One of these
Images are sometimes not shown due to bandwidth/network limitations. Refreshing the page usually helps.
You are currently reading a thread in /mu/ - Music
You are currently reading a thread in /mu/ - Music
Template coming
>>66051131
808 a 4 and TLOP a 6 are you stupid
bump
>>66050544
Full name?
>>66048918
>>66049182
>>66051131
>>66052744
nice generic opinions
>>66052947
what
>>66053418
he wants your information so he can swat you for teens of denial not being god tier
>>66048918
>Let's Dance anything but a 10
>Blackstar anything but a 10
>>66053483
ah sorry
i'm Will Barnes of William and Mary University, Virginia
in retrospect Denial is probably a 9 i got lost in the moment with the ratings
>>66053483
>>66053536
OK thanks
>>66051131
My man
>>66048918
>Never Let Me Down rated higher than Tonight
Stop
>>66052989
Generic but accurate nonetheless
>>66054755
I honestly can't get into pre-Lamb Genesis. Try as hard as I may, they always come off as a poor man's Yes on those albums to me.
When Peter Gabriel left to start his solo career he became a lot better, as well as Genesis became better because they started abandoning those symphonic prog cliches that were done better by the likes of Yes and King Crimson before.
Why albums like And Then There Were Three, Duke and Abacab get all this hate is beyond me, they're genuinely great art rock albums.
>>66048918
David Bowie - 3
Space Oddity - 6
TMWSTW - 7
Hunky Dory - 8
Ziggy Stardust - 10
Aladdin Sane - 9
Pinups - 6
Diamond Dogs - 7
Young Americans - 5
Station to Station - 9
Low - 10
Heroes - 10
Lodger - 7
Scary Monsters - 9
Let's Dance - 7
Tonight - 2
NLMD - 1
BTWN - 7
Outside - 10
Earthling - 5
Hours - 4
Heathen - 8
Reality - 4
The Next Day - 6
Blackstar - 9
>>66049182
Pablo Honey - 4
The Bends - 8
OK Computer - 9
Kid A - 9
Amnesiac - 7
HTTT - 6
In Rainbows - 10
TKOL - 5
AMSP - 8
>>66051131
College Dropout - 8
Late Registration - 9
Graduation 7
808s - 6
MBDTF - 10
Yeezus - 4
TLOP - 5
>>66054755
FGTR - 4
Trespass - 6
Nursery Cryme - 7
Foxtrot - 8
Selling England - 10
The Lamb - 9
Trick of the Tail - 9
Wind & Wuthering - 10
ATTWT - 6
Duke - 8
Abacab - 8
Genesis - 7
Invisible Touch - 6
We Can't Dance - 4
Clling All Stations - 1
>>66051131
Yeezus: 3
TLOP: 6
oh im laffin
>>66056055
what is happening
>>66056316
They were both my favorite albums at different points in time. I think that to get the full experience of Significant Other, you absolutely have to watch the entirety of Limp Bizkit's Woodstock 1999 video.
As for Three Dolla' Bill Ya'll, listen to Stuck and Counterfeit and Faith. The rest of the album is good for raw guitar bumping' jams too. It's got a good hardcore raw sound. Drumming is on point.
>>66056442
At first, I wasn't thinking you weren't serious with your post because Chocolate Starfish is probably the least good LB album out of the original three. Yet, it's the most popular so most people don't even bother checking out the original two.
>>66048918
these are some of the cringiest threads on /mu/
Accurate Kanye chart
>>66056481
Chocolate Starfish didn't click with me as heavy as it did until about a year n a half after i bought it.
Now it's kind of my go to album. The thing with Chocolate starfish is that its not their heaviest, but the ambience is heavy and forbidding.
It'll be OK
Livin' it up
Those two songs sell the atmosphere of Limp Bizkit harder than anything else I can think of. It's fucking stinky stuff.
>>66056641
my negro
>>66056970
>someone actually went to all this trouble
wew
>>66056970
>>66049182
Youre a pleb if you think kid a is better than amnesiac
>>66048918
Switch Hunky Dory and Ziggy Stardust ratings and you're good
>>66058188
>post-The Game Queen
>good
>>66050544
everything is inflated, but relative to each other those scores are pretty accurate
>>66056970
damn son where'd you find this?
>>66056641
I wanna wake up with you in my eyes
Please Please Me 10/10
With The Beatles 10/10
Hard Day's Night 10/10
Beatles For Sale 9/10
Help! 9/10
Rubber Soul 10/10
Revolver 10/10
Magical Mystery Tour 10/10
Sgt. Pepper 10/10
White Album 10/10
Let it Be 10/10
Abbey Road 10/10
Past Masters 10/10
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VzqoUqTwVVU
>>66054755
Trespass and Wind & Wuthering are their best
>>66056055
>altered states of america
>1
Is their only good album
>>66049182
i'm a radiohead fanboy but AMSP is nowhere near a 9, unfortunately
>>66056970
my nigga
>>66059022
Based Larry!
>>66059022
God, why is he so based? You can tell he just doesn't give a single fuck. Damn Larry, I wish you were my Dad sometimes... We could drink wine, watch comedies and talk Sparks and The Beatles all day.
>>66054921
I think Duke is pretty well accepted by most people outside of that American Psycho meme. But, shit, you really dont like Nursery Cryme or Foxtrot?
>>66056970
#truth #tybg
>>66048918
>outside that low
>>66048918
How is Pinups better than Diamond Dogs???
>>66048918
Here let me fix that okay?
David Bowie 5/10
Space Oddity 8/10
Man Who Sold The World 9/10
Hunky Dory 10/10
Ziggy Stardust 10/10
Aladdin Sane 10/10
Pin Ups 5/10
Diamond Dogs 9/10
Young Americans 9/10
Station To Station 10/10
Low 10/10
"Heroes" 9/10
Lodger 9/10
Scary Monsters 10/10
Let's Dance 9/10
Tonight 4/10
Never Let Me down 3/10
Black Tie 6/10
1.Outside 10/10
Earthling 7/10
Hours 6/10
Heathen 9/10
Reality 7/10
Next Day 8/10
Black Star 10/10
>>66052744
AnCo has a really solid discography
>>66061512
Not that I particularly dislike the earlier albums, they're well-crafted and the musicians playing on it are definitely competent at what they do, but I always get the feeling that I've seen that stuff being done before. Although I like some separate pieces like The Musical Box, Giant Hogweed, Watcher of the Skies, Supper's Ready, Firth of Fifth and Cinema Show, the albums on their entirety don't click much with me.
Which is why The Lamb was a surprise to me. I didn't expect to enjoy it that much since I only enjoyed specific tracks of the previous albums, but it just kept getting better and better from start to finish. It's my favorite Genesis album, followed by Duke, A Trick of the Tail and Wind & Wuthering.
But I seem to be on the minority, considering most people love those albums from Nursery Cryme to Selling England, so maybe I should give them more shots later on.
>>66061993
>puts the contrarian albums as god tier
>>66062320
What's contrarian about CS and HCTI
I'm sorry that MPP isn't my favorite
>>66048918
>Low better than Blackstar
You're garbage
>>66056641
Yes! YES!
>>66052794
where is her first album?
All 3 of Mr. Bungle's studio albums are absolutely flawless to me.
>>66065190
"Your opinion is wrong" - Montie
>>66049182
actually accurate
>>66051131
fuckin triggered desu
>>66049182
i just puked in my mouth a little
Please Please Me, 3/10
With The Beatles, 3/10
Meet The Beatles, 4/10
Hard Days' Night, 5/10
For Sale, 3/10
Help, 3/10
Rubber Soul, 5/10
Revolver, 5/10
Sgt Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band, 7/10
Magical Mystery Tour, 6/10
The Beatles, 6/10
Yellow Submarine, 5/10
Abbey Road, 7/10
Let It Be, 4/10
>>66056055
prob shitposting but i agree with korn and lb
>>66054755
You're a saint
also I would've gave Genesis to Revelation a 6
>>66061993
>MPP less than a 10
the fuck are you smoking
>>66065538
thanks scaruffi
>>66065538
unironically agreed
>>66065653
idiot
>>66054755
>not liking Invisible Touch
>>66065653
I just think it's a bit overrated. I still like it though
>>66058188
>Sheer Heart Attack
>not the best
>>66048918
Does anyone have that Heroes album art where Bowie is getting stopped by bullies with someone sticking a hand in his face?
>>66066416
It would be if it didn't include that awful She Makes Me song
>>66056641
I just realized this left off Exciter, which I would rate a 5.
>>66052744
bretty good
get it?
>>66067731
Those are some horrendous album covers
>>66056970
tybg!!!
>>66067731
Citgo Underated af desu
>>66052989
what a retarded thing to say
>>66048918
I'm actually alright with this
>>66051131
my friend. this is not good.
>>66070466
pretty much this, maybe switch UU and TPAB but they're both around 7.5 desu
>>66070761
end your life
>>66070852
switch dbr and Rodeo desu also owl pharaoh is more of a 4-5
>Hybrid theory 10/10
>Meteora 8/10
>the rest 1/10
you know that edgy kid inside you is still there /mu/
>>66062891
meme-ing faggot
>>66066828
Barter 6 is god-tier dammit
>>66054921
Poor man's Yes? Nah. Better lyrics.
>>66067731
First bang mixtape has to be a 10
>>66048918
I'd give Pinups a lower rating, Diamond Dogs a higher rating, Scary Monsters a god tier rating and black star a god tier rating, but other than that pretty good rankings desu.
>>66051131
>808s has become my favorite Kanye record
No one shares my accidental contrarian opinion with me. :(
>>66056641
Yeezus a 9? .... ok.
It sucks
>>66049182
hey i actually agree with one of these things for once
well done anon
>>66070886
>end your life
for having patrician taste?
This is the correct Pearl Jam one of these. Jesus god was Lightning Bolt horrible
>>66061993
feels = mpp = fucking painting shit what is wrong with you
>>66064955
>Licensed to Ill a 4
why
>>66058188
>Jazz
>Anything but a 10
>>66071611
I think that Feels and MPP are overrated, and that PW is pretty good.
>Painting Shit
get it together anon
>>66071751
>Feels
>anything but underrated ]
seriously, I don't understand this one. It's at LEAST MPP worthy and blows SJ out the agua.
>>66067421
>you decide what is ri-i-i-ight
Your privileges have been taken away.
>>66071806
I don't know, I feel like Fireworks and Cuckoo Cuckoo are better than anything on MPP.
Just different tastes I guess
>>66071303
pretty accurate
>>66066879
no love for Hardcore Devo. I mean yeah its a compilation but most of the tracks never got an official release till hardcore devo
>>66059022
Larry Graves is my nigger
>>66071303
Damn you beat me to it, anon. Same ratings I would have done. 10/10
>>66065408
Was Wildflower that good?
>>66061019
Let it grow on you anon.
Bring on the hate
>>66071590
i'd put every 10+god tier two points down and make riot act a 6, but you got this pretty much on point
>>66048918
there is only one god tier
>>66063314
Pretty good
>>66075455
>Live at Leeds
>Quadrophenia
>God Tier
My mate
>>66061959
You are correct
>>66063314
awful
exm
nldw
notm=gp>tms
and then dg became an official meme
>>66071303
I agree except Anatomy and Coma need to be lower while Parallax I should be higher
>>66065653
more like what ARENT you smoking haha get it because its stoner music
>>66056970
What year is it?
>>66052744
i would reduce feels and jam, and give PW an 8
anco are so consistenly good
>>66070466
somebody that gets it
>>66065538
>edgy opinions 101
>>66052794
I agree
>>66063262
>low higher than blackstar
you're garbage
>>66076791
debut 4
post 6
homogenic 8
vespertine 8
medulla 7
i don't remember the next ones enough they didn't click i didn't bother
>>66056006
nobody cares, use the fucking template provided you weirdo
haven't listened to all his material but this what i've heard so far
Make one for Massive Attack, New Order, or Grace Jones.
>>66051131
>808s a 4
kill yourself my man
>>66071180
i share it
>>66071094
This 2bh, Genesis' lyrics were a lot more meaningful than whatever pretentious shit Jon Davison was singing on Yes back then.
what do you fags think?
>>66055617
put hiram clarke hustler up to god tier
>>66048918
>earthling 5/10
Topkek
Sufjan Stevens
>>66062891
>a-a-anybody else like h3h3 here? ha ha
>>66056641
yeah but what about Cruel Summer?
>>66077547
>self-titled: 8
>Contra: god tier
>MVOTC: 6
>>66077547
self-titled:2/10
Contra:4/10
MVOTC:1/10
>>66056055
>altered states of america
>1
I bet you didn't even listen to the full thing you fucking pussy
>>66056970
Thank You Based God!! TYBG
>>66077907
He's an ilovesoftmusic-fag
>>66056641
Am I the only one who's not into 808's and heart breaks?
What do you guys like about this album?
>>66065538
You have to be really a pleb to have that generic opinion about The Beatles discography, I bet you're one of those who says "hurr the beatles are overrated hurr". Seriously, you must to be really ignorant to not understand the impact of Please Please Me on early 60s pop music. Here are the right ratings for the beatles discography.
>>66077971
And of course I'm stupid and left out the Magical Mystery Tour one of their best. Anyway it's a 9/10.
>>66077971
He's parroting Scaruffi for (You)s, silly anon.
>>66071180
>>66077398
Me too familia.
>>66078046
hmm, thanks for the advise anon.
>>66077971
>Let It Be is a 5
It honestly isn't that horrible. I've Got A Feeling, I Me Mine, Two Of Us, and Dig A Pony are great songs. The album seems like more of a collection than a cohesive thing.
>>66061993
Feels is defiantly more than a 6 anon.
>>66078242
Kinda agree with you, but it's just not my cup of tea and I prefer the "naked" version better.
>>66077406
you got the order wrong. instrument came out in 99. also furniture isn't that special but whatever. steady diet of nothing is underrated, everything else is fine
>>66076098
Pretty much!
>>66077547
7/10
6/10
5/10
>>66077971
>the impact of Please Please Me on early 60s pop music
who cares? who's that real art? what's the merit besides popularity? it sounds like washed up rock n roll for silly teenaged girls. grow up my man
>>66077975
i cannot stop laughing omg how did no one notice this
>>66079385
>who's that real art?
how's**
>>66064375
>out of order
>sergeant peppers being anything but god tier
>>66078516
>Let It Be... Naked
my nigga
>>66071180
same here
>>66056970
The only real God tiers are red flame and Gods Father
>>66063314
holy shit I completely agree with this
>>66077547
Pretty Accurate
>>66052744
![[Discography] Tori Amos.jpg](https://i.imgur.com/0v3d9cQ.jpg "[Discography] Tori Amos.jpg")
Get on my level
>>66080601
And the rest of them too
>>66063314
I don't get the love for no love deep web, it really fell flat on my first listen and then just proceeded to piss me off the more I listened to it, I thought it was a letdown desu, why do you like it?
>>66081195
I have no fucking clue why i wrote desu, I'm very tired and posting on a phone
>>66059022
He gets it. BASED Larry is my nigga.
>>66081195
>>66081248
>desu
it's a 4chan filter for "t b h" (i can't type it or else it'll filter me too)
>>66081015
change white album and abbey road to god tier and this is spot on
>>66077368
Memory vague is God- tier
>>66056641
yeezus is trash
>>66077427
forreal, my hops alone makes it god tier
>>66063314
exactly correct if GP is 7 and NLDW is an 8
>>66050544
>no little pieces of paper
>no disjecta membra
>no wave goodbye to the jets
>monomania not a god tier
>teens of style a 10
>>66076098
Solid 8/10
>>66076402
Lol you are the 2nd person who thinks Riot Act should be a 6, I just can't get into the album.
I stand by the 10's and God Tiers though. Ten and Verses have some of the best songs not only from the 90's grunge era, but all around are just amazing.
Vitalogy took some real chances with the experimental stuff, and it works because the ten core songs are all amazing. Vitalogy is just a top level album in all aspects.
The Pearl Jam self-titled was a total surprise when it came out because it really caught the best of their earlier stuff.
>>66084902
i figured that almost literally no one has listened to those on this board so why bother
also im obsessed with ToS version of strangers
>>66077975
AHAHAAH oh shit...
This joke is what like, 6 years old at this point? It's still just amazing at how many iterations of it are out there.
>>66049182
In Rainbows is better than OKC
>>66051131
Make Grad a 7, 808s an 8 and LR god tier
![[Discography] Kent.jpg](https://i.imgur.com/85MZWaA.jpg "[Discography] Kent.jpg")
Reposting old chart to keep the thread going
>>66056641
why do people always rate Late Registration so low? Especially with Graduation at 8 lol
>>66086287
bloot
>>66077957
It pretty much influenced every single post-2010 pop act
>>66077831
Agreed.
>>66070761
>muse
>anything over a five
kys memelord
>>66051131
>808s 4
>yeezus 3
triggered
>>66053499
>Let's Dance a 10
>>66077463
>Carrie and Lowell god tier
That's just wrong.AoA was better.
>>66063314
exm 8
tms 7
nldw 9
gp 7
notm 7
fw 6
jd 8
bp 8
Evidently, both commercial and creative success can destroy a band.
>>66067421
the first one is 7 and depression cherry is 9 but otherwise accurate
>>66070761
faggot
>>66086974
Why do you use four for five, eight for seven, ten for eight, and those stupid blood images for nine?
Anyway,
Bjork - 5/10
Debut - 8/10
Post - 9/10
Homogenic - 10/10
Vespertine - 8/10
Medulla - 7/10
Volta - 5/10
Biophilia - 6/10
Vulnicura - 8/10
Call me a pleb, but I think pop Bjork is best Bjork. Also, I don't think enjoying pop music constitutes as being a pleb as much as fearing certain genres of music does, even if that genre is pop.
>>66070761
>the resistance 9
>black holes 6
>>66071180
same desu
>>66087087
I picked my own ones out of several charts that I liked best and in my opinion best represented each score.
I don't have a 1, haven't needed to use yet and don't have an appropriate image. Then again 2 might be god for 1 but I'd need one new "reaction" to the bottom end. Oh well.
>>66076386
>in sorte diaboli lower than abrahadabra
>>66086922
exmg10
tms9
nldw8
gp7
notm9
fw7
jd9
bp8
>>66077645
THEY HAVE A FUCKING FIRST ALBUM?!?!
>>66086967 (Me)
I will say, though, Tales From Topographic Oceans and Relayer have god-tier album covers, but [the albums] were disappointing, because they arouse a desire for the highest without fulfilling it.
>>66087130
Those graphics make you look like a depraved fuck.
>>66065408
correct
>>66087434
At least they're good drawings as opposed to the shit most people now use.
>>66086442
and that's a good thing?
>>66086337
>Red only a 7
>>66088192
If it makes you feel better less than a year ago I would've rated it 5.
>>66077007
Maybe a 9 to Parallax I, but I think the others are just fine. I'm the OP by the way.
>>66088230
I'm also curious, why is SaBB only a 5?
>>66086755
nah. CaL is better
>>66087502
>good drawing
lol no
>>66088307
It's just so bland I can't really even answer that, run of the mill prog of its variety. Even at it's supposedly more adventurous moments it feels forced. Very typical KC sound without the interesting bits. I feel it lacks the melodic and even lyrical engagement present on their other records, something that their style vitally needs. 5 might even be an overstatement since I really just don't like it at all.
>>66088372
considerably better drawings*
>>66088463
>considerably better drawings*
are you kidding me? this is better? grow up
>>66087884
Well it did it better than every single post-2010 pop act
>>66088627
>still le fapping position
>still le star meme faec
>still le meaning of life XD
just fucking end yourself already
>>66077547
fuck off to tumblr
>>66064060
>The name of this band is talking heads
>8
what the fuck is this
let me help out with a relevant repost
>>66088785
all of the white ones are cringy af
>>66088785
how's the 'tism?
