So since the movie is coming out, have you guys discussed the actual politics of the civil war in the comics?
Do you believe that if super powered beings existed that they should come clean and be limited by the government?
Was thinking of going to /b/ but I'm interested in what you guys have to say
>>72334617
>Do you believe that if super powered beings existed that they should come clean and be limited by the government?
Fuck no that is what liberals would want.
If this were all real life I would be donating money to Frank Castles patreon.
>>72334794
fucking seconded dude.
I feel like if superpowered beings existed, we'd never find out about them. They would be hidden away or bribed or killed.
Captain America is lolbertarian and Iron man is a conservative.
Rhodey dies.
>>72334617
Wasn't this written by a Britbong and generally accepted as a poorly written event?
I think they should. Otherwise we would get fucked by one of them who turns out to be a total aspie.
Cap is a dumbass idealist. And somehow the crappy marketing asks you to root for him?
>>72334617
Honestly when I first read it I thought it was a commentary on gun control and the 2nd amendment.
I was wrong
>>72335131
NOBODY dies, fuck off shill
>>72335269
Well, the events of it kinda didn't carry over, but I'm just more interested in the politics of it
>>72335196
I don't want to hear opinions on what already happened I want opinions on what would happen if it were applied to the real world
>>72335362
It looked like Cap dies
>>72334617
If they're as benevolent as the superheroes from the comics they won't need gouvernment regulations, and if they're no different from us (except for the superpower thing) most of them will want to hide their abilities from the public and the rest will try to exploit their abilities for their own benefit against which a gouvernment will be inadequate unless they have experimental weapons dedicated to the destruction of evil mutants.
So basically, X-Men.
>>72334617
I stand with Cap.
>>72335530
T'Chakka dies.
the largest power is the de-facto government.
If the superheroes have the power to resist, then they are the government.
>>72335298
I agree to a certain degree, it shouldn't be given to the public, they should be higher than citizens, but they need to be able to be stopped in the event one of them goes off. There needs to be accountability
>>72335637
http://m.imdb.com/title/tt1825683/
>>72335637
Wait..
Movie description
>>72335362
Black Goliath died in the comic.
They couldn't be assed to carve a coffin so they just buried him in a tarp and called it a day instead of shrinking him down.
> Implying the Jews wouldn't just kill any superheroes that didn't swear fealty to them
>>72334794
I agree, although Frankie may not be required to work for the gov. He doesnt have any powers.
>>72335714
Unless they willingly cede power. Your statement is factually correct, but is rarely the case in real-world scenario (in democratic countries.) For example, the government of the U.S. does hold the power, and has control of the military. Because the military allows it. But if the govt became tyrranical, oppressive, overreaching, etc. AND there was a powerful rallying figure (who would almost certainly have to be military, not just some politician or Trump-like figure), there could be a coup even in the U.S.
So when applied to the Marvel universe, the government remains in power regardless of there being individuals who are more powerful than it, because they cede power to the government.
>>72334617
I like the JSA story about the HUAC hearings and all the Golden Age superheroes retiring. Fuck Marvel.
>>72334794
/thread
Iron man is a statist faggoy
>>72335610
In the comics this is essentially what it boils down to
But in the movie it seems as if it is triggered by a question of "are super humans responsible for collateral damages associated with the awesome nature of their powers" (think hulkbuster armor v hulk in Age of Ultron movie). This is the type of argument that sparks the initial debate in the comics as well. A super hero reality show goes wrong and a whole suburb gets blown up.
still comes down to a question of liberty, im all for Cap
>>72336910
>there could be a coup even in the U.S.
some say this already happened after WW2, culminating in the JFK hit
the movie sucked dick , avengers fighting in an empty airport then they get tired of fighting and become friends again 90 mins of this
