Discography Ratings
Images are sometimes not shown due to bandwidth/network limitations. Refreshing the page usually helps.
You are currently reading a thread in /mu/ - Music
You are currently reading a thread in /mu/ - Music
Old one hit its bump limit and is falling off the board.
Old thread:
>>63686347
I'll start it off.
>wu tang clan aint nuttin ta fuck wit
>:^)
>>63708121
"yes"
Bumb love these
>>63708338
I actually mostly agree with this. I probably would've rated Mouse & Mask 8 though. It's good, but I can't rate it the same as Operation Doomsday.
>>63708101
a 6 for Fables? really OP? other than that, solid list
>>63708101
Beep Beep Best Opinions Coming Through
>>63708120
very good, starting to become a fan of this band, why are the old albums not more famoes ?
>>63709075
Honestly, it's just boring to me. It's not bad, but I never particularly get interested in it.
>>63709422
Kill em all is the best
>dad-metal
>>63710453
Accurate
>>63709187
I listened to Art Angels again today, and I was surprised at how much I enjoyed it.
re-posting from the last thread
because more people need to listen to andrew bird
>>63709270
>why are the old albums not more famoes ?
Honestly, they are. Many of the first 8 albums are almost universally considered some of the greatest albums of the 80's and early 90's. Even people who aren't huge REM fans usually accept their prominence as one of the most influential bands of the late 20th c., and their renown usually focuses on their early work.
>>63709120
Wheres Everywhere and His Nasty Parlour Tricks you fucking dip
>>63708120
Except for Fables (too low) and Green (too high), this is pretty good. I'd also give Reveal a 6 at least, but I know not many agree.
>>63711026
EP, didn't feel like rating it.
>>63711234
>rates a compilation album
>doesnt one of the best things MM has put out
I don't have time to make one, sorry.
Spirit They're Gone, Spirit They've Vanished - 10/10
Danse Manatee - 6/10
Hollinndagain - 8/10
Campfire Songs - 10/10
Here Comes the Indian - 10/10
Sung Tongs - 9/10
Feels - 10/10
Strawberry Jam - 8/10
Merriweather Post Pavilion - 9/10
ODDSAC - 9/10
Centipede Hz - 3/10
Painting With - 2/10
Why do most great bands end up putting out bad albums? It's really depressing. Every great band I can think of - Animal Collective, Mercury Rev, Pink Floyd, etcetera - went through periods of putting out really great albums and then went to shit. Why does this always happen? The only instance I can think of where this didn't happen is Talk Talk.
>>63708338
how do you feel about kmd?
>>63709928
Pretty Hate Machine should be God Tier
>>63711980
This is precisely why Kurt killed himself
>>63708101
I left /mu/ like two or so years ago and I come back and see ya'll are still doing this? wow, i mean i understand these threads are kind of fun but...
>>63711980
Not everyone can infinitely churn out amazing albums-- somewhere down the line the quality will depreciate, or the band will take a direction you don't like, that's just the way she goes bro
>>63710725
You didn't like Echo locations canyon? That's honestly one of his more interesting works in my opinion. Besides that I generally agree with you
>>63708120
Fables is too low man
>>63711880
htaaaaatsright
>>63710453
PP, Tomboy, and PBVSGR are all god-tier.
>>63712256
If you had just given ode lay god tier then it would have been perfect
>>63708809
Queen - 7/10
Queen II - 9/10
Sheer Heart Attack - 10/10
A Night at the Opera - 9/10
A Day at the Races - 8/10
News of the World - 5/10
Jazz - 8/10
The Game - 7/10
Flash Gordon - 3/10
Hot Space - 4/10
The Works - 6/10
A Kind of Magic - 7/10
The Miracle - 5/10
Innuendo - 8/10
>>63708120
Every one of these is too low except for AtS and CiN.
>>63714591
>>63714608
>>63714953
anon you're gonna get murdered
>>63709120
i think sto is better than we were dead imo tbqh
>>63714608
Lol fuck you Speak Now is her best album
>>63711880
chz and pw aren't THAT bad
>>63709147
>Having s/t at a 10 but dude ranch at an 8
Ok then
>>63715638
>Mariah Carey
mahnigga.jpg
>>63711165
great band
>>63710453
>PB 7/10
>YP 9/10
>PP God tier/10
>Tomboy 8/10
>PBVSGR 6/10
>>63716095
is this bait
>>63715588
Get out contrarians
>>63714608
wtf mane
>>63716356
Wtf the middle album looks like Get To Heaven by Everything Everything not zoomed in
Having multiple 10's and multiple God tiers per chart...it just doesn't tell us much
what the fuck is going on in this thread
>>63717244
Rating discographies.
>>63712218
I really didn't dig it. Just felt like aimless musical ramblings. I know that was sort of the point, but it didn't work for me.
I guess I'll be that fag
>>63718822
You're right about one thing, you ARE a faggot.
>>63718865
>danse = sung tongs
ok
>>63718865
bump stgstv up and this is the correct ratings
>>63709422
>St. Anger better than Load
sure
>>63718281
Switch Sister and Daydream Nation and you've got it.
>>63719287
>>63718281
Also delete Master-Dik you fag.
>>63719347
switch slanted and brighten and this is correct
(i still have yet to listen to the ones not listed on here)
>>63718281
why is experimental jet set so high? it was really inadequate
>>63719139
>Asunder
>6
Why do people think Asunder is bad? I think it's one of their stronger releases, better than Don't Bend, at least
>>63709422
>St. Anger (shit album) better than Load and Reload (great albums)
>>63709165
was honestly surprised how good hot sauce committee part two was. After Hello Nasty I honestly wondered if they would make anything listenable again.
>>63719633
>not metal
>no Jason Byron vocals
Driver conned people into paying for a Kayo Dot record. Solid 8/10 though
>>63720051
That's an awfully cynical view. Just because it doesn't have death growls doesn't mean it's not still a great maudlin album. And honestly it doesn't even resemble Kayo Dot
