Daily reminder that these are the ten best artists of all time
>1. Led Zeppelin
>2. The Smiths
>3. The Beatles
>4. Pink Floyd
>5. The Jimi Hendrix Experience
>6. Oasis
>7. Dire Straits
>8. The Who
>9. The Rolling Stones
>10. David Bowie
You literally can't prove me wrong
Protip: You can't
>6. Oasis
That's a funny way to spell The Beatles
K
1. beatles
2. pink floyd
3. led zeppelin
4. rolling stones
5. sonic youth
>5. The Jimi Hendrix Experience
maybe for album or song but otherwise that discography is way too short even if the quality were higher than it is.
agree with the smiths, flawless discography.
but not a single other artist you listed belongs there
can't speak for dire straits though haven't heard them yet
>>63772008
>rock
>best
pick one family
It's missing Autechre
>>63772008
Thanks for sharing your opinion, OP
>>63772196
kill urself my man
>1. Led Zeppelin
>2. The Smiths
>3. The Beatles
>4. Pink Floyd
>5. The Jimi Hendrix Experience
>6. Oasis
>7. Dire Straits
>8. The Who
>9. The Rolling Stones
>10. David Bowie
literally who
>>63772842
>>63772008
fucking normie AF
Best = ?
Most successful? Most well known?
>>63772008
>The Smiths
>Oasis
>Dire Straits
'no'
>>63772008
that's some nice rockism going on there, op
oasis and dire straits are the ones who are least deserving of a place on the list
please put Zappa on there at least
>>63772008
Kill yourself
>>63773633
best = objectively the best music
>>63773634
>The Smiths, Oasis and Dire Straits are bad
kill urself
>>63773639
>that's some nice rockism going on there, op
rock is objectively the best genre. nothing else is really interesting enough to put there. miles davis? maybe but jazz is kind of memey and gets boring much quicker
>oasis and dire straits are the ones who are least deserving of a place on the list
please listen to music objectively next time
>please put Zappa on there at least
meme
>>63773653
They're not bad, they're just not top 10 good.
>>63773675
post top 10
shit b8, Not even half of them are top 10
>>63772008
>The Smiths
There's more to life than self loathing and fan girling, anon.
>>63772008
>only rock artists/bands
>no King Crimson
>>63772008
woman detected
>>63773712
>Ignoring Johnny Marr's guitar work
>Ignoring the fact that The Smiths are possibly the most unique good rock band ever
kill urself
>>63773722
King Crimson is literally #11
>>63773653
And at this juncture, it became clear to anon that OP was merely baiting and that he should be left to ferment in his own juice instead of being graced with an argument.
>>63773729
>Most unique
Give me a break, Oingo Boingo surpasses the Smiths in that regard by a mile, might as well say Depeche Mode is the most influential synth act and is comparable to Bach while you're at it.
>>63773786
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RgNfTx9pGzA
>>63773729
>The Smiths are possibly the most unique good rock band ever
>>63772008
>Black Sabbath
>Modest Mouse
Yep Modest Mouse, trust me
>>63773896
New Order does it better.
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=NEjX0nmx8-E
>>63773928
this actually continues to get even funnier each time I pass this thread and read that.
>>63774016
awful taste
>>63772008
Dad pls go.
>>63774028
Kek, says the Smiths fag. Go home, kid.
>>63774051
Glad to see you know your place, now be a good faggot and go there.
My list includes Primus. Objectively the best band ever, subjectively speaking.
>>63774068
>He doesn't like The Smiths
>Oasis
>What the h
Tell me another song by them other than WonderWall.
>>63774090
>Implying that's ever a bad thing
I know it's hard to hear not everybody shares your crappy opinion, but you need to embrace your outer prison bitch and suck it.
Actual top 10 rock artists list:
>The Velvet Underground
>King Crimson
>Pink Floyd
>The Beatles
>Black Sabbath
>Radiohead
>David Bowie
>Talk Talk
>Can
>Metallica
prove me wrong protip you cannot
>>63774090
>being a fag for morrissey
>>63774099
Don't look back in anger
Rock n roll star
Champagne supernova
Oasis
Live forever
Cigarettes and alcohol
She's electric
I hate Oasis but it's not hard bruh
>>63774147
this is in order? vu discog is way too small even if it were stronger than it is.
>>63774147
Hello, dad.
>>63774099
>Supersonic
>Some Might Say
>Gas Panic
>Slide Away
>Champagne Supernova
>Acquiesce
>>63774168
TVU discog is small but it could easily be argued to be the most influential rock band, shaping the sound of rock for years to come.
>>63774181
>Radiohead, Talk Talk
>dad
don't talk to me or my son ever again
>>63774147
>Metallica
no, not even close, props for King Crimson and Black Sabbath though.
>>63774198
>Pink Floyd, Beatles, Black Sabbath, Bowie, Metallica
>not dad
Throwing in Radiomeme and jazz-rock won't make that list any less dadrock.
>>63772008
rolling stones > gay ass beatles
>>63774147
totally inferior to this
>>63772008
>>63774219
You're not going to be able to build a top 10 rock band list without acknowledging that it mostly comes from the 60s and 70s.
>>63774237
Besides, look at OP's list
>Dire Straits
>Rolling Stones
>Joy Division
>Velvet Underground
>Sanic Youth
>The Smiths
>King Crimson
>Modest Mouse
>Jimi Hendrix
>Led Zeppelin
>Bowie
>Pavement
>>63773653
>jazz is kind of memey
>>63774243
>having taste this bad
>>63774090
is there any hope for him anon?
>>63776064
you can only hope that he hasn't actually listened to them
>>63774147
>metallica
April's fools is over you know
>>63772008
>literally all white people
>>63772008
hi dad
>>63772152
basically this
>>63776400
you're a fucking white male
>>63772008
ebin bait friendo
>>63772008
>1. Led Zeppelin
>2. The Smiths
>3. The Beatles
>4. Pink Floyd
>5. The Jimi Hendrix Experience
>6. Oasis
>7. Dire Straits
>8. The Who
>9. The Rolling Stones
>10. David Bowie
Literally 9gag-core
>dire straits
cmon guy try a little harder
>11. King Crimson
>12. Alice in Chains
>13. The Police
>14. Black Sabbath
>15. The Doors
Seeing a lot of Dire Straits hate here, please give their s/t and Communique a listen at least
>>63772152
>The fact that so many books still name the Beatles as "the greatest or most significant or most influential" rock band ever only tells you how far rock music still is from becoming a serious art. Jazz critics have long recognized that the greatest jazz musicians of all times are Duke Ellington and John Coltrane, who were not the most famous or richest or best sellers of their times, let alone of all times. Classical critics rank the highly controversial Beethoven over classical musicians who were highly popular in courts around Europe. Rock critics are still blinded by commercial success. The Beatles sold more than anyone else (not true, by the way), therefore they must have been the greatest. Jazz critics grow up listening to a lot of jazz music of the past, classical critics grow up listening to a lot of classical music of the past. Rock critics are often totally ignorant of the rock music of the past, they barely know the best sellers. No wonder they will think that the Beatles did anything worthy of being saved.
That's you
That's what you sound like right now
>>63773729
You are funny
>>63774147
>Radiohead
>Metallica
>Floyd
Hahahahah, you are totally deluded
Dire Straits are pretty lame OP
>>63772008
Morrisey has to be the most overrated artist of all time, so so so shit
>>63777989
based anon
>>63777989
Their S/T gives me a weird feeling of nostalgia, and I like it.
>>63772008(You)
>>63772008
>The Smiths
>Oasis
>Dire Straits
The smiths should be number 1
>>63772008
>start thread with OP pic of the #2 guy
i mean you know to me the smiths are #1 of all time but the question is why?
>no mention of Bob Dylan in this thread
these are the artists he's influenced mentioned in the thread so far:
The Beatles
Pink Floyd (both Syd and Roger Waters cite him as an influence)
Jimi Hendrix
The Rolling Stones
David Bowie
Dire Straits
The Velvet Underground
King Crimson (Robert Fripp has mentioned how Dylan helped him realize songs don't need to adhere to radio format length)
Radiohead
The Doors (Jim Morrison at least)
>>63781660
influence ≠ best
>>63781923
Fun fact: Dylan has the most bolded albums out of any non-jazz artist on rym.
>>63772008
Led Zeppelin is a clusterfuck of stolen blues riffs
The Jimmi Hendrix Experience has too short a discography
David Bowie is overrated
Pink Floyd's post debut is shit
kill yourself, mr. dadrock
Why are they all rock bands?
>>63774183
A SED MAAYBEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE
>>63773653
>music taste
>objective
pick one
>>63774147
Correction: Metallica before Load
>No Lynyrd Skynyrd
Heh heh heehee hawww y'all sleepin on 'em.
P.s. Brand New's TDAGARIM beats The Smith's entire discography... With just a single album!
>>63772008
>oasis
>best artist
wheres radiohead
>>63774161
why would you hate oasis
>>63782845
In the gutter below oasis
OP should get rid of the 1-10 scale and replace Led Zep and Pink Floyd with the Jam and the Clash
>>63773634
Dire Straits is pretty great senpai.
mfw oasis is in the top 10
