>3 tracks of some guy yelling than shitting himself
What defines music?
If I record my farts is it music?
Yes.
>some guy yelling than shitting himself
Sounds like my average Monday morning.
It is if you autotune them.
https://youtu.be/uLpJdrj0m4I?t=1m6s
Music is subject.
Anything can (and can't) be music depending on your opinions.
/discussion
>What is music?
Sounds deliberately organized in time.
it's two tracks don't lie on the internet
>>63951627
>What defines music?
Like all art; deliberation.
>If I record my farts is it music?
Sure.
Regardless, get over this stupid "I don't like it so it's bad" idea.
Deliberation doesn't define art. Art can be improvised, a la free jazz, a lot of noise since we're on the subject, abstract painting, acting, etc.
>>63951679
>>63951688
>>63951718
only importants posts ITT until it bursts in shitposting and "le noise is not music xD"
>>63951718
i think art is easier to define than music tho, which is what op is asking about
i always went with "art is anything created to cause an emotional response" though
>>63951718
>Art can be improvised, a la free jazz, a lot of noise since we're on the subject, abstract painting, acting, etc.
It's still deliberate. There is a conscious acknowledgement of creating something, otherwise these people wouldn't be doing what they do in the first place.
>>63951683
So 4'33 isn't music?
>>63951825
>he still thinks 4'33" consists of silence
You missed the entire point.
>>63951763
Art can be created for mental rather than emotional reasons as well.
>>63951773
You're stretching "deliberate" so far that it applies to any action taken while not completely zoned out. If you want to say that walking your dog or scratching your balls is art, that's fine with me, but it doesn't seem to be a very useful definition.
>>63951825
I wouldn't say it is.
>>63951852
He actually didn't say that.
>>63951909
No, I'm not. These people are performing in some way - whether it be on instruments, putting pencil/painbrush to canvas or moving their body on a stage. They are fully within that process and AWARE they are involved in a creative practice; whether their actions are improvised are not is irrelevant.
To me, the product of any creative practice can be called art. I've seen people argue that machines programmed to generate an image or audio piece isn't art, but someone has made the program to do that with the intent of an outcome. That very process of deliberation defines art.
