ITT: One of these
Images are sometimes not shown due to bandwidth/network limitations. Refreshing the page usually helps.
You are currently reading a thread in /mu/ - Music
You are currently reading a thread in /mu/ - Music
ITT: One of these
>>66022615
Template?
>>66022660
here you go
>>66022731
patrician detected
![[Discography] Kent.jpg](https://i.imgur.com/q8RW6eu.jpg "[Discography] Kent.jpg")
This was harder than I thought to balance out ratings properly.
>tfw most /mu/tants will have absolutely no relation to this discog
beginning dump 1/9
>inb4 people will only reply to my last post
>>66024216
2/9
>>66024228
3/9
>>66024242
4/9
i can feel how no one cares about these great bands but everyone cares about my final pleb band
>>66024253
5/9
>>66024273
6/9
>>66024289
7/9
>>66024305
8/9
i can feel them pleb tears already
>>66024315
9/9
here we go
>>66024329
I was totally digging your taste untill I saw your qotsa ratings, those are terrible my man
Other than that, good taste friendo
>>66024338
i will never understand qotsa fans
>>66024329
>build up you final post as something to get the plebs mad
>it's the same fucking QOTSA/Kyuss chart that's in all of these threads
Good job on saving that image and posting it again
>>66024375
that's because i always post in these threads, tho
>>66024375
also
>didn't even notice i always post that one image with the other bunch
classical pleb qotsa fans
>>66024305
>pod is only an 8
>>66024405
Do you really expect me to believe that someone who says "i can feel them pleb tears already" has anything but a newfag?
>>66024413
Really, show me when you've posted all of them together in the archive.
(Also, I don't even listen to QOTSA)
>>66023020
pleb from /b/ here, haven't been to /mu/ for more than one day, but I love Kent. Röd is a fucking masterpiece and Du & Jag Döden gives me the chills everytime
>>66024445
>has anything but a newfag
>has
wut
u retarded son
also i don't know if someone copied these ratings or something, but those are originally mine, idk and idc baka desu senpai
>>66024216
Bitch Magnet is raw, love it.
posting my one from last thread
>>66023020
isn't kent a swedish equivalent to coldplay? i used to listen to them a bit in 2010-ish.
>>66024242
what are the 1st and 3rd of the upper row called? haven't got those myself. also, 13 songs is a 10/10 as well.
>>66024289
i didn't find without a sound to be that bad, really. you're living all over me is definitely their high point though.
>>66024305
surfer rosa+come on pilgrim combined are definitely 10/10, i can understand your score on doolittle but that's a personal 10/10 as well. bossanova and trompe le monde aren't as good as the first ones but still very enjoyable imo
>>66024705
worst ratings itt desu, michigan is atleast 9/10, illinoise is more like 8, age of adz needs atleast 2 points more and carrie and lowell is definitely not his best... i have to admit i haven't listened to his whole discography yet so can't comment on the rest. also, all delighted people ep is probably the same rank as c&l in my books. maybe better.
>>66024496
I'll admit that I fucked up typing has instead of is, I'm probably fucking dyslexic or something. I just don't see why you'd go out of your way to be a contrarian asshole to prove what exactly? If you legit didn't like the band, or at least a half decent troll, you would have at least made a statement on why you didn't like them as opposed to "lol qotsa plebs".
>>66024988
i'm not trying to be contrary tho, i just don't see the appeal in qotsa, more specifically post-2002 qotsa
>>66024907
demos an margin walker. 1st ep + margin walkers were later combined into 13 songs, which is a compilation. also every single pixies album is good 2bh
>>66023020
>>66024485
Du & Jag Döden is by far the best album
I'm obviously a big fan so don't take it seriously if you disagree. I'll post more in a bit.
>>66023020
i love vapen & ammunition. good chart.
>>66024315
> badmotorfinger and louder than love that low
Take it back
>>66024988
alright, i'm gonna post a more intricate review.
first things first, josh homme started out as a really young guitar player (iirc he was like 16 or so) for a legendary metal band called kyuss, and just with that he started out great so consequently i will always think his later work is worse. not that it's bad by itself of course, but if i'm comparing kyuss will always be much better. kyuss is imo the high point of his career, it's just such a good band, i think most people will agree with me on this.
qotsa imo started out as a sort of kyuss side-project which basically took kyuss's riffs but put them into catchier songs, a sort of pop-stoner metal if you will. and it worked really nicely actually. qotsa's first album (which is basically just a josh homme solo album right after kyuss broke up) works really well, i love all of the instrumentals. i know he tried to look for a lead singer for his new band but because he didn't like anyone he saw for the range he wanted, he sang himself of that first album. and it sorta works, it's not amazing but it does the job. the songs sound cool and sorta dirty too, like an updated version of 70's music without the degrading part of the 80's.
next came rated r, a more commercial album, that despite everything works well and is basically a followup, but without the "edge" (not trying to sound ironic here, josh homme's music imo always had some punkish feeling to it), a bit more washed out. still the songs are decent. songs for the deaf is basically a more well produced and more thought out follow up, with technically better songs.
the thing about these 2 albums (rated r and sftd) is that they're both ok. they're not amazing jaw dropping, and they're not weak and lame either. 3 years later, when lullabies came out, i thought this trend of being lamer would stop but it only increased. lullabies has basically no good points going for it other than it sounds like previous qotsa albums. (cont.)
>>66026104
(cont.) lullabies is weak, most songs are passable (little sister is probably the only one i can tend to like more) and their overall structure is too embedded in this bluesy sound that's just kinda eh. era vulgaris is sort of a mess, the title track (probably the most interesting song) isn't even a part of the track list, the singles are "ok" (a rammstein cover and a lame qotsa style love song), the structure of the whole album is kinda weak. the album was kinda forgettable for so long, it's strange people seem to praise it so much these days. for its time no one cared about it.
like clockwork, the new album, is even weaker, the songs are too long for stuff that just never becomes interesting, everyone seems to praise it for no real reason, and when you talk to these people it just feels like its the first album they've listened too for the first time start to finish. protip: there are way better things out there. i could talk about it more but why? it has no theme (people insist it does when most songs don't even flow together), the song struture is weak for qotsa standards, nothing is catchy (this is important for qotsa since this is their whole purpose) nor is it introspective (not like kyuss), it's just something eh that sort of exists.
idk i just feel like josh basically took the way of every beat up washed out rock start has, his songwriting skills declined, became less interesting, and sadly only became well known in retrospect (this is important), which means every time people get to hear a new qotsa album they think it's the second coming of jesus (since all those other ones were too right?), when it's just another weak album from an ok guy who did some interesting stuff some years ago.
it's really overrated and it tires me to have to reply almost solely about qotsa every time i post these ratings. qotsa isn't even that good or popular in /mu/, or at least it wasn't a few years ago.
>>66026257
I thought the songwriting on Like Clockwork was great, it's one of my favourites if not my favourite qotsa record
And no, this is not my first qotsa album, I've been a long time qotsa and Kyuss fan
Also, sftd is better than rated r, I thought rated r was rather bland actually
>>66024253
Leaves Turn Inside You not at least a 9?
>>66022731
Kill this fucking meme how do you regurgitate the same shit every single day of your life every chance you get like holy shit bro do us all a favor and go out and fuck a female please
>>66026382
i thought the same when it came out too actually, but listening to their discography one day made me realize it's actually a pretty decent album.
idk what to tell you about like clockwork, then, i just don't like it and i don't see the appeal. to each his own i guess.
>>66023020
De här betygen är inflaterade helt åt helvete. Hur fan är Vapen & ammunition en tia? Gå tillbaka till Eskilstuna.
>>66025513
Subtract 2 from each of those scores and that looks pretty accurate
>>66024705
Illinois>Michigan>All Delighted People>Age of Adz=Carrie & Lowell>the rest
>>66024705
Damn dude do you only like stuff if p4k likes it?
>>66025424
This has got to be the weirdest taste in AnCo I have ever seen.
Like usually if Spirits is a top they like Danse and HCTI. Its like you just started listening to AnCo, but somehow like Spirits.
>>66024305
What would you rate Indie Cindy?
Personally I would rate em like this:
COP 6
SR 10
D 8
B 7
TLM 8
IC 6
>>66026438
Not gonna happen because he's obviously a fucking faggot
>>66025513
kill yoruself my man
>>66022615
>>66024329
>those QotSA ratings
holey moley
>>66024315
>vitalogy is the best pearl jam
Yep.
>superunknown is the best soundgarden
Not bad, bro. Not bad. I figured you'd try to be contrarian with Soundgarden and rank Superunknown low just because it's popular.
>>66027063
like a 5 or a 4 even
>>66028547
nah superunknown is like the best grunge album out there probably. perfect songwriting
>>66025513
Neither Pablo Honey nor The Bends nor Amnesiac nor In Rainbows nor Moon are that good.
>>66028456
>Thrills and Bowl of Fire not God-Tier
>>66022615
I agree with this chart so much. Neil has been based since Damn Skippy.
>>66024705
>carrie & lowell
>the most consistently boring
>the least adventurous
>the most cringe-worthy lyrics
>god tier
Carrie & Lowell is, at best, Angsty High School Poetry Tier.
>>66028904
Thrills is barely a proper Andrew Bird album. It's got a lot of good ideas, but it's more just him experimenting and trying shit out to see what happens. There's no cohesion and no refinement.
Bowl of Fire at God Tier? Are you fucking kidding me? It's not bad at all, but it's nowhere near his Eggs/Armchair/Beast output.
this took a while
>>66029229
Man Who Sold The World probably isn't an 8 in my book.
Honky Dory is top tier.
Pinups is a bit too hight.
Station to Stations definitely isn't God Tier.
Lodger and Scary Monsters are definitely too high.
Let's Dance? Really?
Good job recognizing that Heath was great.
>>66029229
Not bad friend.
David Bowie 5/10
Space Oddity/David Bowie 8/10
Man Who Sold The World 7/10
Hunky Dory 10/10
Ziggy Stardust 10/10
Aladdin Sane 10/10
Pin Ups 5/10
Diamond Dogs 9/10
Young Americans 9/10
Station To Station 9/10
Low 10/10
"Heroes" 9/10
Lodger 9/10
Scary Monsters 10/10
Let's Dance 8/10
Tonight 4/10
Bowie goofs AKA Never Let Me Down 3/10
Black Tie 6/10
1. Outside 10/10
Earthling 7/10
Hours 6/10
Heathen 9/10
Reality 7/10
Next Day 8/10
Black Star 9/10
>>66029397
>Man Who Sold The World probably isn't an 8 in my book.
>Pinups is a bit too high.
>Lodger and Scary Monsters are definitely too high.
>Let's Dance? Really?
I can kinda see these, but I'm a huge Bowie fan. Also, I don't know why people hate on Let's Dance so much. I don't like the albums following it or the effects it had on Bowie, but I still like it.
>Good job recognizing that Heath was great.
I'm pretty sure everyone knows it was great, but thanks anyways.
1 million hours in paint
>>66029497
Let's Dance is underrated and commonly associated with Tonight and Never Let Me Down. Shame really, for what it is (an 80s dance album with some smart song writing) it's pretty remarkable.
>>66029229
Literally me
I'll probably make one for LOC/CV and maybe SFH later on
>>66022731
is the first album cover a reference to HANL?
>>66024705
What a pleb
>>66028456
Pulaski at Night is his best tho..
I'll just leave this here :')
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VzqoUqTwVVU
>>66029497
>I'm pretty sure everyone knows it was great, but thanks anyways
I think fans know it's great, but he has such a huge catalog that, among the general populous, it's never mentioned in the same breath as his great 70's output.
Jimmy Buffet ratings when?
>>66029540
TGM is God tier, the seer is inferior
>>66029540
Swans are Dead is amazing
>>66025513
Amnesiac is leagues better than the bends and amsp m8
>>66024705
Adz is his best imo
>>66024705
>age of adz
>5/10
>>66026594
Respekterar åsikten, även om jag aldrig har varit i Eskilstuna.
Generellt sätt skulle jag ändå säga att deras average skiva ligger kring 7-8, och jag betygsätter personligen dessa charts utifrån bandets diskografi. Jämfört med deras övriga skivor är det enligt mig helt klart en tia, om man jämför med alla album i världen så skulle jag säga att det är 8.5-9.0. Men sen är jag en äcklig fanboy för Kent so yeah.
>>66030976
>prospect hummer and hcti 5
>>66024216
lol why are these bands together? Jon Fine was in Don Caballero for like 7 live performances or something, but that's it.
>>66031434
cause bitch magnet and slint each have very small discographies and even the two together would make up a small pic. don cab also as a small-ish discography so i just put them all together for genre thing
thread's dead :(
1/3
>>66032091
2/3
>>66032117
3/3
>>66025513
Pablo Honey = 4/10
The Bends = 7/10
OK Computer = 7/10
Kid A = 10/10
Amnesiac = 9/10
HTTF = 7/10
In Rainbows = 10/10
TKOL = 5/10
AMSP = 8/10
>>66032117
>Let It Be
>Anything higher than 5
That album was a trainwreck
>>66030906
How can anyone think this?
>>66024705
I've been meaning to check out his discography but have no idea where to start. Suggestions anyone?
>>66031054
>>66032117
Please Please Me 9/10
With The Beatles 9/10
Hard Day's Night 10/10
Beatles for Sale 9/10
Help! 9/10
Rubber Soul 10/10
Revolver 10/10
SGT. Pepper 10/10
Abbey Road 10/10
Let It Be 9/10
I'm not even joking...
>>66026594
>>66031329
Känns som jag är den enda som i stort sett älskar alla Kent-album lika mycket, jag tycker verkligen de är skitbra allihop. Men om jag skulle vara tvungen att rangordna dem blir det ungefär:
Röd
Du & Jag Döden
Hagnesta Hill
Tillbaka till Samtiden
Vapen & Ammunition
Då Som Nu För Alltid
Verkligen
Isola
Jag är inte rädd för mörkret
Tigerdrottningen
En plats i solen
Kent
>>66032585
Får man fråga vad det är som får dig att sätta Verkligen över Isola, och hur det kommer sig att Tillbaka till Samtiden är så högt upp? No hate, bara intresserad.
>>66031054
>white album
>10/10
what you smoking son
>>66032692
Det är nog inte tillräckligt många låtar som tilltalar mig på Isola, på Verkligen tycker jag samtliga låtar är mycket bra, men endast en handfull på Isola. (Dock har jag varit lite dålig på att lyssna på just det albumet av någon anledning, kan vara låtar jag egentligen skulle tycka mycket om, om jag gav de några chanser)
Jag gillar det nya soundet på Tillbaka till samtiden, och tycker att texterna är fantastiska. Favoriter är Vid din sida, LSD, någon? och Columbus
>>66025424
ultrapleb detected
>>66032759
The White album was fucking fantastic anon, what are YOU smoking
>>66030976
not only are you a massive and irredeemable pleb, you're a p4k drone
wow
>>66032835
>crack cocaine
too much filler to be 10/10 and it's definitely not the best beatles album
>>66030976
STGSTV is god-tier, and yeah, CHZ and PW weren't that good, but 2's? Jesus.
>>66032200
really?
>ITI - 9
>ROF - 9
>everything else 5-6
>>66032968
what do you consider to be filler on that album. Genuinely want to know
>>66032968
>too much filler
Eh, White Album to me has always been one of the rare cases where filler actually really worked. The Beatles were beginning to drift apart at this point, and had to follow Sgt Pepper's up with something amazing, so it gave each member a chance to show their own individual musical identity and having such a sporadic and colorful track listing showed this. Understandable why people might not like it but it's genius to me.
>>66032814
Bra val av favoriter på TtS.
>>66033070
Why Don't We Do it in the Road, Ob-La-Di, Piggies,
to be honest looking back over the track listing it's not as bad as I remember, filler was the wrong term to use
>>66033085
I think my problem with the album is more this, the White Album doesn't feel like a cohesive musical project, although it does contain some of the Beatles best songs, it's not the Beatles as a band working at their peak
>>66033267
>ob-la di
>piggies
KYS, my man
>>66033279
>>66033053
But Angles is their best album. Room On Fire is their worst.
>>66032310
By not being autistic
>>66032390
how do you not realize that ratings become meaningless when used this way. do you honestly think please please me is ONE POINT away from revolver?
>>66033267
>it's not the Beatles as a band working at their peak
That's sort of my point really. As a band they weren't at their peak, that was in the Rubber Soul/Revolver years IMO. The White Album was Paul/John/George at their own individual best.
>>66025424
Thanks for the template
>>66033482
completely agree my man
test
>>66033413
Yes I do. It's early Beatles, oh it was recorded in a few hours sooo yeah. Pretty nifty when you think about
>>66029682
No it's a reference to The Death of Marat, the second most famous paining of all time after the Mona Lisa.
KYS
>>66026257
Like Clockwork is full of little details and has some of their most detailed and better guitar work. The sobgwriting is consistently great. The lyrics are personal yet still slightly abstract, and the delivery is great. It's easily Homme's most emotional work yet. It also is pretty diverse and has some neat ideas (the low, heavy tone on the bass (?) Of the first song, for example)
Regarding Era Vulgaris, it's their dirtiest, more angular release and my personal favorite. It sounds glued together, with song parts that barely fit into eachother. Yet, it oddly works, and that's its charm. It's an album full of personality imo. Homme's sarcastic political lyrics add to its charm.
>>66032138
From a Basement is a 10 my friend
I'm not even mad their latest output is terrible, it just makes me really sad. They should have disbanded after Wish.
>>66033267
>ob-la-di
i hate the beatles but you're genuinely wrong here
>>66032358
Illinois is easily his most accessible. I'd say it's definitely the place to start.
>>66028886
Looks like someone needs to get better taste. Nah just kidding. I did say it's my personal opinion as I'm a big fan :)
>>66030976
Sung tongs that low?
>>66031054
How the fuck is MMT scored higher than rubber soul, revolver and Sgt. Pepper? Also using .5s is autistic as fuck
>>66032015
I liked Always
PART 1
>>66031054
How do you even rate Please, Please Me? I mean in the context of The Beatles it's trash but as pop music goes it is 9/10
>>66031054
these rating are okay, but i would put please please me and with the beatles at a 5 and a 4 respectively
>>66025102
CC#DGBbCCBbCC#DGBbCCBbCC#DGBbCCBbCC#DGBbCCBb
>>66037851
i was trying to figure this out but it feels like you took waiting room and transcribed it wrong
>>66032138
>tfw Either/Or, S/t, and Roman Candle isn't 10/10
my dude.
Also, basement is shite. Figure 8 was a 6-ish. XO is p-good.
>>66029540
>TGM
>not a 10
>>66028482
but you've forgotten one crucial detail,
REM sucks donkey balls
>>66029974
It's definitely his best EP. I just feel like there's not enough of it to constitute true God Tier. It's like an incomplete perfect thought.
>>66031054
>Let it Be
> 5
wtf?
>>66038901
>REM sucks donkey balls
Woah there, Edgemeister. You need to slow it down just a bit.
>>66031054
This is some of the trolliest trolling I've ever seen on /mu/, and that's saying something for this board.
>revolver only an 8
>sgt pepper only an 8
>white the best?
>mmt anything above 5
>>66024329
Kek nigger clockwork is the best rock album from the last 3 decades.
>>66039058
I'll admit to coming on a little strong, but I've never been able to get past how whiny they sound
>>66031054
> Beatles "Most Underrated album" For Sale a 3
>Yellow Submarine a is above For Sale?!
>Let It Be a 5?!?!
As a Beatles fanatic... I disagree.
>>66037870
>Campfire Songs
>not god tier
Step up nigga.
>>66039106
Out of curiosity, have you listened to any particular albums, or are you just going on a few random singles you've heard?
>>66039142
>beatles fanatic
>>66039142
>Let It Be a 5
That's probably too generous. That's one of the worst Beatles album. It's certainly the worst of their later discography, and it's only on par with some of their mid-tier early albums. It sounds like a disjointed collection of half-baked ideas from a group of individuals who had long since ceased to be a coherent band.
Because that's exactly what it is.
>>66039436
That doesn't make since Abbey Road is the last album that was recorded. Not Let It Be.
If anything, the real reason Let It Be sucks is because Phil Spector, who knew nothing about the Beatle's dynamics or how they should sound, was producing instead of George Martin. Don't get me wrong, Phil Spector is not a bad producer, just not for an experimental pop rock band that was slowly but surely breaking up.
>>66026680
I actually have no problems with this except I would lower the Shapes S/T to a 7
>>66033138
> RAM not a 10 or 11
>>66039639
Fuck me, meant to say it didn't make sense, not since.
>>66039255
sister is a big REM fan, used to have to listen to a whole bunch of their stuff in the car driving around
I would name particulars, but unfortunately I was never interested enough to pursue their music fully
time for a re-listen I guess......
>>66028482
>not liking Fables
Why?
>>66022615
Pablo Honey - Annoyingly generic
The Bends - Descent, still too generic sometimes
OK Computer - Magic
Kid A - Good, but not that good
Amnesiac - I forgot a lot of it. I think the ending was good
Hail to the Thief - Underrated and pretty good from what I remember. I don't know.
In Rainbows - At lest descent, I think. I don't recall.
Hail to the Thief - Who gives a shit?
A Moon Shaped - Descent Growing on me, I guess.
if anyone here actually knows about bluebird handwriting here i'll be extremely surprised but w/e
>>66039722
*least
>>66030976
Like the other dude said, I will never understand why people will give Spirit a 10 and then shit on Danse/Indian/Hollind/e.t.c
It's like they like it just for indie cred or something
>>66024253
LEAVES TURN INSIDE YOU ISNT A FUCKING GOD TIER ALBUM??!??????? YOU FUCKING PLEBEIAN
>>66039722
>Descent
>>66039722
>Descent Growing on me, I guess.
We /vr/ now?
But your still a pleb, even while ignoring your spelling mistakes.
>>66032138
Roman Candle is personally a God tier album for me but I agree with this wholeheartedly
>>66025513
this is accurate, maybe knock AMSP down 1
>>66033027
It's to show how hip he is with the /mu/ scene.
>See guys, I love the albums you praise and hate the ones you don't.
But really anon, it's okay to form your own opinion, in fact, music is way better when you feel like you can enjoy whatever you want, instead of wondering if Anthony Fandango will give it an 8 or not. That's 2 people now that love the shit out of STGSTV, but they don't love HCTI or at least like Danse more than CHz? Wtf?
>>66037870
Swap HCTI with ST and do the same for MPP and SJ. You're a real fan of AnCo huh? It's a shame people like you get shit on here for pleb taste.
>>66041259
You know whatsup
(except f#a# infinity is God tier and you know it you son of a bitch)
>>66041336
idk LYSF really comes together as a whole, with a wide array of emotional states, whereas F#A#infinity has 2 god-tier songs and a good-tier dark ambient song. It gives a strong atmosphere, but doesn't have the biblical scale as LYSF.
At least, not to me.
>>66033327
maybe if you don't actually like the strokes
SJ would be starry eyes if it was thicker
>>66039722
>Hail to the Thief - Underrated and pretty good from what I remember. I don't know.
>Hail to the Thief - Who gives a shit?
What did he mean by this?
>>66032015
Bump twin peaks to a nine and I can agree with this
