>Best: Barbarism Begins At Home
>Second best: I Want the One I Can't Have
>Worst: Rusholme Ruffians
>Underrated: Well I Wonder
>Overrated: The Headmaster Ritual
>>65676188
I actually totally agree with you
>>65676218
Thank you, fellow patrician taste
>>65676188
This seems
Right
>>65676188
>Worst: Rusholme Ruffians
kill urself my man
>Best: I Want the One I Can't Have
>Second best: That Joke Isn't Funny Anymore
>Worst: Meat is Murder
>Underrated: Rusholme Ruffians
>Overrated: Barbarism Begins At Home
suck my dick OP
>Best
Headmaster Ritual
>Second Best
Nowhere Fast
>Worst
That Joke Isn't Funny Anymore
>Underrated
Well I Wonder
>Overrated
Barbarism Begins At Home
>Best
Help Me, Ronda
>Second Best
I'm So Young
>Worst
Dance Dance Dance
>Underrated
Good to my Baby (my overall favourite)
>Overrated
Please Let Me Wonder
>>65677123
This, but swap That Joke Isn't Funny Anymore for the title track and it's perfect
>>65677160
B-but I like the title track ;_;
these are the best threads
>best
prom night
>runner up
14400 minutes
>worst
22 offs
>overrated
brain cells
>underrated
long time II
>>65676188
>best
nowhere fast
>runner up
well i wonder
>worst
what she said
>overrated
i want the one i can't have
>underrated
meat is murder
>>65677194
me too, gotta have a worst though
MBDTF
Best: Lost in the World
Runner up: Devil in New Dress
Worst: Gorgeous (still like the Kanye parts tho)
Overrated: So Apalled
Underrated: Who will Survive in America
>>65677406
>worst
>what she said
I'm curious why you think it's the worst. I think it's a sweet track with god tier lyrics.
>Best
Nowhere Fast
>Second Best
Headmaster's Ritual
>Worst
Rusholme Ruffians (still at least 9/10)
>Underrated
Meat Is Murder
>Overrated
I Want The One I Can't Have
>Best: there is a light that never goes out
>second best: bigmouth strikes again
>worst: No one has ever
>underrated: vicar in a tutu
>Overrated: cemetery gates
...this was pretty hard to do
>>65678006
>best: Some girls
>second best: Bigmouth strikes again
>worst: Vicar in a tutu
>underrated: Never had no one ever or Frankly mr. shankly
>overrated: Cemetery gates or There is a light that never goes out
They're all still stellar tracks, of course. All except Vicar, fuck that song.
>>65678087
I actually like yours better, I should of put there is a light as overrated
>Best
Ruiner
>Second best
A Warm Place
>Worst
I Do Not Want This
>Underrated
Reptile
>Overrated
Hurt
>>65678006
How is that hard to do
Except for the runner up those are all the commonly accepted answers
>>65678303
>Worst
Big Man With A Gun
FTFY
>Best : Apostate
>Second best : The Seer
>Worst : 93 Ave. Blues
>Underrated : The Daughter Brings the Water / The Wolf
>Overrated : Lunacy
>>65676188
>Best: I Want the One I Can't Have
>Second best: Nowhere Fast
>Worst: Meat Is Murder
>Underrated: Rusholme Ruffians
>Overrated: The Headmaster Ritual
Meat is murder is absolutely the worst. Fuck I hate that horrible dirge. There is no reason to listen to that song more than once
>Best
Casimir Pulaski Day
>Runner Up
Come on! Feel the Illinoise!/John Wayne Gacy Jr.
>Worst
In This Temple
>Underrated
Concerning the UFO Sighting
>Overrated
Come On! Feel the Illinoise!
>>65678303
desu the Johnny Cash cover is hella overrated but original Hurt is still pretty nice
>>65678006
>>65678087
>cemetery
>e
Best: The Purple Bottle
Runner up: Banshee Beat
Worst: Flesh Canoe
Overrated: Grass
Underrated: Daffy Duck
Great thread OP
>>65679123
I'd put Chicago as overrated
>>65676188
>best: that joke isn't funny anymore
>second best: well i wonder
>worst: what she said
>underrated: nowhere fast
>overrated: none of it?
>>65677155
>best: kiss me baby
>second best: please let me wonder
>worst: don't hurt my little sister (not counting bull session with big daddy)
>underrated: when i grow up to be a man
>overrated: again none of it
worst is dance dance dance? fucking kill yourself. thrilling track
>>65677424
>best: lost in the world/who will survive in america
>second best: all of the lights
>worst: hell of a life
>underrated: devil in a new dress
>overrated: runaway
>>65678006
>best: the boy with the thorn in his side
>second best: i know it's over
>worst: vicar in a tutu
>underrated: the queen is dead
>overrated: some girls are bigger than others
>>65679089
best: a piece of the sky
second best: the apostate
worst: the wolf
underrated: 93 ave b blues or the seer returns
overrated: mother of the world
>>65679123
best: predatory wasp of the palisades
second best: john wayne gacy jr.
worst: jacksonville i guess
underrated: to the workers of the rock valley region AND night zombies
overrated: chicago i guess except not even
classic album
>Best: i want her she wants me
>Second best: care of cell 44
>Worst: maybe after he's gone
>Underrated: friends of mine or hung up on a dream
>Overrated: brief candles
i like all the tracks though
>>65679797
Mother of the World overrated ? C'mon.
Also how the fuck The Seer Returns is overrated m8, it's the most popular song on that album (and rightly so, it's as close to a hit as Swans can come).
>>65679851
>Worst: maybe after he's gone
>Best: I Only Said
>Second Best: To Here Knows When
>Worst: Touched
>Underrated: What You Want
>Overrated: When You Sleep
>>65676188
>Best: Barbarism Begins At Home
what
>Second best: I Want the One I Can't Have
the
>Worst: Rusholme Ruffians
fuck
>Underrated: Well I Wonder
you
>Overrated: The Headmaster Ritual
doing
>Best: The Headmaster Ritual
>Second Best: That Joke Isn't Funny Anymore
>Worst: Meat Is Murder
>Underrated: What She Said
>Overrated: Rusholme Ruffians
>>65678006
>Best: Bigmouth Strikes Again
>Second Best: The Queen Is Dead
>Worst: Vicar In A Tutu
>Underrated: I Know It's Over
>Overrated: There Is A Light That Never Goes Out
>Best
Nobody Moves
>Runner-up
1996
>Worst
Missing You
>Underrated
Battalions
>Overrated
Fork and Knife
>>65677091
Correct
>>65677424
>Best
Runaway
>Runner-up
Lost in the World
>Worst
Monster
>Underrated
Gorgeous
>Overrated
Devil in a New Dress
>>65678006
>Best
I Know It's Over
>Runner-up
Bigmouth Strikes Again
>Worst
Vicar in a Tutu
>Underrated
Some Girls Are Bigger Than Others
>Overrated
The Boy with the Thorn in his Side
>Best: Lions
>Second Best: Down To The Waterline
>Worst: Setting Me Up
>Underrated: In The Gallery/Six Blade Knife
>Overrated: None, I guess Sultans maybe
>Best: Untitled
>Second best: Untitled
>Worst: Untitled
>Underrated: Untitled
>Overrated: Untitled
>>65680206
>Worst
>Missing You
Noooooooo. I always thought the Luca version on this was awful.
>>65678006
>Best
There is a Light
>Runner-Up
I Know It's Over
>Worst
Vicar in a Tutu
>Underrated
Frankly, Mr. Shankly
>Overrated
Bigmouth Strikes Again
>Best: Rock 'n' Roll Star
>Second Best: Slide Away
>Worst: Up In The Sky
>Underrated: Columbia
>Overrated: Cigarettes & Alcohol
>Best
Tired of Sex
>Second Best
The Good Life
>Worst
No Other One (still a solid 7/10)
>Underrated
Why Bother?
>Overrated
El Scorcho
>Best: The Cinema Show
>Second Best: Battle of Epping Forest
>Worst: Firth of Fifth
>Underrated: More Fool Me
>Overrated Firth of Fifth
>Best: For Reverend Green
>Second best: Chores
>Worst: Peacebone
>Underrated: Winter Wonder Land
>Overrated: Peacebone
>>65679140
What was Morrissey smoking?
>Best
Mayonaise
>Second best
Soma
>Worst
Sweet Sweet
>Underrated
Spaceboy
>Overrated
Cherub Rock
>>65680270
>Best
Supersonic
>Runner-up
Slide Away
>Worst
Digsy's Diner
>Underrated
Supersonic
>Overrated
Rock 'n' Roll Star
>>65680343
I'll 2nd this.
>>65680343
almost right
>underrated
Geek USA
>>65680334
cock
>>65680320
Bored, so I'll do another.
>Best: Entangled
>Second Best: Ripples
>Worst: A Trick of the Tail
>Underrated: Mad Man Moon
>Overrated: Squonk
>>65678006
>underrated: vicar in a tutu
agree with this, i don't get the hate for it 2bh
>>65678006
>Best: I know it's over
>Second Best: Never had no one ever
>Worst: NO BAD SONGS FOR FUCKS SAKE
>Best
Change (In the House of Flies)
>Second Best
Knife Prty
>Worst
Elite
>Underrated
Teenager
>Overrated
Passenger
>Best: Eriatarka
>Second best: Cicatriz ESP
>Worst: Son Et Lumiere
>Underrated: This Apparatus Must Be Unearthed
>Overrated: Televators
>Best
Angeles
>Second best
Between the Bars
>Worst
Punch and Judy
>Underrated
Cupid's Trick
>Overrated
Pictures of Me
>>65676188
best is headmaster ritual desu
That Joke Isnt Funny Anymore is overrrated
Otherwise I agree
>>65678006
Hope all of you know the best song is The Boy With The Thorn In His Side
>>65679094
I feel like the only reason people hate Meat is Murder is because it takes a pretty hard stance about vegetarianism. I like the song, the lyrics don't bother me. I get that Morrissey is passionate about the topic. The only thing I dislike are the cow noises, it's a little cheesy to me.
>>65680555
>Best
Angeles
>Second Best
Ballad of Big Nothing
>Worst
2:45 am
>Underrated
Cupid's Trick
>Overrated
Say Yes
>Best
Jesus of Suburbia
>Runner-up
Letterbomb
>Worst
She's a Rebel
>Underrated
Whatsername
>Overrated
Wake Me Up When September Ends
>>65678006
>Best
The Queen is Dead
>Second Best
Bigmouth
>Worst
Vicar
>Underrated
Frankly Mr Shankly
>Overrated
There Is A Light
>>65679123
>best
Casimir
>second best
the predatory wasp
>worst
night zombies, maybe?
>underrated
seer tower
>overrated chicago
>>65680343
>best
geek usa
>second best
silverfuck
>worst
sweet sweet
>underrated
spaceboy
>overrated
mayonaise
>>65681239
>Best
>Runner-up
>Worst
all of them
>Underrated
>Overrated
none of them because I'm not 12
>>65680270
>worst
>Up in the Sky
say whaaaaaaaaa
>Best
Reckoner
>Second Best
All I Need
>Worst
House of Cards
>Underrated
Jigsaw Falling Into Place
>Overrated
Nude
>Best
Dopesmoker
>Runner-Up
Dopesmoker
>Worst
Dopesmoker
>Underrated
Dopesmoker
>Overrated
Dopesmoker
>>65680091
>Best: To Here Knows When
>Second Best: Only Shallow
>Worst: Blown a Wish
>Underrated: Touched
>Overrated: Soon
>>65681470
Reckoner is average at best. Weird Fishes is miles better than that.
All I need is absolute trash. So is House of Cards.
Jigsaw falling into place is amazing.
>>Overrated
>Nude
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=R35_vb04Lfw
>Best
If You're Feeling Sinister
>Runner Up
Get Me Away From Here I'm Dying
>Worst
The Boy Done Wrong Again
>Underrated
Me and the Major/Judy and the Dream of Horses
>Overrated
Mayfly
>Best: Bonny
>Second: Moving the River
>Worst: Faron Young
>Underrated: Hallelujah (honourable mention: Horsin' Around)
>Overrated: Desire As
>>65676188
>Best: Well I Wonder
>Second: I Want the One I Can't Have
>Worst: Meat is Murder (I came across a live version that was listenable thought)
>Underrated: What She Said
>Overrated: Nowhere Fast
>>65681556
I love both the original acoustic and '98 organ version of Nude. I'm just not a huge fan of the IR version. Maybe because I'm so used to the original (I listened to the 98 version hundreds of times).
The rest is just my opinion, man.
>>65676188
Best: Rushole Ruffians
Runner Up: That Joke Isn't Funny Anymore
Worst: What She Said
Underrated: Well I Wonder
Overrated: I want the one I can't have
Get btfo normie
>>65680287
>Best
El Scorcho
>Runner Up
Across the Sea
>Worst
Pink Triangle
>Underrated
No Other One
>Overrated
Pink Triangle
>>65681367
>all of them are the worst
>none of the tracks are overrated
pick one
>>65681756
How can you overrate something that's widely accepted as trash?
>>65681493
>the definition of an underrated post
>>65681772
I think it's shit too, but...
>Allmusic: 5/5 ("easily the best reviewed album of their career")
>Pitchfork: 7.2
>Rolling Stone: 3.5/5 (#225 on greatest albums of all time list)
>NME: 8/10
>Christgau: C+
Won two grammys and sold 6 million copies in the US alone. That doesn't sound like trash.
>>65681556
>>65681470
>All I Need and House of Cards trash
Edgy opinions lads.
>Best
House of Cards
>Runner Up
Weird Fishes
>Worst
Faust Arp
>Overrated
Reckoner or Jigsaw
>Underrated
15 Step
>>65681862
>7.2 from p4k
into the trash it goes
>>65681862
who gives a shit. kenny g sells 20 million albums but his music is a joke
>>65679227
Wrong
>Best
Banshee Beat
>Runner up
Purple Bottle
>Worst
Bees
>Overrated
Did You See The Words
>Underrated
Loch Raven
>>65681975
>tries to discredit album with critical acclaim and record sales by using an artist with no critical acclaim as an example
nice
>>65681904
>Best
>House of Cards
lmoa
Jigsaw's a nice song but I agree on Reckoner being overrated.
Also, 15 step isn't underrated at all.
>>65682010
http://www.allmusic.com/album/greatest-hits-mw0000031320
http://www.allmusic.com/album/r38566
>he's retarded
nice
>Best
God's Away on Business
>Runner Up
Misery is the River of the World
>Worst
Calliope
>Underrated
Another Man's Vine
>Overrated
All the World is Green
>>65682115
Allmusic on Kenny G:
>"Melodic alto saxophonist who braved negative criticism from all circles to eventually become the top-selling instrumentalist in history. "
Also, those are his only two albums rated 4.5/5.
>>65681470
>Best
Reckoner
>Runner Up
Weird Fishes
>Worst
House of Cards
>Underrated
Faust Arp
>Overrated
15 Step or Videotape
>Best
Neuköln
>Runner Up
Blackout
>Worst
Heroes
>Overrated
Heroes
>Underrated
The Secret Life of Arabia
Heroes isn't a bad song. It's just, on reflection, really my least favorite, which I think says something really great for the album. Underrated; that's what immediately came to mind, but I could have put half the damn songs there.
>>65677424
>Best
Lost in the World/Who Will Surivive in America
>Runner Up
Devil In A New Dress
>Worst
Blame Game (It was just too fucking much)
>Overrated
All Of The Lights
>Underrated
Dark Fantasy. (But the original version, fuck Minaj.)
>>65682378
edgy
the actual worst is sons of the silent age.
Heroes is not only the best song from that record, but one of Bowie's best songs period.
>>65682414
Dunno, I think it's a great song, I just love the others more. Maybe I'm just real sick of hearing it. Sons was the second candidate for worst and I still love it.
>Best
Blackest Bile
>Second
Spectral Bride
>Worst
Buried Above Ground
>Underrated
Empty Churches
>Overrated
No One is Ever Going to Want Me
>>65679089
>Best
A Piece of the Sky
>Second
Mother of the World
>Worst
The Daughter Brings the Water
>Underrated
93 Ave Blues
>Overrated
Lunacy
>>65680091
exactly mine
>>65680287
>Best
Across the Sea
>Second
El Scorcho
>Worst
Getchoo
>Underrated
Butterfly
>Overrated
Falling for You
>>65681470
>Best
Weird Fishes
>Second
Reckoner
>Worst
House of Cards
>Underrated
House of Cards (insofar as people calling it bad, rather than just the weakest track)
>Overrated
Bodysnatchers
>>65682414
>>65682378
Heroes actually feels out of place compared to the rest of the album
i actually skip it sometimes because i get so riled up from Beauty and the Beast and Joe the Lion that i cant just settle down
and secret life of arabia fucking blows my mind with that piano playing during the end
>>65681470
>Worst
>House of Cards
kys
>Best
Buckingham Green
>Runner Up
The Mollusk
>Worst
I'm Dancing in the Show Tonight
>Underrated
I'll Be Your Johnny on the Spot
>Overrated
Ocean Man
>>65680384
>Best
Dance on a Volcano
>Runner Up
Mad Man Moon
>Worst
A Trick of the Tail
>Underrated
Robbery, Assault, and Battery
>Overrated
Squonk
>>65680270
>Best
Live Forever
>Runner Up
Bring it on Down
>Worst
Digsy's Dinner
>Underrated
Slide Away
>Overrated
Supersonic
>>65676188
>Best
The Headmaster Ritual
>Runner Up
Barbarism Begins at Home
>Worst
Meat is Murder
>Underrated
Rusholme Ruffians
>Overrated
That Joke Isn't Funny Anymore
>best
Suffer little children
>second best
The hand that rocks the cradle
>worst
Pretty Girls make graves
>underrated
You got everything now
>overrated
Hand in glove
>>65680343
Now this is some good taste right here.
>>65684375
>Best
This Charming Man (US Version) / Still Ill
>Runner Up
Suffer Little Children
>Worst
I Don't Owe You Anything
>Underrated
You've Got Everything Now/Miserable Lie
>Overrated
Reel Around the Fountain
>best
Last Night I Dreamt
>runner up
A Rush And A Push
>worst
girlfriend in a coma
>underrated
paint a vulgar picture
>overrated
girlfriend in a coma
>>65684375
>best
Still Ill
>runner up
you've got everything now
>underrated
you got everything now
>overrated
hand in glove
>>65676188
>best
well i wonder
>runner up
[spoiler]how soon is now[/spoiler]
>worst
meat is murder
>underrated
well i wonder
>overrated
barabrism begins at home
>>65678006
>best
there is a light
>second best
bigmouth strikes again
>worst
vicar in tutu
>underrated
some girls are bigger than others
>overrated
the boy with the thorn/vicar in tutu
>>65676188
>>65678006
>>65684375
>>65684602
>best
The Queen Is Dead
>runner up
The Smiths
>worst
Meat Is Murder
>underrated
Strangeways
>overrated
The Queen Is Dead
/thread
>everybody listing What She Said as the worst track
why do yo think it's the worst? For me, it's one of the best Smiths songs period.
>best: drain you
>second best: lithium
>worst: stay away
>underrated: lounge act
>overrated: smells like teen spirit, come as you are
>>65684375
>best
Still Ill
>second best
You've Got Everything Now
>worst
Miserable Lie (actually one of the absolute worst Smiths songs ever)
>underrated
Suffer Little Children
>overrated
This Charming Man
>>65680099
>>65681615
>>65684200
>>65684602
>meat is murder
>worst
spotted the plebs
>>65684995
Best
>Something In The Way
Runner up
>On A Plain
Worst
>Smells Like Teen Spirit
Underrated
>Territorial Pissings
Overrated
>Come As You Are
Best
>Ask
Runner up
>Stretch Out and Wait
Worst
>Golden Lights
Underrated
>Shakespeare's Sister
Overrated
>Panic
The Smiths are one of my favourites but I never understood the love for panic
>>65684945
>the version with the rubber ring intro
hard every time
>Best: So Begins Our Alabee
>Runner Up: Oslo In The Summertime
>Worst: October Is Eternal
>Underrated: I Was A Landscape
>Overrated: Wraith Pinned
>>65679123
>Best: PredatoryWasp
>Runner Up: Casimir Pulaski Day
>Worst: Man of Metropolis idk
>Underrated: Seer's Tower
>Overrated: Chicago
>>65684602
>Best: Rush And A Push
>Runner Up: Last Night I Dreamt
>Worst: Paint A Vulgar Picture
>Underrated: I Won't Share You
>Overrated: Girlfriend In A Coma
>best
truckers atlas
>runner up
cowboy dan
>worst
long distance drunk
>underrated
out of gas
>overrated
teeth like god's shoeshine (still an amazing track, though)
>>65680287
>best
none
>runner up
none
>worst
all of them
>underrated
none
>overrated
all of them
>>65684602
>best
I Won't Share You
>runner up
Stop Me If You Think You Heard This One Before
>worst
Death at One's Elbow
>underrated
Paint a Vulgar Picture
>overrated
Death of a Disco Dancer
>Best: Equator
>Runner Up: This Town Ain't Big Enough
>Worst: Complaints
>Underrated: Here In Heaven
>Overrated: This Town Ain't Big Enough
>Best
Johnny Violent Getting His Ass Kicked By Morrissey
>Runner up
Everyone in Anal Cunt Is Dumb
>Worst
Tom Arnold
>Underrated
Phyllis is An Old Annoying Cunt
>Overrated
Van Full of Retards
