>SOMETHING INSIDE THAT WAS ALWAYS DENIED
>FOR SO MANY YEEEEEAAAAARS!
Why does /mu/ hate this album again?
we dont
we don't
it's a pop masterpiece desu
>>64154246
McCartney's
>SHEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE
is amazing on this track. The whole thing is like an Eleanor Rigby for church. Great stuff.
She's Leaving Home is the best track on Sgt. Pepper's.
>>64154246
Because it's dated as fuck. It has a couple masterpieces, but a few duds as well. She's Leaving Home is a mawkish, failed attempt at McCartney trying to be Brian Wilson. The whole album basically sounds like The Beatles trying to be trippy and overly ambitious and cram everything into one album, but comes across as gimmicky and amateur compared to some other pop albums of the time.
>>64154455
If it's mawkish like you say then I'd say it's a successful attempt to be Brian Wilson, Sgt. Schmaltz.
>>64154246
>WE NEVER THOUGHT OF OURSELVES
You lying fucks
>>64154598
The difference is that She's Leaving Home is dishonest and heavy-handed while Brian's music comes from the heart and is pleasant to listen to. I mean, the chorus is alright but the verses just drag on and on. It really wouldn't be so bad with a more traditional rock arrangement, but McCartney's abuse of muh strings and the slow tempo just ruin it
>>64154246
A slightly better Pet Sounds that didn't bring the innovations Pet Sounds brought, nothing great desu
Rubber Soul and Revolver are way better
>>64154691
I don't know how you're ascribing dishonesty to it but okay.
All agreed that Within You Without You is worst track?
>>64155086
nah it's Lovely Rita
>>64155086
Good Morning Good Morning is worse
>>64155109
bruv.. I hope you're memeing right now bruv
>>64155120
GMGM is tied with Lovely Rita for worst. Seeing him play Lovely Rita live made me realize how underwritten and average it is
>>64155086
this >>64155120
and Fixing a Hole are probably the worst. I also don't particularly care for the Sgt. Pepper Reprise. Within You Without You is probably after those in terms of least favorites
>>64155144
Although I agree it's certainly not a lyrical masterpiece, those vocal harmonies man... they get to me
>>64155120
>underwritten
What does this even mean? It has verses, bridges, a solo and an outro just like a lot of their songs. And just in my opinion it's one of McCartney's finest melodies
The worst song is CLEARly Getting Better. It's essentially a novelty song and it's just one dumb riff for most of the song
>>64155148
Fixing a Hole is kind of dumb but it has impressive production and good lyrics
>>64155187
>Getting Better
FUCK no, it's in the top 5
>>64155148
I think the Reprise is way better than the opener. The riff is scorching.
>tfw you realize 3/4 of the people who play the closing chord of A Day In The Life are dead
>>64155276
this, also
>Sgt pepper's one and only lonely hearts club band
I love that part
best song on SGTP'sLHCBand?
>>64155340
A Day in the Life should be everyone's choice
The real question is second best song
For me its Lucy in the sky
>>64155340
SGTP'sLHCBand
Jesus Christ, just call it Sgt Peppers like a normal person
>>64155397
>not calling it Sargey P's Lonesome Soulsome Discotheque DJ Division
ISHYGDDT
>>64155340
pinni layn deshu
>>64155299
same, same.
>>64155588
wrong ablum desu desu desu senpai desu senpai desu senpai senpai senpai desu
>>64155600
how about carnival of light, desune?
listening to this on acid dude
you can't even
>>64155086
FUCKING
P L E B
>>64155732
I listened to all the Beatles albums on acid. Honestly, you could listen to Toby Keith 9/11 boot in your ass music on acid and it's awesome. I did that too.
Best thing I ever heard on acid was the fucking Ying Yang twins lol
One of the best
>>64155109
TAKE IT BACK
>>64155294
>>64155294
damn..
>>64154691
>Brian's music comes from heart
Oh my fucking kek... So music that "comes from heart" is better than the music that is actually better? Nice logic mate.
>>64154269
this
>>64154269
>>64154246
>>64154691
The instrumental for Shes leaving home is better than anything PM did.
Based George Martin
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wpbNrbz8Tcw
>>64157226
define "actually better"
>>64154246
it's grandpa pop
>>64154246
Because its objectively the best album of all time.
>>64157536
The instrumental for Don't Talk is better than anything either of those slimy limies did
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=14LdxsbYX4U
>>64157536
George Martin didn't make the arrangement for Shes Leaving Home, mate.
>The day before McCartney wanted to work on the song's score, he learned that George Martin, who usually handled the Beatles' string arrangements, was not available. He contacted Mike Leander, who did it in Martin's place. It was the first time a Beatles song was not arranged by Martin. Martin was hurt by McCartney's actions, but he produced the song and conducted the string section.
obnoxious emotionally devoid kitsch
>>64158467
>emotionally devoid
have you never listened to it? every song is emotional.
>>64154269
That song was the single moment when The Beatles went next-level.
It's the pivot point of the entire album, and it's the song that prepared the listeners for god-tier art pop of A Day In The Life.
A Day In The Life really is the greatest song in the history of music
>>64158666
>dude crescendos and long fade out lmao
its just a gimmick
>>64158683
you mean it was something that literally had never been done before and forever changed popular music
>>64158666
trips confirm
>>64154455
A day in the life is a master piece.
>>64158703
>the beatles are the most revolutionary band ever
Strawberry Fields is the best technical work they've ever done
Walrus was good too
>>64155148
I was about to refute that, but >>64155187
and >>64155276 did it for me.
Fixing A Hole had decent lyrics, and the production was great. The repeat also kicked ass.
>>64158741
HOLY
>>64158666
>he fell for the meme
>>64155352
It's a tie between With A Little Help From My Friends or She's Leaving Home, would be my pick for #2.
But I also think that Magical Mystery Tour is the better album.
basically, Sgt. Pepper's has the better opener and a far, far better closer, but it really only has a couple good tracks in the middle (Getting Better, Fixing A Hole, and She's Leaving Home)
Meanwhile, Magical Mystery Tour has an equally good opener, and the songs in the middle are utterly god-tier Beatles (The Fool On The Hill, Hello, Goodbye, Strawberry Fields Forever, Penny Lane), and even the normie memed-to-death closer is a better wannabe vaudeville song than anything on Sgt. Peppers.
>>64158856
Damn, I also forgot I Am The Walrus.
>>64158703
bands inspired by the beatles are fucking shit
>oasis
>blur
>coldplay
>the list goes on
and don't say DERP Can man said... because u know that's grasping straws m8
>A Day in the Life is my least favourite and Getting Better is my favourite
>>64158911
Getting better was one of the best songs on the album, desu senpai
>>64158520
the majority of the songs are wacky goofy happy-go-lucky schlock
This album is literally Rubber Soul and Revolver with better production. Why do you say its worse than those albums?
>>64158900
yeah the list does go on because the impact the beatles had was medium-transcending, they did something new on such a large scale that everyone was affected by it, picking a handful of artists that were inspired by them that you personally don't like is just retarded
>>64158900
>hating on Oasis
>not understanding that Wonderwall is un-ironically one of the greatest pop songs of all time
>not understanding that Definitely Maybe was a legitimately great album
>>64158991
holy shit kill yourself montie
>>64158968
>the impact the beatles had was medium-transcending
that's a pretty fancy way of saying "people copied their haircuts for a little while"
>>64159024
yeh keep cracking jokes to avoid the fact that you're wong if that makes you feel better
>>64155086
Absolutely
>>64158991
Wonderwall is not even a good song.
>>64159177
You had to be there, man
>>64158955
it's a compeletely different experience. the fuck you're talking about?
A resounding eh, to me.
Better baroque pop albums
>>64154691
>Brian's music comes from the heart
yeah it's so fucking true and geniune that he needs someone else to write half of his "close to heart" lyrics
Amazing album. Good Morning Good Morning is obviously the worst track, but it's not even bad. I know every note on this album by memory, that's how much I love it.
>>64160229
He collaborated with others on lyrics because he knew he wasn't the best at them and had enough of a load to carry anyway. The lyrics are still obviously based on his feelings and inner state of mind.
Why bring up MUH LYRICS when talking about Brian's songwriting, anyway? He communicates through music. No one is as good at crafting emotionally resonant melodies as him. The lyrics could be about literally fucking anything and his music would still be touching and heartfelt.
>yfw you realize Scaruffi only gave it a 7 for the Mr. Kite circus song
>>64154246
Because it's immensely overrated and not very good.
>>64155086
This and Good Morning, Good Morning arent very good. Everything else is fantastic, particularly Paul's songs.
>>64154691
Jesus Beach Boy fags are the worst
Good Morning Good Morning is a great song, you plebs.
>>64154455
IMHO it's really dated when you compare it to Revolver - it feels really odd how popular Sgt. Pepper's was at the time, Revolver, The Beatles and Abbey Road are easily better albums
But then, having the ability to do all that crazy shit in the studio was new, so it was really influential for proving musicians around the world that you can expand the boundaries of your artistic vision and musical ability by taking advance of new studio technology and that step forward had a massive effect on rock/pop music so Sgt. Pepper's deserves a lot of credit for making that obvious and inspiring musicians to take their music forward with technology far more than more modest users of studio capabilities like Beach Boys or trailblazers with smaller audiences like Frank Zappa did.
>>64155144
it's these and Fixing a Hole ain't good either
Both Lovely Rita and GMGM feel like they could be good parts of a Abbey Road like medley if they were about 90 seconds long and flowed well to neighboring tracks
In retrospect, a lot of Sgt. Pepper's seems like a rehearsal for the B-side of Abbey Road where the idea of connecting separate tracks comes together almost magically and really makes every little bit better in this context. If Abbey Road never happened, I guess Sgt. Pepper's might seem better as an album, but now the transitions from one track to the next just feel like a rehearsal.
On that note, Good Morning, Good Morning is actually somewhat saved by the barnyard transition to the title track reprise - it's a great underrated moment imho, flows quite nicely
>>64155732
first time i did acid i listened to sgt peppers 4 times in a row
good times
>>64161782
>defending She's Leaving Home
the whole thing sounds like mccartney trying to make this serious and dramatic song with an elaborate string arrangement but it just ends up being pure corn
>>64162163
>more modest users of studio capabilities like Beach Boys
What's the problem with Good Morning, Good Morning? Some characteristically great Lennon lyrics on that one.
>>64154269
I teared up listening to it for the first time on full blast desu
If you're not listening to the mono version of Sgt. Pepper, you're fucking up.
Revolver and the white album are probably still my personal favorites, though.
>>64155086
yes
>>64155109
DELETE THIS
>>64154246
What is the most criminally underrated Beatles song and why is it "When I'm Sixty-Four"?
>>64155086
>the best song on the album by far is the worst, everyone agree?
kys pleb
paul is dead
