Last one went stale and crusty tbqh.
Feel free to share your music, recommend others' soundclouds and give feedback.
Also, please actually give recs. It's pretty embarrassing when you ask for feedback but give none of your own.
https://soundcloud.com/vhsmidnightstyle/ice-zone1
>Trip-hop, vaportrap, electronic
>Sounds like Blank Banshee
I will try to give feedback once theres more posts.
haha hi
https://soundcloud.com/yamir-s/angakok
>dark ambient
>drone
>post-rock
>spoken word
https://soundcloud.com/therealredstar/social-disconnect
>Electronic, kinda ambient, chill, fuck genres are hard.
https://soundcloud.com/gogozeppelli/soul-prod-byou
>hardcore hip-hop
>edgy as fuck
https://soundcloud.com/sublime-vibes
Intrumental HipHop/DnB
https://soundcloud.com/glutenfreebeats
>hip hop beats
>>66086067
rex
https://soundcloud.com/nathanoriginal/another-dimension
>electro hop
>rap
>>66085687
New Track!
https://soundcloud.com/swollenskinny/goin-up
>Beats
>Ambient
>Chill
Reccin hard
>>66086067
https://soundcloud.com/Avantier
>synthwave
>chillwave
>ambient
>vapor
Hey whats up you bitch ass sluts its fuckin scrimzoola and I love you all more synth shit coming soon mother fuckers
https://soundcloud.com/scrimzoola/trackshttps://soundcloud.com/scrimzoola/tracks
https://soundcloud.com/scrimzoola/tracks
https://soundcloud.com/scrimzoola/tracks
https://soundcloud.com/scrimzoola/tracks
EP is now out!
https://soundcloud.com/user-115731221/sets/spirit-logs-1-ep-1
>Electronic
>Ambient
>Jazz-Influenced
Will do feeback later!
>Vibe & Chill
> Alternative Rap
Misfit music
https://soundcloud.com/kuaczar_0_0/eternal-autumn-prod-by-hanto
soundcloud.com/totinoboy
>trap
>dark
>melancholic
https://soundcloud.com/kubasc
>instrumental
>orchestral
>melodic rock
https://soundcloud.com/ice-cold-slush
British Garage/Surf/Rock
https://soundcloud.com/user-511366453
>bedroom recordings
https://soundcloud.com/the_cartridge_family/absolution
>Post Rock, Chamber Folk, Orchestral, Experimental
Brand new track just released! Inspired by Talk Talk, Miles Davis, Popol Vuh, Arthur Russell, and Catholic Religious musical traditions. Includes and Organ and Choir. Would love love love feedback. Cheers x
https://soundcloud.com/yngsn
>sample based hip hop beats
>music to pet your dog to
>idktbhfam
https://soundcloud.com/theidiotbox/didnt-ask
>postpunk
>indie
>didntask
https://soundcloud.com/avoid-life/sets/twenty
>rap/hip-hop
recs
>>66086067
>>66086009
>>66086138
>>66086453
https://soundcloud.com/eternalnote
>Ambient
>Drone
>Dreamy
https://soundcloud.com/benjiboy316/rauhfasertapete
>Dark
>Electronic
>IDM/Experimental
Recs:
>>66085727
>>66086453
https://soundcloud.com/user536029835/backing-track
smelly garbage, i need help
https://soundcloud.com/adumskeez/eggys
>video games
>electronic
oh boy
https://soundcloud.com/tokarev
>synthwave
>electro
>midtempo
>cyberpunkish
Just finished 'rust' any sort of criticisms or critiques on it would be pretty swell
>>66086453
I would most surly pet a dog to this
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HQUL2D6IYrc
>Chill Hip Hop
> Psych Hop
> Dream Hop
>>Hop Hop
https://soundcloud.com/alexauld
>Rap/HipHop
>Alt
NEW Song!!
Enjoy.
https://soundcloud.com/tyler-cetura
>>66085687
https://soundcloud.com/atcreams/snapchat-prod-bricc-senpai
>Hip-hop
>Self-made
>atcreams
>frequent releases
Just dropped my new track, let me kmlw what you all think. Returning all feedback
https://soundcloud.com/funzip-1/drips
>Electronic
>Chill
>Samples
>whoknows
Recs:
>>66085727
>>66086067
>>66086138
>>66086252
>>66086453
>>66086095
>>66086138
>>66086232
>>66086282
>>66086301
RECS
https://soundcloud.com/solarcrematorium
>>66085687
new song
https://soundcloud.com/boredinfinity/fatalist-the-dawn
>>66085687
https://soundcloud.com/samuel-belman/matter-of-days
>Conscious R&B/Deep House
>Abundance EP coming soon
>I return feedback
>Get at me
https://soundcloud.com/super_matic/chimera
>Trap
>Wonky
>fun shit
I return feedback on SC
Heres my latest track! Feedback would be awesome :)
https://soundcloud.com/luciddd/motion-lucid-x-lo-erless
>lofi
>hiphop
>beats
I will return all feedback I get on soundcloud :) ill be listening to everyones stuff in the thread too.
>>66085687
https://soundcloud.com/trey-chops/vitamin-t
>hip hop
>self produced most of the time
>>66085687
https://soundcloud.com/broken-bit/lunatic-verge
>Heavy Electro / Glitch / Industrial
>Kind of like if Pertubator had sex with Angelspit
https://soundcloud.com/jakuchudakami
> chill / soul / rap
Returning and giving feedback on soundcloud, expect the recs shortly <3
https://soundcloud.com/zoqe
>trap beats.
>Yake
https://soundcloud.com/zolton-2/6-foot-2-prod-lucid-soundz
Newest release looking for fantano tier feedback
Wanna work or anything let me know
https://soundcloud.com/empty-church/snow-for-will
>sample based sad beats
Just released a new track! Feedback appreciated
https://soundcloud.com/ttedak/my-place-is-nowhere
>beat, instrumental hip hop
More tracks:
https://soundcloud.com/ttedak/drop-bear
https://soundcloud.com/ttedak/plunge
>breakbeat
https://soundcloud.com/ttedak/chomp
>beat, instrumental hip hop
https://soundcloud.com/777souljah
>Hip-Hop
>Trap
>Instrumental
>Cloud
https://soundcloud.com/brynmorgan
Beats, rhymes and life
Should be back on the singing tip real soon
https://soundcloud.com/molo-fly/tangrinemist
>NEW MUSIC
I will give everyone feedback.
recs
>>66085724
>>66086067
>>66086095
>>66086138
>>66086252
>>66086453
>>66086582
>Honest impressions incoming, 1/2
>>66085724
Chill and trippy. Like it.
>>66085727
Sounds like menu music to some post-apocalyptic feelsy shit like The Last Of Us. Solid.
>>66085855
Ahhh, my negro amigo. This is Royksopp-y s fuck. Love it.
>>66085981
Love the backing, but fuck me that rap is painful to listen to. Stick to instrumentals.
>>66086009
Kind of Massive Attack / Aivisura-esque. Cool stuff.
>>66086067
Oh shit son
This is funky as fuck. Followed.
>>66086095
Cool synth work, but feels a bit bland to me. Excellent production values, though.
>>66086138
Man I don't know enough jazz to compare this to anything, but it seems well done.
>>66086173
Lovely mix of Chiptune/Retrowave. Like it a lot.
>>66086181
Interesting ideas, but your production values are shit. Seriously, look up basic mixing and mastering.
>>66086220
interesting soundscapes, but your percussion is very obviously MIDI-based. Look for some better percussion samples, there's loads about.
>>66086232
Cool track, but your vocal recording sounds mumbled and muffled. Try pushing the high-end up on the vocal mix and maybe minding your pronunciation a bit. Otherwise, very solid.
>>66086252
Chill. I like it.
>>66086282
Very nicely put together, if a little cliché. Not much to set it apart. Excellently produced, well constructed.
>>66086301
YEAH. Very nice work. You could do with booking some serious studio time though, hashing out an EP. You sound like you'd be a riot live.
>>66086310
This is silence coloured in. Not much to say about it desu.
>>66086324
Atmospheric as fuck. Love it.
>>66086453
Oldschool. Cool stuff.
>>66086465
There's the seed of something good there but there's a very amateur feel across the whole thing, like the individual mixed tracks don't quite fit somehow.
>>66086582
Shit, it's like Death Grips took a shit-ton of ketamine and calmed down for fifteen minutes. I wasn't sure at first, but actually I quite like this.
>>66085855
Amazing sound man, really spacey take this here rec <3
>>66085687
https://soundcloud.com/cancanfly
NEW SONG
https://soundcloud.com/cancanfly/ranon-ep-mix
>Featured in Rave Mag!
>Feels Hop
>Electronic
>Beat
>Ambient
>Downtempo
>IDM
>Experimental
>Chillwave
I blend electronics with real instruments and beats. Will return feedback.
>MY MOST WELL RECEIVED SONG :
https://soundcloud.com/cancanfly/posing-for-rosey
>NEW SONG :
https://soundcloud.com/cancanfly/ranon-ep-mix
>>66088004
You're a good man for doing this
>>66088004
>>66088020
Wow guys, thanks a ton.
>>66086009
Dope track, rec, I guess I could kind of compare it to Pretty Lights a little, tight production, you'll only get better with time as well. The only thing I didn't like was the mixing, the percussion was overpowering those lovely sounds. :c
>>66086138
Last rec, much too dank for u.
>>66085687
Found this in my feed a few days ago.
https://soundcloud.com/legacy-of-thought/sets/ancient-olympia
Awesome downtempo album. Very trippy.
been a while since I posted in here
https://soundcloud.com/realreptoidshit
> Raps and instrumentals
>>66087887 here, gonna give some recs/feedback now
>>66087631
Rhyme scheme is kinda basic but I dig it otherwise, nice production
>>66087861
Enjoyed this a lot, feel like you could definitely do some really nice ambient without the beat if you wanted
>>66087490
Fuck this is great, much cooler sounding than your logo indicates, I was expecting some lame chiptune shit
>>66087301
Loving the synth noises
>>66087251
Maybe just my taste but I feel this track would be better as an instrumental, I find the voice distracting. Solid otherwise, like the jazzy piano/synth
>>66088004
2/2
>so much talent on display here, fuck
>>66086606
Meditation music. Simple and refined. Like it.
>>66086610
Some interesting ideas, but badly put together. Aim for more cohesion in the tracks, also, lose the MIDI drums, find something meatier. Glitch/experimental is best when it's chaotic but following a larger pattern. Drop yourself into an Aphex or Venetian Snares album for a while and listen to how the songs are put together.
>>66086668
Interesting drum opening. Needs literally anything else after the first break to make it interesting.
>>66086714
Fun and happy. You part of the Chiptunes=Win community on FB?
>>66086743
OH YEAH. FOLLOWED THE FIST OF THE NORTH STAR. Imma get in touch.
>>66086854
This is funky. Like it. You're a decent rapper too.
>>66087085
10/10 would Hindu again
>>66087088
>embed not found
Make sure you've not set it to Private
>>66087097
Interesting soundscape, but not a lot to break it up. Needs a lead or something.
>>66087215
Cool stuff, not quite to my tastes but well put together nonetheless.
>>66087243
Just fuck my shit up senpai
>>66087251
Nicely put together, but your vocal track is fucked up. Push up that high end and work on the stereo sep.
>>66087301
Look up Cyriak's music. Take notes.
>>66087426
Yeeesss. Chill and interesting.
>>66087428
Interesting, but this style isn't for me. Well put together though.
>>66087490
>That one's mine, I'm not going to comment on more since they're being posted faster than I can listen to them, I'll be here all night.
Would like feedback though.
https://soundcloud.com/dynamaxx-music-1/blood-moon
>80s
>retro
.>synthwave
>darkwave
Will return feedback
>>66088336
>BrokenBit here
Lame Chiptune shit is literally how I got started.
(I'm still really into the genre, I just do whatever nowadays)
https://soundcloud.com/lordgaijin
>hip hop
>trap
>rap
>nerdcore
http://soundcloud.com/siriustexra/shooshoo
I'm 27 and have been trying to make an album since I was 17. I have a whole shit tonne of music and songs and slowly just now finishing some up.
This is the barebones of a song, what I'd call like maybe half done for a home demo.
I need bandmates but I live in buttfuck nowhere Australia so I can't find anyone except abos. I think I need to move.
Pic semi related, it's the neighbours
>>66088380
Ah well you should do more heavy industrial stuff, it really works imo
>>66085687
hi hope im not too late to the party!
https://soundcloud.com/rhinopalace/page-turner
>lo fi
>Stonesthrow
>type
>shit
https://soundcloud.com/afghamistam
>hip hop beats
>Some Techno
Gonna start from the bottom and work my way up the thread will leave feedback on sc.
AND KEEP WORKING ON YOUR MUSIC NEVER GIVE UP NO MATTER WHAT! DONT GIVE UP ON YOUR DREAMS.
https://soundcloud.com/coburn-dialect
>electronic
https://soundcloud.com/sex-camel/crow-flex-prod-sex-camel
this is my fist collab with a rapper i don't know irl!
https://soundcloud.com/dschulezrulez/for-x-sample-01
>new small beat tape i made
>samples
Feedback is appreciated and will be returned.
Gonna post one more, then leave it for tonight.
Track's based off something I heard in a really intense, vivid dream.
https://soundcloud.com/broken-bit/journey-through-the-nexus
>Chill / Electro / Progressive
>Kind of Sebastian Svahn-ish
https://soundcloud.com/joncallirgos/wimm-flip
>electronic
>future
Im new, feedback please.
>>66086453
Had to borrow room mates dog.
soundcloud.com/akeswick
>folk/singer-songwriter
Just threw a new demo up today. I'll be going through the thread and giving feedback in a sec.
https://soundcloud.com/rookie-the-mc/sets/finee
>hiphop
https://soundcloud.com/lord_kyo
he's also dope to listen too.
>>66089332
>>66089209
This is tight dude. Super into this.
I'm always here
Love you all
Shout out Nathan original
soundcloud.com/ronniescholarship
>>66089332
>>66089354
Nice production. I dig lounge-y hip-hop.
>>66089153
I wanna be drunk in a basement listening to this too loud.
https://soundcloud.com/iikrisgm/h41yytqyizze
https://soundcloud.com/dopeydfromtdt/wockhardt64
>beats
>n64ish
>bass
>>66085687
Got a track up that's still pretty new!
https://soundcloud.com/kylejohnkenowski
>spooky forest atmosphere
>melodic psychedelia
>lots of layers
>lots of drums and noises
https://soundcloud.com/sammyt-7
NEW TRACK and new tune coming soon!
so keep your ears peeled
>lo-fi funk
>psychedelic
>sampling
>R&B
>trill
https://soundcloud.com/pomegranatepop
>arabic, middle-eastern vinyl and cassettes
>60s, 70s, 80s
>music for your armenian wedding
>>66086067
Started listening and was getting into it, but then I realized... this is the sort of sampling that legitimately just feels like lazy theft. You just sped up or repitched an entire fantastic song and just added a beat, what the fuck? Listening to your second track now and it's the same thing. If you're going to sample, make it your own, this is pathetic, despite the quality of the songs your lifting.
https://soundcloud.com/notadmin
a bunch of throwaway/unfinished rap instrumentals
>>66089982
https://soundcloud.com/hailey-smith-8/moscow-station
https://soundcloud.com/lewis-the-funky-hip-fellow
>instrumental hip hop
>chill
Just made a new beat!
https://soundcloud.com/musica-francesco-marangoni
>indie
>beats
>very amateur
https://soundcloud.com/abracadanny/when-i-leave
>>downtempo// synthpop
dark summer vibes ahoy
https://soundcloud.com/guardinmusic/haveuseenramenpls
>chill/future/hip-hop
>boom bap beat
i'll be returning feedback on soundcloud as well as checkin' everyone out in the thread. thank you for all of the support. it's appreciated.
reccin' the homies
>>66086067
>>66086095
>>66086252
>>66086453
>>66087428
>>66087426
>>66087543
>>66087605
>>66088050
>>66088387
>>66089982
https://soundcloud.com/mephisto_waltz/the-visitation-feat-ornate-exit
>Glitch, Experimental, Electronic
>>66090127
I started reading this and I was happy that you were getting into it but as I read further I realized this is the sort of shallow criticism I've already contemplated through and through. You see plenty of hip hop producers do exactly what you described I mean listen to any song Dr. Dre is famous for producing. Do you think I didn't realize what I was doing? The skill is not in the song writing or sample chopping for those particular tracks it's about taking an old song with noise and harsh frequencies and doing lots of PRODUCTION to make it sound huge and bouncy and captivating so people who wouldn't necessarily appreciate the original track can enjoy it. I mean do you actually think subtly tweaking EQ's and compressors and distortion and stereo imagers and parallel compressors and reverb to the point where the mix is that tight is lazy, or do you think that maybe took some skill and meticulous work?
https://soundcloud.com/20051996
>electronic stuff
Return feedback
https://soundcloud.com/pro_fane
new music soon
>808,ethereal,hiphop,beats,dark
https://soundcloud.com/lachlan-slaughter/sets/pistols
NEW BEAT TAPE
Be my first notification or sumn. All feedback returned and always check out similar artists
https://soundcloud.com/officialdtb/the-centrum
>Post Rock
>Emo
https://soundcloud.com/aguyincollege/rightoverhere
pls respond
https://soundcloud.com/berrybluegum/how-many-toys-can-you-fit-in-your-dickhole
>original Christmas Carol
>>66091887
REC
https://soundcloud.com/youngveggie/reefer-madness-1
Young Veggie - Reefer Madness
>instrumental hip hop, dub, plunderphonics kind of
Reccs:
>>66085724
>>66086067
>>66086232
>>66086854
Will return feedback and give more reccs soon
https://soundcloud.com/yoccoohno/sets/666a
just dropped a short ep
check it out if you like good rap
https://soundcloud.com/yaranrecs2/yaranzo-alone3k17
>plunderphonics
>chillwave
>vaporwave
https://m.soundcloud.com/moagang777
A friend of mine from middle school; clearly heavily inspired by Odd Future, but still some pretty legit chops
https://soundcloud.com/n-horn
best music of all time tbqh
>Rap
>One song core
https://soundcloud.com/seni0r/loss-for-words
>>66091804
Really atmospheric my dude! Glad to see you're still around!!
https://soundcloud.com/navigating/saw-you-in-a-dream
>low-end
>chill
>dreamhop
Will gladly return feedback. Gonna go through the thread and give some either way, most likely.
Hope it makes you nod and feel.
https://soundcloud.com/butitwasnt/distorted
>i have no fucking clue what it is
>maybe it is better that way
>7.1 and volume leveler makes some cool space
>couple db wrong here and there
>WIP
>>66091885
Most artists making music already have to produce their shit exactly as you say on top of actually crafting the composition as distinct from the production. You cut out the low end and made some notches in the eq to leave room for a couple drum samples, maybe sped it up, maybe rearranged the movements to change the pacing, but that doesn't change the fact that the entire groundwork and most of the most interesting details were laid out for you by people that you don't even credit. I don't even dislike it, but moreso because of the work of the original artists. And like I said, nothing wrong with sampling, but man, some of those tracks are just straight regurgitation. And saying other artists did it first doesn't really justify it at all. Keep sampling, keep doing what you're doing, but at least rework it into something new, not just adding beats to complete songs.
>>66087426
Real dope
>>66097245
rekt
>>66085687
https://soundcloud.com/yungo0n-0n/dj-khaled-is-my-baby-mamma
https://soundcloud.com/unvoiced-velar-plosive/your-cow-wont-bark
>Improvised pop music/ experimental blues, tape music
Album I made in my spare room on reel-to-reel tape
also available here: https://dariolt.bandcamp.com/releases
https://soundcloud.com/stonedalf/great-spirits
>hip hop sample
will feedbck on soundcloud back
>>66087085
>https://soundcloud.com/tyler-cetura
loving this
>>66097245
>Most artists making music already have to produce their shit exactly as you say on top of actually crafting the composition as distinct from the production.
This is false and you know it. Most artists send the stems of their track to a mixing engineer and a mastering engineer. And if they don't then the final mix is incomparable.
Plus there's plenty of songs where I chop and splice samples together. Almost all of my music is done that way. But I'm not going to not use dope samples I find on account of your moral principles. Especially when it's a commonplace in the genre.
I mean really the whole crux of your argument is that I didn't rework the sample enough for your personal ethical code. Which only makes sense in your mind because you belittle what I've actually done to rework it.
>the fact that the entire groundwork and most of the most interesting details were laid out for you by people that you don't even credit
This is what what all sample based music is. You have a blatant double standard with the justification being that in one circumstance it's okay because you can explicitly hear everything being done to rework the sample and in the other the subtly eludes you so that producer just didn't do "enough"
Really you're just an asshole. You're talking to me like I don't know what I did trying to tell me that I'm regurgitating music when in reality the only thing being regurgitated is the tried and true
>muh originality
argument
And saying other artists did it first completely justifies it. The biggest rap beats of all time are literally drums layered over an old vinyl track without even half of the production techniques I employ to make it sound as good.
The real pathetic thing is you're taking time out of your day to hurt the pride of an 18 year old on the internet who's learning production probably because you're bitter that your ambient glitch noise industrial post punk lofi indie folk shoegaze isn't doing so hot.
>>66099491
https://dariolt.bandcamp.com/track/give-me-room
this really reminds me of old blues tracks
>>66100043
REKT
>>66090127
>>66097245
This guy is completely right
>>66100097
NOT AN ARGUMENT
O
T
A
N
A
R
G
U
M
E
N
T
>>66100043
>This is what what all sample based music is.
Not at all, artists like the Avalanches make a sound collage consisting of many different samples and blend them together in interesting ways to creat a new sound, wheras you are adding nothing new beyond a kick and a snare and some nice mastering. Stop trying to attack the guy criticizing you (I'm not him btw) just because he called you out for lazy sampling. You shouldn't post stuff on the internet if you're gonna be this salty about it. If you want to do what you're doing maybe you should credit the original song in the description. I can't see people having an issue then.
https://soundcloud.com/cauldronic/fight-for-your-life
>beats
>wavvy
>Sample based
>anime vibes
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rzmaMu-Qt2Q
Video i made for it as well~
https://soundcloud.com/atticussd/seventeen
>Trap
>Hiphop
>>66100237
>you should take unfair criticism deliberately intended to attack you lying down
okay
really tho he's talking about 2 songs out of the 30 or so I have uploaded because I wanted to try the specific style that now I'm getting battered for. It's not like that's all I do it's not like he's telling me something I don't know.
>you are adding nothing new beyond a kick and a snare and some nice mastering
do you see how this argument only works when you completely disregard everything I actually did?
>>66088091
Thanks! Other Producers I showed the track said the same thing about the drums but I felt like lowering them would take the energy away.
recs
>>66089209
>>66095321
>>66090845
>>66100237
>the avalanches
>here this one fringe example not even related to the genre ur producing negates the 30 years of hip hop songs that utilize the exact technique i'm criticizing you for
i listened and liked a lot, but really can't offer anything to the producers so I picked some of the song people out to jerk off
>>66089153
i like your band like... alot. you'd fit in well with my posse
>>66086282
one of my favorites, great music I like the production
>>66086301
you guys are god. what fuzz pedal on the live shit
>>66086465
really good. neat guitar sounds and in that track didnt ask that's a weird shape/tuning you're moving around.
>>66087085
this was pretty original and interesting
>>66088425
good music.
>>66090468
i really like your songs and the honest sound. no fancy production needed
>>66093618
I really like the spaceman song but the other 2 songs are cockteases (20 seconds long)
still cool though
>G H O O L E S
>Death grips samples
>suicidal tendencies
>sad man music
https://soundcloud.com/ghooles/eyedrops-death-grips-samples
https://soundcloud.com/kidmethodrone/ghost-of-a-girl-wip
Originally went to work on a house tune, but ended up completely something else.
>>66100501
zach here thanks man
can someone explain me the difference between bandcamp and soundcloud? I mean which wo you use for what etc.
>>66100705
idk but it took way too long to upload all my hits to soundcloud so I am just sticking with it
https://soundcloud.com/sebuky/thenyoubloom
>bedroomcore
https://soundcloud.com/3uho/sack-un-feeling
>funk
https://soundcloud.com/user-882275012-244583403/garden-of-departure/s-tVUNS
Thrash
https://soundcloud.com/user-495597075/untitled
1:00
https://soundcloud.com/user670597593/taste-of-a-lo-fi-mind
>chip-tune
>electronic
Made by iPhone app BM2.
Please listen (^ ^)
>>66100913
this is pretty good for a young band.
What country are you guys from? I can tell you're not 'murican
>>66101000
you goofed on trips
http://www.soundcloud.com/mr-shiggles
>Sample-based hip-hop
>Cloud Rap
Only have two tracks :)
>fuck
https://soundcloud.com/hvurcake/untitled
https://soundcloud.com/xallthey/facade
>post / math rock
reccs ;
>>66089982
>>66087085
>>66093490
>>66100817
>>66101204
thanks :) Norway
>>66085687
http://www.soundcloud/jamieandthebuzz
Glasgow based rock band, I'm the guitarist.
https://soundcloud.com/halfaccidental/half-accidental-pozynegatywka
>punk-cabaret piano thing
>>66101652
i like it but Cake is taken g
https://soundcloud.com/martus/purple-dinosaur
>lo fi um rock influenced by black metal? duno
everybody wants to be a cake
https://soundcloud.com/sureva/a-devil-letter
>lo fi freak-folktronica with cheesy synths, lazy vocals and bedroom production
Looking for critical feedback here. I know there's tons stuff to improve on but I'm not really sure where to start aside from more practice.
>>66102560
This is great
https://soundcloud.com/holydomino
>Boom Bap hip hop stuff
>>66100043
>This is false and you know it. Most artists send the stems of their track to a mixing engineer and a mastering engineer.
Fair enough, many do, but many don't. But if the spectrum has the architect on one end and the engineer on the other, I'd say you're more on the engineer end of it, and even then, how much are you really doing? A few eq's, compressors, and reverbs is great, but again, the composition itself ALONG with the obviously competent sound engineering is already done. Those tracks aren't stems, they're mixed and master compositions that you carve away some space for a, albeit effective, beat.
My main point has nothing to do with ethics, that's just a side note. I'm not even trying to make you feel bad, really. All I'm encouraging you to do is make enough actual artistic decisions that the end product ends up more your own than the original artists. Use samples as building blocks with which you create something distinct from the original piece, don't merely repaint the walls and add a deck and say you built a house. It's not about ethics, it's about being an artist.
>This is what what all sample based music is.
This is reductive. There is a gradient on which all sampled music, and in fact all music, lies, somewhere between "this is somebody else's work" and "this is my own". If I go cover Blowin in the Wind, but include a drummer, who wrote it? I'd say at least some of your tracks belong almost entirely to the original artist. They're cover songs.
>The biggest rap beats of all time...
This argument still doesn't work. If anything it functions more as a critique of them than vindication.
>you're taking time out of your day to hurt the pride of an 18 year old
Sorry man, maybe I came on too harsh. I hope this functions more as critique than hating. I like it, I just think you could make it more your own, and thus more artistically valid.
And just so I have stakes in this too, this is me.
https://soundcloud.com/kylejohnkenowski
>>66100043
>18 year old
>Muh pride. Muh feelings
That explains a lot ("I'm right everyone else is wrong"). Maybe your pride wouldn't be so easily wounded if you put more originality into your tracks instead of making songs that are 90% ripped off.
>Using your age to somehow guilt people into laying off you in an 18+ environment (especially 4chan).
Take your feewings, go find a safe-space with wifi and cry about it on reddit.
You put yourself and your work out on the internet for all to see, and surprise surprise: Not everybody who listens to your songs wants to suck your dick and Some people actually don't like your songs or how you went about making them.
Welcome to 4chan and welcome to adult-hood you millennial faggot. Life isn't a meritocracy. Nobody in the real world cares about your feewings or your pride, The only care about what you can offer. And you offered songs that were half-assed and HEAVILY featured samples that you didn't credit.
The world is and will always be critical of you.
>>66100043
>The real pathetic thing is you're taking time out of your day to hurt the pride of an 18 year old on the internet who's learning production
If you cant handle the bants get the fuck off this site you nearly underage baby
>>66105898
>>66106344
lol stellar arguments
glad the angle you chose to argue from was essentially an admission of defeat
>>66105898
I'm not saying that because you hurt my feelings I'm just framing your argument for what it actually is and what it obviously is after reading this monstrosity of your own bitter feelings masked as "teh real world"
btw i think you meant life is a meritocracy
you're criticizing it because you want it to be something it's not and then you're acting like it's all I'm capable of just to try and hurt my feelings
your heavily featuring samples exemplifies your uselessness line of thought is laughable regarding the fact that most of the music and most of the popular music in the genre is made exactly that way.
first you were bitching about your personal ethics to someone on the internet and now you take the most pathetic and petty angle you possibly could have
>>66108198
it's also laughable because properly knowing how to mix/master is a much more marketable skill set than being able to write original music
>>66108198
That's not me.
>>66105246
This is me, the person who started all this in the first place.
Wanna hear a song about killing a man and taking his woman?
>https://www.soundcloud.com/jhost/mr-mccready
Wanna hear a song about killing a man who is hitting the woman you love?
>https://www.soundcloud.com/jhost/leaf-stone-and-discretion-demo
Wanna hear a song about gay sex?
>https://www.soundcloud.com/jhost/two-ships-demo
How about a song about the presidential debate being a joke and marxist dreams?
>https://www.soundcloud.com/jhost/working-class-mercenary
It's all folk acoustic bedroom demos. But you might like some of it. I'd appreciate the comments on soundcloud
>>66105246
>this is what all sample based music is
I misspoke I should've said hip hop specifically boom bap
>biggest rap beats of all time
this argument really does work though
I mean there's songs that Dr. Dre just looped and EQd, had his label pay royalties on and took the writing credit
and there's 1,000s of other examples of things that are not much better
you want it to be something it's not and you're coming from a complete lack of understanding of the genre.
I understand exactly what it is and exactly what I can get away with, which is why I *tried* out the style and shit it worked out well for me
One track got on a YT channel with 40,000 subs and the other got reposted by a promo page with 50,000 followers
But I mean there's songs on my soundcloud that are 90 - 95% original although old and not that great and there's songs where I collage lots and lots of samples together. case and point the track I did with Nathan Original
I appreciate what you're trying to do, but I'm fully aware of your point of view
>>66108742
>1,000s
wat am i even doing
>>66108742
the track with nathan is one of many in that style but it's some of my best work
>>66107739
>calling you out on how laughably butthurt you sound is an admission of defeat
>putting your age into an argument to somehow deflect criticism isn't
Uhh I just made something. My voice and some random messing around in Audacity.
Going to practice doing more stuff. I like a lo-fi sound. Noise pop or something. I'll get better.
https://soundcloud.com/online_band
>>66108986
that wasn't in my argument it was in my framing of the opponents argument
>not being able to tell the difference
pls stop engaging in an activity u suck at
>>66109019
there's 2 other soundcloud threads up i'd recommend posting in those
this one is dead
>>66108742
>I mean there's songs that Dr. Dre just looped and EQd
Ok, but like I said, that's more of an indictment of his integrity than a validation of the practice. It would be a lot better if you were adding more content to those tracks. If you wrote and performed some lyrics, or mixed together multiple tracks, or added more layers I wouldn't have said anything at all. Like I said, I have no problem whatsoever with samples, broadly speaking, but I do think there are ways in which they can be used that are either more or less artistic. I didn't mean to ruin your day, and looking back, I was too harsh in my early comments. But I do stick by the general contention that some of your most popular tracks are more to the credit of others, and that maybe in the future either use them more creatively or at least link to the source. If it was a hodgepodge of 10 different tracks you could hardly discern from one another, yea, whatever, but if it's a cut and paste job with a beat and some light engineering work I think that'd be fair.
>>66109023
>backtracking this hard
>>66109102
and like I've said 3 times already I understand your point of view and it's fine and you can hold it but it's coming from a fundamental refusal to understand the genre
There's hundreds of producers who do exactly what I did and take the credit. and then market their songs to dumb teenagers who think they actual wrote it instead of my following who fully understand it's sample.
my most popular song is samples that I spliced together btw
but even when I give you the resource to find examples of my tracks being exactly what you're claiming they should be you come back to me with the same exact argument as before
>>66109205
>doubling down on not knowing the difference between framing an argument and actually stating your argument
wew lad
dropped a tape the other day let me know what you think!
https://soundcloud.com/lettucebythepound/sets/greenhouse
>hip-hop
>producer
>would love feedback
>>66109328
the difference between framing an opponents argument and stating your own that is
https://soundcloud.com/wateroverdose
>Experimental/Chill Stuff
https://soundcloud.com/jonny-koi/hennessy-ocean
>fluid rnb / pop rap
"white girl turnup music/10" as theneedledrop would say... probably not something /mu/ would like but hey it's me
>>66087490
Solar Crematorium here. Thanks for the feedback. Really like the lead synth sound on Lunatic Verge. On the more critical side, I feel the timing on the drums sounds a bit too quantized, maybe needs a bit more of a human feel and dirt to really do the track justice. On the other hand, there's really, really good development in the track - the progression never gets boring. Liking the other tracks too. Good stuff!
>>66107739
>I'm going to treat all criticism of my music like it's a debate to be fought against rather than an opinion to consider and possibly develop from
Are you sure you're 18 years old rather than 8?
>>66100498
>66086282
Hey thanks man!
>>66109282
Yea, I don't know what you don't get. For a bit there I was kind of taking it easy on you because I didn't want to discourage you in general, but the fact that you're so adamant about this is changing my mind. Here's a metaphor if you can handle it. Saying somebody else got away with a murder doesn't mean that it's ok to murder, for them or for you. You can say it's a genre thing or a culture thing, but that's just a distraction from the actual concept we're talking about. What you did was hackery. When Dr. Dre did it it was hackery. Don't be a tool and lift entire songs. Don't argue that because the cancerous parasitic nature of the pop music industry does something that it makes it ok. If you're going to sample, sample, but be a fucking artist about it, and if you aren't going to be, then cite your source you coward. You say your most popular song was one you spliced together? Great. Do that. But don't sit atop praise and talk as though you're a valid artist if you're just adding a generic beat dance beat to dumb down a song you lack the integrity or talent to make yourself to appeal to an audience that, like you, doesn't seem to recognize the virtues of the original artist. It is not something to be proud of, and if my saying this hurts your pride maybe take that hurt and let it compel you to do something you can still be proud of when somebody calls you out on it.
>>66109883
>muh kids these days
stay mad oldfag
i'll have you remember you started this
and again you're criticizing 2 songs out of lack of understanding for the genre. the fact that the most revered producers in hip hop do exactly what i did is absolutely justification.
your point is perfectly fine and you can think that and have your morals, but you're literally asking me to admit that I did nothing creative with the songs and that's just untrue
>But don't sit atop praise and talk as though you're a valid artist if you're just adding a generic beat dance beat to dumb down a song you lack the integrity or talent to make yourself
or maybe lack the money to buy a proper space or proper equipment to record with why you acting like you know me senpai?
this seems to hinge on the fact that you can't distinguish production from composition, really
http://www.soundcloud.com/m4ndal4/
hip hop, funk carioca, soulection fan
NIGGAS SAID I DIDNT HAVE BARS
https://soundcloud.com/tsutsukakush/third-rock-from-the-sunprod-gf-retro
>>66110259
niggas wuz right
>>66110153
>lack of understanding for the genre
If an entire genre is reliant on plagiarism it's not much of a genre and I'm amazed you're so dense that you're still using this point. Again, that's like saying covers of classic rock is a genre.
>asking me to admit that I did nothing creative with the songs and that's just untrue
It's mostly true, despite some minimal input.
>you can't distinguish production from composition, really
I've articulated the distinction in this argument already. But even as a producer what you did with at least those two songs was still pretty negligible.
Oh, and this?
>>muh kids these days
>stay mad oldfag
Summarizes your capacity to have this conversation in the first place.
>>66110412
but it's not mostly true
I've completely reworked the song into something it absolutely was not beforehand and that's the essence of sample based hip hop
>But even as a producer what you did with at least those two songs was still pretty negligible.
>production is some of the tightest in these threads
>production is negligible
pick one
>Summarizes your capacity to have this conversation
my capacity to have this conversation is summarized quite well by the fact that you're still responding to me
>>66110153
Just stop.
Everything you've posted in this thread in response to obviously valid criticism is pathetic.
You could have just taken it as that, criticism, something to maybe take into account the next time you "make" a song. Instead you took it as an attack on your fragile ego.
>>66110618
not an argument
also i've explained to you that i've already considered your point of view and have plenty of songs that follow the exact pattern that you personally deem acceptable
>>66108198
I'm not trying to hurt your feelings you douche. I'm trying to get you to grow up so that way someday when you're older than 18, you can hold down a Job and socialize with real adults who can handle blunt criticism without being a little bitch about it.
And I meant what I said. Life is NOT a meritocracy. Merit doesn't count 90% of the time in the real world. For example, even though it wasn't my intention or the other criticizer's intention to hurt your feelings, you totally got butthurt. "Don't fire me boss, I know I can't produce quality work and I don't have original ideas, but I have MERIT!".... It doesn't work that way dude.
The only reason me and the other anon's in this thread were brutally honest with you is because we would rather have a person grow up than remain a whiny child forever- Because those people don't contribute anything worthwhile to society. If we wanted to troll you we'd just say "Your music is cringe/10 kys faggot" or something like that, we wouldn't waste time writing back and forth like this.
You can continue to defend yourself. Defend your pride (the number 1 thing that screws most adults out of true happiness). Or you can take a step back and admit that maybe we're right and you're wrong.
And It's okay Anon, because admitting that you're wrong means that moving forward, you get to be RIGHT. And when you're right, you won't have to constantly argue to defend your pride. And when you get to that point, you'll have more respect for yourself and your music, and so will the rest of the world.
>>66110941
you trying to win this argument by pulling a power move over me is not going to work
"this is how the real world works, kid. because i did so well in it that now as an adult i'm having a petty argument with you on the internet out of spite"
you're also talking about an industry that is built off sampling as if they'd reject me for sampling
again you're only still arguing out of misunderstanding
or maybe you realized you fucked up and that maybe i have a valid point of view and now you're trying to daddy me to maintain to superiority
https://soundcloud.com/kickingandpunching/bokenbones
>electronic, future bass
Powerful lead and bass. I'm quite proud of this and would appreciate any kind of feedback! I'll return feedback for sure (:
>>66110259
>https://soundcloud.com/tsutsukakush/third-rock-from-the-sunprod-gf-retro
Dig this, I left a comment that maybe a few more ideas (musically) could benefit the track but it's short and sweet. Good goin boyyyy
>>66110204
This is some good stuff too especially Lame Boy, very chill. Your production is really nice, too. Hi hats are a bit trebly but it's fine.
Here is the track I just released if you enjoy nostalgic chill electronic noise wall at 4 AM in the morning
https://soundcloud.com/wendigovegasdaddy/wvd-ritual-corruption-gate
>>66110663
>>66111138
>Some of my songs aren't rip-off's
>That fact validates my songs that are rip-offs
Jesus christ dude, I've seen young musicians/producers in these threads get criticized WAY harsher than you and handle it with more maturity and class.
Accepting criticism doesn't mean you have to incorporate it into your work. In fact you can accept criticism and then totally ignore it. Accepting criticism is really the same as "tolerating it". And judging from your responses, you can't. You can't tolerate real criticism.
I'm not trying to be your daddy, You twat. You sound like an angsty whiny teenage "producer" who wants to be taken seriously by other adults but can't act like one. Again, you're using your age and my age to somehow defend your bullshit arguments and thin skin.
Almost every single response you've given to criticism in this thread is basically
"I know what I'm talking about, you don't."
"I'm immune to criticism about my work, because muh genre, muh age"
You post in these threads like everyday and get tons of positive feedback, but today you get some substantive criticism beyond "I just wasn't feelin' it, dude", and you act like a whiny argumentative thin-skinned pussy... In a FEEDBACK THREAD.
There's been plenty of 18 year olds that get ripped to shreds when they share in these threads and they handle it like more of an adult than you did. So if you want to make it about age, okay: You're acting immature for your age, and there are people your age who are using criticisms from the world around them to grow and surpass you in life.
>>66111494
the only person still bringing up my age is you to gain a perceived edge
i'm handling it with class you're just on the receiving end of my arguments so you're getting more and more assblasted looking for ways to discredit my arguments without addressing their merit
and you've settled on "i'm not mad, you're the one who's mad, and i'm not the overly prideful one yet i continue to write you 2000 character responses that have linearly regressed into name calling and posturing"
you're absolutely right in one respect tho. i think you're wrong m8. i think you don't know what you're talking about. we're having a conversation about sample based hip hop. something that i do and you don't. i've outlined why you're wrong and given you examples but you just keeping shutting down and refusing to understand the nature of the hip hop industry.
also hurling insults and then acting like you're just giving innocent criticism is pretty transparent
>>66111213
You SHOULD be proud
Your work is phenomenal, especially "super real"
>>66111766
You were the first person to bring up YOUR age, and then MY age. And anyone who can read can see that in this thread. Who says I don't do sample based hip-hop? How would you know? Oh right, You're never wrong.
Alrighty then, I think that about wraps it up for me then. You had several anons trying to help you and you poo-poo'd and got so argumentative and defensive that now they think you're a whiny bitch when an hour or so ago you were still in pretty good standing. Way to alienate potential allies. Potential fans (one anon even said he liked your songs, just not the manner in which you "regurgitated").
You demonstrated that you care more about winning an argument than about growing as a person and learning from others.
You demonstrated that your pride is more valuable to you than honest feedback from the world.
You demonstrated that you believe that Merit should be valued equally by all, and when it is not, it is they who are wrong.
Good luck out there, Anon. You'll need it.
https://soundcloud.com/dasjchvxbzvc7/brand-new-wheels
>short sample based beat
>just posted
>music to ride your tricycle too
>funky
>>66112064
i brought it up my age for the sole purpose of framing your argument as the pathetic garbage pile it was and i haven't brought it up since yet you continue to to try to gain seniority.
again you're just posturing and trying to daddy me
i demonstrated i care as much about winning an argument as you do
especially when i'm arguing a completely valid point against someone refusing to acknowledge its validity
i demonstrated my pride is just as valuable as your pride
i demonstrated i believe merit should be valued equally by all. maybe not equally by all but should it be the largest factor? i don't see why not
are you arguing merit shouldn't play a role?
i'd say good luck out there but you won't get out there with your "melodic psychedelia"
>>66112213
>Pathetic garbage pile
You really do think everyone's point of view is inferior to yours, don't you? Or is that just the butthurt talking?
>Trying to daddy me
>Confusing daddying with "trying to help a pathetic bitch be less pathetic"
Do you have daddy issues? You've said the daddy thing twice now. Since you think everyone who criticizes you is trying to "daddy" you, do you also think everyone who gives you positive feedback is trying to fuck you?
>My argument is Valid. It's VALID! IT'S VALID!!!!!
When nobody acknowledges the validity of an argument, that means it's probably not valid you fuck-wit. Something isn't valid just because you think it is.
>>66112573
no i think your point of view on this particular topic is inferior to mine and i've given you clear examples and arguments as to why which you refuse to address
>daddy issues
real classy senpai
i don't think everyone who criticizes me is trying to daddy me
i think you are
you're using our age difference as a way to posture yourself to make it look like i'm just some stupid kid who doesn't know what i'm talking about and if i was just more mature than i'd agree with you
this all being in lieu of of actually discrediting the arguments i've presented
if an argument is invalid then debunk it instead of just saying it's invalid you moron
you saying it's invalid doesn't magically make it invalid
>>66112573
>>66112763
You're both pathetic
Stop trying to be smarter
>inb4 2000 characters of hot trash
>>66112763
>>66112573
You're both smart, stop being pathetic.
>>66112573
>>66112763
You're both smart pathetic beings
>>66113126
>internet argument
>pathetic
pick two
