Christgau about prog
Images are sometimes not shown due to bandwidth/network limitations. Refreshing the page usually helps.
You are currently reading a thread in /mu/ - Music
You are currently reading a thread in /mu/ - Music
Is he right about prog-rock? it is really a shit genre?
>>64307500
all prog is shit fuck you mean
when a /mu/tant says he likes prog
>what i hope for
genesis, yes, ELP, gentle giant
>what he means
can, magma, cardiacs, henry cow
>>64307513
yeah
>>64307500
Christgau was wrong about everything he said. He's an utter idiot and a Cultural Marxist.
>>64307653
So you hope for the most publicly well-known of the genre and instead get the most poseurcore ones? I don't know what you expected on here.
>>64307653
>ELP
disgusting. why would you hope for that?
on the other hand
>cardiacs
when will the mutants learn
>>64307500
This dude has been irrelevant for at least 20 years at this point. His rating scale is shit and constantly changes.
I wish he posted here.
I can't name a better single current writer that's half as good as him. Not even mentioning his pretty good taste.
>>64307500
He's only saying that because he's a punker
>>64307653
genesis is so bad lmao
>>64307500
no, i just don't think its a type of music he understands or relates to. doesn't change the fact that prog resonates with millions of others though
>>64307500
Christgau is the biggest living hack in the music industry
>>64308723
t. Robert Christgau
>>64308986
kek
>>64307500
He's a dumb poptimist
>>64308057
How the hell is this relevant to the thread?
>>64307653
when a normie says he likes prog
>what i hope for
genesis, yes, ELP, gentle giant
>what he means
dream theater, muse, opeth, tool
Christgau thinks Beatles pop songs are the ultimate level of music, and has probably sucked Lennons' cock at least 5 times in his life.
>>64307653
LETS GO ElP
>>64309385
especially at the morgue after he got shot amirite?
>>64308907
I really want to get into them but I just can't. Firth of Filth is goat tho
>>64309580
listen to The Colony of Slippermen
well yes, prog is shit
>>64309705
pleb
>>64309310
>Implying Opeth isn't GOAT
>>64309310
>implying Tool isnt GOAT
>>64309310
>Implying muse isn't...wait, nvm.
Generally speaking, yes.
