Hey, this is really good. Why do people think this is Floyd's worst album?
Because it is?
That doesn't necessarily mean an album is bad.
Not a bad album senpai, just not a floyd album.
Because it's essentially Roger Water's first solo album that would spark the end of success era Pink Floyd.
It's a great album though.
It is really good. And plebs are always wrong.
>>66118559
It's one of their best, most heartfelt albums.
Roger Waters was like 80% of the band up until that point. Nick Mason and Rick Wright did nothing too important, and Gilmour had great guitar solos. The concepts, most of the music, lyrics, and singing was done by Roger Waters, and it proved to be their most productive, influential, and successful period
While I like it, there's still something intangible I can't put my finger on that seems missing. Something I think Waters later Pros and Cons of Hitchhiking captured pretty well.
>>66118960
>Rick Wright did nothing
Tough to do anything when you're fired.
>>66118586
>The Final Cut
>worse than More, AMLOR, Division Bell, or Endless River
Hard to be as bad as Ummagumma
>>66120171
holy shit kill yourself plebian
>>66120167
division bell is notthatbad. easily better than the other two you mentioned but yeah still worse than final cut
>>66118559
Not their worst, but still, Roger yelling "my dad died, war is shite" for 43 minutes does not a good album make. It's also closer to a Waters solo album than a Pink Floyd albilum, and would have been better off released as such instead of latching Waters' angst onto the band's name.
Maybe my dad needs to die before I can 'understand' His pain, His anger, and His thoughts, but until then, I just don't think I'm going to understand.
>>66120171
or Atom Heart Mother
>>66120650
This, Atom Heart Mother fucking sucks.
Literally sounds like fucking elevator music.
>>66120171
*ahem*
>>66120171
>>66120650
>>66120700
literally kill yourself jesus fuck
