Good afternoon, why is A Moon Shaped Pool so mediocre?
https://rateyourmusic.com/~boldfaure
https://rateyourmusic.com/~thedb
https://rateyourmusic.com/~thedb
https://rateyourmusic.com/~thedb
https://rateyourmusic.com/~thedb
https://rateyourmusic.com/~thedb
i really really like what they did with True Love Waits
>>64701639
>3.5
>mediocre
m8...
why does horb even try? lol
https://rateyourmusic.com/~Thelemonish
add
the AMSP comment box is the worst i've ever seen
boldfaure is such an asshole
>>64701906
>talking shit about based horb
>>64702057
horb isn't based hes got something wrong in his head
>>64702057
>deformed mentally damaged human being
>based
>>64702080
So what? She has god-tier taste and that's all i care about
>>64701708
I mean I still like it.
>>64702030
>people insult me
>I insult them back
>"WOW BOLDFAURE"
>>64702110
>she
lol
horb isnt trans at all
>>64701639
check out ted hearne's from last year, and horse lords from this year, would interest me what you think of those
https://rateyourmusic.com/~floatings
new radiohead is ok, i especially like present tense
>>64702124
Are you blind?
https://rateyourmusic.com/~TheHorbgorbler
>26 / Female
>>64702123
>Wow I really like this album! it's really good! 5/5! i'm really happy now!
>Tsk tsk silly children, stop being blinded by hype GET ON MY LEVEL
>fuck off nerd
>POSER PIECE OF SHIT
>please stop boldfaure
>I was only defending myself!
>>64702227
>Tsk tsk silly children, stop being blinded by hype GET ON MY LEVEL
Who are you quoting?
>>64702251
What are you currently wearing this is important
>>64702131
awful taste
>>64702131
why don't you like kid a?
What kind of hipster faggot uses "RateYourMusic"
>>64702251
not quoting just describing what reading boldfaure's (you?) posts came off in that particular comment box.
"oh well. hypebeasts will be hypebeasts" while also admonishing others for not being objective. then when you were called out on this ridiculousness you pretend that you were being attacked, when in fact, you were just being condescending to everybody and stirring up shit.
>>64702289
xus may be a psycho schizophrenic but he DOESN'T have a bad taste
https://rateyourmusic.com/~schtraw
Its album of the decade so far, not a doubt in my mind.
Hi anonfriends!
https://rateyourmusic.com/~megido18
>>64702315
>(you?)
yeah it's me
>"oh well. hypebeasts will be hypebeasts" while also admonishing others for not being objective. then when you were called out on this ridiculousness you pretend that you were being attacked, when in fact, you were just being condescending to everybody and stirring up shit.
I can't recall the context I left that comment in and unfortunately it's too old to still on the album page so whatever.
you're taking shitposting too seriously.
>>64702289
i don't want to look at that
>>64702292
i think it's a really lame album but i haven't heard it in a long time and i'm in a radiohead mood today so maybe i'll give it another spin tonight
>>64702488
yeah I agree actually :( you're not an asshole i'm just overreacting
>>64702316
fucking hell you are so embarrassing
>>64701639
ITT: tumblr kids
"look at my page xD" the thread
>>64702567
go away loser
>>64701695
You seem boring
Your taste is boring
Great afternoon
https://rateyourmusic.com/~Keolia
>>64702109
>Linkshänder
>>64702131
You rated a lot of obscure 7/10's 5 stars
Weird
http://rateyourmusic.com/~jmarvin_
hi
>>64702643
Can somebody tell me who that guy is? I keep seeing him everywhere but he's completely dead in the soul so I don't know who he is
>>64702576
When we create our RYM, are we supposed to not let others see our ratings?
>>64702611
>miles davis
>the beatles
kek
>>64702509
>i think it's a really lame album
yeah but WHY
>>64702701
It is cheesy he is right there
>>64702657
Music is a commodity to him, what did you expect.
>>64702663
>sun kil moon
boring shit taste detected
>>64702657
what do you think is a 7/10
>>64702674
linkshander is my buddy
>>64702643
>>64702674
>>64702699
>>64702743
(you)
>>64702771
All of them
You're probably just trying to impress people
>>64702786
If you tried this out the bullets would go straight through because you have no soul
>>64702743
b-but mark kozelek is a great songwriter with a beautiful voice
and you've ignored literally everything else i like :(
>>64702289
>>64702316
>>64702599
>>64702604
>>64702699
>>64702743
xus why do you keep coming here? And why do you keep making RYM accounts? Genuinely curious.
>>64702786
newtrip fuck off
>>64702843
You're a fucking joke, sal.
>>64702826
You're a shitty faggot
>>64702809
probably, I'm just a husk of a human
>>64702771
rec me some classical sal
>>64702826
>>64702843
>>64702890
>>64702891
>>64702701
thom's vocals are awful and most of the songs on the album are frustratingly familiar and not very interesting
>>64702808
with the music i listen to? i don't talk to people that look at music that way so you don't make sense
>>64702786
why did you rate Koroliov's AoF twice
trying to boost your numbers eh
>>64702920
You're fat
>>64702950
hey now
>>64702908
have you heard any of mozart's violin sonatas? this one compilation i have of a handful of them is a lot of fun and i know you like mozart
also what do you generally think of solo piano music cuz that's what i listen to and enjoy the most
>>64702826
mfw none of those people are me
>>64702993
Such a brave woman!
>>64702993
who is this beautiful girl
>>64702576
this
https://rateyourmusic.com/~74av
https://rateyourmusic.com/~74av
>>64703067
sal if u like solo piano you should listen to dobrowen's jugend-sonate and medtner's romantic sketches for the young
also moszkowski's trois etudes
>>64703155
Laughing stock is 7/10 tops
>>64703155
>brave little abacus
Can't tell if shill or pleb
>>64702948
accident I swear
>>64703067
I've heard some of his violin concertos but none of the sonatas, will check out
I'm not huge into piano sonatas other than mozart and haydn. I should probably listen to more piano sonatas desu
>>64702993
would you """""""""""""fuck"""""""""""'""" her?
>>64703288
lmfao no
>>64703449
>I'm not huge into piano sonatas other than mozart and haydn.
beethoven
liszt (b minor)
brahms
schoenberg (klavierstucke)
boulez
>>64703502
thanks bud, gonna listen to brahms right now
>>64703288
ok ill change it
>>64703329
both
>>64703246
ok thank you
>>64703449
yeah dude brahms' late piano works and beethoven's piano sonatas are really fucking beautiful
>>64702948
>>64703449
ok now you just have to fix the mistake of only giving it a 3
i mean i get that it's off-putting that all the fake raters are pretending to love it, but it's seriously an impeccable recording
how do i become a fake rater?
>>64704209
for phillip guston, ascension, desertshore, the art of fugue the list goes on...
Reminder that fake-rating is against the rules and RYM has banned users for it in the past.
Reminder that people who complain about "fake-raters" are jealous /mu/ drones.
>>64704355
t. Zizekian
>>64704355
just because its in the rules it stops people from fake rating??
>>64704355
people are obviously still going to get away with it
just look at Verkrah
>>64704385
>>64704512
https://rateyourmusic.com/board_message?message_id=6086533
https://rateyourmusic.com/~AtomicRust
just when i begin to whittle away at my backlog, it grows back again tenfold
https://rateyourmusic.com/~aqam
I haven't heard the new radiohead, but I did download it for ratio this morning
>>64704808
gelapeno chips
>>64704895
Never heard of Twin Infinitives, but gonna check it out now
>>64701639
>praises the new andy stott at 3.5
>calls the new radiohead mediocre at 3.5
hmmm
>>64704895
finish your scaruffi 9s list
give me a user to drone for a few days
bored of my own taste
>>64704986
What do you want me to review next? I'll probably write one this week and finish the rest during summer when I have nothing to do
>>64705043
review sing to god he gave that 9
>>64705043
Twin Infinitives. 9 I've struggled with the most probably
>>64705006
This guy is pretty underrated https://rateyourmusic.com/~AntiWarhol
>>64705111
It's one of my favorite albums.
>>64704950
it's fun
>>64705056
you wish, avant math :^)
>>64705006
~SellMeAGod
>>64705111
I can try, that's probably going to be one of the more difficult to review though
Why do so many people think that In A Silent Way is better than Bitches Brew? Like I understand they enjoy being contrarian 16 year old hipsters, but god damn it's getting ridiculous. In A Silent Way is great though, don't get me wrong.
https://rateyourmusic.com/~KingChile96
https://rateyourmusic.com/~thefunkmob
>>64705111
the album represented an analytical reflection on the perception of the details and the linguistic system which transcend the literal and create an abstraction, but an abstraction anchored to the literal. a cubist masterpiece of deconstruction and reconstruction of musical forms.
>>64705398
They are very different albums, why compare them?
>>64705398
Maybe it because, you know... people enjoy it more???
>>64705398
In a Silent Way has more melody and more drive to it. Bitches Brew is a lot free-er and a lot less enjoyable. Sounds a lot more like wank.
good evening
>>64705725
Fuck off orz
https://rateyourmusic.com/~vApOrzfuok
>>64705780
smae
æ
>>64705780
what's with all the torture in the recent ratings? trying to lower your curve? ;^)
>>64705398
These albums aren't remotely comparable though
In A Silent Way is so fucking comfy
>>64705780
>stupid hoe
>0.5
try deleting your account
>>64705874
i saw that people rated things highly when they are, in actual fact, very bad
>>64706017
dumb hipster
>>64706036
>dumb hipster
ah, tru
the grimes ratings make up for it anyway
amsp IS a 10/10
you dumb avant teens
https://rateyourmusic.com/~Montie_Ray
>>64706142
which of her first two albums do you prefer? i can't decide
>>64706170
Literally Redd it the account
https://rateyourmusic.com/~b1ackjack
>>64706170
how do you do it?
how do you make people fall for your bait every single time?
>>64706258
what album that you've rated, when placed on this chart, has the greatest area, anon?
https://rateyourmusic.com/~deciBel23
Recommend me some bad shit so I can fix my curve
>>64706300
I'm 70% sure he's not baiting... unless it's a beautifully well planned and orchestrated bait. His kikebook profile before he even started posting here was the exact same, filled with meme music. I think he's legit tbqh. Idk how he does it
>>64706328
Mine: https://rateyourmusic.com/release/album/monks_of_the_drepung_loseling_monastery/sacred_tibetan_chants_from_the_great_prayer_festival/
>>64706216
Literally [other forum that is not 4chan but caters to a younger and more left audience and which you have to have an account] the post
>>64706300
>implying its bait
>>64706404
Reddit has been fairly right winged for a while now
>>64706371
It's honestly about 50/50
My RYM is not bait but a lot of my posts here are.
Its a balancing act
>>64706328
https://rateyourmusic.com/release/album/his_name_is_alive/love_cant_buy_happiness/
>>64706371
>>64706404
impressive then desu
>>64706404
Hey Montie, just wanted to let you know that A Moon Shaped Pool is very mediocre and it's telling that a newfag like you would think it's their best work. It's so frail, so weak-hearted, you feel like just blowing on Thom and the gang would knock them over. The songs start with ideas that might evolve into a track like Weird Fishes, with big payoff, but instead are just mediocre jams meant to appease Oasis fans like you who hated their experimental music on TKOL. In short, you're every bit the pleb you've always been, and you should just give up on trying to be taken seriously, because you are not and will not be ever.
>>64706476
>A Moon Shaped Pool is very mediocre
That is your opinion, but I think it is amazing and has not a single bad moment.
>And it's telling a newfag like you would think its their best work
Let's not use buzzwords here. Also I think it's not their best work-OK Computer is. Most Radiohead albums have 1 song I do not like on them. This one and OK Computer have all good songs.
>Its so frail, So weak-hearted, you feel like just blowing on Thom and the gang would knock them over
What the fuck are you even trying to get at here?
>The songs start with ideas that might evolve into a track like weird fishes with big payoff, but instead are just mediocre jams meant to appease Oasis fans like you
LOL that is bait if I ever saw it. This album is nothing like britpop, if you want Oasis appeasing Radiohead listen to the Bends my pal.
>Who hated their experimental music on TKOL
Bait again, TKOL's was a Thom Yorke solo album disguised as a Radiohead album. It was cold and boring.
Jesus christ.
>>64706192
are they really that much better and if so, what went wrong?
>>64706694
>Bait again, TKOL's was a Thom Yorke solo album disguised as a Radiohead album. It was cold and boring.
No, this is the bait. Just because you can't handle the polyrhythms, the modal tonalities, the canonic designs, and the lack of edgy Oasis riffs doesn't mean it isn't massively more inspired, creative, and powerful than this shitty pop album.
>>64706694
yikes
>>64706782
Can you please name one area in AMSP that has a Oasis riff?
Please?
>>64706694
>>64706694
>can't get into TKOL
>>64706815
I will, but first address my other points. You're trying to avoid the fact that I'm massively more capable about discussing this music than you are.
>>64706776
she was getting more popular, but had already run out of interesting ideas. so rather than applying herself she turns to shallow pop appeal to save her. you can already hear it starting in her split with d'eon. by the time she gets to art angels, she's already resorting to the buzziest, most 'happening' mainstream electronic beat sounds. it's lazy and gross.
>>64706839
fucking thank you. tkol is radiohead's best
>>64707004
you're welcome, anon
And Montie has chickened out.
What a fucking awful poster.
>>64706839
I can get into it, I just don't care for it at all.
>>64706891
No, you are literally just throwing shit out there in a attempt to make me look stupid.
I am 99% sure I had this argument with you last night
>>64707058
>No, you are literally just throwing shit out there in a attempt to make me look stupid.
Are you claiming that TKOL does not use polyrhythms, modal tonalities, and canonic structures?
>>64707058
>attempt to make me look stupid.
You do a good enough job yourself
Of course I know Montie isn't claiming that about TKOL: how would he know if the album lacks basic terms that he doesn't understand, being an idiot?
>>64707096
No, I am not. It does.
I just think the album is cold and is not Radioheads best work. I think Radiohead at their best is when they are not making cold electronic music.
It is not a good album, it is stupid to say it is their best because the quality simply is not there.
Maybe for avant teens who claim they don't like pop music.
>>64707443
i bet you actually like the bends lmao
>>64707468
>implying the bends is bad
Its a transitional album. I don't like parts of it, but you have to admit it is a pretty fun album.
>>64707468
the bends is a great album
>>64707443
>I just think the album is cold and is not Radioheads best work.
How? Thom is incredibly emotive: he bellows in Bloom, he's sinister on Magpie, he's soulful on Lotus Flower and LBL.
>I think Radiohead at their best is when they are not making cold electronic music.
You're literally no better than the "DAE EDM NOT REAL MUSIC" faggots.
>It is not a good album
Why? Because you're too pleb to understand music is more than just Oasis and Coldplay?
>Maybe for avant teens
You do realize I'm older and more mature than you, right?
>>64707499
>>64707503
no
Montie:
>If music is made with electronic equipment, that makes it cold and unemotional.
This is the kid who killed /mu/, everyone...
>>64703067
barging in here, but I enjoy a lot of Haydn/D'vorak for my classical, and of course Chopin for my Piano.
And Montie ran away.
>>64708945
or just went to bed? do you know what time it is?
i can never decide if it's best being unnoticed or being a hated meme
>>64709621
hated meme, duh
>>64703499
>lmfao
typical talk talk fan
https://rateyourmusic.com/~schtraw
fight me its amazing
https://rateyourmusic.com/list/schtraw/obligatory_radiohead_albums_b_sides_ranking
>>64705398
>miles Davis, 2pac, joy division
kek normie
posting at 12 am wew
https://rateyourmusic.com/~animeregrets
>>64705428
Kanye West
Are you 12?
>>64705780
lol
>>64706170
you have the cringiest profile I've ever seen
>>64712206
like it, huh?
>>64708945
put your trip back on montie
you try so hard to shill your name on this site, it's embarrassing
>>64706170
Disgusting. I always wonder why people with nothing to say always trip
wow AMSP sucks major ding dong
>>64706170
nice taste, retard
>>64701639
>BP that low
pleb
>>64712339
>amsp sucks major ding dong
yeah i listened to like four tracks and got bored and turned it off
i dont udnerstand the hype
>people still mentioning or replying to autists like m0ntie
just fucking stop, he won't ever go away otherwise. please
I was hating the shit out of TKOL in the other thread. I relistened a little more closely and dropped my ego and I realized its a lot bette rthan I thought.
The only thing is I don't really like having to force myself to like something. I prefer music that connects immediately and deeply. TKOL is very atmospheric, and very interesting. It's spaced out.
I underrated it, no question. It's their deepest album thematically and emotionally, actually. It's far far better than I remembered, no joke.
>>64712389
you're doing it now
i'm doing it now
Now that I'm finally unbanned:
How is YOUR Musique Concrete May going familia? What is YOUR favorite album so far?
Mine's a tossup between Riga by ZGA and La stazione by Herbert Distel.
https://rateyourmusic.com/~wawbax
>>64712380
>i dont udnerstand the hype
you don't know many radiohead fanboys, right? :^)
the internet is full of them
>>64712423
nah senpai i replaced the o with a 0 so he won't see that post when he searches the archive for his name
>>64712430
i was so close to forgetting but now i'm ruined again for a good week at least... ;_ ;
>>64712445
yeah i noticed that but still
>>64712479
OK Computer isn't even Radiohead's best album. That list just depresses me.
>>64712519
i know
[sobs quietly]
>>64712534
What'd you think of the new album?
>>64712552
>>>64712339
>>amsp sucks major ding dong
>yeah i listened to like four tracks and got bored and turned it off
>i dont udnerstand the hype
>>64712593
Cool. I really like it though.
eccojams is just too beautiful...
>>64706404
reddit is right as fuck you complete tard and why do you care so much about liberals
youre so embarrassing why havent you killed yourself?
>>64706404
You are lying to yourself if you think that Reddit isn't right.
Wrote a quick (1.5 star) review to balance out the absurd amount of 5 star reviews
I'm actually surprised there aren't a bunch of 0.5 reviews yet, saying the typical 'Radiohead sucks' type of stuff or whatever
>>64713061
>the typical 'Radiohead sucks' type of stuff or whatever
Hope you realise that's you if you wrote a 1.5 star review.
>>64713122
I don't think Radiohead sucks, though. AMSP is actually pretty good
>>64713166
>1.5
>pretty good
DAE le epic positive ratings xDDDDD
>>64713122
>>64713166
>>64713188
XPPPPPPPP xDDDDDDD BOI
>>64713188
my rating of 1.5 and me saying it's 'pretty good' aren't related at all. and I'm not a positive ratings person, 2.5 is my middle
