his argument was really bad too
>>64282947
tfw all the flaws are appeals
>>64282947
he is a musical authority. you keep making threads about hhim
>>64282947
I like the Blue album more than Pinkerton. I think Songs From The Black Hole was better too
>>64282968
>you keep making threads about him
this is my first anti-fantano thread, and if you think he IS a musical authority, you're a new kind of stupid
Is it just me or did he seem really irritable in that video? Especially the way he said "forever" at the end.
Pinkerton has barely a coupla good songs on it, while the Blue Album has about 5 pretty decent ones.
>>64284320
He knows it's all coming to an end
>>64284366
I hope it does
I dont care that he likes blue more. I have trouble deciding between the two myself. But his reasons were shit and the way he presented it as an objective fact really rustled my jimmies.
bruh i thought it was satire that poked fun at both of the album's flaws
i mean i love the blue album but hell if half of the songs make any sense
>>64282947
I like blue more than Pinkerton and this video pissed me the fuck off.
I just watch him for memes. I doubt anyone takes him seriously as a critic. He is the Jeremy jahns of music
>>64284393
I feel like the objective fact part was just a mock of people who say things like that
Fantano has objectively shit taste and frequently discusses musical genres he clearly knows nothing about. Every once in awhile he gets something right, but even when he does it's usually for the wrong reasons.
He gets a light 3
>>64283024
agreed
>getting butthurt over a joke video
c'mon son
Fantano is literally a shitposter with a webcam.
I bet he made this thread too.
sage
It was a joke video I think. Consequence of Sound had just posted a video on Pinkerton, plus Fantano came off really shitposty and trolling in that video.
>>64284415
The only satire was the way he presented it. I'm sure that's his actual opinion
I dread the day you bastards subconsciously lull me into watching a few seconds of this guy. I swear he's the most discussed "critic" I've ever seen.
>tfw you also have terrible internet until 1 am so you couldn't watch him if you wanted to
>>64288497
Go to bed Anthony
>>64282947
I actually agree. Even though I think pinkerton has more "artistic merit" to it or whatever it isn't nearly as catchy and just plain fun as the blue album.
>>64284335
Fuck you, every song on both albums is at the very least good.
please don't tell me fantano fans actually enjoy watching someone talk about how one thing is better than another for 5 minutes. no doubt they'll all drone his opinions too and this board will start to claim they thought the same all along.
>tfw you realize the only reason anyone cares about fantano is the fact that he's actually capable of describing what led him to his opinions instead of just saying "it's great" or "it's shit"
Doesn't matter if it's music, film, literature or whatever, reviewers should only be valued for their capacity to help you develop your OWN opinion. Ebert was a great film reviewer, who happened to really not like David Lynch, who happens to be one of my favorite directors. I don't agree with his opinions, but he helped me temper my own, and helped me develop a more nuanced understanding of his films. Fantano is no Roger Ebert, but it's the same basic principle.
>there are people who actually took the "it's objectively better" comment seriously
>there are people who actually took the fucking video seriously
>He says Pinkerton fans jump at any opportunity to shout about how much Pinkerton is better than blue"
>He makes a video shouting about how much better blue is
Logic
>>64288692
I'd agree if he weren't the redpill youtube type. Dude is turning into some fucking vapid talking head.
