ITT: Albums with both a 5-star song and a .5-star song.
>5 Star - Saturday Night Inside Out
>.5 Star - Noisy Eater
Easy
>5-star
Happiness is a warm gun
>0.5-star
Ob-la-di, ob-la-da
>>66186188
>5-star - Happiness is a warm gun
Yeah this I agre-
>0.5-star - Ob-la-di, ob-la-da
Fuck no
>5 Star:
To Binge
>.5 Star:
Sweepstakes
>>66186083, I'm curious as to what your picks are. I don't think there's really a .5 song but if I had to guess I think it'd be Sara.
>>66186188
Haha, no.
>.5 Star:
Wild Honey Pie
it's kind of the point, though
>>66186083
You gonna say which songs, or what?
>>66186188
You're fucking high.
>>66186188
The 0.5 star song is Wild Honey Pie
>5 star
The Suburbs
>.5 star
Rococo
>>66186540
>Sara
>a .5 star song
is this bait
joey would be the .5 star song
>>66186083
I'm going to guess... your 5 star is Hurricane, the 0.5 star is Joey.
>>66189114
...although actually Black Diamond Bay is my favourite. Not such a fan of Hurricane, but lots of people seem to like it.
>5 star
Loved Ones
>0.5 star
title track
>>66186540
>5 star
>not empire ants
>best
Sara
>runner up
Isis
>worst
Mozambique
>overrated
Hurricane
>underrated
Oh Sister
>>66190258
>worst
>not Joey
>>66190258
You can fuck off if you think Mozambique is the worst
Also:
>5 star
Michelle
>0.5 star
What Goes On
>>66186650
whats the .5 song though. I cant think of any
>5.0
anything that isnt poledo
>0.5
poledo
>5
The boy with the thorn in his side/ There is a Light
>.5
Frankly Mr. Shankly
do i even have to say it
Meddle
>5-star
Streets on Fire
(also Gold Watch)
>.5-star
Baba Says Cool for Thought
(or if that's cheating Intruder Alert is like 1-star)
>>66192122
I understand that Echoes is 5.5 stars, but that's not what this thread is.
>5 star
Echoes
>0.5 star
You already know
>>66187610
Fuck off Rococo is spook-tier
Of all the shitty filler on that too-long album, you couldn't pick Ready to Start, Suburban War, Month of May, or Deep Blue?
Arcade Fire is definitely a band that goes from unbelievably good to unbelievably bad unbelievably fast though.
>>66192332 here
Sorry lad >>66192122 didn't see your post.
>5
Styrofoam Boots
>0.5
Shit Luck (please don't even pretend this isn't the case)
>>66187182
My first thought in this thread was that song desu
very rarely will I delete a song from my computer but not the rest of the album. That time I had to.
>>66186083
>5 star - Debra
>0.5 star - Get Real Paid
>>66187610
I think every Arcade Fire album has a 5 and a .5, except maybe Funeral (but I just don't have any opinions about Funeral desu)
>5 stars
ultralight beam
>.5 stars
freestyle 4
>>66192362
>k Ready to Start, Suburban War, Month of May, or Deep Blue
>shity filler
kys yourself
>>66191614
hope this is a bait
>>66192415
You fucked up
>5 stars
I Love Kanye
>.5 stars
Famous
>>66192415
>5 stars
ultralight beam
>.5 stars
literally everything else
>>66192362
ready to start and deep blue are some of my favorites from the record tho. but i do agree that the suburbs has a lot of filler
>>66192362
>Suburban War
>Deep fucking Blue
>filler
I literally can't think of one
>>66192468
oh come on Wolves is at least a 3
>>66192501
waves* senpai
>5 star
It's Never Over (Oh Orpheus)
>0.5 star
Normal Person
>5
I Luv the Valley OH!
>0.5
Support Our Troops OH!
>>66192415
>freestyle 4
>not waves
>5 star
In the Flowers
>0.5 star
Also Frightened
>>66192514
>0.5 star
>Normal Person
Oh wow
>>66192487
What the fuck was the fucking point of posting this you fucking shithead motherfucker. Jesus fucking cuntfuck mcdick cock. What the fuck!? You're literally saying dick bloody all here you cock-mongering son of a whoreson. I ought to cunt-punt your fucken dick into a goddamn sunuvagun.
YOU CHODE-ASS CUNTBOY FIGHT ME IN REAL LIFE RIGHT NOW MY ADDRESS IS YOUR FUCKING ANUS YA DICKLOVING FAGKID.
I've never been this mad in my life I literally can't even see what I'm typing. YOu're going to die now, do you hear me? You are literally about to be dead, because I'm just wishing you were never born as hard as I ever goddamn could.
YOU CAN'T THINK OF AN ALBUM? SO YOU POSTED? WHY WOULD YOU EVER DARE TO THINK EVEN THE MOST WRETCHED FUCK ON 4CHAN WOULD DEIGN TO READ YOUR SHITEY OPINION, YOU KEK! YOU PIXIE KEK FAGGOT MOTHERFUCKER!
I hope you literally die more times than anyone else has ever died before.
>5
Caroline, No
>.5
Sloop John B
>>66192514
>5 star
Reflektor/Afterlife
>0.5 stars
Porno/SUSY
>>66192583
also frightened is good
>>66192514
>0.5 star
>not You Already Know
u okay anon
>>66186650
The fucked jam?
>>66192610
Ok...
>>66192585
Normal Person is the best song they're ever made, UNTIL the part at the end where the lyrics turn the entire thing around from a thing about how "normal" doesn't make a lot of sense into a thing that's just harping on people with a lifestyle other than theirs. You look back on the song and the entire thing just becomes maximum cringe.
It's really hard to rate because of that but I certainly sympathize with that rating.
>>66192620
>0.5
>Porno
lyrics hit a little too close to home huh?
>>66191436
>likes mozambique
>thinks michelle is five stars
lmaofamm
>>66192569
t. not wavy dude
>5 Stars
Can't Tell me Nothing
>0,5 Stars
Drunk and Hot Girls
>>66192391
AND MY AND MY AND MY AND MY AND MY AND MY AND MY AND MY AND MY AND MY AND MY AND MY AND MY AND MY AND MY AND MY AND MY AND MY AND MY
AND MY HEART HAS SLOWLY DRIED UP
>>66192514
objectively wrong
>>66186083
>>66190258
>best
Sara
>runner up
Oh, Sister
>worst
Romance in Durango
>overrated
Hurricane
>underrated
One More Cup of Coffee
5: Imago
.5: The Whip Hand
How can you build up such anticipation with bad ass live performances and then completely destroy it with the studio recording so hard
>>66193571
Agreed 100%. The synth in that song legit sounds like a fart noise
Also Noctourniquet is super underrated, great album. Man I'm still bummed about not having any more TMV.
>>66191436
cmon man, any song ringo sings is automatically 3 star
>>66192819
Legitimately some of his best songs (Can't tell me nothing, Everything I am) and worst songs (Drunk and Hot Girls, Barry Bonds) on one album
5 - I'm Not Done
0.5 - Seven
>>66192614
Am I the only one who actually likes Sloop John B?
>5 star
Please let me wonder
>.5 star
I forget the name but that pointless spoken word track at the end. Literally no reason for it in the slightest. I like listening to interviews of artists I like but on an official album it's bizarre and out of place.
5 - On GP
0.5 - Turned Off
>>66194998
it's not even an interview, it's literally just them fucking around
it is pointless, but it doesn't bother me enough to consider it a .5 though desu
>>66191563
even though poledo single handedly makes the entire album subtly unnerving? that song is incredibly powerful
>>66192113
Liberation? far too fucking long
>>66186188
fucking finally someone else who hates that song
I go a little higher on Pree-Sisters than most people, but it's still a bizarre inclusion.
>>66192362
This has to be bait? (you're right about Rococo though)
>>66192391
w h a t
>>66192514
no
>>66195562
I actually really like that track. Hardly the worst "experimental soundscape" type ending an artist has added onto an album to me.
>>66186107
>neither the best or the worst songs
You need to get your shit together, anon.
>>66194998
>>66195077
I think it's comfy af desu
here's the full version
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U2dbpnbrrSc
>>66195922
Yeah I'm totally fine with an interview, or listening to them mess around, but it just feels weird on an album as a main track. It's just out of place to me.
Thanks for that though I'll probably listen to it.
