live from time to time. Germany should have been dismantled after the war. This thing has no reason to exist.
>>
>>73056579

/thread

>muh natural borders
>muh turkish alliance to constantly keep Europe as a blood pump
>muh let's betray the Catholic League to sate my penis envy towards the Habsburgs

>League of Cambrai
>War of Devolution
>War of the Spanish Succession
>Seven Years War

>fucking Revolutionary wars and muh NAPOLEON

>why are Germans so bloodthirsty and evil? :^)
>>
>>73056990

t. frog cuck
>>
>>73055981
It was, the germans at that time were like muslims, they wanted to conquer as much lands as possible
>>
>>73056990

Then maybe you shouldn't have declared war...

You slimy fucks.
>>
>>73056990
What?

They literally only finished paying it back a few years ago
>>
>>73056492
But none of that happened in WWI.
>>
>>73057182
>Then maybe you shouldn't have declared war...
Nice meme, faggot. They literally asked for it.
>>
>>73055962
>>73055962
If the USA had entered the war in the allied side earlier, Germany would have been defeated earlier:
No rise of Communism in Imperial Russia.
No rise of National Socialism post war in Germany.
No punishing Versailles Treaty and Post War inflation in Germany.
>>
>>73057310
Fuck sake, why did honest Tommys die fighting to defend land that the Franks couldn't defend themselves, they're our traditional enemies and the Krauts where always close to us
>>
>>73057498
Because Churchill was owned by the Jewish bankers in London
>>
>>73057562
In the First World War?
>>
>>73057722
sorry. I didn't know which one you were on about
>>
>>73053872
Nonsense, the triple entente (Britain, France, Russia) won it. Evil cunts who had been murdering, raping, and pillaging the world for hundreds of years.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Triple_Entente

Reminder that the world wars were probably instigated by them in the first place to defeat opposition and consolidate their control.
>>
File: LolSoviets.png (19 KB, 532x300) Image search: [Google]
LolSoviets.png
19 KB, 532x300
>>73056492
Have you never opened a history book in your life? The Russians had the T-34 before the Germans invaded, which they Germans easily countered by using anti-tank guns and vastly superior tactics.
And the Soviets never developed superior tanks, but simply relied on numbers alone. They were constantly raped by the Germans in battle up until the last few months of the war. The Germans didn't lose because they were outfought. They lost because they didn't have the endless resources and manpower of the allies.
>>
File: germany_bombs_london.jpg (55 KB, 640x360) Image search: [Google]
germany_bombs_london.jpg
55 KB, 640x360
>>73057498
Don't be a cuck, William

Germans are fiends who always try to destroy the Europe.
>>
Why do you cunts keep mixing WW1 with WW2?
>>
>>73055842
>Imperialism is bad.
If cousre good for nothinh norway doednt know the glories of imperialism.
It turned irrelevant England into the Mighty, All powerful British Empire.
>>
>>73058087
Why is their a huge patch of monarchless nations with boring tricolours in Europe Franc?
>>
File: 1447706865348.gif (894 KB, 628x341) Image search: [Google]
1447706865348.gif
894 KB, 628x341
>>73053479
German blood is evil.
>>
>>73053479
The West was the loser in WWI.
>>
>>73058340
>defending Frank
>after napoleon
>after based Prussia helped us

Becoming friends with the Frog is the greatest insult to our ancestors bar letting your daughter fuck Abdul
>>
>>73053872
/thread

>>73054341
>>73055693
>>73056119
>>73056990
>>73057137
>>73057310
>>73058087
>all dem butthurt cheese eating surrender monkeys
>>
> give A-H a blank check when negotiating with serbia, thereby escalating what was a regional conflict
> invade a neutral country in order to invade France
> somehow not clearly the bad guys

ok
>>
File: 1460493380394.jpg (32 KB, 300x300) Image search: [Google]
1460493380394.jpg
32 KB, 300x300
>>73058545
Fuck off back to Pakistan Ahmed
>>
>>73058722
>WW1
>>
>>73056990

You fail to mention the million and half French men killed, and millions more wounded as well as destroying all the French coal mines before pulling out of French territories...

If anything France didn't get anything out of the Treaty of Versailles except for Alsace Lorraine which belonged to France anyway.

>>73058597

You lost both wars you cunt.

Anyway rape of belgium in WW1 and Poland in WW2, invading neutral countries, invading France twice in twenty five years causing massive damages and human losses in the process. Even a fucking genocide while at it.

>we dindu nuthinn' :'( :'( :'(

Fuck you Germany, I for one welcome the death of your people and culture.
>>
>>73058776
(that was WWI m80)
>>
>>73053479
Yes thanks for the islands
>>
>>73053479
No.
Absolutely not.
>>
File: 90154_max.jpg (8 KB, 269x187) Image search: [Google]
90154_max.jpg
8 KB, 269x187
>>73058956
Oh fuck I misread A-H as Adolf Hitler not Austria-Hungary.
>>
File: spankie.jpg (56 KB, 500x346) Image search: [Google]
spankie.jpg
56 KB, 500x346
>>73058883
>You lost both wars you cunt.

not due to you frogs m80

>Anyway rape of belgium in WW1 and Poland in WW2, invading neutral countries, invading France twice in twenty five years causing massive damages and human losses in the process. Even a fucking genocide while at it.
now thats metal, isnt it?
>>
>>73057498

Because Germany was building a navy that could have challenged the British navy, they had huge colonial ambitions as well as the largest population in mainland Europe.

Your leaders just did what they always did to maintain the balance of power. If anything it's Franks who died in droves for your bullshit.

None of this wouldn't have happened if you kept out of French affairs the years following the 1789 revolution.
>>
>>73054341
>muh clay
>>
File: 1460342160277.jpg (48 KB, 960x960) Image search: [Google]
1460342160277.jpg
48 KB, 960x960
>>73059171
>tfw all of Germany's ambitions could've been curbed if they had a decisive loss in the Franco-Prussian war
>>
>>73059160

It's all because of France you lost the first world war. You really think the British had a massive impact in the first decisive months of the war with their micro penis of a land army?

Germany was a lot more populated, more industrialized, your military better equipment in 1914. You still failed.
>>
>>73059362
Napoleon III was a cuck.
>>
>>73059461
Britain is the only reason you exist, we introduced Tanks (winning the worlds first tank battle), held the Somme and innovated in ways that a filthy frank would find as alien as deodorant
>>
>>73059461
hahahaha funny that you say that since you had massive deserters no morale why german military was high morale no deserters better officeers war is sadly a numbers game and the french were always good at getting others to fight
>>
File: ww1.png (18 KB, 345x271) Image search: [Google]
ww1.png
18 KB, 345x271
>>73059461
> their micro penis of a land army?
>>
>>73057026
based hungaryan New habsburg era when?
>>
>>73056990
>>73057310
>Declare war
>OH MY GOD WHY ARE THEY FIGHTING US!?
>T-they were asking for it!
the fuck?
>>
>>73059843
The British army at the start of the war was about an 1/8th of the size of the Germans, Amir
>>
>>73054341
>Lothringen and Elsass
>French Clay

top kek
>>
Well it certainly royally fucked up my country, the Habsburgs were just about to grant us equal status to Austria and Hungary. And it started all the Yugoslavia shit which resulted in communism ruining us and our mentality.
>>
>>73060142
t. Danish clay
>>
>>73059696

That's one shitty bait.

>>73059611

Britain was first to field tanks , which were complete unreliable garbage, true. However France had more tanks than everyone else when the technology actually became viable enough to have a decisive impact.

Anyway falf the divisions at the Somme were French. How about for once in your history give it a rest with that stolen valor bs...

Didn't see much british at Verdun or la Marne though...

>>73059843

I was talking about the 1914-15, you buffon. I'm starting to think you are actually retarded.
>>
>>73060142
They are french, and they will never be and don't want to be german.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wlogKJhiGOQ
>>
File: FT_17.jpg (363 KB, 735x600) Image search: [Google]
FT_17.jpg
363 KB, 735x600
>>73059611

Best tank of the war coming through.
>>
>>73060244
Country/Men mobilised/Killed
France/8.4m/1.3m
GB/8.9m/908k
Germany/11m/1.7m

http://www.historylearningsite.co.uk/world-war-one/world-war-one-and-casualties/first-world-war-casualties/

>Rossbeef dindu nuffin

Shut up frank
>>
>>73053479
There were no good or bad guys. However Germany did start it.
>>
>>73060761

The BEF in France was only 150k strong at the beginning of the war. Stop pretending you don't know...
>>
>>73060941
>hurr a global empire takes time to mobilise to defend my shitty country

How is that even relevant? We committed more troops than you yet you act as if we sat at home
>>
File: Joker_Venom_(DCAU).jpg (46 KB, 640x480) Image search: [Google]
Joker_Venom_(DCAU).jpg
46 KB, 640x480
>>73054341
Fuck you and your Exocet
>>
>>73056041
He's right
>>
>>73059461
>French soldiers go on strike to no longer attack
>WE WON YOU LOST HAHAHAHAHAHAH


You double nigger. King Albert flooded his god damn country and it took all of the entire British professional army to hold off the Germany war machine from raping your butt.
>>
>>73060871

The jews started it

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lEDPOPr7qiY
>>
>>73061048

I'm just pointing out the fact that Britain didn't have conscription until 1916 and the land army at the beginning of hostilies was tiny compared to French and German armies. Recruiting and training people takes time.

I'm very well aware Brits only commit themselves into wars when their interests are seriously threatened and generally preferably let their allies do the dying.
>>
>>73061048
The Germans were very close to taking Paris and ending the war in the first year if the conflict. The French put up a heroic defense and killed German momentum. Read a book, Achmed.
>>
>>73055962
If Germany didn't try to keep up with British in the Arms race with the Navy they would've been fine.
>>
>>73055875
White race lost millions people
Jews made tons of money
>>
>>73061273
>let their allies do the dying.

You didn't have time to die the 2nd we had to defend your shitty country.

We were also first on the battle field at Waterloo, Prussia merely hammered the last nail home

Or modern day, our workload in Afghanistan and Iraq was far above and beyond what was expected of us while the French and Krauts just held shitty non Kinetic mountain ranges in the north.
>>
File: 1462229108317.png (211 KB, 800x757) Image search: [Google]
1462229108317.png
211 KB, 800x757
>>73053479

if the anglo cannot rule the world..then the ayrian will not either
>>
>>73053479
Yes indeed! Look at what Deutschland is doing now. Totally serving our historical enemy, Islam. If the krauts would work together and implement the Muslim Clock Game they would start a movement to take back their women and dignity. America is on the path to do it by vote. Day one Trump cuts checks to all illegal invaders and they will start trouble cause day not getting Der money! That's when the citizens protect their country and send to Allah in hell!. This Friday starts the Muslim Clock Game. Videos a plus! Maybe the world will finally join in the fun! Pa-yow! Muslim on his ass!
>>
>>73061693
This.

Shut the fuck up Spics, Bratwurst's and Frogs.

>>73061415
>mfw if you actually look at everything, the Brits tried to stop the Jews leaving Germany and placed travel embargos on them, ensuring Hitler killed more of them.

Is your mind blown? It should be.
>>
>>73053479
The world lost WW1. Didn't matter which side would win.
>>
>>73060244
>Didn't see much british at Verdun or la Marne though...

But the entire BEF was present at the marne. And Verdun was a french response to the german offensive.

>>73061273
The British didn't NEED conscription until 1916 where we lost so many men that we needed it to keep strategic parity. Before that there were enough volunteers to field an army able to conduct large scale offensive operations. In 1915 two field armies were activated from volunteers alone.

You should be mad at your commanders who fucked it up so hard in 1914 instead of moaning at everybody else.
>>
>>73053479

It didn't matter who won ww1. What mattered was the u.s. intervention swung the balance of power drastically one way so that the winners could impose strict terms on the loser.

Imagine two even football teams that grind each other down for a whole game. Then a fresh team shows up, fills in for one side and starts kicking ass. Not fair, and would skew the result for sure.
>>
>>73061693

Actually 600k people died in France during WW2.

The RAF bombed my birth place, Brest, until there was nothing but rubbles. No Uboat were harmed in those bombings.

The brits were in bad shape at Waterloo, fighting a second hand army anyway, Wellington would have lost with the Prussians. Where were you during the six previous coalitions anyway? Signing checks while Austrians, Russians and Prussians did all the dying.
>>
>>73061693

>being prood of fighting American wars
>>
>>73061290
This. Taxis literally saved us.
>>
>>73062149

How do you think countries become and maintain themselves as super powers? They get other people to fight their rivals for them. Their decline is when they have to, or start, participating directly themselves. Happened to Britain and it's happening to us.
>>
>>73062074

Not saying US intervention did not push things but Germany was in a much worst shape than the Entente. They were literraly dying of anger thanks to British blockade and the Spanish flu was taking its toll.
>>
>>73053479
There were no good guys in WWI. Or in WWII. Just the elite feeding the young into the meatgrinder.

They wanted their glorious war, and they got it. Also the only time in the 20th century where my country's government acted sensibly. Of course, then we changed the system in 1918, and it all went downhill from there.
>>
>>73062074
The Allies would've been able to beat the Germans eventually even without direct American intervention. After the US declared war, it took a year for American troops to get mobilized and shipped to the front, by then the entente had already picked up an offensive momentum.

American doctrine was horribly out of date with the rest of the entente, they acted more as cannon fodder than anything very useful.

Without American help the war would've gone past 1918, but the Germans still would've lost.
>>
>>73057865
>Britian
>tells people that he's the bad guy
No national pride whatsoever, disgusting.
>>
>>73062149
>bad shape
Our cavalry (which utterly smashed you) was in the best shape in Europe, you're just talking shit now.

Napoleon tried to create diversionary attacks to bog down our reserves but overcommitted himself and had the opposite effect of sapping his own reserves

>>73062190

The reason why aren't the point, the fact is Brits fought hard in the Middle East, the only thing France does is send the FFL to shoot gold diggers in Guyana
>>
>>73062216
Meh. This is inflated propaganda. In reality, there just wasn't a goddamn thing anyone could do to break the stalemate of organised defense in modern war. The only thing that came close was the first German gas attack, and only because it was the first. It was a test attack, but the entire line folded. The Germans didn't have the manpower to take advantage, though. When the Allies started using improvised anti-gas gear during the next attack, the momentum had been lost.
>>
>>73058179
Look at Britain and Sweden and you'll know why.
Thread replies: 101
Thread images: 14

banner
banner
[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Home]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
If a post contains personal/copyrighted/illegal content you can contact me at [email protected] with that post and thread number and it will be removed as soon as possible.
DMCA Content Takedown via dmca.com
All images are hosted on imgur.com, send takedown notices to them.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from them. If you need IP information for a Poster - you need to contact them. This website shows only archived content.