Can we do a best/runner-up/worst/underrated/overrated thread but with albums instead of songs?
I'll go first
Best: Kid A
Runner-Up: In rainbows
Worst: Pablo honey
Underrated: Hail to the thief
Overrated: The bends
Best: tweez
Runner up: Slint EP
Worst: Spiderland
Underrated: Slint EP
Overrated: Spiderland
best: illinois
runner-up: michigan
worst: the avalanche
overrated: age of adz
underrated: seven swans
>best
virgins
>runner-up
harmony in ultraviolet
>worst
an imaginary country
>underrated
mirages
>overrated
ravedeath 1979
best: draft 7.30
runner up: oversteps
worst: incunabula
overrated: untilted
underrated: quaristice
Best: Meddle
Runner up: Animals
Worst: Endless River
Underrated: AMLOR
Overrated: Besides the obvious Wall and DSOTM I'll say PATGOD
>>64269606
>>64269668
>>64269746
>>64269766
literally who?
>>64269796
literally google it you spoon-fed babby
Best: Plastic Surgery Disasters
Runner-Up/Underrated: Frankenchrist
Overrated: Fresh Fruit For Rotting Vegetables:
Worst: Bedtime For Democracy
>>64269543
This is actually pretty congruent to what I would write
Best: Paul's Boutique
Runner-Up: Ill Communication
Worst: To The 5 Boroughs
Underrated: Hot Sauce Committee Part 2
Overrated: Licensed To Ill
>>64270105
Pretty much this. Probobly Check your head as a runner up for me.
Best: Morningrise
Runner-up: Still Life
Worst: Heritage
Overrated: My Arms your Hearse
Underrtaed: Damnation
>>64269766
>best
chiastic slide
>runner up
confield
>worst
quaristice
>overrated
lp5
>underrated
oversteps
Best: Aus den Sieben Tagen
Runner-Up: Gesang der Junglinge
Worst: Momente
Underrated: Telemusik
Overrated: Sternklang
Tried not to repeat.
Best: String Quartet No. 4
Runner-Up: Hurqualia
Worst: Canti del Capricorno
Underrated: Suite 9
Overrated: Quattro Pezzi
Mogwai:
>Best
EP+6
>Runner-Up
Rock Action
>Worst
Hawk is Howling
>Overrated
Happy Songs
>Underrated
Rock Action
Best: Perfect From Now On
Runner-Up: Keep It Like A Secret
Worst: Ultimate Alternative Wavers
Underrated: You In Reverse
Overrated: There's Nothing Wrong With Love
Best: Folie ā deux
Runner-Up: American beauty/ American psycho
Worst: Pax am days
Underrated: Folie ā deux
Overrated: From under the cork tree
Best: DUM SPIRO SPERO
Runner-up: VULGAR
Worst: THE MARROW OF A BONE
Overrated: GAUZE
Underrated: Kisou
zxcv
>>64270235
Replace MAyH with Blackwater Park and Heritage with Pale Communion
>>64269606
Best: Pinkerton (fuck fagtano)
Runner-Up: Blue
Worst: Hurley
Underrated: Make Believe
Overrated: Green
Best: Leviathan
Runner-Up: Crack the Skye
Worst: Once More 'round the Sun
Overrated: Leviathan
Underrated: Blood Mountain
Best: Magical Mystery Tour
Runner-Up: white album
Worst: Beatles For Sale
Underrated: Help!
Overrated: Sgt. Peppers
>>64272208
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VfM06M6Ki4w
Best: spirit they're gone . . .
Runner-Up: idk
Worst: strawberry jam
Underrated: none
Overrated: all of them
>>64269766
best: draft 7.30 or amber
runner up: confield
worst: quaristice
overrated: lp5
underrated: oversteps
>>64270023
desu, Fresh Fruit is Runner Up/Overrated while Frankenchrist is Underrated.
>>64272121
>best
Drukqs or RDJ Album
>runner up
SAW II or Rushup Edge
>worst
I Care Because You Do
>overrated
SAW 85-92
>underrated
Syro
Best: Kill em All
Runner-Up: Ride the Lightning
Worst: Re-Load
Overrated: Black Album
Underrated: St. Anger
Best: Ummagumma
Runner-Up: Animals
Worst: The Final Cut and subsequent
Underrated: Meddle
Overrated: Atom Heart Mother
>Best
XO
>Runner-up
Elliott Smith
(these two pretty much interchangeable desu)
>Worst
Figure 8
>Overrated
Either/Or
>Underrated
From A Basement On The Hill
>>64272247
shit opinion
Best: Sung Tongs
Runnner-Up: STGSTV
Worst: CHz
Underrated: Campfire Songs or Hollinndagain
Overrated: Feels
>best
Pet Sounds
>runner-up
Friends
>worst
Summer In Paradise
>overrated
Surf's Up
>underrated
All Summer Long
>>64272349
but anco sucks
>>64272467
no u
>>64269606
>bait
Best: Soundtracks for the Blind
Runner up: To Be Kind tied with The Seer
Worst: The Burning World
Underrated: Holy Money
Overrated: The Great Annihilator
>>64272464
>Surf's Up overrated
>>64272349
shitty shit shit opinion
Best: CHz
Runner up: Strawberry Jam
Worst: MWPP
Underrated: CHz
Overrated: MWPP
>>64272003
Would definitely not say American Beauty/American Psycho was one of their best. Everything after Folie a deux was utter garbage.
>>64269668
Best: Michigan
Runner Up: IL
Worst: rabbit
Underrated: Seven Swans
Overrated: IL
>>64269543
completely accurate
>>64272349
Best: Feels
Runner- UP: STGSTV
Worst: PW
Underrated: Danse Manatee
Overrated: SJ
Best: Duty Now For The Future
Runner-Up: Q: Are We Not Men? A: We Are Devo!
Worst: Shout
Underrated: New Traditionalists
Overrated: Freedom of Choice
>>64272324
objectively true
>>64272500
>A different opinions from mines Is bait
>>64273834
No, that specific contrarian opinion is bait
best: You're Living All Over Me
runner-up: Farm
worst: Hand it Over
underrated: Dinosaur
overrated: Beyond
>>64274025
Farm is great but I'd put Where You Been at runner-up
>>64272241
fuck no
>Best
The Beatles
>Runner-Up
Sgt. Pepper's
>Worst
Please Please Me
>Underrated
Rubber Soul
>Overrated
Abbey Road
>Best
Frizzle Fry
>Runner-Up
Pork Soda
>Worst
Chocolate Factory
>Underrated
Brown Album
>Overrated
Seas of Cheese
>>64272343
THIS
>>64274398
>Best
Frizzle Fry
>Runner-Up
Seas of Cheese
>Worst
Tales from the Punchbowl
>Underrated
Animals Should Not Try To Act Like People
>Overrated
Pork Soda
Best: You Made Me Realize
Runner-Up: Loveless
Worst: Glider
Underrated: mbv
Overrated: Loveless
Best: Let It Bleed
Runner-Up: Sticky Fingers
Worst: Out of Our Heads
Underrated: It's Only Rock 'n Roll
Overrated: Some Girls
Best: Loaded
Runner-Up: The Velvet Underground & Nico
Worst: Squeeze [spoiler]surprise[/spoiler]
Underrated: White Light/White Heat
Overrated: Eponymous (The Murder Mystery is their best song tho)
Boredoms:
Best: Super ae
Runner-Up: Vision Creation Newsun
Worst: Osorezan no Stooges Kyo
Underrated: Chocolate Synthesizer
Overrated: Vision Creation Newsun
heres my shit beatles opinions
Best: White Album
Runner Up: Revolver
Worst: With The Beatles
Underrated: Rubber Soul
Overrated: Sgt. Peppers (sorry middle of the album is weak desu)
>>64273851
Whatever you say.
I guess my opinion is bait
My life is bait..........
>>64269543
Interpol
Best: Turn On the Bright Lights
Runner-up: Antics
Worst: El Pintor
Overrated: Antics
Underrated: self-titled
I would have said El Pintor is overrated, but no one really rates any album post-Antics. And I unironically enjoy the much maligned s/t record, easily their third best (Our Love To Admire is too uneven)
>>64275225
SONIC YOUTH
Best: Daydream Nation
Runner-up: EVOL
Worst: s/t
Overrated: Goo
Underrated: Sonic Nurse
>>64275707
fuck, didn't mean to quote
Modest Mouse
Best - Lonesome Crowded West
Runner up - This is a Long Drive for Someone with Nothing to Think About
Worst - Strangers to Ourselves
Underrated - Moon and Antarctica
Overrated - Good News for People who love Bad News
pic related
>Best
The Fragile
>Runner Up
The Downward Spiral
>Worst
The Slip
>Overrated
With Teeth
>Underrated
Year Zero
>>64272311
>Best
And Justice for All
>Runner Up
Master of Puppets
>Worst
The Black Album
>Overrated
The Black Album
>Underrated
Kill Em All
>>64272220
>Best
Blood Mountain
>Runner Up
Leviathan
>Worst
OMRTS
>Overrated
The Hunter
>Underrated
Remission
>>64269543
>Best
OKC
>Runner Up
Kid A
>Worst
Pablo Honey
>Underrated
Amnesiac
>Overrated
The Bends
>>64269668
>OVERRATED
>AGE OF ADZ
GET OFF MY PROPERTY
My main man Kanye
Best: My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy
Runner-Up: Yeezus
Worst: Late Registration
Underrated: The College Dropout
Overrated: Graduation
>>64276135
nah
>Best
MBDTF
>Runner Up
Yeezus
>Worst
TLOP
>Underrated
Late Registration
>Overrated
Graduation
>>64272142
Swap Morningrise and Still Life and it's perfect
>>64276135
>Best: My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy
>>>>>Worst: Late Registration
>Overrated: Graduation
Please don't be real.
Best: Nashville Skyline
Runner Up: Blonde on Blonde
Worst: Empire Burlesque
Underrated: Bootleg Series Vol. 8 - Tell Tale Signs
Overrated: Desire
>>64269543
Best: In Rainbows
Runner-Up: Kid A
Worst: Pablo Honey
Underrated: The Bends
Overrated: OK computer
>>64272349
Best: Prospect Hummer
Runner-Up: Feels
Worst: Painting With
Underrated: Prospect Hummer
Overrated: none
>>64269543
Best: Feels
Runner-up: Here Comes the Indian
Worst: Painting With
Overrated: Merriweather Post Pavilion (or Sung Tongs, but I'll probably get in trouble for that.)
Underrated: Campfire Songs
>>64272349
>Overrated: Feels
Everyone aside from me says Feels is overrated which makes me think most people don't realize how good Feels is, as I think it's their best album by far.
>>64269796
holy new
