Where do they rank amongst the greatest bands of all time, /mu/?
>>64735358
yes
1. The Beatles
2. Dylan
3. Bowie
4. Pink Floyd
5. Neil Young
6. The Rolling Stones
7. Radiohead
8. The Clash
9. The Talking Heads
10. Kate Bush
#1
>>64735358
589
>>64735589
>The Talking Heads
>The
at the very top along with pixies, the velvet underground and sonic youth (and none of those bands stayed amazing for 24 years, though sonic youth remained good)
34
above death grips but below coldplay
1. beatles
2. pink floyd
3. led zeppelin
4. rolling stones
5. sonic youth
6. king crimson
7. black sabbath
8. can
9. ween
0. radiohead
>>64735832
>ween
>>64735896
whats your list
>>64735896
ween are far more deserving than fucking king crimson
>>64735589
Stones>Beatles>Floyd>Talking Heads>Dylan>Radiohead>Bowie>Clash
>>64735832
>below ween
>ween being on the list
http://www.besteveralbums.com/bandstats.php
>>64735912
whats your problem with kc
>>64735960
>http://www.besteveralbums.com/bandstats.php
radiohead below the memetles LOL
can
beatles
the velvet undergronud
talking heads
radiohead
in no order
1. The Velvet Underground
9000. The Beatles
9001. Coldplay
9002. Radiohead
>>64735961
they're not one of the top 10 bands of all time
>>64736023
whats your list
>>64736023
More so than ween lol
>>64735910
The velvet underground
talking heads
can
pink floyd
mahavishnu orchestra
jesus lizard
radiohead
>>64736107
What's so great about Jesus lizard to make them top 10?
>>64736148
idk i just fucking love them. One of the best shows of my life.
>>64736001
The only correct answer
>>64736039 OP says bands so
1. radiohead
2. the velvet underground
3. pixies
4. sonic youth
5. the beatles
6. talk talk
7. love
8. pink floyd
9. mbv
10. the doors
s/o joy division & nick cave + the bad seeds & portishead
>>64736161
do you have to be a pioneer or incredibly innovative to best "top 10 of all time"? Are they? Serious question, I don't know. Great band nonetheless. When did you see them live?
>>64736161
I have your back man. I understand how good Ween is. Up there with the Beatles.
>>64735931
>Talking Heads>Dylan
wut
>Radiohead>Bowie
Kid A would not exist without Low.
>>64736185
Sonic Youth above Pixies hands down
>>64735358
zep > stones > ac/dc > beatels > beach boys > skynard > radiohead > bowie > dylan
>>64736217
he was talking about the jesus lizard
>>64736185
>Free People the ranking
>>64736192
I don't take that into account in my list too much but it doesnt hurt. I say them in 97 in columbus. Just saw that another anon posted talk talk and they would be in my list too.
What do we think of scaruffi's top 12 (in order)?
Velvet Underground
Pere Ubu
Doors
Faust
Rolling Stones
Can
Grateful Dead
Pink Floyd
Soft Machine
Jefferson Airplane
Pop Group
Talking Heads
Pretty good taste, though I would omit The Grateful Dead, The Jefferson Airplane and The Pop Group.
>>64736244
only one position away from each other in my list so i'll cop that
>>64735620
Agreed
>>64736245
>Skynard
>Ahead of Radiohead
>>64736245
It took this long for someone to mention Beach Boys.
>>64736276
Too much of the same strain of rock. It's fine, but by no means definitive.
>>64736276
I was just going to say to omit those three and then i saw you did. Nice list. Scaruffi is really likes and really dislikes some unpredictable stuff.
>>64736276
tvu GOAT
pere ubu good but not that good
doors yeah okay
faust stfu scruffy
stones no
can yeah
grateful dead NICE
floyd of course
soft machine yeah
jefferson airplane LOL
pop group no
talking heads yeah
anyway he's not wanted in a radiohead thread his favourite album of theirs is pablo honey
>>64736299
I don't necessarily agree, but skynard was tight as fuck. Some talented musicians
>>64736377
He also fucking loves korn
>>64736107
>mahavishnu
more like John McLaughlin, his album "Devotion" is more important than all of Mahavishnu's discog combined
>>64736412
I'm a drumfag and I need that billy cobham.
>>64736001
well played sir
>>64735358
1. Can
2.Talking Heads
3. Velvet Underground
4. Animal Collective
5. Coltrane
6.Dylan
7. Radiohead
8. Sonic Youth
9. MBV
10. Pavement?
Inb4 Animal Collective and MBV making me a cuck It's my oipnion man
lol whats with all the dads in this thread?
>marvin gaye
>James brown
the fact that noone mentioned them ITT means that /mu/ is retarded
>>64735589
>Dylan
>Kate Bush
>Neil Young
>bands
>>64736301
Only had like 1-2 good albums lol
>>64736525
i saw we were memeing so i tired to outmeme them but i just ended up blending in
>>64736504
im not saying Devotion is better, im saying its more important. Birds of Fire is the superior McLaughlin/Cobham/Vishnu album
>>64736525
I was fired today, son. Don't tell your mother.
>>64736525
Go to bed son
>>64736377
nah OKC and Amnesiac have a 7
he something like "half of OKC is a masterpiece"
>>64736526
they aren't bands
>>64736553
Gotcha. I like inner mounting flame and birds of fire equally
>>64736554
>>64736557
there's no way i can sleep after that bombshell
can you read me a story about how people used to make guitar music?
>>64736574
most people ITT aren't treating the original post in that way are they? Also, Brown created funk, which is highly instrumental, its not funk without a band
>>64736301
And he put them behind AC/DC
1. Nirvana
2. Black Flag
9999. Radiohead
10 000. Alice In Chains
>>64736637
But thats nigger music
>>64735358
My favorites are:
1. Husker Du
2. Foetus
3. Slint
4. Type O Negative
5. The Velvet Underground
6. Barret-era Pink Floyd
7. Residents
8. King Crimson
.
.
.
~110. Radiohead.
>>64736684
thats all you had to say
Who is that?
Probably in my top 60 desu
beatles
floyd
stones
radiohead
>>64736709
>"[insert Chronolgy] era [insert band]"
Thats not how this works, or else I would say
"1. Fragile and CttE era Yes
2. Full King Crimson discog..."
when in reality i would say
"1. Full King Crimson discog
.
.
.
~30. Full Yes discog..."
>>64735589
>>64735832
>>64736185
>>64736245
>>64736276
>>64736377
>>64736709
K why is Deep Purple and The Who not anywhere here
1. David Bowie
2. Guided By Voices
3. Dave Brubek Quartet
4. The Beatles
5. Radiohead
1. Beatles
2. Radiohead
3. Rolling Stones
4. Velvet Underground
5. Pink Floyd
>>64736245
who dat
somewhere in the 90s or low 100s
>>64736864
>2. Guided By Voices
How do you like the new one? I fucking love it.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qBtLo91JphU
pretty polvo at times
BRITISH INVASION SQUAD
-the Beats
-the Stones
-the Kinkaroos
FUCK DISCO CREW
-Led Zeppelin
-the Who
-Pink Floyd
PROTOPUNK POSSE
-VU
-the Stooges
AVANT SAVANTS
-Capn. Beefheart and Magic Band
-Can
POSTPUNK PALS
-Talking Heads
-Sonic Youth
-Pixies
ONLY NINETIES KIDZ
-Radiohead
-Pavement
*Note: Dylan, Neil, Bowie, etc. not included as they are individuals, not bands
*honorable mentions:
-Beach Boys
-White Stripes
-the Clash
-Roxy Music
>>64736276
Great
Great
Amazing
Good
Great
Good
Great
Good
Good
Amazing
Great
>>64735832
>LED ZEPPELIN
At #1
>>64735358
not
>>64736815
But nobody is stopping you from doing that.
>>64736857
1. Beatles
2. Zeppelin
3. Sonic Youth
4. Radiohead
5. Queen
6. Stones
7. Talking Heads
8. R.E.M.
Other top 20: Beach Boys, Pink Floyd (overrated af, though), metal & progressive shit I don't know or care about, Can/Beefheart/Scaruffi-core shit, U2 (honestly tragic how good they were), miscellaneous 70s dadcore, The Clash, The Smiths, etc
Way the fuck down: The Velvet Underground, The Who
Radiohead doesn't even figure in my list.
The Beatles
The Clash
Liliput
The New York Dolls
Pavement
The Ramones
Sleater-Kinney
Sonic Youth
The Velvet Underground
Wussy
