What would've been the better release, Pinkerton or SFTBH
Pinkerton.
SFTB is completely all over the place, and moves far too quickly for the concept album its trying to be.
Pinkerton most definitely, but Longtime Sunshine is an 11/10 closer which is far better than Butterfly, and You Won't Get With Me Tonight is better than most songs on Pinkerton
I feel like they would have refined SFTBH if they actually were to make it. What we have now is just a combination of demos and other tracks that were intended to be on it.
Either way, I still think Pinkerton is the better due to how honest Rivers was trying to be. Of course that led to having a breakdown over the bad reviews, but it's still a great album despite what it caused.
>>63933839
I like SFTB but Pinkerton is clearly better
I really wish they would have put Longtime Sunshine as the album's closer instead of Butterfly
>>63933884
>>63934110
How can you say this? From what I've listened to, SFTBH wasn't even remotely close to being finished, so nobody knows the answer.
>Why don't we have both?
elpaso.gif
Songs easy
someone should fix up all the production and shit on SFTBH
>>63934110
Most people don't really seem to realize that Pinkerton is based off a play called Madame Butterfly.
where can i find the closest thing to a canonical tracklist for SFTBH?
I'm confused, wasn't SFTBH never completed? What's its status, I know a few tracks were on the deluxe Pinkerton release but there was never a full album was there?
>>63938964
there are leaked versions that contain what it was at the time it was scraped but officially nothing
weezer is shit
>>63938940
http://albumsthatneverwere.blogspot.com.au/2013/08/weezer-songs-from-black-hole.html
>>63939426
thanks for your contribution :)
They need to do a 1992-1997 Weezer Box Set with Blue, SFTBH and Pinkerton with all the Bonus Tracks, Demos, a Live Show and unreleased stuff. That would be amazing.
>>63933839
I'm 34 and what is this
>my entire life in another universe is somehow perfect
t-t-t-thanks
