![zxYrCNM[1].png](https://i.imgur.com/aO5QMpW.png "zxYrCNM[1].png")
just a reminder that some of you retards worship a guy who thinks pablo honey is just as good as kid a and also that pablo honey is better than in rainbows.
>>63617114
Fuck Scaruffi.
He has his head stuck so far up his own ass he can't see the light of day.
Kid A isnt that good, sorry to break it to you kid
also i bet you havent even listened to pablo honey
>>63617155
I have, and Kid A is a lot better than fucking Pablo Honey lol. And do you really think Pablo Honey is better than In Rainbows or TKoL?
>>63617155
>Kid A isnt that good, sorry to break it to you kid
How can I enjoy it now?
>>63617114
Radiohead isn't that good, although that is pretty ridiculous. Pablo Honey and The Bends are just average britpop but honestly I prefer both of them to In Rainbows which is a piece of shit.
He's right though, anyone that actually tries to defend the opinion that In Rainbows is good needs to go hang themselves.
>>63617114
I agree with all of those ratings.
>>63617148
>look who's talking.jpg
>>63617148
he's not wrong just because somebody doesnt think that this shitty middle class white boy band isnt the BEST and ONLY music to ever exist doesnt make somebody pretentious
i think you may need to go back to r/music
>>63617187
Do you even know what Britpop is?
calm down op, you'll grow out of your radiohead phase eventually
>>63617148
post examples pleb
>>63617172
Do you even know why In Rainbows is better?
>>63617180
i dunno man
>>63617207
do you?
i agree they're all rated too highly
>>63617199
no one was saying any of that. kid a is pretty obviously superior to palbo honey...
>>63617114
He rates early albums by a band much less critically than later albums.
>>63617462
why not rate a piece of music for what it is? that's a retarded system to be honest with you.
>>63617114
did you even read the review?
>"The sound of Kid A (Capitol, 2000) has decomposed and absorbed countless new perfumes, like a carcass in the woods."
>In fact, this album is as good (at what it does) as the celebrated OK Computer, if not even more inventive, unpredictable and baroque.
Radiohead are masters of the artificial. Their parable crowns a long tradition in British rock music...
even if this is a "negative" review it (to me) describes Kid A pretty perfectly. There's more to criticism than a number/star grade. In fact, I would say that's the LEAST important and most trivial part of criticism to get hung up on.
>>63617493
maybe because one should expect more from musicians that have more experience under their belts?
![tAOaYbA[1].jpg](https://i.imgur.com/J58IBmM.jpg "tAOaYbA[1].jpg")
>>63617721
>Radiohead are masters of the artificial. Their parable crowns a long tradition in British rock music...
nice meme
>>63617114
#RadioheadIsn'tThatGood
>>63617114
so what
radiohead is the most overrated shit out there
>>63617835
I don't know, I think people just like them senpai
>>63617187
>Radiohead isn't that good,
>is at the forefront of electronic music
>isn't that good,
>>63617855
still doesn't invalidate a man that made me discover don caballero, codeine, three mile pilot and black heart procession, birds of the mesozoic, bitch magnet and blind idiot god
>>63617148
gayboy spotted
>>63617911
>>is at the forefront of electronic music
are you serious lmao
>>63617781
it's just a line from the review
Ah, looks like all the contrarian faggots have crawled out of their rooms to shit on Radiohead again. Yes they're not the second coming of Christ but they're not fucking AC/DC or some shit. Kill yourselves.
>>63617721
who rates based on fucking expectations
>>63617961
you mean experience
>>63617957
that's exactly what they are though
in 20 years kids will be making fun of our generation for liking radiohead as much as we make fun of older people for liking dadrock
and some will defend older music le wrong generashun too
radiohead is fucking garbage, pink floyd tier, saturated boring rock music for boring people
>>63617930
Scarufi is really good but he hates popular music.
I kinda hate popular music too but I happen to like Radiohead.
He can have good taste.
1. Opinions
2. Obviously Scaruffi looks for a innovation/edgy factor in his opinions
3. You can always filter what opinions from Scaruffi are valuable if you developed a small bit of personal taste. He is a great entry point into """experimental""" music.
Why does he make people so butthurt? Can he be stopped?
>>63618015
he hates predictable music, he likes pop (van dyke parks, simon and garfunkel, belle and sebastian)
>>63618058
People like what he's saying overall but hate when he attacks their favorite band.
At what age did you grow out of Radiohead, /mu/?
>>63618116
never did, never will senpai
>>63618116
16 for me. Now I listen to them on occasion but I can never sit through an entire album, I get too bored
Scaruffi is nothing but a more complete version of wikipedia.
I haver better understanding of music than Scaruffi, and i'm dumb as fuck.
>>63617911
>at the forefront of electronic music
Radiohead doesn't even compare in importance to greats like Kraftwerk
>>63617114
Serious question: does anybody here ACTUALLY take Scaruffi seriously?
As far as I can tell it's always just been a meme and literally no one actually takes him seriously.
>>63618014
Floyd is much better than Radiohead.
>>63617148
shut up
>>63617207
Can we all agree /mu/core collapsed onto itself. This time I nominate Robert Wyatt's Rock Bottom it's just hipster enough to trick some people
>>63617114
In Rainbows is (slightly) better than Pablo Honey but you can't say the same about KoL, which is a shit album.
>>63618839
so you're saying you're smarter than wikipedia
>>63619105
i don't get what you said then
>>63617114
Pablo Honey is better than Kid A
>>63617114
Correct ratings:
PH: 6 (+0,5)
The Bends: 6,5 (-0,5)
OKC: 7 (same)
Kid A: 7 (-0,5)
Amnesiac: 7,5 (-0,5)
HTTT: 5,5 (-0,5)
In Rainbows: 6+ (-1,2)
KOL: 5 (same)
Scaruffi is not that far.
I see nothing wrong with Scaruffi's scorse.
>>63617207
This is
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=O5Nhul_AV0M
Not your precious oasis shit.
>>63617114
all wrong
Pablo: 5/10
The Bends: 7/10
OKC: 10/10
Kid A: 10/10
Amnesiac: 9/10
HTTT: 9/10
In Rainbows: 9/10
TKOL: 9/10
>>63619651
holy shit that's inflated as fuck
>>63617148
>>>63617114 (OP)
>Fuck Scaruffi.
>He has his head stuck so far up his own ass he can't see the light of day.
The next time you post a /posercore/ general or shit talk Coil, Comus, or This Heat, leave your fucking trip on.
>>63619669
I don't inflate ratings, i rate like a school teacher would grade assignments.
>>63619679
so you're saying radiohead is at the level of a school project?
>>63619723
Life is, really.
>>63619734
what a shitty life you must have then
>taking any person who uses the term 'overrated' seriously
>>63619767
It's aight. Could be better, could be worse.
>>63619791
i'm reporting you for being under 18. i know i broke the rules by telling you so, but i thought you should know.
>>63619851
I'm 24, turning 25 in june. I've just accepted my fate as a manchild.
>>63619890
yeah well you need to grow up son
>>63619919
yeah well so does ur mom
>>63617148
You like Oasis my nigga lmao
Is 7/10 considered good by this guys standards?
>>63620005
buy it eventually
>>63619677
If I'm remembering correctly he likes Comus
>>63618897
Kraftwerk were just a bunch of nerds who started using computers
>>63620005
By his rating scale, a 7 is not bad at all. It's like a 7,8 given by Pitchfork.
>>63618897
Kid A and OKC are better individual albums than anything Kraftwerk made though.
>>63620135
radiohead were a bunch of normies who pretended to be emo and then artistic and used the loops and bloops that had already been made by others
>>63617114
>TKOL - 5/10
>Amok - 4/10
Scaruffi confirmed meme reviewer and absolute pleb
>>63620161
>Kid A and OKC are better individual albums than anything Kraftwerk made though.
LOL, no.
Maybe they are better than a couple of their lesser albums.
(Amnesiac is better than those, btw)
>>63620453
Amnesiac is a minor masterpiece. Kid A is a life-changing masterpiece. Kid A changed the way i approach music, and because of that it'll always be a contender for my favorite album of all time.
>>63619651
true
>>63620495
you should listen to more music then
>>63620556
I've likely listened to more music than you have.
>>63620593
you don't even know me, why do you assume that?
>>63620617
post your last.fm
>>63620668
i don't have that, never have
but you can show me yours if you want to and i'll be honest
i don't mind admitting i don't listen to as much stuff as another person, it makes me want to listen to more stuff and i like that
>caring about ratings
doesn't get any more pleb than that
literally end your life my friend
>>63620005
7/10 from Scaruffi is considered very good. He doesn't have inflated ratings like P4K or Fantano. 7/10 albums often end up on his best-of lists. He's never given a 10 and he's only given about 30 9s I think.
>>63620182
hahaha fuckign nerd. Even kraftwerk's fans are fuckign losers lol
