Find a flaw with Scaruffi's greatest classical list.
>>63832260
>no female composers
>>63832260
no music before Bach.
>>63832292
>No black transgender composers
>>63832454
>they're all European
>>63832260
I mean it's like 95% tonal but whatever. For the basic bitches that follow him it's a pretty good intro to classical music
>>63832454
>no one-legged MtF dragonkin half-blood niggerginger composers
>>63832260
>Brahms 4
What a newfaggy choice for your only Brahms
>>63832535
that's fair. and probably better than just telling them to listen to Schonberg until they get it.
>>63832260
I wonder what limitations he put upon himself in formulating this list. It's so hard to form a list of best classical works. I'm a violinist of 18 years and I've never come across a professional classical musician who would even go so far as to say a single work was their favourite
>>63832406
This
Beethoven's 5th and 7th symphonies are better than 9th.
Art of the Fugue and the Well-Tempered Clavier are better than the Brandenburg Concertos. He doesn't include cantatas.
>Verdi's Requiem and not his operas. Choosing Verdi's requiem over Berlioz's requiem.
>Including Wagner at all
>No Don Giovanni or Mozart's sacred music
Worst Brahms symphony.
No Dvorak chamber music.
>No Boulez, Berg, Bruckner, Sibelius, Ravel, Schumann, Haydn, Schoenberg or Mendelssohn
All in all, for someone who claims to be a patrician for rock music, he's the plebiest or plebs when it comes to everything else.
>>63832659
>for someone who claims to be a patrician for rock music, he's the plebiest or plebs when it comes to everything else.
...
>>63832659
>Beethoven's 5th and 7th symphonies are better than 9th
I sure hope you never intend to make a career out of music.
>>63832535
Mozart is better than whatever you listen to.
>>63832260
>all meme classical
>>63832260
>beethoven 9
>not 3, 5, or 6.
>schubert 9
>not his lied and chamber music
>mozart 21
>not Le Nozze or Don Giovanni
>bach mass in b minor
>not WTC or AOF or St Matthew
this really pissed me off
>shostakovich 15
HAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA
>mahler 9
acceptable
>wagner tristan
Good.
>Verdi Requiem
>not La Traviata or Othello
>bach brandenburgs
fucking pleb
>bartok concerto
>not music for strings
>brahms 4
acceptable
>schubert quintet
just why?
>bartok quartet 4
meme quartet
>beethoven quartet 14
meme quartet
>shostakovich quintet
HAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA
>beethoven triple concerto
just why
>janacek glagiotic
Not even close to GOAT
>le sacre
HAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA
>dvorak 9
HAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA
>vivaldi at all
HA
>berlioz symphonie
duh
>Messiaen quatuor
>not turangalila/des canyons/l'ascension
>debussy jeux
>not La Mer, preludes, etc
This is probably the worst list of classical music I've ever seen, if this is intended to be objective then I am fucking flabbergasted.
>>63833736
this guy gets it
>>63832659
That's some shitty taste you have there, friend.
>>63833736
What are you smoking? Vivaldi was great.
>>63833736
>he doesn't realize schubert's C major quintet is GOAT
HAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA
No Chopin?
>>63834353
chopin is 4 fags
>>63834472
Chopin single handed lay changed counterpoint
>>63832260
well if it's anything like his jazz list than I know it's shit. also no Chopin, Saint-saëns Ravel or Tchaikovsky
>>63834493
still 4 fags
>Scaruffi's greatest classical list
It's a teaser, you imbeciles. He did this with his jazz and film pages. It's the lists on the right that people should be critical of.
>>63832406
This and there's no Prokofiev
>>63833736
>schubert quintet just why?
Uh, that's not an unpopular opinion...It generally ends up at the top of or at least 2nd to Beethoven op. 131 in rankings of chamber music.
>>63835310
Can you point me to some credible classical ranked lists? So far i only scaruffi's lists to refer to.
>>63833736
>vivaldi
>bad
quick, the wiener-schnitzel's burning!
>>63835692
seconding this question
>>63832260
>tfw no bruckner
>>63833736
Le sacre was good stuff, although I do agree that more substantial works of Debussy could have made it on, or at least other French composers like Ravel or Fauré.
There's also a surprising lack of Chopin, Schumann, and atonal composers.
>>63832260
no reich
