Pet Sounds for the feels

SMiLE by a MiLE

Smile Sessions meanders towards the latter half of the album.
Pet Sounds has 0% filler. Easy choice

>>64148685
underrated

Pet Sounds

Smile Sessions. They both share a sense of cohesion and what not, but I feel as though that Smile Sessions is more 'From the mind of Brian Wilson (and Van Dyke Parks)' than just 'Brian Wilson covering songs brian wilsony'

File: image.jpg (294 KB, 1024x689) Image search: [Google]

294 KB, 1024x689

Please, don't shit on me, but I've always liked Smiley the best.

Especially this song
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=3r8kx-ICtN8

File: BW-faces2.jpg (744 KB, 2086x2067) Image search: [Google]

744 KB, 2086x2067

>>64148630
Pet Sounds to me is like that one really good movie that just managed to do everything right

SMiLE is like that sequel that tries to be more deep or over the top than the first one and while still enjoyable, just doesnt capture the same feels as the original movie

I still like both

File: sunflower-su.jpg (76 KB, 600x300) Image search: [Google]

76 KB, 600x300

Alright /mu/. Sunflower or Surf's Up?

well pet sounds was actually finished

>>64148924
surf's up has student demonstration time, thus sunflower is better.

>>64148924
Sunflower

>>64148924
tough choice, both have a lot of duds, but i'd lean towards surfs up

>>64148630
Pet Sounds. SMiLE WOULD have been better but at this stage sounds clearly unfinished (it is at least a 9/10 for me though)

>>64148924
sunflower

>>64148924

I give the edge to Sunflower as it's more consistent throughout.

Don't Go Near the Water and Student Demonstration Time ruin Surf's Up imo even if the last three tracks + feel flows & long promised road are brilliant

>>64148630
none

>>64148924
Sunflower and I don't think it's that close. Surf's Up has some great highs, but really isn't that consistent. Sunflower is amazing start to finish imo.

To answer OPs question, I go back and forth but have been leaning towards Pet Sounds lately.