Thoughts on the new and revised chart?
What do you rate them?
bump?
>>65587588
Just happy Forever Changes made the cut
nobody has time for tbat
but i'll tell you which ones are 10/10s:
TVU&N
ITAOTS
that's it
Is Since I Left You back just because new album's coming?
>>65588793
the album is very much liked here and discussed here, so, no.
>>65588784
except no.
>>65587588
>Pet Sounds-9.5/10
>TVU&N-10/10
>Forever Changes-8/10
>TMR-9.5/10
>ITCOTCK-9/10
>Tago Mago-9/10
>CTTE-7/10
>Low-9/10
>RIL-9/10
>Spiderland-10/10
>Loveless-10/10
>Laughing Stock-10/10
>SAW85-92-7/10
>SFTB-10/10
>TLS-9.5/10
>ITAOTS-9/10
>Kid A-10/10
>LYSFLATH-10/10
>SILY-8/10
>V:D:C-6/10
>Madvillainy-9.5/10
>MPP-8/10
>HOOM-haven't listened
>MBDTF-7/10
>TMS-9/10
Really happy with how it turned out, need to listen to HOOM, and I'm a little upset that Deathconciousness did t make the cut.
>>65588784
Lol no
>>65588719
>happy certain album made it into a meme chart on a japanese cartoon board
>>65588793
Are you stupid? Do you post on /mu/ at all?
>>65589028
Isn't MPP the most "8" album in existence?
>>65589136
Yeah it really is.
>>65589104
>You can't have fun in this website because I said so
lel
>>65589161
>having fun is getting a certain album into a meme chart
heh, glad you're having fun
Perfect except that mbdtf is horrid
>Sweet Trip
Oh great now all of you faggots are going to meme sweet trip into oblivion
Turned out really good guys - great work!
I still feel like ITAOTS isn't discussed too much anymore, the next chart this board makes will probably exclude it. Also, I find it weird that with how popular hip hop got here recently no new hip hop albums were added (hinting at TPAB)...
>>65589363
>>65589337
That album is overrated "lol so obscure" shit.
>>65589599
Oh great it's already started
>>65589638
Bitch you can't even pretend that albums good, I don't even think enough people talk about sweet trip for it to warrant /mu/ core.
>>65589678
whatever you say pal
>>65589664
>Dance Site
7.5/10
>Pyokotra
10/10
>LOVE Machine
8/10
>Kimagure Princess
7.2/10
>One Two Three
8.3/10
>Morning Coffee
10/10
>Toki wo Koe
10/10
>Happy Summer
9/10
>>65589539
I actually wanted TPAB in the chart. Some people didnt agree tho
eh
>>65587588
replace talk talk, tat barely gets discussed much compared to other material, same with newsom and sweet trip. i see it occasionally but this looks more like a chart someone would've made in 2011. replace them with TPAB or twin fantasy or something to that manner
>>65589807
>Madvillainy a 5
Back the fuck off?!
>>65589864
no u
>>65589862
the original plan was to have TPAB and Twin Fantsy instead of Talk Talk and MBDTF
>>65589727
Explain why it's good.
>pet sounds - 100000/10
>vu&n - 10/10
>forever changes - 8/10
>trout mask - 7/10
>Crimson King - 9/10
>tago Mago - just started listening to this recently so too early to say but so far 8+
>close to the edge - eh/10
>low - 10/10
>remain in light - 10/10
>spiderland - 9/10
>loveless - 10/10
>laughing stock - holy fuck/10
>85-92 - 8/10
>soundtracks for the blind - 10/10
>ITAOTS - what do you think/10
>kid eh - the eyes of God/10
>LYSFLATH - I want this to be the last album I hear before I die/10
>MPP - 7/10
>MBDTF - 8/10
>>65589862
>twin fantasy gets discussed more than Talk Talk or HOOM
No just no, that is so very very wrong.
>>65588868
you haven't heard forever changes, low, close to the edge, laughing stock or ambient works, and want people to give a shit about your other ratings?
>>65587588
Pet Sounds - 8/10
TVU&N - 9/10
Trout Mask Replica - 8/10
ITCOTCK - 8/10
Close to the Edge - 8/10
Spiderland - 10/10
Loveless - 10/10
Laughing Stock - 8/10
SAW 85-92 - 9/10
SFTB - 9/10
ITAOTS - 8/10
Kid A - 9/10
LYSFLATH - 9/10
Madvillainy - 8/10
Merriweather Post Pavilion - 9/10
MBDTF - 10/10
The Money Store - 7/10
wow I really like /mu/core huh
>>65589937
Pretty accurate tbqh.
>>65589943
I don't care if you don't care mane. Will give them a listen, don't worry. Do you agree with the other ratings tho?
>>65589886
yeah that makes sense, probably just anti-toledo shitposters running amok again like >>65589942
here. TPAB did cause a huge wave similar to MBDTF's release so the replacement would make sense. Overall i think those are the only fixes needed to make this a chart that's actually current and relevant.
>>65589985
I never said he was bad, he just is rarely discussed here and most people hate him or haven't evens listens to anything by him.
>>65589807
give us albums you'd consider 10s
>>65590016
>rarely discussed
i see at least 10 threads in the catalog every day about his works so that argument it just a little invalid. haven't seen anybody try to start discussion about talk talk in ages. (sadly)
>>65589937
you are way too influenced by the board lol
>>65590060
or, you know, he likes albums that happen to be critically acclaimed?
>>65589894
I don't have to explain shit tough guy
>>65590024
This Heat - Deceit
The Mystery of The Bulgarian Voices - Vol 1
Beethoven's last piano sonatas performed by either Pollini or Richter
>>65590083
but anon, don't you know that you can't like anything /mu/ likes if you want to be cool?
>>65590179
>Beethoven's last piano sonatas performed by either Pollini or Richter
dropped
>>65590055
>10 threads a day
Slow down with the exaggerations there pal. One it's like three at the most and zero on most days.
Secondly they rarely discuss his music and mostly just talk about how he got famous on /mu/. I bet less than half this board has even heard Twin Fantasy.
>>65590170
Typical
>>65590231
:^(
>>65590293
yikes
>>65590234
hold it with the exaggerations there buddy.
>>65590335
wat happing
I honestly don't think this is that edgy. I'm rating only my enjoyment of the album, since fuck me if I could consider its "objective" merits or context inside the genre
>>65589807
>Skinny fists
>4
>>65589028
Yeah I love deathconciousness too, unfortunately it was mentioned literally 0 times the whole day when i was working on the chart. Same with Burial, and amfootball only once. Just to give an idea of some of the updates
btw, what was wrong with the previous chart? Why is there a new one?
>>65590406
What exaggerations? I agree three was probably to much I think the most I've ever seen was 2 in one day but that's it.
>>65589363
>meme into oblivion
this really is an exaggerated fear. Not everything has the meme potential of death grips and animal collective.
>>65587588
Pet Sounds 9
VU&N 8
ITCOCK 10
Low 8
Remain in Light 8
Spiderland 8
Loveless 8
aphx twin 6
STFTB 10
ITAOTS 7
Kid A 9
Madvillainy 7
Merriweather 8
Kanye 8
DG 8
>>65589599
it's not obscure, what are you talking about
>>65589801
Yeah I actually started out with tpab in te chart. it stayed for a long time until near the end when a couple people decided King Crimson had to make the cut, so I decided to cut TPAB.
1) A lot of newfags will have heard of it anyway because of how recent and popular it is
2) quite divisive on /mu/, and a ton of people are annoyed by how critically acclaimed it is, many for meme racial reasons but many (like me) because its not thaaat good. (10, fantano? really?)
3) TMR is divisive as well, and its inclusion was contentious, but we decided to keep it simply because of how big a part of this board's culture it is.
>>65590535
not so much meme the shit out of it as just collectively shit on it because some underage fags saw it on the chart and therefore it must be bad because it's popular
>>65589862
We discussed this ad nauseum yesterday. IMHO talk talk is essential. It's so commonly recommended to newfags - look at that In Rainbows thread yesterday where the drunk /v/ newfag got recd talk talk 100 times. ill link the thread when i get back to my computer.
>>65590652
what about newsom? her album is barely discussed here to warrant being on a chart of "core" albums.
>>65590718
She's very much discussed in threads about females musicians. She always takes a central role in those threads. Waifugas love her (like it or not, they're a part of the community), and, unlike some other female musicians, she almost universally acclaimed for her music.
>>65587588
>10/10
TVU&N
ITCOTCK
Kid A
Madvillainy
MBDTF
>9.5/10
Remain in Light
Since I Left You
Spiderland
Laughing Stock
>9/10
Low
Close to The Edge
MPP
>8.5/10
Loveless
Long Season
haven't listened to the rest
>>65590775
Good taste
>>65587588
>pet sounds
never heard
>banana
never heard
>forever changes
10/10
>fish meme
never heard
>mouth
never heard
>can
never heard
>green thing
never heard
>bowie
never heard but i hate him
>talking heads
2/10
>spiderman
quit in the middle of the first song
>loveless
7/10
>tree thing
never heard
>aphex
8/10
>swans
4/10
>fishmans
6/10
>itaots
5/10
>radiohead
never heard
>gybe
5/10
>islands thing
never heard
>corner thing
never heard
>mask guy
never heard
>mpp
5/10
>joanna
6/10
>kanye
never heard
>meme grips
never heard
>>65590767
admittedly, the waifu fanboys was precisely why i asked. as long as it doesn't devolve to kpop on the chart i'm fine. only album here i've never seen before at all is velocity design comfort
>>65590767
>>65590767
this. was originally planning also to have a bjork album but too many people were against it. there were shouts for art angels as well. I think HOOM covers the waifu quota pretty nicely.
>>65590717
>>65580784
here's the thread
>Low
No
>Tago Mago
No, not discussed enough or really something that has to do with /mu/ at all. Just a good canon album.
>TMR
why
>No Endtroducing
>>65590794
thx
>>65590803
>>65590851
>someone hasn't wasted time listening to the same popular music as me, they must be baiting
>>65590844
>tago mago
>not discussed on /mu/
>TMR
I hate it too but it's a necessary evil
>endtroducing
not that great an album and not discussed as much as this other material either
>>65590713
That hasn't really happened with loveless, itcotck, etc. I mean sure it could happen but including it will bring it to the attention of a lot of people who will fall in love with it who otherwise wouldn't have. I think that outweighs most negatives.
>>65590522
best chart ITT
>>65590844
If you were going to make a new /mu/core you'd really have to make a big ass chart again. At least one with second tier classics.
>>65590775
Forgot ITAOTS, it's an 8.5
>>65589664
best chart itt
>>65590892
hahaha :^)
>>65590268
>typical
W e W
>>65590916
Second tier classics and so on get way too far down the rabbit hole and it's impossible to be objective. 25 is plenty.
Besides, if someone wants some more classics, they can get a much, much better experience from using the rym charts than from a bigass chart. And lets be honest, rym's taste (and userbase) matches up quite closely with /mu/'s
>>65590892
Sorry these bands are 2popular4u mr. Obsecure. Please enlighten us with your eclectic taste
>>65587588
10
7.5
N/A
N/A
8
7.5
8.5
7
5.5
7
4
7
6
6
8
8
6
5
7.5
8.5
8.5
3.5
9
7
6
>>65590775
damn, also forgot Pet Sounds, it's 9.5
>>65590652
Seems quite weird, TPAB is discussed a lot more than Crimson. Newfags heard about Kanye as well, you know, it's discussed daily and is loved by many mutants. Also, some hate it for meme reasons, but whoever has a legitimate reason usually doesn't hate it, just thinks it's overrated.
>>65590947
you certainly are, it's shitting up the thread
>>65591070
Hm, fair point. TPAB is definitely, definitely more popular and relevant today in the normie sphere than MBDTF is, however. Idk, it's a close call. I think it's fine as it is because you can make a very convincing argument for King Crimson as well. With Madvillainy, MBDTF, and TMS I think there's enough hip-hop.
Gay
>>65587588
why isnt american football on there
>>65588784
nahhhh
>>65591358
it's rarely talked about anymore. Along with Burial and HANL, other casualties
my two cents
>>65590550
Yes yes it is. Even by /mu/ standards it's obscure.
>>65591453
several of the different albums were discussed and rejected in the threads yesterday. tpab, twin fantasy were both v close to making it in.
>>65591453
Objectively wrong
>>65591582
nice counterpoint desu
>>65591582
i tried to make something with more variety at least, i prob should've swapped TPAB with low end theory, but overall i think this has a better selection of albums than the one on OP's.
Besides, we tried this a few months ago and nothing came of it because it was basically the same as OP's chart.
>>65591684
wtf i did not type that at the end
>>65591739
>wtf i did not type that at the end
you are far too new to be making a /mu/core chart.
Pet Sounds: 10/10
TVU&N: 8/10
Forever Changes: 7/10
TMR: 8/10
ITCOTCK: 7/10
Tago Mago: 7/10
Close to the Edge: 8/10
Low: 7/10
RiL: 8/10
Spiderland: 7/10
Loveless: 7/10
Laughing Stock: 9/10
SAW: 4/10
SftB: 5/10
Long Season: 6/10
ITAOTS: 7/10
Kid A: 4/10
Skinny Fists: 7/10
Since I Left You: 7/10
V/D/C: 4/10
Madvillainy: 6/10
MPP: 5/10
Have One on Me: unlistenable/10
MBDTF: 6/10
TMS: 7/10
>>65591880
i've been here since 2012 so don't go trying to call me new
>>65591453
Miles Davis should be there but all of your other additions aren't talked about much
>>65591905
And you don't fucking know about the world filter??
smdh tbqh fammo
>>65591931
i didn't type any words that could've been filtered tho famillamadingdong, i literally just typed "nice counterpoint"
>>65591298
Cool. Last question: why TMS and not TPTB? Seems way more relevant today.
>>65591965
nice counterpoint
>>65591984
We talked about this quite a bit in the last couple of threads. At the end of the day more people were in favor of TMS. I'm far from a death grips fan and have only heard TMS a couple of times, so I just went with what more people seemed to want. It was close though. At the end of the day I guess their first studio album makes more sense as an introduction.
>>65591739
Music has the Right to Children, Twin Fantasy, What's Going On, and Kind of Blue are not popular enough to be /mu/-core, not any of them are bad, their just no popular enough.
I see why you put Homogenic on, (all the Bjork shut posting and generals.) but I'm he's taint to call that /mu/-core.
Kid A is more /mu/-core than OK Conputer.
Agree with Illinois and TPAB though.
>>65592052
*shitposting
>>65592052
Homogenic was originally on my chart and it was voted off.
TPAB barely missed out.
Illinois wasn't mentioned at all
>>65592052
i mainly just put bork there so it would have at least one female artist there, nobody really fits better than her in terms of most discussed. Jazz had no real representation so I'd think that the first entry-level jazz album everyone gets rec'd deserves the spot. I didn't put Boards on my chart tho. KidA and OKC are pretty interchangable IMO. I mainly put WGO and TF to get some highly discussed albums that would fill more variety than some of OP's choices
>tago mago
>sweet trip
stop
take those off
stop ruining good albums
>>65592157
>at least one female artist there
Joanna Newsom
>Jazz had no real representation
Just like on /mu/ unfortunately. If people want to get into jazz there are plenty of charts for that. If you were to ask /jazz/ I don't know if they would give you Kind of Blue anyway.
>WGO
>highly discussed
ok sure
>TF
>more variety
It's generic indie rock and is only talked about because Toledo shilled it on here
>>65592157
Kid A is agreed by most to be better than OKC
>>65592203
How does it ruin them? This meme needs to end. Not everything turns into Anco and DG.
It's not even like people will think they're bad and entry level now. That didn't happen with Loveless or ITCOTCK did it?
>>65592157
>didn't put boards of Canada on there at all
Holy shit your right, I'm sorry I have no idea why I thought that was in there.
I see what your saying about KoB and Homogenic but at the end of the day I don't think they should be on there, maybe Homogeinc, but if you were going to pick a jazz album it would have to be Ascension.
I have barely ever seen WGO discussed at all, he'll I see Magot Brain discussed more than that, but then again Magggot Brain is barely ever discussed too so I wouldn't call it /mu/-core.
People barely ever talk about Twin Fantasy they just talk about Will, and how he posted here, also most people hate it.
>>65592203
Whatever's most popular becomes /mu/-core l. Also sweet trip is shit. And most of the other albums are better than those too so shut up.
>>65592330
Agree with everything this guy said.
>>65587588
Forever Changes should not be on there, it's never discussed here. If you need another album from the 60s, make it Astral Weeks, or better yet, something like A Love Supreme.
Fishmans shouldn't be there either, they were spammed a lot like Plantasia was and only stuck because of that weird meme comparing them to Jason Aldean. A better 90s album would be something like Aquemini.
>>65592584
Actually, scratch Aquemini. Put Boards of Canada back, I didn't notice that MHTRTC was removed.
decent chart desu senpai
>>65592584
>>65592610
these
Which column is the best
>1: Pet Sounds - Tago Mago - Loveless - NMH - Madvillain
>2: Banana - CTTE - Laughing Stock - Kid A - MPP
>3: Forever Changes - Low - SAW1 - LYSF - HOOM
>4. TMR - Remain in Light - SFTB - SILY - MBDTF
>5. ITCOTCK - Spiderland - Long Season - V:D:C - Money Store
I'm gonna have to go with 2
>>65592584
Forever Changes is going nowhere, /mu/ just needs to hear it more and it will be very well-loved, trust me. It's NMH before NMH, and better
Fishmans for Boards of Canada is an interesting proposition but tbqh Fishmans is discussed a lot more. I still see it regularly, unlike BOC. And yeah there is that weird meme but it's still discussed often. The chart needs a little something from Japan as well.
>>65592584
>Fishmans
>meme
How to spot someone who has never heard Fishmans.
Also aquemini is never discussed here, and forever changed is discussed all the time.
>>65592746
>How to spot someone who has never heard Fishmans.
yeah and tbqh Fishmans isn't even a one hit wonder. Their live album is talked about almost as much as Long Season and they have a solid discography
>>65592661
1>2>5>4>3
>>65589864
Thats a generous rating pleb
>>65587588 (OP)
>Pet Sounds - 9/10
>TVU&N - 7/10
>Forever Changes - 7/10
>TMR - 8/10
>ITCOTCK - 7/10
>Tago Mago - 9/10
>CTTE - 7/10
>Low - 7/10
>RIL - 8/10
>Spiderland - 10/10
>Loveless - 7/10
>Laughing Stock - 8/10
>SAW85-92 - 6/10
>SFTB - 8/10
>TLS - 5/10
>ITAOTS - 7/10
>Kid A - 5/10
>LYSFLATH - 8/10
>SILY - 6/10
>V:D:C - 7/10
>Madvillainy - 5/10
>MPP - 7/10
>HOOM - Not my style, can't really rate it
>MBDTF - 5/10
>TMS - 7/10
>>65587588
Pet Sounds - 7/10
VU&N - 8.5/10
Forever Changes - 6.5/10
TMR - 8/10
In the Court - 8.5/10
Taco Mayo - 8/10
Close to the Edge - 7/10
Low - 7/10
Remain in Light - 7/10
Spiderland - 9/10
Loveless - 10/10
Laughing Stock - 7/10
Selected Ambient Works - 6/10
Soundtracks for the Blind - 8/10
Long Season - 6/10
In the Aeroplane - 7.5/10
Kid A - 7.5/10
Lift Yr. Skinny Fists - 7.5/10
Avalanches - n/a
V:D:C - n/a but from what I've heard 6/10
Madvillainy - 7/10
MPP - 6/10
Have One on Me - n/a
MBDTF - 6.5/10
Money Store - 7/10
>>65593174
>(OP)
?
>>65593212
>>65593174
>>65593031
>>65591881
>>65591329
>>65590546
How come Madvillainy < 8? Genuinely curious.
>>65593395
For me 7 or 7.5/10 hip hop is essentially 10/10 for hip hop fans. Not too into the genre.
