One of these artist discography ranking threads.
Joanna Newsom
Ys > HOOM = MEM = Divers
>>65321556
how is exmilitary that much better than the rest of their albums?
Its got two of their worst and most memed songs; Takyon and Guillotine.
Tracks go on for way too long - ie Beware and I Want It.
like, its a good album but i never understood why its held up as such a masterpiece compared to the rest of their discography
>>65321611
they are the genwunners of the DG fanbase.
>>65321611
personal opinion
>>65321556
>being this wrong
NLDW > NOTM > BP > TMS > GP > JD > Exmil
>>65321632
You forgot Pablo Honey
>>65321684
your mom forgot to eat my penis
we actually havent had any sex at all
>>65321700
You forgot Pablo Honey
>>65321632
sounds about right
keep this thread aliv
e bump
bujmp
>>65321569
HOOM is her magnum opus. Ys comes very close, but HOOM is truly her best.
>>65322081
lol i wanted to just put them all equal. i think divers is maybe a step down but its still a masterpiece
>>65322100
Divers is very well done, it's just less ambitious. Who knows if she'll ever attempt anything like Ys or HOOM again. Those albums are monumental.
>>65322260
i appreciate the effort wow
>>65322275
Yeah, Bowie is about the only artist with that extensive of a discography (and that extensive of a shitty streak) that I've listened to enough to do this for.
Forgot Buddha of Suburbia. It'd be about tied with, like, Reality in the inessential blur.
I surprisingly still haven't listened to Gore yet. What did you guys think of it? I guess I was a bit discouraged after watching Fantano's review (even though he didn't like Koi no Yokan either, and that's one of my faves. Guess I'm just lazy and don't listen to them as much).
Just the ones I've heard
>>65321632
amnesiac and hail to the thief are out of order
also you're a massive pleb for thinking Kid A is better than Amnesiac, all the patricians know that Amnesiac is Kid A without the filler
>>65322260
Agreed for the most part.
This is depressing to look at. Really puts into perspective what a terrible streak he hit from 1980 to the 2000s and how he was finally starting to make respectable music again.
>>65322445
They're actually very different albums, and how can you call Morning Bell Amnesiac anything but shitty filler?
>>65322445
i mean sure Treefingers can be filler idc. but how is the rest filler
I was just gonna do the microphones but decided to do mount eerie as well so had to make the image longer lmao
>>65322523
Personally think Kerplunk and Dookie deserve to be higher, and Insomniac deserves to be lower. Not sure about Nimrod, I need to relisten to that one. American Idiot is 100% correctomundo tho.
>>65322260
youre putting diamond dogs and lodger too low honestly
some of bowies best vocal performances are on diamond dogs, and great songwriting with the very long tracks separated into acts
and lodger is just all around super interesting to hear and have happen as a record, it really gets shot down by being compared to his berlin work, which its not really a part of
>>65322358
listen to project doomsday more it's better than you think
This'll have some disagreement
Someone should do one for lil B im too fucking lazy
>>65322641
seems exactly right
>>65322641
I agree with everything else, but I wouldn't rank TLOP on the same spot as Later Registration and 808's
>>65322670
Dexter's lab freestyle followed by Dexter's lab freestyle and then finally Dexter's lab freestyle
>>65322641
That seems fairly standard, maybe some Yeezus fanboys will get annoyed tho
>>65322747
This seems to be the popular opinion of most Em listeners, except Encore is usually the lowest instead of Recovery.
Personally TES is my favorite.
>>65321700
You have to be 18 to post.
Only chart you'll ever need
>>65322963
>>65322747
>>65322641
>>65322523
>this is /mu/ in 2016
wow things really have gone to shit
>>65321611
This album has nothing on TPTB and GP
>>65322993
I know man, seriously
Where did all the true patricians like us go?
>>65321556
imma fix death grips
>>65322993
you're clearly a newfag. Kanye has been huge here since 2010 if not earlier, Green Day has always had a certain following given the kind of people that come to 4chan in the first place, and Eminem has always been popular. you're just trying to REE over things to get the scent of summer off your back
>>65323163
that's actually almost perfect, just move tms and bp up very slightly and split tptb into two with notm higher and jd slightly lower
>>65322541
winds poem should be much higher imo
>>65322445
>implying half of Amnesiac isn't filler
Some one do Tom Waits
>>65323593
if I'm going to be honest I didn't give it much of a shot, listened to it about 3 times like a year ago
>>65323466
Maladroit, Red, and Raditude need to be higher, and Hurley lower
Otherwise pretty gud ranks
mp
>>65321569
Ys>HOOM>Divers=MEM
>>65321569
>>65324392
These niggas know what's up. Ys is the GOAT
>>65322081
lmao fuccboi detected
>>65321678
Although I would have Adz as high as Michigan and you forgot All Delighted People as well as his first two albums, this is still very accurate.
>>65322541
Generally very accurate.
>>65321556
BP=TPTB>GP>NLDW>=TMS>ExMil
They got better with every album, pleb.
Surprised not to see this one yet
Judge me harshly
>>65325636
How retarded are you?
>>65325660
Very, why?
>>65322641
lol that is literally the most agreeable ranking
>>65325636
We've got the same 4 favorites
seems good to me
>>65322260
>Earthling, Space Oddity and Let's Dance that low
Fuckin get some taste ya asshole
>>65322523
>>65322567
Get these fucking normies off my board
>>65323884
Everything after Silent Alarm is on the same level as their last album
>>65322747
>Infinite too low
>Encore way too high
IMO it goes:
MMLP>SSLP>Infinite>TES>MMLP2>Recovery>Encore
never listened to Relapse, that fucking autotune is unbearable, also i'd include the Slim Shady EP which is amazing
>>65322641
switch yeezus w/ tlop and you're on the money
>>65322260
How can you be this pleb?
>>65326478
>likes Let's Dance
>tells somebody else to get taste
>>65323163
i disagree
>>65322523
>american idiot is higher than nimrod, kerplunk, and dookie
fucking kill yourself my man
>>65323163
this is equally as retarded as OP's
>>65327691
I actually think for what it is, Let's Dance is really well made.
>>65322260
"Heroes is higher than Low?! Well, Earthling is higher than 1. Outside so I can spot the pleb a mile away.
>>65321632
I like HTTT more then TKOL
/mu/ sleepin on Okkervil River big time
>>65329120
i might see them in new orleans
should i do it
>>65321556
fixed
>>65323310
I debated splitting TPTB, I probably should have since I think NOTM is leagues better than JD
>>65329353
well then it looks like we have literally the same taste anon
good taste
>>65325636
Solid opinion, dont let Barrett or Watersfags tell you otherwise.
>>65325636
It doesn't matter how much you hate it, The Endless River is still an official Pink Floyd studio album.
>inb4 b-but AMLOR is shit
fuck you it had a bunch of good stuff on it.
Thanks for the template anyway
>>65321678
>Sufjan
>Everything at the top of the image
You're not wrong
>>65329229
wew
