A solo Andre 3000 would be nothing short of spectacular.
he's a nigger
he doesnt make music anymore because hes out of ideas
honestly it's questionable whether or not this guy is actually a musician
>>63672107
explain
>>63672075
>>63672090
>>63672107
jesus christ
>>63672042
or would it be fantastically well
>>63672127
>>63672107
im gonna second this request
>>63672127
>>63672225
Making shit rhyme has nothing to do with music. I underhand that there's a musical element to the flow and vocal inflection from which you write rhymes, but just straight rapping is not music the same way spoken word poetry is not music.
>>63672263
damn art has some strict rules
frank lotion
>>63672263
you just went full retard bud. rap, and being a rapper (choosing beats/producers etc.) is much more than just making cool rhymes with some rhythms man.
>>63672263
>Instruments Vocals • guitar • bass guitar • keyboards • saxophone • violin
try again
>>63672263
So if someone was the lead singer in a band they wouldn't be a musician either if they did nothing but sing?
>>63672315
and on top of that when a rapper makes a record its not like he just writes down a bunch of words walks into the both and records them. it is a process that the rapper should have heavy involvement in, and the music will reflect that just like any other artist creating a record.
>>63672315
m8 choosing a beat and production engineer to work your album has nothing to do with music either. The actual record production is the musical facet of hip hop.
See
>Madlib
NOT
>DOOM
>>63672343
>>63672361
You're conflating singing vocals and rapped vocals. Not the same thing, lads.
>>63672361
>>63672343
>>63672315
>fistbump.jpg
>>63672075
go back to /pol/
Sam Mehran
He need come out of hiding ASAP
>>63672393
where do you draw that line though.... like what about tobacco/bmsr or Why? or some tom waits, i mean im sure theres better examples too but still
>>63672429
Tobacco, all the members of Black Moth Super Rainbow, and Yoni Wolf are all musicians in the sense that they contribute more than a written complement to their respective projects. Same with Tom Waits, although it's a completely incongruent style.
There's a difference between being a musician and a rapper.
>>63672042
>>63672478
ya and most importantly they arent black people
>>63672575
brer ebin racism meme
Sometimes I love threads like these, you get to see the completely nonsensical ideas that form in the vaccuum of actual music knowledge. Nothing like arbitrary distinctions based on arbitrary definitions for the sake of arbitrary prejudices.
>>63673039
How about you arbitrary suck my dick?????
>>63673135
how does that work anon?
>>63673174
i didnt think this out well enough im sorry
>>63673245
that's ok, existence is arbitrary anyway, maybe one day we'll do this for real
>>63672478
and explain to me how kanye or chance don't do both... as do most rappers
>>63673421
What the fuck are you even trying to say in this post? Explain how they don't do both? They DO do both, you fucking moron. Kanye and Chance are both musicians and rappers. Do you have autism?
>>63672075
Back to /pol/ bitch
>>63672107
musician = someone who makes music
what's so hard to understand about that
>>63672042
Fuck Andre 3000 we need another Bran Van 3000 album!!!!
>>63673472
right... and what about a rapper.... who doesn't necessarily MAKE the beat.... but has a huge influence on the way it sounds.... much like maybe a lead singer might in a band
what im trying to say is that i dont understand where this line your drawing in the sand is, at what point does it switch from rapper to 'musician'
>>63673648
A rapper is a musician. They're not two different things.
>>63673690
i agree that why im asking him to explain this 'distinction' he is making between the 2 because, like you say, it is nonsense
>>63673535
>>63672400
fooled you both, i'm on the feel the burn meme train
>>63673866
checkd
>>63673580
That's exactly what I'm saying.
Making shit rhyme =! music
>>63673648
Creative director =! musician
The production engineer is the musician.
>>63672393
DOOM produces
>>63674606
>prod engineer = musician
>person making music =! musician
SCIENCE!
>>63674630
See
>making shit rhyme
A new album by Slowdive would be nice right now.
Or anything from Oasis
>>63674621
My mistake, but you understand the analogy.
>>63674652
>implying all rhymes are shit rhymes?
>or only rappers with dope rhymes are musicians?
>>63674676
>>63674684
ANY AND ALL RHYMES are not music.
>>63674727
>unless they sing?
>>63674748
If the question is whether or not singing is a form of music, then "yes".
I'm pretty sure Andre has no interesting in releasing new material, guest appearances sure but I think he's done with making music. It's been 10 years since his last release
>>63672042
Based off The Love Below it could be a bit of a mess but if he has a collaborator to reign him in or a really go co-producer it mite b gud
Andre is kind of off the rails now. He said the last music release that got him excited was Kid Cudi's Speedin' Bullet 2 Heaven.
I can't imagine what a musical release by him would sound like. Maybe he just digs the sound but wouldn't put out anything like it.
>>63672393
Andre 3000 sings as well, you idiot
>>63677153
>honestly it's questionable whether or not this guy is actually a musician
>questionable
>>63672042
Lauryn Hill
>>63674606
He's taking a part in making the piece of music. Therefore he's a musician.
>>63677420
Why did she only ever release one album? Well and the one with Fugees. What's she been doing for the past 20 years?
>>63672075
(you)
>>63674676
>Oasis
GOD NO. I COULD NOT FUCKING DEAL WITH THAT SHIT.
More out of morbid curiosity than actually caring. I want to see him commit to another LP and see if he can bring something new to the table with it.
Also holy shit at whatever the fuck is happening above my post.
